Battle Widens Over ‘Gas Rush’ Climate Footprint

An employee checks piping in the main turbine hall at the EON AG gas fired power station on the Isle of Grain, U.K., on Thursday, Oct. 4, 2012. The National Grid Plc and E.ON have worked together to link two plants with twin pipelines, allowing surplus heat from electricity generation at E.ON.s power station to heat LNG and convert it back to gas. Photographer: Chris Ratcliffe/Bloomberg via Getty Images
National Journal
Ben Geman
Add to Briefcase
Ben Geman
Dec. 6, 2013, 2:33 p.m.

Nat­ur­al gas ad­voc­ates are fa­cing fresh cri­ti­cism about the fuel’s cli­mate foot­print, even as gas-fired power plants snag mar­ket share from coal units that emit vastly more car­bon.

Gas crit­ics have ar­gued in re­cent years that leaks of meth­ane — a po­tent green­house gas — from pro­duc­tion wells risk sub­stan­tially off­set­ting the car­bon ad­vant­age gas holds over coal.

And now a new study is rais­ing a sep­ar­ate set of ques­tions about the cli­mate foot­print of the U.S. nat­ur­al-gas pro­duc­tion boom.

The En­vir­on­ment­al In­teg­rity Pro­ject (EIP) re­port looks at green­house-gas emis­sions from big in­fra­struc­ture and in­dus­tri­al pro­jects that are crop­ping up along­side sur­ging U.S. gas pro­duc­tion.

“The shale gas boom has un­leashed a tid­al wave of pro­pos­als to build new com­pressors and pipelines, and ex­pand chem­ic­al, fer­til­izer, and pet­ro­leum plants that de­pend on nat­ur­al gas for feed­stock or fuel,” the re­port states.

“Since Janu­ary 1, 2012, these in­dus­tries have pro­posed or already ob­tained Clean Air Act per­mits that au­thor­ize a 91 mil­lion ton in­crease in green­house gas emis­sions — as much as the out­put from twenty large (500 mega­watt) coal-fired power plants,” adds the study titled “Gas Rush: In­creas­ing Green­house Gas Emis­sions from New Oil, Gas and Chem­ic­al Plants.”

To be sure, EIP isn’t claim­ing that these emis­sions neg­ate the ad­vant­age of gas-fired power plants that emit roughly half as much car­bon di­ox­ide as coal-fired plants.

In­deed EIP pre­dicts the emis­sions from the vari­ous planned gas-re­lated in­fra­struc­ture pro­jects they sur­veyed, such as li­que­fied-nat­ur­al-gas ter­min­als and chem­ic­al plants that use nat­ur­al gas, would be the equi­val­ent of 10 gigawatts of coal-fired power gen­er­a­tion.

That’s a lot few­er coal gigawatts than ana­lysts pre­dict will be re­tired in com­ing years — due in part to com­pet­i­tion from low-cost gas and in part to Obama ad­min­is­tra­tion air-pol­lu­tion rules.

A late 2012 re­port by the Brattle Group fore­casts that 59 to 77 gigawatts of coal-plant ca­pa­city will be moth­balled over the next five years, while a re­cent Re­u­ters ana­lys­is is less ag­gress­ive, pre­dict­ing about 46 gigawatts of re­tire­ments over 10 years.

And the growth of nat­ur­al-gas-fired elec­tri­city plants at coal’s ex­pense has helped cut U.S. en­ergy-re­lated car­bon emis­sions to their low­est level since 1994, ac­cord­ing to the fed­er­al En­ergy In­form­a­tion Ad­min­is­tra­tion.

But the EIP re­port notes that the build-out of oth­er gas-re­lated or gas-en­abled in­fra­struc­ture means these power-sec­tor cli­mate ad­vant­ages will be “par­tially off­set by high­er emis­sions from oth­er in­dus­tries cash­ing in on cheap and abund­ant sup­plies of oil and gas from shale de­pos­its.”

EIP Dir­ect­or Eric Schaef­fer said the re­port shows the need for ex­pan­ded green­house-gas reg­u­la­tions bey­ond the power-plant stand­ards the En­vir­on­ment­al Pro­tec­tion Agency is craft­ing.

