The Politics of Creating a 2016 Soundtrack

It’s not easy picking a perfect presidential playlist. And it can take a lot of staffpower.

Republican presidential candidate Ben Carson speaks during a campaign rally Sept. 9 in Anaheim, California.
Kevork Djansezian AFP/Getty
Clare Foran
Add to Briefcase
Clare Foran
Oct. 2, 2015, 5 a.m.

Be­fore Ben Car­son uttered a word at his 2016 pres­id­en­tial cam­paign kick­off, a gos­pel choir belted out the na­tion­al an­them and a rendi­tion of Em­inem’s 2002 hit-single “Lose Your­self.” The De­troit Mu­sic Hall crowd went wild.

It wasn’t a typ­ic­al start to a cam­paign, and that was the point. “We were try­ing to show that we were dif­fer­ent, we were not the es­tab­lish­ment. We wanted people to walk away say­ing ‘Wow, that was so un-Wash­ing­ton’,” Doug Watts, Car­son’s com­mu­nic­a­tions dir­ect­or said, re­call­ing how he, cam­paign man­ager Barry Ben­nett, and cam­paign strategist Ed Brookover spent nearly a full day brain­storm­ing be­fore hit­ting on the idea to ask the De­troit-fam­ous gos­pel choir Se­lec­ted of God to play a star­ring role.

Not every 2016 can­did­ate cre­ated quite that much of a spec­tacle with a cam­paign launch. But as White House con­tenders work to win over the Amer­ic­an pub­lic, they aren’t leav­ing any­thing to chance. That means painstak­ing de­lib­er­a­tion, stress­ing, and strategiz­ing over every last de­tail of a can­did­ate’s im­age—in­clud­ing pick­ing the per­fect soundtrack.

The right song can de­liv­er a mes­sage, leav­ing it stuck on loop in the minds of voters. Mu­sic sets the tone at cam­paign ral­lies and provides a back­drop for videos, tele­vi­sion, and ra­dio ad­vert­ising churned out by the cam­paign. But there are pit­falls too: Fail to check the right boxes, and you could end up with an angry pop-artist pub­licly drag­ging your cam­paign through the so­cial me­dia mud, or threat­en­ing to sue.

There are no hard and fast rules for pick­ing a polit­ic­al an­them. Jon Bon Jovi gave Chris Christie per­mis­sion to use his mu­sic on the cam­paign trail. Bernie Sanders enters and exits massive ral­lies to the tune of Neil Young’s “Rockin’ in the Free World.” Mar­tin O’Mal­ley some­times plays gui­tar on the trail. (The O’Mal­ley cam­paign has also taken mu­sic­al ad­vice from a Mary­land ra­dio sta­tion DJ.) Rick San­tor­um has an of­fi­cial cam­paign theme song titled “Take Back Amer­ica,” and you’ll of­ten hear “Homegrown” by the Zac Brown Band at Jeb Bush events.

“You have to have a soundtrack. If you don’t have a soundtrack, you don’t have as clear an iden­tity with voters. It’s something to be very de­lib­er­ate about. If you’re not choos­ing wisely, you’re miss­ing an op­por­tun­ity,” said An­drew Bar­low, a speech writ­ing con­sult­ant for Re­pub­lic­an can­did­ates, in­clud­ing Ted Cruz, and founder and CEO of me­dia firm Over­flow Com­mu­nic­a­tions.

A lot of thought goes in­to se­lect­ing a song. At a rally, cam­paigns look for mu­sic that can wake up a crowd. For ad­vert­ising and pro­mo­tion­al videos, mu­sic that in­spires or in­stills fear, de­pend­ing on what kind of mes­sage the cam­paign wants to send, may work best. And it’s not just the ven­ue. Geo­graph­ic loc­a­tion mat­ters as well. Pres­id­en­tial con­tenders some­times spot­light loc­al fa­vor­ites as a way of telling the audi­ence: “I’m just like you!”

“These are not de­cisions you ar­rive at lightly. You want something con­sist­ent with your val­ues, you want it to be en­er­get­ic, and some­times there’s a deep­er mean­ing,” said Rick Ab­bruzzese, a former O’Mal­ley aide and con­sult­ant for a pro-O’Mal­ley su­per PAC.

At least one 2016 con­tender is out­sourcing the task. Hil­lary Clin­ton’s cam­paign paid $9,000 to en­list the aid of a boutique mu­sic agency based in Port­land, Ore­gon, re­cords from the Fed­er­al Elec­tion Com­mis­sion show. Bill­board re­por­ted that the agency “has been tasked with mu­sic su­per­vi­sion and cre­at­ive sup­port” for a series of Clin­ton cam­paign videos, in­clud­ing the video that launched Clin­ton’s 2016 bid. (A spokes­per­son for the mu­sic agency said the firm is “ex­cited about our re­la­tion­ship with the Hil­lary cam­paign” but ad­ded that an in­ter­view would not be pos­sible due to a nondis­clos­ure agree­ment. The Clin­ton cam­paign de­clined to com­ment.)

But pres­id­en­tial can­did­ates don’t al­ways get the mu­sic they want. Car­son’s cam­paign hoped to use the gos­pel rendi­tion of Em­inem’s “Lose Your­self” as a 2016 an­them. But Watts, the cam­paign com­mu­nic­a­tions dir­ect­or, dis­covered he “could not get through the pub­lish­er without empty­ing our bank ac­count.” So he settled for second-best: The cam­paign got the gos­pel choir to re­cord a song modeled after the ori­gin­al, a mu­sic­al se­lec­tion that the cam­paign has since used in a cam­paign video.

