Five Days in August That Changed the Nation

This day, 40 years ago, Richard Nixon’s defenses crumbled and a humiliated man went into exile. Here is what I witnessed.

9th AUGUST 1974: President Richard Nixon with arms outstretched with veed fingers at doorway to helicopter as he departs after his resignation with others on ground.
National Journal
Tom DeFrank
Add to Briefcase
Tom DeFrank
Aug. 8, 2014, 1 a.m.

Forty years ago Fri­day, Amer­ica’s gravest con­sti­tu­tion­al crisis since the Civil War ended with the un­think­able — the resig­na­tion of an Amer­ic­an pres­id­ent in dis­grace. After more than two years of leg­al and polit­ic­al trauma that wracked and di­vided a na­tion, the 2,026 days of Richard M. Nix­on’s pres­id­ency were over.

It’s dif­fi­cult to con­vey the enorm­ity of those har­row­ing times to gen­er­a­tions who have lived through 9/11, two po­lar­iz­ing wars, a pres­id­ency de­cided by the courts, the first Afric­an-Amer­ic­an pres­id­ent, and the Great Re­ces­sion. Yet in its day, Wa­ter­gate was just as seis­mic.

It shook the found­a­tions of our re­pub­lic, en­ga­ging all three branches of gov­ern­ment on an ugly col­li­sion course, pit­ting mil­lions against one an­oth­er in ideo­lo­gic­al com­bat, and shat­ter­ing the coun­try’s faith in its lead­ers and in­sti­tu­tions.

Amer­ica’s com­mit­ment to civil liber­ties was sorely chal­lenged by a “plumb­er’s unit” cre­ated to spy on White House polit­ic­al ad­versar­ies and an­ti­war zealots. A pres­id­ent of the United States tried to con­ceal crim­in­al deeds by claim­ing his agents were pro­tect­ing na­tion­al se­cur­ity. When a spe­cial pro­sec­utor who was ap­poin­ted to find the truth came too close to it, the pres­id­ent fired him in the in­fam­ous “Sat­urday Night Mas­sacre.” It was, un­be­liev­ably, the stuff of ba­nana re­pub­lics.

In today’s 24/7, so­cial-me­dia-driv­en uni­verse, Wa­ter­gate would have played out in a few months; it dragged on for parts of three years, riv­et­ing the na­tion and dom­in­at­ing head­lines morn­ing and night.

Though justice ul­ti­mately pre­vailed and our demo­crat­ic pro­cesses sur­vived, Wa­ter­gate’s cor­ros­ive fal­lout is with us still. Ever since, polit­ic­al lead­ers are viewed with more sus­pi­cion and cyn­icism. Pres­id­ents aren’t con­sidered nearly so trust­worthy any­more. Es­cal­at­ing po­lar­iz­a­tion between Con­gress and the White House has crippled bi­par­tis­an gov­ernance. Re­port­ers and pres­id­ents have little use for each oth­er now. All this traces to Wa­ter­gate.

What fol­lows is a per­son­al re­mem­brance — not just of his­tory, but his­tory that altered Amer­ica forever. I was for­tu­nate to watch it all un­fold firsthand, es­pe­cially that fate­ful fi­nal week, as the 29-year-old White House cor­res­pond­ent for New­s­week.

Four dec­ades later, in one of life’s small iron­ies, my of­fice at Na­tion­al Journ­al is in the Wa­ter­gate com­plex. Driv­ing to work I pass the old Howard John­son’s mo­tor lodge, now a George Wash­ing­ton Uni­versity dorm, where Nix­on par­tis­ans mon­itored a botched burg­lary of the Demo­crat­ic Na­tion­al Com­mit­tee’s Wa­ter­gate headquar­ters across the street on the night of June 17, 1972.

* * * * * *

At 12:20 p.m. on Aug. 8, 1974, Richard Nix­on’s press sec­ret­ary entered the White House brief­ing room. We knew it must be ser­i­ous — Ron Zie­g­ler had checked his Marl­boro Lights, Styro­foam cup of cof­fee, and trade­mark cock­i­ness at the door.

