Turning Obamacare into a Frankenmonster

Vulnerable Democrats need to be seen fixing Obamacare. Obama needs them not to.

People dressed as Frankenstein's Monster and Mrs. Frankenstein's Monster stand on the South Lawn of the White House, October 31.
National Journal
Sam Baker
Nov. 20, 2013, 5 p.m.

Burdened by the botched rol­lout of his health care law, Pres­id­ent Obama has run out of good op­tions.

He can stick to a policy he fought for and be­lieves in, or he can throw a polit­ic­al life­line to Demo­crats who are pan­icked, furi­ous at the ad­min­is­tra­tion, and do­ing their best to keep the Sen­ate in Demo­crat­ic hands. He can’t do both.

Obama has already tried to thread this needle once, with his “fix” to ad­dress a wave of can­celed in­sur­ance plans — or, more ac­cur­ately, to ad­dress the bad pub­li­city sur­round­ing can­celed in­sur­ance plans. His an­nounce­ment gave Demo­crats some breath­ing room, but it frus­trated al­lies who are more com­mit­ted to the Af­ford­able Care Act’s policies than to the party that passed them.

If Con­gres­sion­al Demo­crats keep fret­ting and Obama keeps cav­ing, the al­lies say, the party risks tinker­ing its way in­to a polit­ic­al and policy dis­aster: a mal­func­tion­ing law full of half-meas­ures that neither de­liv­ers on its prom­ises nor provides any­thing for em­battled Demo­crats to rally around.

“I’m con­cerned that the polit­ic­al dif­fi­culties of the mo­ment are go­ing to un­der­mine the ba­sic found­a­tion on which the stat­ute is built,” said Tim Jost, a Wash­ing­ton & Lee Uni­versity law pro­fess­or and a strong sup­port­er of the health care law.

Obama’s own polit­ic­al leg­acy is on the line with health care. He needs the law to work in the long run, and even in­noc­u­ous-seem­ing polit­ic­al con­ces­sions now can cre­ate big­ger prob­lems down the road. Even a change as minor as ex­tend­ing the law’s en­roll­ment win­dow, as Sen. Jeanne Shaheen, D-N.H., has pro­posed, could have un­in­ten­ded con­sequences. It’s the defined en­roll­ment peri­od that stops healthy people from tak­ing their chances without in­sur­ance and sign­ing up on their way to the emer­gency room if they need it.

“Our start­ing point has to be that any­thing you do right now makes the policy worse,” said Jonath­an Gruber, a health care eco­nom­ist at MIT who helped design the law. “I think the policy will work if we leave it alone.”

That’s an in­creas­ingly hard sell, though, for con­gres­sion­al Demo­crats who have already fol­lowed Obama this far down the road, only to end up with a broken web­site and a ra­ging con­tro­versy over can­celed in­sur­ance plans.

Demo­crats es­sen­tially gave up years ago try­ing to re­verse the law’s stub­bornly am­bi­val­ent polling, say­ing the law would work once it was in place and everything would be fine. But that strategy hinged on the White House im­ple­ment­ing the law well, and in­stead the ad­min­is­tra­tion de­livered a bungled web­site whose high-pro­file fail­ure made the in­ev­it­able stor­ies about plan can­cel­la­tions worse.

Now, neg­at­ive per­cep­tions are be­ing ce­men­ted and rank-and-file law­makers want to show their con­stitu­ents either an im­prove­ment or a vote in fa­vor of an im­prove­ment. A de­tailed ex­plan­a­tion of the best ways to struc­ture an in­sur­ance mar­ket won’t cut it.

Obama tried to de­liv­er, but Demo­crats left their op­tions open even after he an­nounced his ad­min­is­trat­ive “fix” for can­celed plans, with in-cycle Sen­ate Demo­crat Mary Landrieu, D-La., say­ing le­gis­la­tion was needed to make the change stick.

Policy-minded sup­port­ers of the health care law are un­happy too and wor­ried about Obama’s will­ing­ness to wade in­to the is­sue. The way Obama ad­dressed the is­sue was the “least bad thing you could do,” Gruber said, but go­ing any fur­ther ““ as many con­gres­sion­al Demo­crats want to do ““ would only fur­ther per­petu­ate the two-tiered sys­tem that Obama­care is try­ing to equal­ize.

