States Aren’t So Sure Their High Schoolers Should Go to College

Education departments around the country are rolling back graduation requirements in a bid to aid students who aren’t headed to university. But they risk marginalizing minorities.

DALLAS, TX - MARCH 23: Young students attend the American Heart Association's Teaching Garden Plant Day at Moss Haven Elementary School on March 23, 2012 in Dallas, Texas. 
Getty Images For The American He
Sophie Quinton
Add to Briefcase
See more stories about...
Sophie Quinton
Nov. 21, 2013, 4 p.m.

Just sev­en years ago, the Texas Le­gis­lature man­dated that all high school­ers pass two al­gebra courses and geo­metry to gradu­ate. This sum­mer, the state re­versed course, eas­ing its strict math, sci­ence, and so­cial-stud­ies re­quire­ments to free up class time for job train­ing.

Texas le­gis­lat­ors want to cre­ate a more flex­ible sys­tem that helps stu­dents who aren’t headed to four-year col­leges enter the work­force. And it’s not just Texas. State le­gis­latures na­tion­wide are en­act­ing laws to pro­mote ca­reer and tech­nic­al edu­ca­tion and work­force train­ing in high school.

But that ap­proach car­ries risks. While it’s true that not all stu­dents will go on to col­lege, pulling back on col­lege pre­par­at­ory course­work has to be handled care­fully in a state like Texas, with its hun­dreds of thou­sands of low-in­come and minor­ity stu­dents. They’re the stu­dents who would be­ne­fit from col­lege the most — and who need the most help get­ting there.

New laws in Texas, as well as in Flor­ida, de-em­phas­ize Al­gebra 2, the math class re­quired for ad­mis­sion to four-year col­leges and place­ment in­to col­lege-level math at two-year in­sti­tu­tions. Know­ledge of Al­gebra 2 is con­sidered an in­dic­at­or of col­lege read­i­ness un­der the Com­mon Core stand­ards, which have been ad­op­ted by 45 states, in­clud­ing Flor­ida.

More than half of pub­lic-school stu­dents in both states are non­white. Fifty per­cent of Texas stu­dents and 56 per­cent of Flor­ida stu­dents qual­i­fy for fed­er­ally sub­sid­ized lunches. It’s par­tic­u­larly im­port­ant that low-in­come, His­pan­ic, and Afric­an-Amer­ic­an stu­dents leave high school qual­i­fied to fur­ther their edu­ca­tion — even if they don’t plan on do­ing so right away. A col­lege de­gree is the most im­port­ant driver of so­cial mo­bil­ity. By 2020, 65 per­cent of all jobs will re­quire some kind of post­sec­ond­ary edu­ca­tion, ac­cord­ing to the Geor­getown Cen­ter on Edu­ca­tion and the Work­force.

Prac­tic­ally speak­ing, Texas’s earli­er col­lege-prep course­work re­com­mend­a­tions didn’t fit real­ity. Des­pite the high bar, only about half of the state’s high school gradu­ates im­me­di­ately headed off to col­lege of any kind. “We wanted to give stu­dents and par­ents more flex­ib­il­ity, to not only be col­lege-pre­pared — which I think we’re do­ing a pretty good job of — but per­haps to ex­pand that pre­par­a­tion to folks who may not be go­ing to col­lege,” Rep. Jim­mie Don Ay­cock, a Re­pub­lic­an who chairs the Texas House’s Pub­lic Edu­ca­tion Com­mit­tee, says of the re­vi­sion. The goal isn’t to dumb down the cur­riculum, he says, but to let kids pur­sue a path that might not have been open to them be­fore. The state’s edu­ca­tion-ac­count­ab­il­ity sys­tem still re­wards schools when stu­dents demon­strate col­lege read­i­ness.

Rather than a re­com­men­ded four years each of math, sci­ence, and so­cial stud­ies, Texas stu­dents now need just three cred­its in each and must take five end-of-course tests rather than 15. Stu­dents will be able to earn “en­dorse­ments” in areas such as pub­lic ser­vice, arts and hu­man­it­ies, and busi­ness and in­dustry. The State Board of Edu­ca­tion is cur­rently de­bat­ing which en­dorse­ments will re­quire Al­gebra 2.

Flor­ida’s new law rolls back the re­quire­ment (signed in­to law in 2010) that stu­dents take Al­gebra 2 and either chem­istry or phys­ics and al­lows some in­dustry-fo­cused courses to sat­is­fy sub­ject-area re­quire­ments. Stu­dents who earn ad­vanced aca­dem­ic cred­its will re­ceive a “schol­ar” des­ig­na­tion on their dip­lo­mas, while stu­dents who earn one or more in­dustry cer­ti­fic­a­tions will earn a “mer­it” des­ig­na­tion.

Over the past dec­ade, states pushed for more ad­vanced aca­dem­ics — more poly­no­mi­al equa­tions! — but the rising cost of col­lege, the du­bi­ous re­turn on in­vest­ment from a lib­er­al-arts de­gree, and the com­pet­it­ive salar­ies earned by the hold­ers of tech­nic­al two-year de­grees have caused many states to re­think their policies. The 16 oth­er states that re­quire Al­gebra 2 are stay­ing the course for now, but that could change when le­gis­latures re­con­vene next year.