Zie­g­ler’s brief­ing las­ted just 83 words and he had trouble fin­ish­ing. “To­night at nine o’clock East­ern Day­light Time,” he an­nounced, strug­gling to main­tain his com­pos­ure, “the pres­id­ent of the United States will ad­dress the na­tion on ra­dio and tele­vi­sion from his Oval Of­fice.”

As Zie­g­ler left the po­di­um, a Wall Street Journ­al cor­res­pond­ent once again shouted the ques­tion he’d been ask­ing at every press brief­ing for weeks: “Ron, is the pres­id­ent go­ing to resign?”

Early on, Zie­g­ler had de­nounced the break-in as a “third-rate burg­lary.” Even a year in­to the scan­dal, Nix­on pro­fessed his ig­nor­ance and in­no­cence. “I am not a crook,” he fam­ously in­sisted in Or­lando, Fla., in Novem­ber 1973.

By then, however, Nix­on’s dam­age-con­trol ef­forts were crater­ing. Guided by an FBI agent known as Deep Throat, The Wash­ing­ton Post‘s Bob Wood­ward and Carl Bern­stein had pro­duced a steady stream of block­buster scoops doc­u­ment­ing that the Wa­ter­gate burg­lars had been cho­reo­graphed by re­tired in­tel­li­gence agents with close ties to the 1972 Nix­on reelec­tion ap­par­at­us and with­in the White House.

A Sen­ate spe­cial com­mit­tee was try­ing to de­term­ine, in the im­mor­tal phrase of the late Sen. Howard Baker, “what did the pres­id­ent know and when did he know it.” Spe­cial Pro­sec­utor Le­on Ja­wor­ski, a le­gendary tri­al law­yer from Texas, was haul­ing pres­id­en­tial as­so­ci­ates be­fore a fed­er­al grand jury. Nix­on’s chief of staff and do­mest­ic policy ad­viser had been forced to resign after Wood­ward and Bern­stein re­por­ted their com­pli­city in the cov­er-up.

When White House aide Al­ex­an­der But­ter­field told the Wa­ter­gate com­mit­tee that Nix­on had been secretly tap­ing his Oval Of­fice con­ver­sa­tions, Ja­wor­ski sub­poenaed the tapes. Nix­on re­fused, claim­ing ex­ec­ut­ive priv­ilege. The spe­cial pro­sec­utor sued the pres­id­ent, trig­ger­ing a con­sti­tu­tion­al con­front­a­tion between the ex­ec­ut­ive branch and the ju­di­ciary. On Ju­ly 24, 1974, a un­an­im­ous Su­preme Court ruled that Nix­on must sur­render the tapes.

Monday, Au­gust 5

After 26 months, the en­dgame reached a stun­ning cres­cendo in just five days, be­gin­ning on the af­ter­noon of Monday, Aug. 5, when the White House re­leased tran­scripts of three tapes. Shortly be­fore they were made pub­lic, Nix­on’s chief of staff, Al­ex­an­der Haig, con­vened about 100 White House seni­or aides in the Old Ex­ec­ut­ive Of­fice Build­ing. He warned that “ma­ter­i­al dam­aging to us” was about to be re­leased and ex­hor­ted them to stay at their posts for the good of the na­tion.

Even more telling, Haig had already in­formed Vice Pres­id­ent Ger­ald Ford that the tapes were a game-changer and that Ford should be­gin think­ing about pre­par­ing him­self to be­come pres­id­ent.

“After that meet­ing, the odds were over­whelm­ing that I would be pres­id­ent,” Ford told me 17 years later. “Of course, even then Haig was say­ing, ‘One minute he’s go­ing to resign, the next minute he’s go­ing to fight it through.’ “

The three 1972 con­ver­sa­tions between Nix­on and Chief of Staff H.R. Hal­de­man de­mol­ished Nix­on’s con­ten­tion that he was merely the in­no­cent vic­tim of overzeal­ous sub­or­din­ates. They showed con­vin­cingly that Nix­on had been deeply in­volved. In fact, one of them re­vealed he was con­spir­ing to cov­er up the break-in six days after it happened — nine months be­fore he claimed he first learned of the in­cid­ent.

