Could Parceling Pell Payments Help Students?

The “Aid Like a Paycheck” system being tested at two community colleges may save federal dollars, help students manage funds, and reduce dropouts.

Triton College is a community college servince Chicago-area residents.
National Journal
Sophie Quinton
Add to Briefcase
See more stories about...
Sophie Quinton
Nov. 4, 2013, 1:05 a.m.

With so much fo­cus on rising col­lege costs, it’s easy to for­get that some stu­dents re­ceive more state and fed­er­al fin­an­cial aid than they need to pay tu­ition and fees. Fed­er­al Pell Grants in­clude money to help stu­dents meet their liv­ing ex­penses, and low-in­come stu­dents, en­rolled full time at in­ex­pens­ive com­munity col­leges, can re­ceive a sub­stan­tial check after their tu­ition bills are paid.

Pres­id­ent Obama would like to re­quire col­leges with high dro­pout rates to par­cel out aid re­funds in in­stall­ments, in or­der to de­crease the num­ber of Pell dol­lars lost when stu­dents drop out. Re­search­ers hope that dis­burs­ing ex­tra aid this way, sim­il­ar to a paycheck, could also help stu­dents man­age their money and give them an ex­tra in­cent­ive to stay in school.

Non­profit re­search or­gan­iz­a­tion MDRC has tested the “Aid Like a Paycheck” concept at two com­munity col­leges. “The vast ma­jor­ity of stu­dents have said, ‘Oh, this makes per­fect sense,’ ” says Evan Weiss­man, op­er­a­tions as­so­ci­ate at MDRC. But it’s not yet clear wheth­er the new dis­burse­ment meth­od will help stu­dents make it to gradu­ation.

Dur­ing the 2011-12 aca­dem­ic year, the fed­er­al gov­ern­ment spent $33 bil­lion on Pell Grants for nearly 9.5 mil­lion stu­dents. The num­ber of com­munity-col­lege stu­dents who re­ceive Pell Grants has al­most doubled since 2006, ac­cord­ing to the Amer­ic­an As­so­ci­ation of Com­munity Col­leges. In 2011-12, 37 per­cent of Pell Grant be­ne­fi­ciar­ies were com­munity-col­lege stu­dents. In 2011, 44 per­cent of pub­lic two-year col­lege en­rollees were non­white, ac­cord­ing to the Na­tion­al Cen­ter for Edu­ca­tion Stat­ist­ics.

Only 20 per­cent per­cent of first-time stu­dents who en­roll full time in pub­lic two-year pro­grams gradu­ate with­in three years. Many drop out mid­way through the semester, which can cre­ate a prob­lem for col­leges. If a stu­dent re­ceiv­ing a Pell Grant drops out be­fore he’s 60 per­cent through the term, his col­lege has to re­turn un­earned aid to the Edu­ca­tion De­part­ment.

MDRC has found that giv­ing stu­dents ad­di­tion­al aid if they main­tained good grades can in­crease the num­ber of cred­its they earn. The In­sti­tute for Col­lege Ac­cess and Suc­cess has said that some Cali­for­nia com­munity col­leges are already dis­trib­ut­ing their aid in in­stall­ments to lim­it their fin­an­cial li­ab­il­ity. The two re­search or­gan­iz­a­tions teamed up to design a pi­lot that would test wheth­er dis­trib­ut­ing aid in in­stall­ments would work for both ad­min­is­trat­ors and stu­dents.

The first test site, Mt. San Ant­o­nio Com­munity Col­lege, is a Los Angeles-area in­sti­tu­tion that en­rolls about 28,000 stu­dents each year, more than 85 per­cent of whom are non­white. The second, Tri­ton Col­lege, en­rolls about 14,000 Chica­go-area stu­dents per year, about two-thirds of whom are non­white. MSACC en­rolled some 200 stu­dents in the Aid Like a Paycheck pi­lot from fall 2010 through fall 2012, while Tri­ton has in­cluded about 200 since its pi­lot began in spring 2012.

“These are stu­dents — many of them — who’ve have nev­er had any dis­cre­tion­ary in­come to man­age,” says Pa­tri­cia Zinga, Tri­ton’s as­so­ci­ate dean of fin­an­cial aid. After tu­ition and fees are paid and books are pur­chased, a Tri­ton stu­dent awar­ded a $2,000 Pell Grant can end up with a $1,000 re­fund — per­haps the largest check the stu­dent has ever re­ceived. 

After con­sult­ing with col­lege staff and stu­dent fo­cus groups, re­search­ers es­tim­ated that bi­weekly pay­ments would have to amount to at least $100 to be mean­ing­ful, re­quir­ing Pell re­funds to amount to $1,600 per aca­dem­ic year. At Mount San Ant­o­nio and Tri­ton, stu­dents par­ti­cip­at­ing in the pi­lots typ­ic­ally were en­rolled full time and re­ceived bi­weekly checks of between $125 to $350. When stu­dents took few­er courses and thus saw their ex­tra Pell aid drop to be­low $75 per week, the col­leges would re­turn to giv­ing them just a single check.

