The GOP’s Missouri Meltdown

Senate Republicans can’t afford to botch recruitment in red-state races if they want to expand their majority. Their experience in Missouri raises a cautionary flag for the midterms.

Missouri Republican Rep. Ann Wagner speaks to supporters on Nov. 7 at her campaign office where she was seeking her third term in office in Missouri's 2nd Congressional District.
AP Photo/Jeff Roberson
July 7, 2017, 12:18 p.m.

In a tu­mul­tu­ous polit­ic­al en­vir­on­ment, Re­pub­lic­ans need to play er­ror-free ball to ex­pand their Sen­ate ma­jor­ity. But if the party’s ex­per­i­ence in Mis­souri is any guide, the GOP needs to sharpen its game be­fore the midterms.

Here’s the back­ground: Sen. Claire Mc­Caskill is ar­gu­ably the most vul­ner­able Demo­crat­ic sen­at­or up for reelec­tion, but she’s also a dogged cam­paign­er who is skilled at ex­ploit­ing her op­pon­ent’s weak­nesses. Rep. Ann Wag­n­er emerged as the ob­vi­ous early fa­vor­ite to chal­lenge Mc­Caskill, giv­en the con­gress­wo­man’s im­press­ive fun­drais­ing re­cord, polit­ic­al base in vote-rich sub­urb­an St. Louis, and abil­ity to ex­pand the num­ber of Re­pub­lic­an wo­men in the Sen­ate. Of­fi­cials at the Na­tion­al Re­pub­lic­an Sen­at­ori­al Com­mit­tee ex­pec­ted her to jump in the race this month. She even hired a cam­paign man­ager for the planned Sen­ate run.

This is where the story gets in­ter­est­ing. Des­pite all of Wag­n­er’s strengths, some Re­pub­lic­an of­fi­cials in Wash­ing­ton were grow­ing en­am­ored with Mis­souri At­tor­ney Gen­er­al Josh Haw­ley, an am­bi­tious 37-year-old former Su­preme Court clerk who rock­eted to polit­ic­al prom­in­ence in last year’s state elec­tions. Mis­souri Re­pub­lic­ans across the ideo­lo­gic­al spec­trum, led by former Sen. John Dan­forth, cham­pioned his polit­ic­al po­ten­tial. At the same time, some lead­ing Mis­souri donors wer­en’t sold on Wag­n­er. They raised ques­tions about her com­mit­ment to con­ser­vat­ism, cre­at­ing the pro­spect of a con­tested primary.

Last month in a trip to Wash­ing­ton, Haw­ley spoke with of­fi­cials at NR­SC, ac­cord­ing to sev­er­al sources fa­mil­i­ar with the meet­ing. Haw­ley is rep­res­en­ted by the same con­sult­ing firm as NR­SC chair­man Cory Gard­ner—On­Mes­sage Inc.—giv­ing him a valu­able con­nec­tion to the key power brokers in the cap­it­al. There’s noth­ing wrong with the com­mit­tee meet­ing with pro­spect­ive can­did­ates, but Wag­n­er was kept in the dark about the dis­cus­sion, ac­cord­ing to a spokes­man for the con­gress­wo­man.

In a state­ment, Wag­n­er said she passed on a run due to fam­ily con­sid­er­a­tions. But a ma­jor reas­on she stepped aside is be­cause she felt snubbed by Re­pub­lic­an of­fi­cials who wer­en’t will­ing to put enough weight be­hind her can­did­acy, ac­cord­ing to sources fa­mil­i­ar with her de­cision. She didn’t dis­cuss her de­cision with Gard­ner or Sen­ate Ma­jor­ity Lead­er Mitch Mc­Con­nell be­fore re­leas­ing her state­ment, leav­ing them blind­sided to the polit­ic­al blow­back.

“When she de­cided not to run, it was more of a re­ac­tion to what she was hear­ing and deal­ing with over the last six months than any per­son­al rev­el­a­tion that she doesn’t want to be a sen­at­or,” said one seni­or GOP of­fi­cial fa­mil­i­ar with her think­ing. “She wasn’t able to unite the party, and prob­ably would have pro­voked some kind of primary.”

Wag­n­er’s ab­rupt re­versal puts Re­pub­lic­an of­fi­cials in a tight spot. They are now put­ting all their chips in re­cruit­ing Haw­ley to the race, be­liev­ing he’s just as strong of a can­did­ate as Wag­n­er. But he’s still ag­on­iz­ing over a de­cision, wary about leav­ing statewide of­fice after less than a year to pur­sue a job in Wash­ing­ton. Des­pite his cor­di­al con­ver­sa­tions in Wash­ing­ton, he nev­er was plan­ning to chal­lenge Wag­n­er in a primary. Now he will need to make a ca­reer-al­ter­ing de­cision in short or­der, risk­ing a com­fort­able job in leg­al circles to be­come the polit­ic­al face of the GOP’s re­cruit­ing class in 2018.

Re­pub­lic­ans have oth­er in­ter­ested can­did­ates if Haw­ley de­cides not to run, in­clud­ing state Treas­urer Eric Schmitt and Rep. Vicky Hartz­ler. But neither comes close to Haw­ley’s polit­ic­al fire­power. The big­ger GOP fear is that a wide-open, crowded primary field would lower the bar for win­ning, lead­ing to a weak can­did­ate emer­ging as Mc­Caskill’s chal­lenger—ex­actly what happened with Todd Akin’s flawed can­did­acy in 2012.

In­deed, fail­ing to ef­fect­ively nav­ig­ate in­tra­party chal­lenges five years ago is the reas­on why Mc­Caskill is still a sen­at­or today. Back then, Re­pub­lic­ans failed to clear the field for a cred­ible can­did­ate, even though the statewide polit­ic­al en­vir­on­ment was highly fa­vor­able for the party. In turn, the polit­ic­ally tone-deaf Akin won the nom­in­a­tion, giv­ing Demo­crats a gift-wrapped Sen­ate seat they oth­er­wise wouldn’t have won.

That scen­ario looked un­likely to re­peat it­self in 2018, giv­en the deep bench of top Re­pub­lic­an of­fice­hold­ers and the state’s con­ser­vat­ive trend line. But there are some eer­ie sim­il­ar­it­ies in the party’s in­ab­il­ity to land its top can­did­ate and grow­ing fears of a messy Re­pub­lic­an free-for-all. If Re­pub­lic­ans can’t win in Mis­souri next year, it’s go­ing to be a very rough midterm cycle for the GOP.

What We're Following See More »
Mueller Requests Four-Year Prison Time for Cohen
2 days ago

"Michael Cohen, President Trump’s former lawyer, should receive a “substantial” prison term of roughly four years, federal prosecutors in New York said on Friday. Mr. Cohen, 52, is to be sentenced in Manhattan for two separate guilty pleas: one for campaign finance violations and financial crimes charged by federal prosecutors in Manhattan, and the other for lying to Congress in the Russia inquiry, filed by Mr. Mueller’s office."

Trump Nominates Bill Barr as AG
2 days ago
Mueller Questioning Trump Aide About Appearances on RT
3 days ago

"Robert Mueller is allegedly examining a Trump campaign adviser’s appearances on the Kremlin-controlled broadcaster RT, offering new hints about the investigation into possible collusion between Moscow and Donald Trump’s associates. Mueller’s investigators have asked Ted Malloch, the London-based American academic who is also close to Nigel Farage, about his frequent appearances on RT, which US intelligence authorities have called Russia’s principal propaganda arm."

Senate Passes Two-Week Stopgap
3 days ago
House Passes Two-Week Stopgap
3 days ago

Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.