The in­crim­in­at­ing tran­scripts not only sealed Nix­on’s fate, they coined a new phrase in the Amer­ic­an polit­ic­al lex­icon: “the smoking gun.”

I called my boss, New­s­week‘s le­gendary bur­eau chief Mel Elfin, and read him what we liked to call the “nut graf” from each of the tapes. Mel had im­pec­cable polit­ic­al in­stincts, but this was a no-brain­er. “It’s over,” he said. “You’re about to cov­er the biggest story of your life.”

 

+ Re­port­ers swarm Re­pub­lic­an con­gres­sion­al lead­ers at the White House after their meet­ing with Pres­id­ent Nix­on on the af­ter­noon of Aug. 7, 1974. (Of­fi­cial White House Photo by Wil­li­am Fitz-Patrick)

Tues­day, Au­gust 6

After a 10-minute hair­cut in the base­ment barber shop, Nix­on walked up­stairs for an emer­gency Cab­in­et meet­ing. For 88 minutes, he led the con­ver­sa­tion as if the busi­ness of gov­ern­ment were para­mount on his mind. He began by say­ing he wanted to talk about the most im­port­ant prob­lem fa­cing the coun­try — in­fla­tion.

At some point he brought up the Wa­ter­gate crisis, dis­sect­ing the mess for about 25 minutes. Yes, he ac­know­ledged, he’d made some mis­takes; these were dif­fi­cult times for him and his fam­ily, but he in­ten­ded to sol­dier on and let “the con­sti­tu­tion­al pro­cess” go for­ward.

The de­lu­sion­al qual­ity of the meet­ing was jerked back to real­ity when George H.W. Bush, chair­man of the Re­pub­lic­an Na­tion­al Com­mit­tee, po­litely sug­ges­ted it was time for Nix­on to resign. Sev­er­al par­ti­cipants later re­por­ted that Nix­on kept talk­ing, ig­nor­ing Bush’s re­com­mend­a­tion as though it had nev­er been uttered.

Cer­tain that Nix­on hadn’t got­ten the mes­sage, Bush fol­lowed up with a per­son­al note:

“It is my con­sidered judg­ment that you should now resign. I ex­pect in your lonely em­battled po­s­i­tion this would seem to you as an act of dis­loy­alty from one you have sup­por­ted and helped in so many ways. My own view is that I would now ill serve a pres­id­ent whose massive ac­com­plish­ments I will al­ways re­spect and whose fam­ily I love, if I did not now give you my judg­ment. Un­til this mo­ment resig­na­tion has been no an­swer at all, but giv­en the im­pact of the latest de­vel­op­ment, and it will be a last­ing one, I now firmly feel resig­na­tion is best for the coun­try, best for this pres­id­ent. I be­lieve this view is held by most Re­pub­lic­an lead­ers across the coun­try. This let­ter is much more dif­fi­cult be­cause of the grat­it­ude I will al­ways have for you. If you do leave of­fice his­tory will prop­erly re­cord your achieve­ments with a last­ing re­spect.”

By day’s end, Nix­on’s de­fenses were crum­bling. All 10 Re­pub­lic­ans on the House Ju­di­ciary Com­mit­tee who had voted against im­peach­ment now agreed the pres­id­ent must go.

Wed­nes­day, Au­gust 7

Late Wed­nes­day af­ter­noon, as what little polit­ic­al sup­port he had left evap­or­ated, Nix­on met with three of his old­est friends from Con­gress: Sen­ate Minor­ity Lead­er Hugh Scott, House Minor­ity Lead­er John Rhodes, and Sen. Barry Gold­wa­ter, one of the pres­id­ent’s con­ser­vat­ive her­oes. The meet­ing las­ted only 23 minutes be­cause the lead­ers car­ried a simple, non­nego­ti­able mes­sage: If Nix­on didn’t resign, the House would im­peach him; he’d then be tried in the Sen­ate, con­victed, and re­moved from of­fice. If he were lucky, they guessed, 15 of the 100 sen­at­ors would stick with him.