Most full-time stu­dents at both col­leges work part time. Along with Aid Like a Paycheck pay­ments, stu­dents re­ceived on­line ad­vice on budget­ing, such as re­mind­ers to save up so that they could work less and study more be­fore fi­nals. Stu­dents could leave the pi­lot if they faced a hard­ship — such as a hos­pit­al bill — that they needed a lump sum to pay.

The ma­jor find­ing was that stu­dents said, in sur­veys and fo­cus groups, that they liked get­ting their aid in this man­ner. MDRC has not eval­u­ated wheth­er the pay­ment sys­tem im­proves col­lege com­ple­tion, and is look­ing for fund­ing that would al­low a long-term study to show stat­ist­ic­ally rel­ev­ant find­ings. The Bill and Melinda Gates Found­a­tion, a Next Amer­ica spon­sor, helped cov­er the cost of the pi­lot pro­jects.

MDRC (the name was shortened in 2003 from Man­power Demon­stra­tion Re­search Corp.) es­tim­ates that more than 2 mil­lion stu­dents might re­ceive big enough Pell awards each year to al­low for their ex­tra aid to be dis­trib­uted like a paycheck. It tar­geted Cali­for­nia, Texas, Illinois, Michigan, and North Car­o­lina as states likely to have large num­bers of such stu­dents. 

“Ul­ti­mately, I would love to see this be my col­lege’s policy,” Zinga said. But im­ple­ment­a­tion can be tricky. Tri­ton’s cur­rent soft­ware doesn’t al­low for bi­weekly dis­burse­ments to be pro­cessed auto­mat­ic­ally, mak­ing it hard for the col­lege to ex­pand Aid Like a Paycheck to a large num­ber of stu­dents.

The ef­fects on stu­dent per­sist­ence may be small and hard to gauge. At Tri­ton, of the 55 stu­dents who op­ted to try the pro­gram in spring 2012, 44 are no longer en­rolled in the pro­gram — be­cause they gradu­ated, trans­ferred, left, or were dis­qual­i­fied — and five cur­rently are in­eligible for Aid Like a Paycheck pay­ments be­cause they are not re­ceiv­ing enough aid.  

It’s im­port­ant to re­mem­ber that com­munity-col­leges stu­dents aren’t like uni­versity stu­dents, Zinga says. “In com­munity col­leges, we have a pretty tran­si­ent stu­dent pop­u­la­tion,” she says.  “They’ll at­tend, and maybe they’ll trans­fer on; maybe they’ll gradu­ate—maybe they’ll drop out, start a fam­ily, and come back in a year.”

What the pro­gram does do is shield stu­dents, col­leges, and the gov­ern­ment from fin­an­cial risk. And even small im­prove­ments in com­ple­tion may make the in­ter­ven­tion worth­while, says Sandy Baum, a seni­or fel­low at the Urb­an In­sti­tute and a re­search pro­fess­or at George Wash­ing­ton Uni­versity. “It’s not clear that there’s a reas­on not to do this.”

What We're Following See More »
Trump Taps Rep. McMorris Rodgers for Interior Secretary
2 hours ago
White House Orders Review of Election Hacking
2 hours ago

President Obama has called for a "full review" of the hacking that took place during the 2016 election cycle, according to Obama counterterrorism and homeland security adviser Lisa Monaco. Intelligence officials say it is highly likely that Russia was behind the hacking. The results are not necessarily going to be made public, but will be shared with members of Congress.

Manchin, Brown Holding Up Spending Bill
4 hours ago

Sen. Joe Manchin (D-WV) and Sherrod Brown (D-OH) are threatening to block the spending bill—and prevent the Senate from leaving town—"because it would not extend benefits for retired coal miners for a year or pay for their pension plans. The current version of the bill would extend health benefits for four months. ... Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY) on Thursday afternoon moved to end debate on the continuing resolution to fund the government through April 28. But unless Senate Democrats relent, that vote cannot be held until Saturday at 1 a.m. at the earliest, one hour after the current funding measure expires."

South Korean President Impeached
5 hours ago

The South Korean parliament voted on Friday morning to impeach President Park Geun-hye over charges of corruption, claiming she allowed undue influence to a close confidante of hers. Ms. Park is now suspended as president for 180 days. South Korea's Constitutional Court will hear the case and decide whether to uphold or overturn the impeachment.

NPS: Women’s March Can’t Use Lincoln Memorial
5 hours ago

Participants in the women's march on Washington the day after inauguration won't have access to the Lincoln Memorial. The National Park Service has "filed documents securing large swaths of the national mall and Pennsylvania Avenue, the Washington Monument and the Lincoln Memorial for the inauguration festivities. None of these spots will be open for protesters."


Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.