Opponents of Keystone Pipeline Add Economic Arrows to Their Quiver

The economic impact of the Keystone XL Pipeline is in dispute, but it's unlikely President Obama will wade into that argument.
PR NEWSWIRE
Alex Brown
Add to Briefcase
Alex Brown
Sept. 16, 2013, 5:30 p.m.

As Pres­id­ent Obama con­siders the cli­mate im­pact of the Key­stone XL pipeline, some of the pro­ject’s most vo­cal op­pon­ents are put­ting a re­newed fo­cus on its eco­nom­ic ef­fects.

The pipeline, which would carry heavy crude from Canada’s tar sands to U.S. re­finer­ies on the Gulf Coast, is still pending ap­prov­al by the State De­part­ment, and Obama said this sum­mer he will only is­sue a per­mit if the pro­ject does not ex­acer­bate cli­mate change.

En­vir­on­ment­al­ists be­lieve it will, but they also ques­tion ar­gu­ments by pro­ject pro­ponents that the pipeline will be good for Amer­ic­an con­sumers.

“Here’s the truth: Key­stone oil will travel through Amer­ica, not to Amer­ica,” said in­vestor and en­vir­on­ment­al­ist Tom Stey­er, nar­rat­ing an ad run­ning on na­tion­al net­works re­cently. The 90-second spot, backed by Stey­er’s Nex­t­Gen Cli­mate Ac­tion group, is part of a $1 mil­lion ad series op­pos­ing the pipeline.

Stey­er op­poses Key­stone on en­vir­on­ment­al grounds, but his first pitch against it barely men­tions cli­mate change. His ar­gu­ment — that the pipeline hailed as a linch­pin of North Amer­ic­an en­ergy in­de­pend­ence will in­stead be used to ship oil over­seas — is not a new one. The Si­erra Club, 350.org, and oth­er green groups have long held that Key­stone will be an ex­port pipeline, a point dis­puted by its ad­voc­ates.

“The eco­nom­ic ar­gu­ment [for Key­stone] is crum­bling,” said Si­erra Club spokes­man Ed­die Scher. “The idea that the United States is dy­ing for this oil from Canada doesn’t hold up…. After [Obama] re­jects this pipeline, he’s go­ing to have his choice on reas­ons why he did.”

A State De­part­ment ana­lys­is this spring said that less than half of re­fined products from the Gulf Coast — Key­stone’s planned en­d­point — enter the U.S. mar­ket. Al­though the Ca­na­dian-piped oil would not fall un­der U.S. re­stric­tions on its own crude ex­ports, the re­port said the ca­pa­city of Gulf re­finer­ies makes it un­likely the crude would be ex­por­ted in great volume. Once it is re­fined, however, it will be sub­ject to the same mar­ket forces that now see nearly 3 mil­lion bar­rels of U.S. oil shipped over­seas daily.

Dani­elle Droitsch, dir­ect­or of the Nat­ur­al Re­sources De­fense Coun­cil’s Canada Pro­ject, blamed mil­lion-dol­lar ad cam­paigns from Key­stone’s back­ers for the per­cep­tion that the pipeline will be an eco­nom­ic boon. “We ab­so­lutely feel that those eco­nom­ic ar­gu­ments are im­port­ant parts of the con­ver­sa­tion,” she said.

“The pres­id­ent’s cli­mate test for Key­stone … did put us in the po­s­i­tion of need­ing to de­fend that, need­ing to ex­plain why Key­stone will worsen cli­mate change, and we can do that,” Droitsch said. But, she ad­ded, “I firmly be­lieve that the Obama ad­min­is­tra­tion is not just look­ing at the cli­mate is­sue…. [The eco­nom­ic ar­gu­ment is] still im­port­ant, be­cause the Amer­ic­an pub­lic is fo­cused on wheth­er the pipeline is for U.S. en­ergy se­cur­ity.”

Tran­sCanada, the com­pany pro­pos­ing to build the pipeline, main­tains that Key­stone XL will cre­ate 20,000 man­u­fac­tur­ing and con­struc­tion jobs. The White House has down­played Tran­sCanada’s jobs es­tim­ate, but nix­ing Key­stone on the grounds that it might be an oil ex­port­er would con­tra­dict the goals set by his ex­port ini­ti­at­ive.

What We're Following See More »
WITH LIVE BLOGGING
Trump Deposition Video Is Online
13 hours ago
STAFF PICKS

The video of Donald Trump's deposition in his case against restaurateur Jeffrey Zakarian is now live. Slate's Jim Newell and Josh Voorhees are live-blogging it while they watch.

Source:
SOUND LEVEL AFFECTED
Debate Commission Admits Issues with Trump’s Mic
14 hours ago
THE LATEST

The Commission on Presidential Debates put out a statement today that gives credence to Donald Trump's claims that he had a bad microphone on Monday night. "Regarding the first debate, there were issues regarding Donald Trump's audio that affected the sound level in the debate hall," read the statement in its entirety.

Source:
TRUMP VS. CHEFS
Trump Deposition Video to Be Released
14 hours ago
THE LATEST

"A video of Donald Trump testifying under oath about his provocative rhetoric about Mexicans and other Latinos is set to go public" as soon as today. "Trump gave the testimony in June at a law office in Washington in connection with one of two lawsuits he filed last year after prominent chefs reacted to the controversy over his remarks by pulling out of plans to open restaurants at his new D.C. hotel. D.C. Superior Court Judge Brian Holeman said in an order issued Thursday evening that fears the testimony might show up in campaign commercials were no basis to keep the public from seeing the video."

Source:
A CANDIDATE TO BE ‘PROUD’ OF
Chicago Tribune Endorses Gary Johnson
17 hours ago
THE LATEST

No matter that his recall of foreign leaders leaves something to be desired, Gary Johnson is the choice of the Chicago Tribune's editorial board. The editors argue that Donald Trump couldn't do the job of president, while hitting Hillary Clinton for "her intent to greatly increase federal spending and taxation, and serious questions about honesty and trust." Which leaves them with Johnson. "Every American who casts a vote for him is standing for principles," they write, "and can be proud of that vote. Yes, proud of a candidate in 2016."

NEVER TRUMP
USA Today Weighs in on Presidential Race for First Time Ever
1 days ago
THE DETAILS

"By all means vote, just not for Donald Trump." That's the message from USA Today editors, who are making the first recommendation on a presidential race in the paper's 34-year history. It's not exactly an endorsement; they make clear that the editorial board "does not have a consensus for a Clinton endorsement." But they state flatly that Donald Trump is, by "unanimous consensus of the editorial board, unfit for the presidency."

Source:
×