Why Delaying Obamacare Could Ultimately Do As Much Damage as Defunding

The GOP-backed one-year delay sounds benign but it would create the kind of chaos that could permanently harm the health insurance program.

Maygan Rollins, 22, a field organizer with Enroll America, holds a clipboard with pamplets while canvassing at a bus stop, Wednesday, Sept. 25, 2013, in Miami. Enroll America is a private, non-profit organization running a grassroots campaign to encourage people to sign up for health care offered by the Affordable Care Act. In less than a week Florida residents can start enrolling for health coverage under the Affordable Care Act. 
National Journal
Jill Lawrence
See more stories about...
Jill Lawrence
Sept. 27, 2013, 5:07 a.m.

The Re­pub­lic­an plan to delay core as­pects of the Af­ford­able Care Act doesn’t sound as dra­mat­ic as tak­ing away its fund­ing, but it could ul­ti­mately do just as much to crush the con­tro­ver­sial law.

The latest wrinkle in the GOP’s stop-Obama­care strategy is a one-year “delay of everything,” says Brendan Buck, spokes­man for House Speak­er John Boehner. And that does mean everything ““ the new in­sur­ance mar­ket­places, the sub­sidies, the taxes, and in­di­vidu­al man­date that re­quires people to have in­sur­ance or pay a fine.

It would be hard to over­state the im­port­ance of the year ahead for both sides in the health ar­gu­ment. Re­pub­lic­ans are seek­ing an­oth­er year to stoke doubts about the health law, which is already un­pop­u­lar, and to take their re­peal plat­form in­to the 2014 midterms. If they win con­trol of the Sen­ate, they could claim a man­date to kill it.

Pres­id­ent Obama and Demo­crats, by con­trast, have been wait­ing im­pa­tiently for the open­ing of the ex­changes that are go­ing on­line Oct. 1 and are the first chance many con­sumers will have to ex­per­i­ence the law. Obama is count­ing on that firsthand con­tact to change views. As he put it Thursday, after de­scrib­ing the new sys­tem, people don’t have to take his word for it: “Go on the web­site. See for your­self what the prices are. See for your­self what the choices are. Then make up your own mind. That’s all I’m ask­ing.”

Demo­crats like to com­pare Obama­care to the Medi­care pre­scrip­tion drug pro­gram and its tra­ject­ory from res­ist­ance to ac­cept­ance. A month after it took ef­fect in Janu­ary 2006, only 23 per­cent of seni­ors in a Kais­er Fam­ily Found­a­tion poll had a fa­vor­able im­pres­sion while 45 per­cent viewed it un­fa­vor­ably. By Novem­ber 2006, that had moved to 42 per­cent fa­vor­able, 34 per­cent un­fa­vor­able. By the end of 2012, 32 mil­lion people ““ 63 per­cent of those eli­gible ““ were en­rolled in the drug plan.

There is rampant am­bi­val­ence in today’s polls. More than half the coun­try op­poses the law, while few­er than four in 10 fa­vor it. But 56 per­cent in a New York Times/CBS News poll say Con­gress should up­hold the ACA and make it work as well as pos­sible. And a new United Tech­no­lo­gies/Na­tion­al Journ­al Con­gres­sion­al Con­nec­tion poll finds a near-even split: 49 per­cent say Con­gress should keep the pro­gram, 44 per­cent say re­peal.

If the ex­changes did open but the in­di­vidu­al man­date was post­poned, ex­perts say those likely to skip buy­ing in­sur­ance are the young and the healthy ““ just the people most needed to broaden the risk pool and keep in­sur­ance rates low. Sur­ging rates would ant­ag­on­ize the pub­lic. So would the ab­sence of in­come-based sub­sidies. And if the ex­changes did not open at all, after lay­ing ground­work for big changes for the last three years, in­surers and con­sumers would be left scram­bling.

“You could think about an or­derly trans­ition back, but just stop­ping it would be chaot­ic,” says Gary Clax­ton, dir­ect­or of the Health Care Mar­ket­place Pro­ject at the Kais­er Fam­ily Found­a­tion. Among his ques­tions: Would the com­pan­ies have to re­sume un­der­writ­ing, charge high­er rates to sick people, and deny cov­er­age to some? And with many high-risk pools gone in pre­par­a­tion for the big shift, where would those people get in­sur­ance? He also notes that if in­surers lost money as a res­ult of the sud­den full stop, the fed­er­al gov­ern­ment would be on the hook to make up much of the loss, as it was the case with the Medi­care drug pro­gram.

From a polit­ic­al se­mantics stand­point, says Robert Blendon, a health policy ex­pert at Har­vard, “de­fund­ing sounds aw­ful. It sounds like you’re tak­ing money away from sick people.” A one-year delay seems more be­nign, he says, but “could have a very neg­at­ive long-term ef­fect on the vi­ab­il­ity of the law.” That makes de­fund and delay a win-win for Re­pub­lic­ans, and a test of back­bone for Demo­crats.

{{ BIZOBJ (video: 4471) }}

What We're Following See More »
Trump Won’t Debate Sanders After All
1 days ago

Trump, in a statement: “Based on the fact that the Democratic nominating process is totally rigged and Crooked Hillary Clinton and Deborah Wasserman Schultz will not allow Bernie Sanders to win, and now that I am the presumptive Republican nominee, it seems inappropriate that I would debate the second place finisher. ... I will wait to debate the first place finisher in the Democratic Party, probably Crooked Hillary Clinton, or whoever it may be.”

UAW: Time to Unite Behind Hillary
2 days ago

"It's about time for unity," said UAW President Dennis Williams. "We're endorsing Hillary Clinton. She's gotten 3 million more votes than Bernie, a million more votes than Donald Trump. She's our nominee." He called Sanders "a great friend of the UAW" while saying Trump "does not support the economic security of UAW families." Some 28 percent of UAW members indicated their support for Trump in an internal survey.

Trump Clinches Enough Delegates for the Nomination
2 days ago

"Donald Trump on Thursday reached the number of delegates needed to clinch the Republican nomination for president, completing an unlikely rise that has upended the political landscape and sets the stage for a bitter fall campaign. Trump was put over the top in the Associated Press delegate count by a small number of the party's unbound delegates who told the AP they would support him at the convention."

Trump/Sanders Debate Before California Primary?
2 days ago
California: It’s Not Over Yet
2 days ago

"Clinton and Bernie Sanders "are now devoting additional money to television advertising. A day after Sanders announced a new ad buy of less than $2 million in the state, Clinton announced her own television campaign. Ads featuring actor Morgan Freeman as well as labor leader and civil rights activist Dolores Huerta will air beginning on Fridayin Fresno, Sacramento, and Los Angeles media markets. Some ads will also target Latino voters and Asian American voters. The total value of the buy is about six figures according to the Clinton campaign." Meanwhile, a new poll shows Sanders within the margin of error, trailing Clinton 44%-46%.