How to Renounce America and Still Be Called a Patriot

Her father is a senator, she’s a CEO, and her company is forsaking its U.S. citizenship.

National Journal
Ron Fournier
Add to Briefcase
See more stories about...
Ron Fournier
July 16, 2014, 5:58 p.m.

This story is about a gil­ded class of people and cor­por­a­tions en­riched by the new Amer­ic­an eco­nomy while the rest of its cit­izens pay the tab. The prot­ag­on­ists could be any num­ber of in­sti­tu­tion­al elites, but this column hap­pens to be about a Demo­crat­ic sen­at­or from West Vir­gin­ia, Joe Manchin, and his daugh­ter, Heath­er Bresch, the chief ex­ec­ut­ive of Mylan, a gi­ant maker of gen­er­ic drugs based out­side Pitt­s­burgh.

Her com­pany’s profits come largely from Medi­caid and Medi­care, which means her nest is feathered by U.S. tax­pay­ers. On Monday, Bresch an­nounced that Mylan will re­nounce its United States cit­izen­ship and in­stead be­come in­cor­por­ated in the Neth­er­lands ““ leav­ing this coun­try, in part, to pay less in taxes.

This is the sort of story that makes blood boil in pop­u­lists ““ voters from the Eliza­beth War­ren wing of the Demo­crat­ic Party to liber­tari­ans who fol­low Rand Paul and in­clud­ing tea party con­ser­vat­ives. These dis­il­lu­sioned souls, grow­ing in num­bers, hate hy­po­crites who con­demn the U.S. polit­ic­al sys­tem while gam­ing it.

Pop­u­lists can’t be happy with how this story was told by An­drew Ross Sor­kin of the New York Times. Un­der the head­line “Re­luct­antly, Pat­ri­ot Flees Home­land for Green­er Tax Pas­tures,” Sor­kin cast Bresch as a help­less vic­tim of a sys­tem that has made her wealthy and her fath­er power­ful.

Heath­er Bresch grew up around polit­ics. Her fath­er is Joe Manchin, the Demo­crat­ic sen­at­or from West Vir­gin­ia and a former gov­ernor. She has heard him say re­peatedly, “We live in the greatest coun­try on Earth,” as he did in count­less polit­ic­al ad­vert­ise­ments. And it ap­peared to rub off on her: Ms. Bresch was named a “Pat­ri­ot of the Year” in 2011 by Es­quire magazine for help­ing to push through the F.D.A. Safety In­nov­a­tion Act.

Ah, so she’s a pat­ri­ot. Bresch told Sor­kin that she en­gin­eered the com­pany’s di­vorce from the United States “re­luct­antly,” and, the re­port­er ad­ded, “she genu­inely seems to mean it.” That cred­u­lous line was fol­lowed by two para­graphs about cor­por­ate tax rates, an im­port­ant re­mind­er of how slowly polit­ic­al and busi­ness lead­ers are ad­apt­ing to the glob­al, tech-in­fused eco­nomy.

If Ms. Bresch’s deal is not a call to Wash­ing­ton to ad­dress what is clearly a grow­ing trend that it has re­mained nearly si­lent on, the na­tion will most likely con­tin­ue to lose large em­ploy­ers and tax­pay­ers in droves to coun­tries with lower tax rates. Al­most 20 large United States com­pan­ies have an­nounced plans to give up their United States cit­izen­ship over the last two years. Just on Monday, the Ir­ish drug maker Shire cleared the way for a mer­ger with Ab­bVie, the drug maker based in Chica­go, and Wal­green is con­sid­er­ing an in­ver­sion through a deal with Al­li­ance Boots, a European drug­store chain.

“It’s not like I’ve not been vo­cal and up there talk­ing to any­body who’d listen to me,” Ms. Bresch told me in an in­ter­view about the cru­sade she had been on in Wash­ing­ton for years, talk­ing to law­makers about over­haul­ing the cor­por­ate tax code to make United States com­pan­ies more com­pet­it­ive. “But you know what they all say? ‘Yeah, uh huh, O.K. Uh huh.’ “

That’s ripe. The daugh­ter of a U.S. sen­at­or and former gov­ernor ““ a Pat­ri­ot of the Year, no less ““ says she got lip-ser­vice from Con­gress. Just like you and me.

