Obama, Clinton, and Carter Represent Different Generations in Racial Struggles

President Barack Obama, right, looks on as  former president Bill Clinton, speaks in a building under construction in Washington, Friday, Dec. 2, 2011, part of   President Obama's  Better Building Initiative to promote energy efficient buildings. 
National Journal
George E. Condon Jr.
Aug. 27, 2013, 3:30 p.m.

The bright­est spot­light Wed­nes­day at the rally com­mem­or­at­ing the 50th an­niversary of the his­tor­ic March on Wash­ing­ton will shine on Pres­id­ent Obama. That is as it should be, for noth­ing bet­ter sym­bol­izes the ad­vances of a half-cen­tury than the pres­ence of a twice-elec­ted Afric­an-Amer­ic­an pres­id­ent of the United States. But look just out­side that spot­light at two oth­er pres­id­ents whose stor­ies also dra­mat­ic­ally altered the course of the coun­try’s race re­la­tions and helped make Obama’s tri­umph pos­sible.

Fel­low Demo­crats Jimmy Carter and Bill Clin­ton will speak just be­fore Obama steps to the spot where Mar­tin Luth­er King Jr. gave his most fam­ous ora­tion in 1963. Be­cause of age and birth­place, they bring something to the oc­ca­sion that the much-young­er Obama can­not: per­son­al know­ledge of Jim Crow, per­son­al memor­ies of state-sanc­tioned dis­crim­in­a­tion, and per­son­al ex­per­i­ence in battles to fun­da­ment­ally change the mind­set of the Amer­ic­an South.

Carter, Clin­ton, and Obama, born in 1924, 1946, and 1961, re­spect­ively, roughly rep­res­ent three dis­tinct gen­er­a­tions in the struggle for ra­cial equal­ity. Ku Klux Klan mem­ber­ship hit its mod­ern peak of 6 mil­lion when Carter was a boy. Fed­er­al troops massed in Clin­ton’s home state when he was young, mo­bil­ized by Wash­ing­ton to pro­tect nine frightened kids try­ing to at­tend Little Rock Cent­ral High School. Both grew up in a world of “Colored Only” and “White Only” drink­ing foun­tains. Both lived in states where blacks were blocked from vot­ing by ques­tions no one could an­swer. Both had black play­mates but had to abide by clear re­stric­tions.

“We hunted, fished, ex­plored, worked, and slept to­geth­er,” wrote Carter in Why Not the Best, his 1976 book. “We ground sug­ar cane, plowed with mules, pruned wa­ter­mel­ons, dug and bed­ded sweet pota­toes, mopped cot­ton, stacked pea­nuts, cut stove­wood, pumped wa­ter, fixed fences, fed chick­ens, picked vel­vet beans, and hauled cot­ton to the gin to­geth­er…. We also found time to spend the night on the banks of the Choctawhat­chee and Kin­cha­foon­ee creeks, catch­ing and cook­ing cat­fish and eels…. We ran, swam, rode horses, drove wag­ons, and floated on rafts to­geth­er.”

But, he ad­ded, “We nev­er went to the same church or school. Our so­cial life and our church life were strictly sep­ar­ate.” He re­called listen­ing to the second Joe Louis-Max Schmel­ing prize fight in 1938, watch­ing his fath­er’s dis­may that Louis knocked out his white op­pon­ent in the first round. Black neigh­bors offered no re­ac­tion in front of the eld­er Carter. But when they got in­side a house only 100 yards away, ju­bil­a­tion erup­ted at the tri­umph of the black fight­er.

Both Carter and Clin­ton grew up at ease with Afric­an-Amer­ic­ans. De­Wayne Wick­ham, who wrote the book Bill Clin­ton and Black Amer­ica in 2002, told Na­tion­al Journ­al, “In black churches, there is this rhythm to the mu­sic and ca­dence to the speech. When he showed up there, un­like many white politi­cians, Clin­ton sunk deep in­to his seat while the oth­ers sat on the edge of their seats. He was com­fort­able and hard to move. The oth­ers were ready to get out the door at the first op­por­tun­ity.”

Dur­ing the 1992 cam­paign, Bill Moy­ers asked can­did­ate Clin­ton if there was any is­sue on which he would nev­er com­prom­ise. “Ra­cial justice,” Clin­ton replied. Clin­ton speech­writer Mi­chael Wald­man later wrote, “The one thing every­body knew was that Bill Clin­ton was at his most elo­quent, most per­suas­ive, more mor­ally com­mand­ing when it came to race. He had been shaped, grow­ing up, by the civil-rights struggle around him.”

Of course, Carter and Clin­ton can­not know what it is like to grow up as a black man as Obama does, nor have they ex­per­i­enced the pre­ju­dice in of­fice that has been dir­ec­ted at Obama. But neither man ever for­got the dis­crim­in­a­tion he saw.

In con­trast, Obama grew up in per­haps the most ra­cially tol­er­ant state, com­ing to the main­land long after Jim Crow had been van­quished. “He spent most of his form­at­ive years in Hawaii and a little bit in In­done­sia,” said Wick­ham, a founder of the Na­tion­al As­so­ci­ation of Black Journ­al­ists and now a USA Today colum­nist and journ­al­ism pro­fess­or at Mor­gan State Uni­versity.

