Hobby Lobby and the Rush Limbaugh Effect

We’ve forgotten Sandra Fluke’s message even as she’s become a household name.

Georgetown Law student Sandra Fluke. 
National Journal
Lucia Graves
July 8, 2014, 1 a.m.

It’s one of the quirks of the con­ver­sa­tion around con­tra­cep­tion that hardly any­one re­calls what Sandra Fluke was ac­tu­ally say­ing in the testi­mony that cata­pul­ted her to na­tion­al at­ten­tion. What people re­mem­ber is that, at some point in the course of the 2012 elec­tions, Rush Limbaugh called her a slut.

And just like that, an in­tel­li­gent con­ver­sa­tion about the med­ic­al needs of mil­lions of Amer­ic­ans turned in­to an as­in­ine In­ter­net firestorm over wheth­er the Geor­getown Uni­versity law stu­dent could right­fully be called a sex­ist slur. Fluke ap­peared on NBC to say she was “stunned” and “out­raged.” Rush penned a rare mea culpa. And Pres­id­ent Obama reached out to her per­son­ally, to em­path­ize. The cov­er­age was such that The Week felt the need to run a large graph­ic en­titled “Rush Limbaugh vs. Sandra Fluke: A Timeline.”

The out­rage was mer­ited, but it was not a re­place­ment for a policy dis­cus­sion about the point that Fluke was ac­tu­ally mak­ing in her testi­mony: that there are sun­dry med­ic­al reas­ons wo­men need ac­cess to birth con­trol as a mat­ter of routine health, in­clud­ing cyst and can­cer pre­ven­tion. It also, as MS­N­BCs Ben­jy Sarlin re­cently mused, has been al­most en­tirely for­got­ten.

{{third­PartyEmbed type:you­tube id:xlRC0n­s­jtKQ}}

So let’s set the re­cord straight. Fluke’s testi­mony re­volved around wo­men for whom ac­cess to con­tra­cept­ives is a med­ic­al im­per­at­ive, not simply a way to pre­vent preg­nancy. In par­tic­u­lar, she fo­cused on a les­bi­an friend of hers at Geor­getown who needed the pill to reg­u­late a com­mon med­ic­al con­di­tion. “In the worst cases wo­men who need this med­ic­a­tion for oth­er med­ic­al reas­ons suf­fer very dire med­ic­al con­sequences,” Fluke said at the time. “A friend of mine, for ex­ample, has poly­cyst­ic ovari­an syn­drome and she has to take pre­scrip­tion birth con­trol to stop cysts from form­ing on her ovar­ies.”

While she made a nu­anced ar­gu­ment for the med­ic­al be­ne­fits of birth con­trol, all we re­mem­ber is later she got labeled a slut. Call it the Rush Limbaugh ef­fect and chalk it up to mis­takes made 2012. The trouble is, it’s still hap­pen­ing, and the rul­ing in the Hobby Lobby case last week is a per­fect ex­ample of how.

The Su­preme Court’s ma­jor­ity opin­ion, which found that closely held cor­por­a­tions may for re­li­gious reas­ons deny their em­ploy­ees cer­tain forms of con­tra­cept­ive cov­er­age, made zero men­tions of wo­men who rely on the pill for med­ic­al reas­ons. It’s not be­cause it wasn’t in any of the leg­al lit­er­at­ure presen­ted to the Court be­fore the de­cision.

“Poly­cyst­ic ovari­an syn­drome” just doesn’t have the same ring to it as “slut.”

An at­tor­ney who cowrote a brief to the Su­preme Court on be­half of ovari­an-can­cer ad­voc­ates said the justices (to say noth­ing of the gen­er­al pub­lic) have failed to con­sider the broad­er nar­rat­ive. “The de­bate was mis-framed as a con­tra­cept­ive de­bate from the be­gin­ning,” Michelle Kisloff, a part­ner at Hogan Lov­ells, told me. “We’ve tried to re­cast that de­bate to ori­ent the Court to the fact that there’s more go­ing on here than preg­nancy and con­tra­cep­tion, but ul­ti­mately the Court went with the way Hobby Lobby had char­ac­ter­ized it.”

That’s not however, be­cause Fluke’s friend is alone in her health prob­lems. PCOS is a com­mon con­di­tion. In fact, as I noted in my piece Thursday, PCOS is the single most fre­quent en­do­crine prob­lem in wo­men of re­pro­duct­ive age, af­fect­ing 5 to 10 per­cent of the fe­male pop­u­la­tion. And hor­mone reg­u­la­tion, via or­al con­tra­cept­ives, is the best known treat­ment.

That the highly for­get­table name makes the con­di­tion sound more ob­scure than it ac­tu­ally is is such a big prob­lem that ex­perts have long re­com­men­ded re­nam­ing the con­di­tion, which af­fects ap­prox­im­ately 5 mil­lion wo­men of re­pro­duct­ive age in the United States. It’s one of a hand­ful of med­ic­al con­di­tions — in­clud­ing en­do­met­ri­os­is, en­do­metri­al can­cer, and ovari­an can­cer — that were ig­nored in last week’s Hobby Lobby de­cision. Not that you’d know it from the tran­script of or­al ar­gu­ments or the cov­er­age of the de­cision that fol­lowed.

The way the Court and the me­dia have been talk­ing about it has more in com­mon with the Limbaugh per­spect­ive. “Sex, sex, sex. That’s what it’s all about,” Limbaugh said over the week­end. “Every­body wants it and whatever it takes to make it safe. And if it takes the tax­pay­er buy­ing wo­men birth con­trol than men are for it too.” In an­oth­er, he claimed wo­men wouldn’t need birth con­trol if they simply “didn’t do a cer­tain thing.”

If Amer­ic­ans have for­got­ten Fluke’s mes­sage, they haven’t for­got­ten Fluke. Though her star has faded con­sid­er­ably since the days of Limbaugh la­beling her with idi­ot­ic epi­thets, she’s back in the news this elec­tion cycle — this time as a can­did­ate.

What We're Following See More »
Jerry Brown Backs Clinton
36 minutes ago

California Gov. Jerry Brown endorsed Hillary Clinton today, calling her "the only path forward to win the presidency and stop the dangerous candidacy of Donald Trump." While praising Sen. Bernie Sanders' campaign, Brown said "Clinton’s lead is insurmountable and Democrats have shown – by millions of votes – that they want her as their nominee. ... This is no time for Democrats to keep fighting each other. The general election has already begun."

Clinton Says Voters Still Hung Up on Gender
3 hours ago

In a New York Magazine profile, Hillary Clinton said she still encounters misogyny at her own events: “‘I really admire you, I really like you, I just don’t know if I can vote for a woman to be president.’ I mean, they come to my events and then they say that to me.”

Trump Vows Not to Change
4 hours ago
McConnell Urging Rubio to Run for Reelection
6 hours ago

Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell: "One of the things that I’m hoping, I and my colleagues have been trying to convince Senator Marco Rubio to run again in Florida. He had indicated he was not going to, but we’re all hoping that he’ll reconsider, because poll data indicates that he is the one who can win for us. He would not only save a terrific senator for the Senate, but help save the majority. ... Well, I hope so. We’re all lobbying hard for him to run again."

Holder: Snowden Performed a Public Service
9 hours ago

Former Attorney General Eric Holder said that NSA leaker Edward Snowden "actually performed a public service by raising the debate that we engaged in and by the changes that we made" by releasing information about government surveillance. Holder, a guest on David Axelrod's "Axe Files" podcast, also said Snowden endangered American interests and should face consequences for his actions.