A polit­ic­al clash can also arise, a prob­lem that af­flicts Re­pub­lic­ans far more of­ten than Demo­crats. R.E.M. front­man Mi­chael Stipe lashed out after Trump took the stage at a rally last month in Wash­ing­ton to “It’s the End of the World as We Know It (And I Feel Fine)”. “Do not use our mu­sic or my voice for your mor­on­ic charade of a cam­paign,” Stipe told The Daily Beast shortly after. Neil Young also took is­sue when Trump played “Rockin’ in the Free World” at his pres­id­en­tial kick­off. Des­pite claims from Trump’s team that they had the rights to the mu­sic, a spokes­per­son for the artist said Trump “was not au­thor­ized,” adding: “Neil Young, a Ca­na­dian cit­izen, is a sup­port­er of Bernie Sanders for Pres­id­ent of the United States of Amer­ica.” Not to be out­done, punk band Drop­kick Murphys tweeted at Scott Walk­er: “please stop us­ing our mu­sic in any way … we lit­er­ally hate you!!!”

Cam­paigns wary of clash­ing with a liv­id mu­si­cian have rushed to shore up a de­fense. The most com­mon leg­al safe­guard is for cam­paigns to pay a fee to a per­form­ing rights or­gan­iz­a­tion, a middle-man between any­one who wants to use a song for a com­mer­cial pur­pose or pub­lic event and the song­writer and pub­lish­er. Rand Paul, Bush, Clin­ton, and Trump’s cam­paigns have paid for a sub­scrip­tion to at least one of the ma­jor per­form­ing rights or­gan­iz­a­tions, ac­cord­ing to FEC re­cords.

Of course, mu­si­cians can still an­grily de­nounce a can­did­ate even if the cam­paign has se­cured the rights to play a cer­tain song. Polit­ic­al con­sult­ants are acutely aware of that, and may try to dis­suade a cam­paign from pick­ing a par­tic­u­lar song if they fear it could stir up trouble.

“If I’m rep­res­ent­ing a con­ser­vat­ive cam­paign that wants to play Rage Against the Ma­chine [a fam­ously Left-lean­ing band] I’m go­ing to tell them: You’re likely to get blas­ted by the artist here on so­cial me­dia. That’s less leg­al and just more com­mon sense,” said Chris Gober, a law­yer with the firm Gober Hil­gers who works on copy­right and cam­paign fin­ance is­sues for dozens of na­tion­al cam­paigns, in­clud­ing the Cruz pres­id­en­tial cam­paign.

Des­pite pre­cau­tions, dus­tups over song se­lec­tion still hap­pen—and at least in some cases that may be in­ten­tion­al.

“I some­times won­der if cam­paigns think it’s easi­er to ask for for­give­ness than per­mis­sion, or fol­low the old ax­iom of any pub­li­city is good pub­li­city, oth­er­wise I can’t think of why it hap­pens so of­ten,” said Joel Schoen­feld, a part­ner with the law firm Mitchell, Sil­ber­berg, and Knupp who spe­cial­izes in li­cens­ing and di­git­al rights.

Still, it’s not al­ways con­ten­tious. Plenty of artists, pro­fes­sion­al and am­a­teur alike, are happy to have their name linked to a pres­id­en­tial cam­paign.

Be­fore Car­son took to the De­troit Mu­sic Hall stage to an­nounce his cam­paign, his wife, Candy, walked in­to the green room at the per­form­ing arts ven­ue, held out her hands and led Ver­itas, a con­tem­por­ary Chris­ti­an clas­sic­al vo­cal group, as well as the gos­pel choir, in pray­er.

“I got to stand right be­side Ms. Car­son and hold her hand,” said James Ber­ri­an, a mem­ber of Ver­itas. “She led the pray­er but you know how it is when you get a circle of church folk, we were all say­ing ‘amen’ and ‘yes, Lord,’ that kind of thing. We were all in it to­geth­er.”

Katy Perry has offered to write a theme song for Clin­ton’s cam­paign. Paul’s cam­paign prom­ises that they have had “mul­tiple artists of­fer to per­form and you’ll see some of them on the road as the cam­paign un­folds,” per spokes­man Ser­gio Gor. And in the end, cam­paigns of­ten have more mu­sic than they know what to do with. “You get a lot of free of­fers, a lot of wacky sug­ges­tions,” Watts said.

What We're Following See More »
Heller, Paul Won’t Vote on Motion to Proceed
12 hours ago
CBO Says 22 Million More Would Be UNinsured
13 hours ago

The Senate bill "would increase the number of people without health insurance by 22 million by 2026, a figure that is only slightly lower than the 23 million more uninsured that the House version would create. Next year, 15 million more people would be uninsured compared with current law...The legislation would decrease federal deficits by a total of $321 billion over a decade."

Cornyn Says Health Vote Needed This Week
17 hours ago
Kislyak Being Recalled to Russia
20 hours ago

"Ending one the most turbulent tenures of a Washington-based ambassador in recent memory, the Kremlin has decided to recall Ambassador to the United States Sergey Kislyak, three individuals familiar with the decision told BuzzFeed News. The decision to bring Kislyak back to Russia rather than appoint him to a senior position at the United Nations in New York, as several outlets previously reported, comes amid investigations by the FBI and Congress into the 66-year-old diplomat’s contacts with President Donald Trump’s top aides during the 2016 presidential campaign."

Deutsche Bank Gave Kushner a $285 Million Loan in October
1 days ago

"One month before Election Day, Jared Kushner’s real estate company finalized a $285 million loan as part of a refinancing package for its property near Times Square in Manhattan. The loan came at a critical moment. Kushner was playing a key role in the presidential campaign of his father-in-law, Donald Trump. The lender, Deutsche Bank, was negotiating to settle a federal mortgage fraud case and charges from New York state regulators that it aided a possible Russian money-laundering scheme."


Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.