To his cred­it, Sor­kin says there is something “mor­ally dis­con­cert­ing” about a com­pany bolt­ing a coun­try that is among its biggest cus­tom­ers. Still, he writes, Bresch “in­sists that the mer­ger is be­ing driv­en mostly by its stra­tegic mer­its, and that the lower tax rate is just an ad­ded be­ne­fit.” OK, now. That’s hard to swal­low. How much in taxes will she save by jilt­ing the United States?

Ms. Bresch, who said the com­pany’s cur­rent ef­fect­ive tax rate is about 25 per­cent, said the rate would come down to 21 per­cent in the first year of the deal and then move in­to the high teens after three to five years. Mylan will con­tin­ue to pay taxes in the United States on its do­mest­ic profits, but not on its busi­ness op­er­a­tions abroad.

All of which raises an im­port­ant ques­tion: Even if the United States were to re­vamp its cor­por­ate tax code, how low would the rate have to drop to be com­pet­it­ive and still raise enough rev­en­ue to pay for the ser­vices that cit­izens ex­pect?

Cor­por­ate taxes will go as low as or­din­ary voters can stand it, no doubt, be­cause their rates are de­term­ined by power­ful spe­cial in­terests and elites like Bresch and her fath­er. Manchin wouldn’t speak to me, but he did is­sue a nugat­ory state­ment to Sor­kin ““ something about be­ing “dis­ap­poin­ted” when U.S. com­pan­ies “feel the need to move over­seas be­cause of the U.S. tax code.”

Too bad Manchin isn’t in a pos­tion to feel the need and find a way to keep Mylan pay­ing taxes to the United States, the coun­try that pre­sum­ably will con­tin­ue to en­rich her firm via Medi­care and Medi­caid. Would he try to cut fed­er­al drug pay­ments to Mylan by roughly the amount of taxes his daugh­ter is tak­ing to the Neth­er­lands? I don’t know, be­cause my call to the sen­at­or’s of­fice was not re­turned.

As for Amer­ic­ans less priv­ileged and power­ful than these two char­ac­ters, your role is clear: Just cast your votes and pay the bills.

What We're Following See More »
Chaffetz Also Caves, Says He’ll Vote Trump
1 hours ago
DNC Sues RNC Over Trump’s Rigged Vote Comments
1 hours ago

The Democratic National Committee sued the Republican National Committee in U.S. District Court in New Jersey for aiding GOP nominee Donald Trump as he argues that the presidential election is "rigged." The DNC claims "that Trump's argument is designed to suppress the vote in minority communities."

Clinton Foundation Staffers Steered Biz to Bill
9 hours ago

"Two chief fundraisers for the Clinton Foundation pressed corporate donors to steer business opportunities to former President Bill Clinton as well, according to a hacked memo published Wednesday by WikiLeaks. The November 2011 memo from Douglas Band, at the time a top aide to Mr. Clinton, outlines extensive fundraising efforts that Mr. Band and a partner deployed on behalf of the Clinton Foundation and how that work sometimes translated into large speaking fees and other paid work for Mr. Clinton."

House Investigators Already Sharpening Their Spears for Clinton
18 hours ago

House Oversight Committee Chairman Jason Chaffetz plans to spend "years, come January, probing the record of a President Hillary Clinton." Chaffetz told the Washington Post: “It’s a target-rich environment. Even before we get to Day One, we’ve got two years’ worth of material already lined up. She has four years of history at the State Department, and it ain’t good.”

Clinton Super PAC Enters the House Fray
23 hours ago

Priorities USA, the super PAC aligned with the Clinton campaign, which has already gotten involved in two Senate races, is now expanding into House races. The group released a 30 second spot which serves to hit Donald Trump and Iowa Rep. Rod Blum, who is in a tough race to win re-election in Iowa's first congressional district. The super PAC's expansion into House and Senate races shows a high level of confidence in Clinton's standing against Trump.


Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.