Judge Rejects Kentucky’s Arguments Against Same-Sex Marriage With So Much Sass

The governor’s arguments in favor of the ban are “at best illogical and even bewildering,” the federal judge writes.

A supporter of same-sex marriage holds American and gay pride flags in San Francisco
National Journal
Sarah Mimms
See more stories about...
Sarah Mimms
July 1, 2014, 9:47 a.m.

A fed­er­al judge ruled Tues­day that Ken­tucky’s ban on same-sex mar­riage vi­ol­ates gay and les­bi­an couples’ equal-pro­tec­tion rights un­der the Four­teenth Amend­ment. U.S. Dis­trict Court Judge John G. Hey­burn II im­me­di­ately is­sued a stay — mean­ing that wed­ding bells in the Bluegrass State won’t be ringing while the state pur­sues an ap­peal — but he did take the op­por­tun­ity to snark about what he termed the state’s “be­wil­der­ing” at­tempts to up­hold the ban.

Demo­crat­ic Gov. Steve Be­s­hear and his at­tor­neys ar­gued — as oth­ers have in sim­il­ar cases across the coun­try — that giv­en the Su­preme Court’s re­fus­al to take up a gay-mar­riage case in 1972 and the fact that same-sex couples can­not pro­cre­ate “nat­ur­ally,” that Ken­tucky should be al­lowed to keep its ban on gay mar­riage. As in many oth­er cases across the coun­try, the court re­jec­ted those ar­gu­ments.

But this is where Be­s­hear and his law­yers get cre­at­ive or, as Hey­burn put it, “disin­genu­ous.” Mar­riage between het­ero­sexu­al couples, they ar­gued, con­trib­utes “to a stable birth rate which, in turn, en­sures the state’s long-term eco­nom­ic sta­bil­ity.”

Hey­burn, to put it mildly, didn’t buy­ing that ar­gu­ment:

Even as­sum­ing the state has a le­git­im­ate in­terest in pro­mot­ing pro­cre­ation, the Court fails to see, and De­fend­ant nev­er ex­plains, how the ex­clu­sion of same-sex couples from mar­riage has any ef­fect what­so­ever on pro­cre­ation among het­ero­sexu­al spouses. Ex­clud­ing same-sex couples from mar­riage does not change the num­ber of het­ero­sexu­al couples who choose to get mar­ried, the num­ber who choose to have chil­dren, or the num­ber of chil­dren they have.

… The state’s at­tempts to con­nect the ex­clu­sion of same-sex couples from mar­riage to its in­terest in eco­nom­ic sta­bil­ity and in “en­sur­ing hu­man­ity’s con­tin­ued ex­ist­ence” are at best il­lo­gic­al and even be­wil­der­ing.

Hey­burn went on to ar­gue that un­der that lo­gic, Ken­tucky could leg­ally deny mar­riage li­censes to couples who could not pro­cre­ate, or chose not to.

Cit­ing pri­or case law, Hey­burn con­cluded: “This Court bases its rul­ing primar­ily upon the ut­ter lack of lo­gic­al re­la­tion between the ex­clu­sion of same-sex couples from mar­riages and any con­ceiv­able le­git­im­ate state in­terest. Any re­la­tion­ship between Ken­tucky’s ban on same-sex mar­riage and its in­terest in pro­cre­ation and long-term eco­nom­ic sta­bil­ity ‘is so at­ten­u­ated as to render the dis­tinc­tion ar­bit­rary or ir­ra­tion­al.’”

Hey­burn wrote an earli­er opin­ion in Feb­ru­ary, alert­ing Ken­tucky that it would have to im­me­di­ately re­cog­nize same-sex mar­riages that were per­formed out-of-state. That rul­ing is be­ing ap­pealed as well. The Sixth Dis­trict Court of Ap­peals will hear or­al ar­gu­ments in the Ken­tucky case and cases in oth­er states be­gin­ning Aug. 6.

For more on the cur­rent state of the battle for same-sex mar­riage, check out our map of laws, court cases and le­gis­lat­ive fights across the coun­try.

What We're Following See More »
UTAH REPUBLICAN
Former Sen. Bob Bennett Dies at 82
1 hours ago
THE DETAILS

Former Utah Republican Sen. Bob Bennett died of pancreatic cancer on Wednesday after a long battle with pancreatic cancer. Bennett was defeated in a primary in 2010 by Tea Party–backed Mike Lee.

Source:
CLINTON HERSELF COULD TESTIFY LATER
Judge Approves Deposition of Clinton Aides
1 hours ago
THE LATEST

"Judge Emmet G. Sullivan, of the United States District Court for the District of Columbia, approved a joint proposal presented by Judicial Watch and the State Department to take the depositions of officials" involved in the setup and use of Hillary Clinton's private email server, "including Cheryl D. Mills, Clinton's former chief of staff, Huma Abedin, a senior adviser to Clinton, and Bryan Pagliano, a State Department employee who serviced and maintained the server." He said Clinton could be deposed later on, though that may not be necessary.

Source:
‘WORLD CLASS’ ORGANIZATION
Trump Will Not Self Fund the General Election
1 hours ago
THE LATEST

Donald Trump will not self-finance his general election campaign as he did the primary season, instead relying on "his expansive personal Rolodex" to create what he called a “world-class finance organization." 

Source:
STATE HAS UNTIL MONDAY TO RESPOND
DOJ: North Carolina’s CB2 Violates Civil Rights Act
2 hours ago
THE LATEST

Department of Justice officials told North Carolina Gov. Pat McCrory that "the law violates the U.S. Civil Rights Act and Title IX—a finding that could jeopardize billions in federal education funding. The department gave state officials until Monday to respond 'by confirming that the State will not comply with or implement HB2.'"

Source:
GOOGLE SEARCHES SPIKE
Libertarians Getting a Second Look?
16 hours ago
WHY WE CARE
×