“The Obama ad­min­is­tra­tion ap­proaches its sixth year without hav­ing even pro­posed green­house-gas stand­ards for the nat­ur­al gas, chem­ic­al, or re­fin­ing sec­tors, al­though a re­view of per­mits in­dic­ates that emis­sions are es­cal­at­ing rap­idly from all three in­dus­tries. Time is run­ning out for ac­tion,” he said in a state­ment.

An oil-and-gas-in­dustry spokes­man de­fen­ded the U.S. nat­ur­al-gas boom.

“The facts are the facts. The United States is lead­ing the world in re­duced emis­sions while at the same time it is the No. 1 pro­du­cer of nat­ur­al gas in the world. It is cre­at­ing jobs and bil­lions of dol­lars rev­en­ue for the gov­ern­ment at the time that it needs it the most,” said Amer­ic­an Pet­ro­leum In­sti­tute spokes­man Eric Wohlschle­gel.

Gas ad­voc­ates have also fiercely pushed back against the cri­ti­cisms over meth­ane, and they have an ally in En­ergy Sec­ret­ary Ern­est Mon­iz, who has said re­peatedly that meth­ane emis­sions won’t neg­ate the fuel’s car­bon ad­vant­ages.

But the new EIP re­port shows that as the U.S. nat­ur­al-gas boom con­tin­ues, the in­dustry’s role in cli­mate policy will re­main con­tested ter­rain.

What We're Following See More »
Obamacare Premiums Set to Soar Next Year
44 minutes ago

The "benchmark" Obamacare silver plan—"upon which federal subsidies are based—will cost an average of $296 a month next year," an increase of 22% over current averages. That figure, however, "masks wide variation among the states. In Arizona, the benchmark plan's average premium will increase 116% in 2017. Arizona had the lowest rates of any state this year, said Kathryn Martin, an acting assistant secretary at the U.S. Department of Health & Human Services. In Indiana, the benchmark plan will be 3% cheaper."

Ron Klain in Line to Be Clinton’s Chief of Staff?
45 minutes ago

Sources tell CNN that longtime Democratic operative Ron Klain, who has been Vice President Biden's chief of staff, is "high on the list of prospects" to be chief of staff in a Clinton White House. "John Podesta, the campaign chairman, has signaled his interest in joining the Cabinet, perhaps as Energy secretary."

Uphill Battle for AT&T/Time Warner Deal
45 minutes ago

"AT&T Inc.’s $85.4 billion deal to buy Time Warner Inc. sails toward two cresting waves of opposition: resurgent antitrust enforcement in Washington and politicians fired by a new bipartisan populist rage. It is too early to know how regulators will treat the AT&T-Time Warner deal. But after several quiet years, President Barack Obama’s antitrust team has switched into high gear in response to a recent spurt of deal-making," a trend that's likely to continue into the next administration. The Obama Justice Department has scuttled 43 mergers, "more than double the mergers blocked by the preceding Bush Justice Department."

CNN/ORC Has Clinton Up 5 Points
14 hours ago

Hillary Clinton leads Donald Trump 49%-44% in a new CNN/ORC poll out Monday afternoon. But it's Gary Johnson's performance, or lack thereof, that's the real story. Johnson, who had cleared 10% in some surveys earlier this fall, as he made a bid to qualify for the debates, is down to 3% support. He must hit 5% nationwide for the Libertarian Party to qualify for some federal matching funds in future elections.

McCarthy, Pelosi Team Up on National Guard Bonuses
17 hours ago

The majority and minority leader of the House are both saying "California's veterans are not to blame for being mistakenly overpaid, after a Los Angeles Times story revealed that officials are trying to claw back millions in bonuses from California National Guardsmen. House Majority Leader Kevin McCarthy called the efforts to recoup the money 'disgraceful,' and asked for the Department of Defense to waive the repayments soldiers would be forced to make if they inappropriately received re-enlistment bonuses for the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan." Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi said she's looking for a "legislative fix" in the lame-duck session.


Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.