How to End the Obamacare Debate

With the GOP opposition showing no signs of abating, the Obama administration has to start showing that the health care law is working.

Linda Norman, right, and Joanna Galt, both from Florida, hold their banners during a "Exempt America from Obamacare" rally on the West Lawn of the Capitol in Washington, Tuesday, Sept. 10, 2013. 
AP2013
Ronald Brownstein
Sept. 19, 2013, 4:05 p.m.

Even amid the high-stakes man­euv­er­ing over Syr­ia and the fed­er­al budget, White House Chief of Staff Denis Mc­Donough has a cal­en­dar on his of­fice door that counts down the days un­til open en­roll­ment for the un­in­sured be­gins Oct. 1 un­der Pres­id­ent Obama’s health care law.

It’s a re­mind­er that noth­ing will shape Obama’s leg­acy more than wheth­er he can suc­cess­fully im­ple­ment, and polit­ic­ally en­trench, his massive health re­form plan. Obama has three years to for­ti­fy the law with enough sup­port to make re­peal dif­fi­cult, even if Re­pub­lic­ans win uni­fied con­trol of Wash­ing­ton in 2016.

The pres­id­ent has a long road to travel. Polls show that most Amer­ic­ans doubt the Af­ford­able Care Act will im­prove con­di­tions for their fam­ily or the coun­try. Im­ple­ment­a­tion of the law’s many pieces has cre­ated com­plex lo­gist­ic­al and com­puter chal­lenges that have already forced the ad­min­is­tra­tion to delay some com­pon­ents. And, most im­port­ant, op­pos­i­tion from Re­pub­lic­ans is blaz­ing un­di­min­ished — and is now flar­ing in­to es­cal­at­ing threats to shut down the gov­ern­ment or de­fault on the fed­er­al debt rather than fund the pro­gram.

No oth­er fed­er­al en­ti­tle­ment has faced such fe­ro­cious op­pos­i­tion after pas­sage. Al­though many con­ser­vat­ives ini­tially raged against Medi­care, that fire ex­tin­guished quickly when be­ne­fits star­ted flow­ing in 1966. Medi­caid, the joint state-fed­er­al health pro­gram for the poor, pro­voked stur­di­er op­pos­i­tion, but two years after its pas­sage in 1965, all but 13 states had signed onto it. (With­in five years, all but two states were par­ti­cip­at­ing.) Re­pub­lic­an res­ist­ance to So­cial Se­cur­ity lingered longer; but after 1936 pres­id­en­tial nom­in­ee Alf Landon won only two states while pledging its re­peal, the party con­fined it­self to guer­rilla snip­ing against the pro­gram, be­fore sur­ren­der­ing en­tirely un­der Pres­id­ent Eis­en­hower.

All of that pales be­side today’s cru­sade against the health care law. This cam­paign ex­tends from the con­gres­sion­al Re­pub­lic­ans’ de­fund­ing de­mands, to the wide­spread re­fus­al of GOP-con­trolled states to ex­pand Medi­caid eli­gib­il­ity, to the pas­sage of laws in states such as Geor­gia and Ohio im­ped­ing “nav­ig­at­ors” work­ing to en­roll people on the in­sur­ance ex­changes. “The mag­nitude of res­ist­ance is un­pre­ced­en­ted,” says Prin­ceton Uni­versity so­ci­olo­gist Paul Starr, au­thor of an ac­claimed his­tory of the Amer­ic­an health care sys­tem.

Without draw­ing mor­al equi­val­ence, it’s fair to say the health care law is fa­cing more wide­spread de­fi­ance than any fed­er­al ini­ti­at­ive since the Su­preme Court ordered pub­lic schools to de­seg­reg­ate in its 1954 Brown v. Board of Edu­ca­tion de­cision. Obama is un­likely to fold against con­gres­sion­al Re­pub­lic­an de­mands for delay. But, even so, some two dozen states — all but two with Re­pub­lic­an gov­ernors — are re­fus­ing to ex­pand Medi­caid (which was ini­tially ex­pec­ted to provide about half the law’s cov­er­age in­crease) and to es­tab­lish the on­line ex­changes for those un­in­sured people with slightly high­er in­comes. Mean­while, al­most all Demo­crat­ic-lean­ing states are em­bra­cing the law.

This con­trast cre­ates two power­ful dy­nam­ics that will shape the un­fold­ing de­bate. First, it means that with half the states in­hib­it­ing it, the pro­gram won’t en­roll as many people na­tion­ally as Obama hoped. Be­cause many of the res­ist­ing states have big un­in­sured pop­u­la­tions and skimpy safety nets, 8 mil­lion of the 13 mil­lion people po­ten­tially eli­gible un­der the law’s Medi­caid ex­pan­sion live in states that are not in­creas­ing cov­er­age, the Urb­an In­sti­tute cal­cu­lates. Without state out­reach, sign-up on those states’ ex­changes also could slip, again de­press­ing the na­tion­al res­ults.