Gold­wa­ter de­livered the coup de grace: If it came to that, he told his old friend, he would be among the ma­jor­ity of sen­at­ors vot­ing to con­vict. Resig­na­tion was now a fore­gone con­clu­sion.

+ New­s­week re­port­er Tom De­Frank works at his desk dur­ing the Wa­ter­gate era. (Cour­tesy of Tom De­Frank)

Thursday, Au­gust 8

With Zie­g­ler’s noon­time Thursday an­nounce­ment of a prime-time pres­id­en­tial speech, the Nix­on death watch con­sumed a White House, city, and na­tion. Shaken Nix­on staffers gamely car­ried on, strug­gling to cope with the real­ity that Nix­on was a gon­er.

One press aide re­ferred to the Nix­on fam­ily din­ner the night be­fore as “the last sup­per.” A dry-eyed West Wing sec­ret­ary said in a voice scarcely above a whis­per: “It’s like death. You know it’s com­ing but it doesn’t really hit you un­til after it hap­pens.”

One of Nix­on’s stoutest de­fend­ers, who’d been with him since the ill-fated 1960 pres­id­en­tial cam­paign against John F. Kennedy, pro­nounced the va­le­dict­ory to the tragedy of Richard Nix­on.

“When you think,” he said, pound­ing a fist on his desk, “what we could have done with the (second-term) man­date he got in 1972, it really makes you sick to your stom­ach.”

Nix­on’s fi­nal full day as pres­id­ent began with a sleep­less night. Between 3:58 a.m. and 5:15 a.m. he spoke twice with Zie­g­ler and four times with speech­writer Ray Price.

At 11 o’clock he met with Jerry Ford, an old friend since their days in the House of Rep­res­ent­at­ives in the late 1940s. For 70 minutes they talked and re­min­isced. Nix­on em­phat­ic­ally urged Ford to keep Henry Kis­sing­er as sec­ret­ary of State; Ford eagerly con­curred.

Nix­on walked around his desk, wrapped his left arm around the about-to-be pres­id­ent and wished him well.

“I was sur­prised about how cool and com­posed he was,” Ford told me in re­tire­ment. “It was a warm but … ob­vi­ously an emo­tion­al meet­ing. His com­pos­ure was strong.”

At 9:01 p.m. from the Oval Of­fice, Nix­on de­livered a 15-minute farewell ad­dress to the na­tion, ac­know­ledging his polit­ic­al base had eroded to the point where he couldn’t be ef­fect­ive.

“I have nev­er been a quit­ter,” he said. “To leave of­fice be­fore my term is com­pleted is ab­hor­rent to every in­stinct in my body. But as pres­id­ent, I must put the in­terest of Amer­ica first. Amer­ica needs a full-time pres­id­ent and a full-time Con­gress, par­tic­u­larly at this time with prob­lems we face at home and abroad.

“There­fore, I shall resign the pres­id­ency ef­fect­ive at noon to­mor­row.”

Across Pennsylvania Av­en­ue in La­fay­ette Square, thou­sands of Nix­on-haters, Vi­et­nam War pro­test­ers, and gawkers had gathered in the en­er­vat­ing hu­mid­ity to await the in­ev­it­able and wit­ness a pivot point in his­tory. At the pre­cise in­stant Nix­on an­nounced his resig­na­tion, a shriek of ju­bil­a­tion erup­ted from the crowd, a roar so loud and gut­tur­al that it cas­caded across the av­en­ue, North Lawn of the White House, and through the sealed win­dows of the brief­ing room. As I watched from a small black-and-white tele­vi­sion in the base­ment, the noise drowned out Nix­on’s next line: “Vice Pres­id­ent Ford will be sworn in as pres­id­ent at that hour in this of­fice.”

The hair on my arms stood straight up. Forty years later, that hap­pens again without fail each time I re­peat the story.

What he termed “the Wa­ter­gate mat­ter” was men­tioned in passing. “I would say only that if some of my judg­ments were wrong, and some were wrong, they were made in what I be­lieved at the time to be the best in­terest of the na­tion,” an as­ser­tion long ago re­jec­ted by a ma­jor­ity of Amer­ic­ans.

