The Terrible History of Human Shields

The possible use of human shields in Syria has a long precedent in some miserable history.

In this citizen journalism image provided by The Syrian Revolution against Bashar Assad which has been authenticated based on its contents and other AP reporting, a Syrian military tank caught on fire during clashes with Free Syrian army fighters in Joubar a suburb of Damascus, Syria, Wednesday, Sept. 4, 2013. 
National Journal
Matt Berman
Add to Briefcase
See more stories about...
Matt Berman
Sept. 4, 2013, 8:44 a.m.

The Mon­gols pierced holes in­to the hands of their fe­male Ja­pan­ese cap­tives. They threaded ropes through the holes to con­nect the wo­men to­geth­er in a long line, and made them march ahead of the Mon­gol sol­diers as a hu­man shield, lead­ing in­to Ja­pan’s fort­resses. 

This is said to have taken place in the late 13th cen­tury. But the ter­rible story of hu­man shields doesn’t end there.

There are new re­ports this week that the As­sad re­gime in Syr­ia is mov­ing troops in­to ci­vil­ian areas ahead of a pos­sible U.S. mis­sile strike, and pos­sibly pla­cing pris­on­ers in mil­it­ary sites. It’s the kind of jaw-drop­ping mil­it­ary tac­tic that is typ­ic­ally scorned by the in­ter­na­tion­al com­munity, and ex­pli­citly banned by the Fourth Geneva Con­ven­tion (of which Syr­ia is a party). It’s also the kind of tac­tic that, if used dur­ing a pos­sible U.S. strike, has the po­ten­tial to com­pletely de­ter and de­grade the Obama ad­min­is­tra­tion’s plans for quick, re­l­at­ively pain­less, and lim­ited ac­tion.

This isn’t the first time we’ve heard of the Syr­i­an re­gime pos­sibly us­ing hu­man shields. The U.N. an­nu­al re­port on Chil­dren and Armed Con­flict re­leased in June 2012 in­cluded the Syr­i­an armed forces on the list of parties that re­cruit, use, or ab­use chil­dren in armed con­flict. The re­port spe­cific­ally ac­cused Syr­i­an troops of us­ing chil­dren as young as 8 as hu­man shields dur­ing raids. In March, based on wit­ness re­ports, Hu­man Rights Watch ac­cused the Syr­i­an gov­ern­ment of hav­ing “en­dangered loc­al res­id­ents by for­cing them to march in front of the army dur­ing re­cent ar­rest op­er­a­tions, troop move­ments, and at­tacks on towns and vil­lages in north­ern Syr­ia.”

Among tyr­an­nic­al re­gimes, the use of hu­man shields has an in­fam­ous re­cent his­tory. NATO wor­ried that forces loy­al to Libya’s Muam­mar el-Qad­dafi were us­ing ci­vil­ians to pro­tect them­selves in April 2011. Liby­an rebels claimed that Au­gust that the gov­ern­ment was us­ing hu­man shields in Qad­dafi’s birth­place of Sirte.

But per­haps the most no­tori­ous re­cent pro­ponent of hu­man shields was Ir­aq’s Sad­dam Hus­sein. Hus­sein used “thou­sands of for­eign and Ir­aqi ci­vil­ians as hu­man shields in bids to ma­nip­u­late do­mest­ic and in­ter­na­tion­al opin­ion and de­ter mil­it­ary ac­tion against his re­gime” when he was in con­flict with the West, ac­cord­ing to a Janu­ary 2003 CIA re­port. The CIA al­leges that in 1990, Hus­sein “held more than 800 West­ern, Ja­pan­ese, and Kuwaiti na­tion­als” in Ir­aq and Kuwait to de­fend his re­gime from an at­tack to end its in­va­sion of Kuwait. In 1997, Hus­sein “en­ticed or co­erced” thou­sands of Ir­aqi ci­vil­ians to act as vol­un­tary hu­man shields to ward against an at­tack after Ir­aq re­fused to let U.N. in­spect­ors in­to some sites. Ir­aqi men, wo­men, and chil­dren served as hu­man shields at roughly 80 palaces and fa­cil­it­ies dur­ing the crisis.