Set­ting up a non­col­lege track doesn’t ne­ces­sar­ily have to di­vert stu­dents from post­sec­ond­ary edu­ca­tion. High school pro­grams aligned to in­dustry of­ten pre­pare stu­dents for an as­so­ci­ate’s de­gree. Stu­dents who fill entry-level jobs in health care and oth­er sec­tors are ex­pec­ted to go back to school to ad­vance their ca­reers.

And it’s worth de­bat­ing, too, wheth­er Al­gebra 2 should be the gate­way course for col­lege ad­mis­sion. Al­though tak­ing ad­vanced high school math has been linked to col­lege and ca­reer suc­cess, it’s un­clear if the con­nec­tion is caus­al. A se­quence of math courses that lay the ground­work for cal­cu­lus has little rel­ev­ance in most ca­reers, let alone in the lib­er­al arts.

Still, the ad­vant­age of state edu­ca­tion­al re­quire­ments that re­quire ad­vanced aca­dem­ics is that they clearly com­mu­nic­ate what top col­leges want. “There may have been a mis­per­cep­tion that by re­quir­ing this course se­quence in math, people were say­ing that all stu­dents had to go to col­lege, and that was nev­er the case,” says Jen­nifer Dounay Zinth, seni­or policy ana­lyst at the Edu­ca­tion Com­mis­sion of the States.

Na­tion­wide, dis­pro­por­tion­ate num­bers of af­flu­ent white stu­dents head to se­lect­ive four-year col­leges, while most low-in­come, minor­ity stu­dents go to two-year col­leges, open-ac­cess in­sti­tu­tions, or no col­lege at all. In­form­a­tion dis­par­it­ies are at least part of the prob­lem. A 2003 Stan­ford Uni­versity study of six states found that less than 12 per­cent of high school stu­dents were aware of course re­quire­ments for their loc­al uni­versit­ies. In fact, simply mail­ing high-achiev­ing low-in­come stu­dents more col­lege-en­roll­ment in­form­a­tion in­creased the num­ber of ap­plic­a­tions those stu­dents sent to se­lect­ive col­leges, re­search­ers at Stan­ford and the Uni­versity of Vir­gin­ia re­cently found.

So the ques­tion is far from settled wheth­er states are prop­erly serving their minor­ity stu­dents by lower­ing aca­dem­ic re­quire­ments. The ad­ded flex­ib­il­ity may give some high schools an ex­cuse to mar­gin­al­ize their stu­dents by not pre­par­ing them for col­lege. And, by do­ing so, not pre­par­ing them for a job mar­ket that re­wards post­sec­ond­ary edu­ca­tion.

What We're Following See More »
Debate Could Sway One-Third of Voters
8 hours ago

"A new Wall Street Journal/NBC News poll found that 34% of registered voters think the three presidential debates would be extremely or quite important in helping them decide whom to support for president. About 11% of voters are considered 'debate persuadables'—that is, they think the debates are important and are either third-party voters or only loosely committed to either major-party candidate."

Gennifer Flowers May Not Appear After All
9 hours ago

Will he or won't he? That's the question surrounding Donald Trump and his on-again, off-again threats to bring onetime Bill Clinton paramour Gennifer Flowers to the debate as his guest. An assistant to flowers initially said she'd be there, but Trump campaign chief Kellyanne Conway "said on ABC’s 'This Week' that the Trump campaign had not invited Flowers to the debate, but she didn’t rule out the possibility of Flowers being in the audience."

For First Debate, Holt Called on NBC Experts for Prep
9 hours ago

NBC's Lester Holt hasn't hosted the "Nightly News" since Tuesday, as he's prepped for moderating the first presidential debate tonight—and the first of his career. He's called on a host of NBC talent to help him, namely NBC News and MSNBC chairman Andy Lack; NBC News president Deborah Turness; the news division's senior vice president of editorial, Janelle Rodriguez; "Nightly News" producer Sam Singal, "Meet the Press" host Chuck Todd, senior political editor Mark Murray and political editor Carrie Dann. But during the debate itself, the only person in Holt's earpiece will be longtime debate producer Marty Slutsky.

House Votes to Bar Cash Payments to Iran
9 hours ago

"The House passed legislation late Thursday that would prohibit the federal government from making any cash payments to Iran, in protest of President Obama's recently discovered decision to pay Iran $1.7 billion in cash in January. And while the White House has said Obama would veto the bill, 16 Democrats joined with Republicans to pass the measure, 254-163."

Trump Eschewing Briefing Materials in Debate Prep
9 hours ago

In contrast to Hillary Clinton's meticulous debate practice sessions, Donald Trump "is largely shun­ning tra­di­tion­al de­bate pre­par­a­tions, but has been watch­ing video of…Clin­ton’s best and worst de­bate mo­ments, look­ing for her vul­ner­ab­il­it­ies.” Trump “has paid only curs­ory at­ten­tion to brief­ing ma­ter­i­als. He has re­fused to use lecterns in mock de­bate ses­sions des­pite the ur­ging of his ad­visers. He prefers spit­balling ideas with his team rather than hon­ing them in­to crisp, two-minute an­swers.”