That pro­spect frames a second, po­ten­tially de­cis­ive, ques­tion: Can the law’s sup­port­ers pro­duce suc­cess in the states that are wel­com­ing it? If Cali­for­nia, Col­or­ado, Min­nesota, and oth­er states that are im­ple­ment­ing the law most en­thu­si­ast­ic­ally can en­roll large num­bers of the un­in­sured, avoid big lo­gist­ic­al snafus, and at­tract enough healthy young people to re­strain premi­um rates, that would strengthen Obama’s hand na­tion­ally — and in­crease pop­u­lar de­mands to par­ti­cip­ate in the res­ist­ing states. If it be­comes “clear that in many of the states that are whole­heartedly im­ple­ment­ing it, it is work­ing well, the in­ter­est­ing ques­tion is, what kind of pres­sure will that put on the “˜re­fusenik’ states?” says Har­vard Uni­versity so­ci­olo­gist Theda Skoc­pol, who stud­ies the safety net. In par­tic­u­lar, suc­cess in par­ti­cip­at­ing states could in­spire grow­ing agit­a­tion from health care pro­viders in the re­fusenik states, which are re­noun­cing nearly $500 bil­lion in fed­er­al money through 2022 (at small state cost) by re­ject­ing the Medi­caid ex­pan­sion, the Urb­an In­sti­tute pro­jects.

In this pro­cess, Cali­for­nia could fig­ure largest be­cause its huge, di­verse, and heav­ily un­in­sured pop­u­la­tion presents a tough­er test than more-ho­mo­gen­ous co­oper­at­ing states such as Min­nesota and Mas­sachu­setts. If Cali­for­nia suc­ceeds, notes An­thony Wright of the ad­vocacy group Health Ac­cess Cali­for­nia, “we can show it can work in a state where the prob­lem is “¦ on the scale of Texas and Flor­ida,” the two largest res­ist­ing states. Cali­for­nia has already ne­go­ti­ated ag­gress­ively to lim­it premi­um rates for in­surers selling through its ex­changes and has en­rolled (through an early-start waiver) about half of those eli­gible for the law’s Medi­caid ex­pan­sion. But, Wright ac­know­ledges, the state con­fronts su­per­sized ver­sions of the same “daunt­ing” lo­gist­ic­al chal­lenges loom­ing else­where as en­roll­ment be­gins. Obama’s best chance of de­fend­ing health care re­form against its en­emies is to en­sure that it works for its friends.

{{ BIZOBJ (video: 4456) }}

What We're Following See More »
TAKATA RECALLS COULD TAKE YEARS TO COMPLETE
Airbag Recalls Target 12 Million Automobiles
2 hours ago
THE LATEST

"The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration identified on Friday the makes and models of 12 million cars and motorcycles that have been recalled because of defective air bag inflators made by Japanese supplier Takata. The action includes 4.3 million Chryslers; 4.5 million Hondas; 1.6 million Toyotas; 731,000 Mazdas; 402,000 Nissans; 383,000 Subarus; 38,000 Mitsubishis; and 2,800 Ferraris. ... Analysts have said it could take years for all of the air bags to be replaced. Some have questioned whether Takata can survive the latest blow."

Source:
INVESTIGATION LEADS TO LEAKER’S RESIGNATION
Secret Service Disciplines 41 Agents Over Chaffetz Leak
2 hours ago
THE LATEST

Homeland Security Secretary Jeh Johnson says 41 Secret Service agents have been disciplined in the fallout of an investigation over the agency's leak of personnel files. The leaker, who has resigned, released records showing that Oversight and Government Reform Chair Jason Chaffetz—who was leading an investigation of Secret Service security lapses—had applied for a job at the agency years before. The punishments include reprimands and suspension without pay. "Like many others I was appalled by the episode reflected in the Inspector General’s report, which brought real discredit to the Secret Service," said Johnson.

Source:
#NEVERTRUMP’S LONELY LEADER
Romney Talks Cost of His Futile Anti-Trump Fight
4 hours ago
THE LATEST

Mitt Romney spoke in an interview with the Wall Street Journal about his decision to challenge Donald Trump. “Friends warned me, ‘Don’t speak out, stay out of the fray,’ because criticizing Mr. Trump will only help him by giving him someone else to attack. They were right. I became his next target, and the incoming attacks have been constant and brutal.” Still, "I wanted my grandkids to see that I simply couldn’t ignore what Mr. Trump was saying and doing, which revealed a character and temperament unfit for the leader of the free world.”

Source:
CONGRESS DIVIDED ON DEBT CRISIS PLAN
Puerto Rico Relief Stalled on the Hill
5 hours ago
THE LATEST

"A bill to help Puerto Rico handle its $70 billion debt crisis is facing an uncertain future in the Senate. No Senate Democrats have endorsed a bill backed by House Speaker Paul Ryan and Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi, while some are actively fighting it. ... On the Republican side, senators say they’re hopeful to pass a bill but don’t know if they can support the current legislation — which is expected to win House approval given its backing from leaders in that chamber."

Source:
LAWMAKERS RECESS WITH NO PLAN IMMINENT
Congress Slow-walking Zika Legislation
5 hours ago
THE LATEST

"Congress abandoned the Capitol Thursday for an almost two-week break without addressing how to combat Zika, even as public health officials issue dire warnings about the spread of the mosquito-driven virus with summer approaching. ... Instead of racing to fund efforts to thwart a potential health crisis, lawmakers are treating the Zika debate like regular legislation, approving Thursday the establishment of a House-Senate committee to hammer out differences in their competing bills."

Source:
×