The CIA re­port was re­leased at a sig­ni­fic­ant time, just months ahead of “shock and awe” and the be­gin­ning of Amer­ica’s war with Ir­aq. For his part, Pres­id­ent Bush warned in a Feb­ru­ary 2003 speech that Hus­sein “re­gards the Ir­aqi people as hu­man shields.” The CIA re­port ex­pressed con­cern that the Ir­aqi re­gime was again pre­par­ing to use hu­man shields ahead of a co­ali­tion strike, and was act­ively court­ing vo­lun­teers from in­ter­na­tion­al an­ti­war groups.

Those vo­lun­teers, in­clud­ing Amer­ic­an and Brit­ish act­iv­ists, showed up and were wel­comed with open arms. They stayed in cushy Bagh­dad ho­tels, and it was “al­most like be­ing on hol­i­day,” one of the act­iv­ists said in a March 2013 BBC in­ter­view. To their chag­rin, the act­iv­ists wound up be­ing moved by an Ir­aqi li­ais­on to in­fra­struc­ture sites, not big ci­vil­ian areas. By the time the bomb­ings oc­curred, there were between 25 and 100 hu­man-shield act­iv­ists in the coun­try, and none of the sites they were pro­tect­ing were hit.

Now act­iv­ists have ar­rived in Syr­ia, too. Ac­cord­ing to Ir­an’s PressTV and Rus­sia’s RT, Syr­i­ans call­ing them­selves a hu­man shield have crowded around some mil­it­ary build­ings in the coun­try. “I’m a nor­mal cit­izen, I’m not a gov­ern­ment em­ploy­ee, and I do not do any­thing in the gov­ern­ment,” a wo­man says in an in­ter­view with PressTV. “When I heard about this cam­paign, I came with my fam­ily.”

An­ti­war pro­test­ers with du­bi­ous back­ing and re­ports of re­gime use of hu­man shields didn’t work to halt a U.S. at­tack on Ir­aq in 2003. With a po­ten­tial hu­man-shield crisis on our hands again, we’ll soon see if a pos­sible ci­vil­ian dis­aster can be avoided.

What We're Following See More »
Clinton Up 9 in USA Today Poll; Up 3 According to Fox
18 hours ago

A new USA Today/Suffolk University poll finds Clinton leads Trump by 9 points nationwide, 47% to 38%. A Fox News national poll has Clinton up just three points, 44% to 41% over Trump.

Cruz: Eight Justices Could Be an Ongoing Situation
20 hours ago

Sen. Ted Cruz (R-TX) said that "there was “precedent” for a Supreme Court with fewer than nine justices—appearing to suggest that the blockade on nominee Merrick Garland could last past the election." Speaking to reporters in Colorado, Cruz said: "I would note, just recently, that Justice Breyer observed that the vacancy is not impacting the ability of the court to do its job. That’s a debate that we are going to have.”

DNC Sues RNC Over Trump’s Rigged Vote Comments
23 hours ago

The Democratic National Committee sued the Republican National Committee in U.S. District Court in New Jersey for aiding GOP nominee Donald Trump as he argues that the presidential election is "rigged." The DNC claims "that Trump's argument is designed to suppress the vote in minority communities."

Clinton Foundation Staffers Steered Biz to Bill
1 days ago

"Two chief fundraisers for the Clinton Foundation pressed corporate donors to steer business opportunities to former President Bill Clinton as well, according to a hacked memo published Wednesday by WikiLeaks. The November 2011 memo from Douglas Band, at the time a top aide to Mr. Clinton, outlines extensive fundraising efforts that Mr. Band and a partner deployed on behalf of the Clinton Foundation and how that work sometimes translated into large speaking fees and other paid work for Mr. Clinton."

House Investigators Already Sharpening Their Spears for Clinton
1 days ago

House Oversight Committee Chairman Jason Chaffetz plans to spend "years, come January, probing the record of a President Hillary Clinton." Chaffetz told the Washington Post: “It’s a target-rich environment. Even before we get to Day One, we’ve got two years’ worth of material already lined up. She has four years of history at the State Department, and it ain’t good.”


Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.