Off to the Races

Firing Rosenstein, Mueller Might Not Solve Trump’s Legal Problems

The investigations could continue even if the president takes those controversial steps.

Deputy Attorney General Rod Rosenstein
AP Photo/Alex Brandon
Charlie Cook
Add to Briefcase
Charlie Cook
April 16, 2018, 8 p.m.

Last week’s raids by the FBI on the home, hotel room, and office of President Trump’s personal lawyer and close adviser Michael Cohen underscore that the investigation by Special Counsel Robert Mueller and the U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of New York are now reaching the innermost concentric circles of Trump’s orbit. And there may not be much the president can do to stop it.

Investigators now have computer files as well as banking and telephone records and, possibly, tapes or audio files, given Cohen’s apparent habit of recording conversations. This has become an even more immediate threat to the president, certain members of his family, former campaign officials, and Trump Organization executives—on top of a guilty plea by Trump’s former national security adviser, Michael Flynn, and indictments of his campaign manager Paul Manafort and senior adviser Rick Gates.

Even though much of what is being investigated has little to do with Russian efforts to influence the outcome of the election, it is a time-honored tradition for prosecutors to find unrelated transgressions in order to apply pressure to get people to sing like canaries, going for the bigger fish. Subpoenas are flying like confetti at a political convention.

Reportedly and not surprisingly, the president is enraged, and it appears that the number of those who are willing and able to convince Trump not to fire Deputy Attorney General Rod Rosenstein and Robert Mueller is diminishing. Some believe it is only a matter of time—perhaps just hours or days—before Trump does it.

George Stephanopoulos’s interview with former FBI Director James Comey, which aired Sunday night on ABC, along with Comey’s book, A Higher Loyalty: Truth, Lies and Leadership, to be released on Tuesday, will only turn the heat up even closer to the boiling point (although I think Comey would have served himself better if he had toned down his language by about 20 percent).

These investigations are getting dangerously close to the president himself. Obviously there would be a firestorm if Rosenstein and Mueller are fired—the media and many in Congress would go crazy—but some suggest that Trump has little choice. Either he can fire Rosenstein and Mueller immediately, or it will be too late and he will wish he had. Putting aside the many ethical, legal, moral, and political reasons not to fire them, arguably the risk is too high for him not to. Does anyone really expect Trump to sit idly by and let the process work?

One problem is that it might require firing more people than just Rosenstein and Mueller. The case can be made that he would also need to fire or replace Attorney General Jeff Sessions, the solicitor general, the head of the Justice Department’s Criminal Division—as far as it takes to find someone who can and will fire Mueller, potentially leaving the DOJ leaderless.

Even firing Rosenstein and Mueller and issuing pardons to whoever needs them might not solve the problem. First, the investigation is not limited to Mueller’s office, as the U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of New York ordered the raid on Cohen. Certainly an attorney general or acting attorney general sympathetic to the president could shut that down too, but it just complicates things.

And keep in mind, the president cannot pardon someone for a conviction of a state, as opposed to federal, crime. Eric Schneiderman, the aggressive Democratic New York state attorney general, may be able to pick up anything involving Michael Cohen and plenty of other matters without missing a beat. Some attorneys have noted that having an investigation independent of the Mueller probe could get around some of the attorney-client privilege issues that have arisen.

As David Ignatius noted recently in The Washington Post, even if Trump fires Mueller, the chief judge of the U.S. District Court in Washington could plug in a new prosecutor, maybe even Mueller himself, to pursue the case. Ignatius points back to the Watergate scandal: After President Nixon fired independent prosecutor Archibald Cox, the chief judge of the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, John Sirica, intended to name a new special counsel oversee the two Watergate grand juries, but things just didn’t get far enough for that to happen. Beryl Howell, the current chief judge, could certainly step in—though there could be a real separation-of-powers problem with this approach, if the judiciary steps into the executive branch’s territory.

In other words, there is no single outcome that saves Trump, no silver bullet that he or someone on his behalf can fire, that would make these problems go away.

What We're Following See More »
North Korea Says It Will Suspend Nuclear Tests
1 hours ago

"North Korea says it has suspended nuclear and long-range missile tests and plans to close its nuclear test site. The North’s official Korean Central News Agency said the suspension of nuclear and ICBM tests went into effect Saturday." The announcement comes shortly before Kim Jong Un "is set to meet South Korean President Moon Jae-in in a border truce village for a rare summit aimed at resolving the nuclear standoff with Pyongyang."

GOP Megadonor Running For Governor In Wyoming
5 hours ago

"Republican megadonor Foster Friess has told party leaders in Wyoming that he plans to run for governor," and is expected to make an announcement this afternoon. Friess has donated "millions of dollars to Republican candidates and causes over the last decade, according to federal campaign finance records," including over "$1.7 million to boost Santorum's [presidential] campaign" in 2016. Gov. Matt Mead (R) is term-limited, and "a handful of Republicans are running in an open primary to succeed him in one of the reddest states in the country."

Israeli Army Kills Four Palestinian Protestors
6 hours ago

Four Palestinian protestors have been killed by Israeli fire near the Gaza-Israel border, bringing the death toll to 38, in what marks the "fourth consecutive week of Gaza's March of Return mass protests." The marches are part of a "month-and-a-half-long protest organized by Hamas near the border fence," which organizers have said will not stop before May 15. The marches are intended to emulate anti-apartheid protests in South Africa, and to commemorate the forced expulsion of Palestinians from their homes in 1948, during the establishment of the State of Israel.

McCabe To Sue For Wrongful Termination, Defamation
7 hours ago

"Former Deputy FBI Director Andrew McCabe is looking to sue for defamation, wrongful termination and other possible civil claims, his lawyer told reporters Friday." McCabe's attorney Michael Bromwich said that his team "hasn't managed to find any witnesses to corroborate McCabe's version of the story," although they have not had enough time to do so. "McCabe’s lawyers are also seeking ways to release the emails between McCabe and Comey, which would offer insight into their communication about the leaks to the Wall Street Journal."

DNC Files Sweeping Lawsuit Over 2016 Election
8 hours ago

"The Democratic National Committee filed a multimillion-dollar lawsuit Friday against the Russian government, the Trump campaign and the WikiLeaks organization alleging a far-reaching conspiracy to disrupt the 2016 campaign and tilt the election to Donald Trump. The complaint, filed in federal district court in Manhattan, alleges that top Trump campaign officials conspired with the Russian government and its military spy agency to hurt Democratic presidential nominee Hillary Clinton and help Trump by hacking the computer networks of the Democratic Party and disseminating stolen material found there." The DNC is seeking "millions of dollars in compensation to offset damage it claims the party suffered from the hacks," and is arguing the cyberattack" undermined its ability to communicate with voters, collect donations and operate effectively as its employees faced personal harassment and, in some cases, death threats."


Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.