It was an em­in­ently pres­id­en­tial per­form­ance, meas­ured and states­man­like, per­haps his finest speech in nearly 30 years as a con­gress­man, sen­at­or, vice pres­id­ent, and pres­id­ent.

 

+ Demon­strat­ors with the Na­tion­al Cam­paign to Im­peach Nix­on pass the White House and Wash­ing­ton Monu­ment on a march to Cap­it­ol Hill on April 27, 1974 to urge law­makers to speed up im­peach­ment of Pres­id­ent Nix­on. (UPI Photo)   

Fri­day, Au­gust 9

His of­fi­cial farewell had been de­livered in a firm, steady voice, ab­sent malice and devoid of emo­tion. Not so the next morn­ing, when Nix­on as­sembled sev­er­al hun­dred friends and staffers in the East Room for a speech so wrench­ing to watch that even some arch-en­emies ad­mit­ted a pang of sym­pathy for a hu­mi­li­ated fel­low hu­man strug­gling to keep from un­rav­el­ing.

As many in the audi­ence wept openly and he him­self al­most broke down more than once, Nix­on was ram­bling, dis­join­ted, tor­tured, awk­ward, maudlin — and, in his own way, power­ful.

Poignantly he paid trib­ute to his par­ents; first his fath­er, a failed lem­on ranch­er yet still a “great man” be­cause he did his job des­pite many trav­ails.

Then, he re­min­isced, al­most break­ing down, “My moth­er was a saint.”

How Nix­on got through it I’ll nev­er know. But some­how he did, at times rising to an elo­quence that oth­er­wise eluded him his en­tire ca­reer.

To­ward the end, he spoke a line for the ages:

“Al­ways re­mem­ber, oth­ers may hate you, but those who hate you don’t win un­less you hate them — and then you des­troy your­self.”

Noble words, in­deed. Yet this was the same guy, I thought at that mo­ment, who kept an “en­emies list” of polit­ic­al op­pon­ents, railed in private against blacks and Jews, and vowed to un­leash the IRS to settle scores with those he was con­vinced were out to des­troy him.

Still, it was ar­gu­ably Nix­on’s most mem­or­able mo­ment in pub­lic life.

Wait­ing out­side on the South Lawn, Man­olo Sanc­hez, Nix­on’s faith­ful Cuban-born valet, was pre­par­ing to ac­com­pany the boss in­to ex­ile with his wife Fina, Pat Nix­on’s as­sist­ant. “I de­cide is my duty to go with this man be­cause I know he’s kinda sad,” a be­wildered Sanc­hez told me. “I don’t be­lieve this thing hap­pen.”

Three minutes after his East Room farewell, Nix­on and his fam­ily joined Jerry and Betty Ford. They walked down a long red car­pet between a mil­it­ary hon­or guard. The wives em­braced, their hus­bands shook hands.

“Dick, I’m sorry about this, you did a good job.” Ford said. “Good luck, Jerry,” the 37th pres­id­ent replied.

He briskly walked up Army One’s ramp, turn­ing for a ma­gis­teri­al wave to thun­der­ous ap­plause. Then, al­most as an af­ter­thought, he snapped off that fi­nal de­fi­ant ges­ture his lib­er­al ad­versar­ies hated most: the double V-for-vic­tory sa­lute.

From his cab­in, Nix­on stared at the red car­pet be­ing rolled up, an­oth­er meta­phor of de­cline. The heli­copter lif­ted slowly, banked to star­board to­ward the Jef­fer­son Me­mori­al, then turned left for the short hop to An­drews Air Force Base and ex­ile to his La Casa Pa­ci­fica re­treat in San Clem­ente, Cal­if.

Walk­ing back to the press room to file a pool re­port, I happened upon a riv­et­ing im­age: the head of Nix­on’s se­cur­ity de­tail star­ing at the van­ish­ing helo, tears stream­ing down both cheeks.

“I totally lost it,” Dick Keiser told me years later over lunch. “I couldn’t help it. We’re all trained to re­act without emo­tion, to take a bul­let for a guy no mat­ter what we think of him per­son­ally. But after all he’d been through, you just couldn’t help feel­ing bad for him.”

