Despite New Rules, Prisoners Still Paying Big to Call Home

Recent reforms were hailed as progress, but advocates say the system is still riddled with problems.

A telephone and a toilet are shown in the holding cell area where arrestees are allowed their phone call at the Santa Barbara County Sheriff Substation May 10, 2005 in Orcutt, California.
National Journal
Alex Brown
Add to Briefcase
Alex Brown
July 9, 2014, 1:13 p.m.

Re­cent fed­er­al re­forms aimed at pro­tect­ing pris­on­ers from ex­or­bit­ant phone bills still fall short of rein­ing in prices on the the vast ma­jor­ity of in­mate calls, fed­er­al of­fi­cials and pris­on­ers’ ad­voc­ates said Wed­nes­day.

The new rules, en­acted in Feb­ru­ary by the Fed­er­al Com­mu­nic­a­tions Com­mis­sion, cap prices for out-of-state calls. But most calls from pris­on­ers are in-state com­mu­nic­a­tions, which re­main un­reg­u­lated.

Ad­voc­ates say call fees have long been a prob­lem for in­mates and their fam­il­ies. Costly charges can leave pris­on­ers with thou­sands of dol­lars in phone bills when they get out. In some cases, people have been forced to choose between phone calls and food. And chil­dren who lack reg­u­lar con­tact with their in­car­cer­ated par­ents are more likely to miss school, be­come home­less, or suf­fer de­pres­sion.

The FCC, led by in­ter­im Chair­wo­man Mignon Cly­burn, took a step to­ward ad­dress­ing that prob­lem last year. The agency’s rul­ing capped prices for in­ter­state phone calls at 21 cents per minute for pre­paid calls and 25 cents per minute for col­lect calls. Pre­vi­ous prices had ex­ceeded $1 a minute in some cases.

When the FCC put forth its ori­gin­al rul­ing in 2013, it ex­pressed a de­sire to ad­dress in-state rates as well, seek­ing com­ment on pos­sible pro­pos­als to do so. But the tele­phone com­pan­ies that chal­lenged the out-of-state caps have threatened op­pos­i­tion to in-state rules as well, and any FCC at­tempt to re­form them would likely trig­ger a leg­al battle over the FCC’s jur­is­dic­tion.

But with in-state calls still un­reg­u­lated, some pris­on­ers are pay­ing much more for their loc­al calls. In New Jer­sey, for in­stance, some in-state calls can run more than $8 for 15 minutes on the phone.

“The re­forms thus far, though sig­ni­fic­ant, have had very little im­pact be­cause the ma­jor­ity of in­mate call­ing is in­trastate,” said Dar­rell Baker, an Alabama util­ity of­fi­cial who has led that state’s push to lower its call rates.

“The FCC’s de­cision did a lot, but it cer­tainly didn’t help for large num­bers of people,” said Cheryl Leanza, an ad­voc­ate with the United Church of Christ.

FCC lead­ers, in­clud­ing Cly­burn, Wheel­er, and Com­mis­sion­er Jes­sica Rosen­wor­cel, said last year’s re­forms are a start­ing point, but agreed that in-state calls still need to be ad­dressed.

“We re­cog­nize that more needs to be done,” FCC Chair­man Tom Wheel­er said in his open­ing re­marks at a Wed­nes­day pan­el at the agency’s Wash­ing­ton headquar­ters.

The FCC, however, is ask­ing states to take the lead on in­trastate call­ing. Some states — in­clud­ing Alabama — have taken steps to pro­tect pris­on­ers from pred­at­ory rates.

Sim­il­ar to the FCC’s out-of-state rules, Alabama moved re­cently to cap in-state call fees at 25 cents per minute.

But with most states still in­act­ive on the is­sue, some are call­ing for fed­er­al in­ter­ven­tion.

“The FCC has both the duty and the au­thor­ity to act un­der the stat­ute if states do not,” Cly­burn said.

Oth­ers think the FCC’s role should be lim­ited ad­vising state of­fi­cials.