When Obama talks about the ra­cism he has en­dured, it is of a dif­fer­ent de­gree than what Carter and Clin­ton ob­served. “There are very few Afric­an-Amer­ic­an men in this coun­try who haven’t had the ex­per­i­ence of be­ing fol­lowed when they were shop­ping in a de­part­ment store. That in­cludes me,” said the pres­id­ent on Ju­ly 19, re­act­ing to the Trayvon Mar­tin ver­dict. “There are very few Afric­an-Amer­ic­an men who haven’t had the ex­per­i­ence of walk­ing across the street and hear­ing the locks click on the doors of cars. That hap­pens to me — at least be­fore I was a sen­at­or. There are very few Afric­an-Amer­ic­ans who haven’t had the ex­per­i­ence of get­ting on an el­ev­at­or and a wo­man clutch­ing her purse nervously and hold­ing her breath un­til she had a chance to get off.”

The per­son­al his­tory re­flects the gen­er­a­tion­al dif­fer­ences. But the links with his older pre­de­cessors are there. Wick­ham sees “a lin­ear con­nec­tion” with the pres­id­ents. Carter and Clin­ton were South­ern­ers who “grew up with an aware­ness of Afric­an-Amer­ic­ans that was fairly unique.” In his book, Wick­ham quoted former At­lanta May­or Bill Camp­bell say­ing, “We know when white folks are com­fort­able around us and when they’re not.” And Carter and Clin­ton are com­fort­able.

Wick­ham noted that Clin­ton, who was fam­ously called “our first black pres­id­ent” in a 1998 es­say by No­bel Prize-win­ning au­thor Toni Mor­ris­on, had mem­or­ized both verses of the Negro na­tion­al an­them “Lift Every Voice and Sing” and un­der­stood its his­tory. As a boy, Clin­ton watched King’s “I Have a Dream” speech and was so moved by it, he mem­or­ized that as well.

Both Carter and Clin­ton had to over­come broad sus­pi­cions as to wheth­er the coun­try was ready for a South­ern gov­ernor. Carter had fol­lowed se­greg­a­tion­ists like Eu­gene Tal­madge and Lester Mad­dox, while Or­val Faubus’s sim­il­ar leg­acy pre­ceded Clin­ton. Carter had drawn na­tion­al no­tice when he used his gubernat­ori­al in­aug­ur­al ad­dress to de­clare, “I say to you quite frankly that the time for ra­cial dis­crim­in­a­tion is over.” But he still needed val­id­a­tion for his ra­cial bona fides be­fore he could be taken ser­i­ously na­tion­ally. That val­id­a­tion came from Mar­tin Luth­er King Sr. and An­drew Young, the former King lieu­ten­ant who was elec­ted to Con­gress, both of whom were strong sup­port­ers of his pres­id­en­tial can­did­acy.

Wed­nes­day, at the Lin­coln Me­mori­al, there is no fur­ther need for out­side val­id­a­tion of any of the three pres­id­ents. His­tory has taken care of that.

What We're Following See More »
Congress Can’t Seem Not to Pay Itself
48 minutes ago

Rep. Dave Young can't even refuse his own paycheck. The Iowa Republican is trying to make a point that if Congress can't pass a budget (it's already missed the April 15 deadline) then it shouldn't be paid. But, he's been informed, the 27th Amendment prohibits him from refusing his own pay. "Young’s efforts to dock his own pay, however, are duck soup compared to his larger goal: docking the pay of every lawmaker when Congress drops the budget ball." His bill to stiff his colleagues has only mustered the support of three of them. Another bill, sponsored by Rep. Jim Cooper (D-TN), has about three dozen co-sponsors.

How Far Away from Cleveland is the California GOP Staying?
1 hours ago

Sixty miles away, in Sandusky, Ohio. "We're pretty bitter about that," said Harmeet Dhillon, vice chairwoman of the California Republican Party. "It sucks to be California, we're like the ugly stepchild. They need us for our cash and our donors, they don't need us for anything else."

SCOTUS Will Not Allow ‘DC Madam’ Phone Records to Be Released
1 hours ago

Anyone looking forward to seeing some boldfaced names on the client list of the late Deborah Jeane Palfrey, the "DC Madam," will have to wait a little longer. "The Supreme Court announced Monday it would not intervene to allow" the release of her phone records, "despite one of her former attorneys claiming the records are “very relevant” to the presidential election. Though he has repeatedly threatened to release the records if courts do not modify a 2007 restraining order, Montgomery Blair Sibley tells U.S. News he’s not quite sure what he now will do."

Sanders Looks to Right the Ship in Indiana
18 hours ago

Hillary Clinton may have the Democratic nomination sewn up, but Bernie Sanders apparently isn't buying it. Buoyed by a poll showing them in a "virtual tie," Sanders is "holding three rallies on the final day before the state primary and hoping to pull off a win after a tough week of election losses and campaign layoffs." 

Cruz Delegates Having Second Thoughts?
22 hours ago

As unbound delegates pledged to Ted Cruz watch him "struggle to tread water in a primary increasingly dominated by Trump, many of them, wary of a bitter convention battle that could rend the party at its seams, are rethinking their commitment to the Texas senator."