Keiser is now a hale 80, long re­tired from the Secret Ser­vice, but the memor­ies of that mo­ment on the South Lawn en­dure. “You’re will­ing to lit­er­ally spend your life pro­tect­ing someone,” he re­membered last week, “and all of a sud­den watch­ing them suf­fer the greatest hurt of their life and you can’t do any­thing about it — I was help­less. It was very emo­tion­al for me.”

 

+ A his­tor­ic­al note marks park­ing spot D32 on Aug. 19, 2011 in a park­ing gar­age where Wash­ing­ton Post re­port­er Bob Wood­ward met in secret with his source “Deep Throat” (seni­or FBI of­fi­cial Mark Felt). (Saul Loeb/AFP/Getty)

Three minutes past noon, Jerry Ford was sworn in as the 38th pres­id­ent — on the same East Room plat­form where Nix­on said his farewells two hours earli­er. Tech­nic­ally, he was already pres­id­ent; Nix­on’s one-sen­tence resig­na­tion let­ter to Sec­ret­ary of State Henry Kis­sing­er was re­ceived at 11:35.

Ford had gra­ciously set aside prime seats for many of Nix­on’s seni­or aides. I still re­mem­ber Al Haig pat­ting a grim-faced Rose­mary Woods on the arm, try­ing to as­sure Nix­on’s most ded­ic­ated, loy­al-to-a-fault per­son­al as­sist­ant that time would heal her grief. Woods wasn’t buy­ing it; she stared word­lessly straight ahead at the po­di­um where her be­loved boss had still been lead­er of the free world just that morn­ing.

“My fel­low Amer­ic­ans, our long na­tion­al night­mare is over,” Ford re­as­sured. “Our Con­sti­tu­tion works; our great re­pub­lic is a gov­ern­ment of laws and not of men. Here the people rule.”

When he asked the coun­try to pray for Nix­on, Ford’s voice quavered and his eyes mis­ted: “May our former pres­id­ent, who brought peace to mil­lions, find it for him­self.”

It had been a re­mark­able 24 hours of tri­umph and tragedy — tri­umph for demo­cracy’s re­si­li­ence and the rule of law, tragedy for a man and a pres­id­ent.

Leav­ing the White House hours later that mo­nu­ment­al Fri­day, I un­ex­pec­tedly came upon one last bit of drama, a hope­ful omen that Nix­on’s leav­ing may have fi­nally be­gun a heal­ing pro­cess the coun­try so des­per­ately craved.

For weeks, a de­term­ined band of pro­test­ers on the north side of Pennsylvania Av­en­ue had waved ban­ners ur­ging mo­tor­ists to “honk if you think he’s guilty.” My en­dur­ing memory of that mo­ment­ous sum­mer was en­ter­ing and leav­ing the White House ser­en­aded by a ca­co­phony of horns. The honk­ing went on for hours day after day, well in­to the night.

Now, with one pres­id­ent ab­ruptly gone and his suc­cessor pledging to “bind up the in­tern­al wounds of Wa­ter­gate, more pain­ful and more pois­on­ous than any for­eign wars,” the horns at last were si­lent.

What We're Following See More »
TIME TO SPLIT
House Passes CR, Sends Bill to President’s Desk
4 hours ago
THE LATEST
CAN’T NAME ONE WORLD LEADER
Gary Johnson Stumbles Again
5 hours ago
WHY WE CARE
GOES TO PRESIDENT
Senate Approves Bill to Preserve Rape Kits
6 hours ago
THE LATEST

"The Senate on Wednesday approved legislation ensuring sexual assault survivors in federal criminal cases have access to forensic evidence collection kits, sending the bill to President Obama's desk. The legislation, known as the Survivors’ Bill of Rights Act, was passed by unanimous consent as lawmakers prepare to leave Washington until after the election. The House passed the measure earlier this month."

Source:
2-MONTH GIG OR 8-YEAR GIG?
Alec Baldwin to Play Trump on ‘SNL’
7 hours ago
THE DETAILS
STRIKES DOWN NEW HAMPSHIRE BAN
Court: Selfies in Voting Booth Now OK
9 hours ago
WHY WE CARE
×