“Much of the heavy lift­ing is now left to the states,” said Jesse Wiese, who works with the faith-based crim­in­al-justice re­form group Justice Fel­low­ship. “We don’t think the com­mis­sion should reg­u­late in­trastate calls.” Wiese said the agency should fo­cus on work­ing with law­makers and reg­u­lat­ors around the coun­try to en­act re­forms.

But in­mate call­ing prob­lems aren’t lim­ited to high in­trastate prices. Many pris­on­ers, said pan­el­ists, are fre­quently plagued by dropped calls. Those are gen­er­ally the fault of three-way de­tec­tion sys­tems, which ex­ist to pre­vent pris­on­ers’ calls from be­ing routed to an­oth­er — un­known — re­cip­i­ent. The prob­lem is that these sys­tems can be overly sens­it­ive, cut­ting off calls when they pick up back­ground noise like a child or wind. “When the call is dropped, the pris­on­er has to call back again, which leads to an­oth­er call-hook­up fee,” said Paul Wright, who heads the Hu­man Rights De­fense Cen­ter.

Baker ad­ded that dropped calls have been the No. 1 com­plaint among the pris­on­ers with whom he’s talked.

Com­mis­sion­ers also men­tioned oth­er pri­or­it­ies in con­tinu­ing to re­form in­mate call­ing ser­vices. Wheel­er, Cly­burn, and Rosen­wor­cel all ex­pressed a de­sire to make the in­ter­state rate caps per­man­ent. The cur­rent fig­ures were set on an in­ter­im status as the agency col­lects more data to set per­man­ent rates.

“The re­lief for fam­ily and friends has been tre­mend­ous,” said Cly­burn, cit­ing the rul­ing’s early suc­cess. “Call volumes have in­creased as much as 30 per­cent.”

What We're Following See More »
FEDERAL APPEALS COURT FINALIZES DECISION
Obama-Era Fiduciary Rule Is Dead
2 hours ago
THE LATEST

"After a long delay, the U.S. Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals confirmed Thursday a March decision to strike down the Labor Department's fiduciary rule. The court issued a mandate making effective the March 15 split decision that vacated the DOL regulation. The court majority held that the agency exceeded its authority in promulgating the rule, which would have required brokers to act in the best interests of their clients in retirement accounts. In the mandate, the court also said the Labor Department has to pay the financial industry plaintiffs the costs related to the appeal."

Source:
$3.2 BILLION WORTH OF GOODS
EU Responds with a Round of Tariffs on American Products
3 hours ago
THE LATEST

"The European Union fought back on Friday against the Trump administration’s tariffs, slapping penalties on an array of American products that target the president’s political base, like bourbon, motorcycles and orange juice. The European counterattack on $3.2 billion of goods, a response to the administration’s measures on steel and aluminum imports, adds another front to a trade war that has engulfed allies and adversaries around the world."

Source:
TEXAS AND ARKANSAS BASES COULD ACCOMMODATE KIDS
U.S. May House 20K Immigrants on Military Bases
3 hours ago
THE LATEST

"The United States is preparing to shelter as many as 20,000 migrant children on four American military bases" in Texas and Arkansas, "as federal officials struggled to carry out President Trump’s order to keep immigrant families together after they are apprehended at the border."

Source:
INCLUDES FOOD STAMP REFORMS
House Narrowly Passes Five-Year Farm Bill
3 hours ago
THE LATEST

"The House narrowly approved a five-year farm bill on Thursday that would impose new work requirements on people who receive food stamps. The legislation initially failed after conservatives demanded a vote on a conservative-backed immigration bill in exchange for their support last month. But the House was able to push the bill forward on Thursday in a 213-211 vote."

Source:
CONFERENCE ASKS FOR FURTHER CHANGES
Vote on Compromise Immigration Bill Gets Bumped to Next Week
15 hours ago
THE LATEST

"House Republican leaders are further delaying a vote on a compromise immigration bill, planning to make changes to the legislation for a vote next week. The news comes after a two-hour Republican Conference meeting Thursday, in which authors of the bill walked through its contents and members raised concerns about issues the bill doesn’t address, multiple GOP lawmakers said. Many members requested the addition of a provision to require employers to use the E-Verify database to cheek the legal status of their employees."

Source:
×
×

Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.

Login