On its face, the tradeoff un­der­ly­ing the Af­ford­able Care Act seems simple: Guar­an­tee cov­er­age to sick people, and bring healthy people in­to the sys­tem to off­set the cost. The ex­e­cu­tion of that bal­ance, though, is com­plic­ated. It re­lies on a web of spe­cif­ic policies that work to­geth­er. Many of those spe­cif­ic tools ““ such as push­ing healthy people off of their in­ex­pens­ive plans ““ are un­pop­u­lar on their own.

But pulling on any one of those threads — and there are no few­er than four Demo­crat­ic plans that would do just that — could up­set the law’s built-in ef­forts to get people covered and avoid ma­jor premi­um hikes next year. Let­ting more people keep old health care plans would up­set that bal­ance. So would delay­ing the in­di­vidu­al man­date, as Sen. Joe Manchin, D-W. Va., has pro­posed. Even Shaheen’s in­noc­u­ous-look­ing pro­pos­al to ex­tend the win­dow to buy cov­er­age is mak­ing in­sur­ance com­pan­ies nervous.

All of those bills would chip away, to some ex­tent, at policies de­signed to push young, healthy people in­to Obama­care’s mar­ket­places. And get­ting young people to sign up is the key to the law’s ul­ti­mate suc­cess.

“I would really hope that there would be some forti­tude in the face of all this “¦ I can un­der­stand that they’re nervous, but I hope they can keep a longer per­spect­ive on things,” Jost said.

What We're Following See More »
JOINS BUSHES, MCCAIN
Romney to Skip Convention
10 minutes ago
THE LATEST

An aide to Mitt Romney confirmed to the Washington Post that the 2102 GOP nominee will not attend the Republican convention this year. He joins the two living Republican presidents, George W. Bush and George H.W. Bush, as well as 2008 nominee John McCain in skipping the event. Even among living Republican nominees, that leaves only Bob Dole who could conceivably show up. Dole did say in January that he'd prefer Trump to Ted Cruz, but his age (92) could keep him from attending.

Source:
CALIFORNIA MAKES IT 21
FDA to Ban All Tobacco Sales to Minors
2 hours ago
THE DETAILS

In a long-awaiting new rule, the Food and Drug Administration will ban sale of all tobacco products—including e-cigarettes—to those under 18. The rule takes effect in 90 days. It's part of a larger package of regulations that "gives FDA authority to regulate—but not to ban—all tobacco products, from e-cigarettes to cigars and hookahs." Meanwhile, California Gov. Jerry Brown (D) signed a bill on Wednesday that would bump the legal age to buy all tobacco products from 18 to 21.

Source:
#NEVERTRUMP
Sen. Sasse Calls for a Third Candidate
3 hours ago
THE LATEST

Sen. Ben Sasse, the most prominent elected official to declare that he's #NeverTrump, wrote an open letter on Facebook to the "majority of Americans who wonder why the nation that put a man on the moon can’t find a healthy leader who can take us forward together." Calling to mind recent conversations at a Fremont, Neb., Walmart, the senator pitted the presumptive general election battle between Donald Trump and Hillary Clinton as such a "terrible choice" that there would be an appetite for another candidate to emerge. In a parenthetical aside to reporters, Sasse ruled himself out. "Such a leader should be able to campaign 24/7 for the next six months," he wrote. "Therefore he/she likely can’t be an engaged parent with little kids." Meanwhile, his colleague Sen. John McCain (R-AZ) admitted in a private recording obtained by Politico that Trump hurts his reelection chances.

Source:
UTAH REPUBLICAN
Former Sen. Bob Bennett Dies at 82
7 hours ago
THE DETAILS

Former Utah Republican Sen. Bob Bennett died of pancreatic cancer on Wednesday after a long battle with pancreatic cancer. Bennett was defeated in a primary in 2010 by Tea Party–backed Mike Lee.

Source:
CLINTON HERSELF COULD TESTIFY LATER
Judge Approves Deposition of Clinton Aides
7 hours ago
THE LATEST

"Judge Emmet G. Sullivan, of the United States District Court for the District of Columbia, approved a joint proposal presented by Judicial Watch and the State Department to take the depositions of officials" involved in the setup and use of Hillary Clinton's private email server, "including Cheryl D. Mills, Clinton's former chief of staff, Huma Abedin, a senior adviser to Clinton, and Bryan Pagliano, a State Department employee who serviced and maintained the server." He said Clinton could be deposed later on, though that may not be necessary.

Source:
×