Conservative Groups Warn GOP Not to Backslide on Obamacare

Activists on the Right say lawmakers should fear them more than they do Democratic protesters.

A man shouts at Rep. Jason Chaffetz during a town hall meeting on Thursday in Cottonwood Heights, Utah.
AP Photo/Rick Bowmer
Andrea Drusch
Add to Briefcase
Andrea Drusch
Feb. 13, 2017, 8:01 p.m.

Re­pub­lic­an law­makers bom­barded by Obama­care pro­test­ers can ex­pect little sym­pathy from con­ser­vat­ive out­side groups that spent mil­lions help­ing them run on the is­sue for the past four elec­tion cycles.

Lead­ers from the Koch-backed group Amer­ic­ans for Prosper­ity and the con­ser­vat­ive Club for Growth are already warn­ing that if GOP law­makers fail to act swiftly on re­peal­ing and re­pla­cing the health care law, they’ll have more to fear from their own party than the Demo­crats show­ing up at their town halls. Stop­ping short of threat­en­ing primary chal­lenges, both groups said they would use paid me­dia and grass­roots or­gan­izers to keep the heat on any Re­pub­lic­an who stands in the way of quick ac­tion.

That warn­ing comes as Demo­crat­ic pro­test­ers have be­come fix­tures in mem­bers’ town halls, in­clud­ing in some of the red­dest dis­tricts, like that of Rep. Jason Chaf­fetz in Utah. Though GOP lead­ers down­played the protests at a con­fer­ence meet­ing last week, some Re­pub­lic­ans on the Hill have star­ted call­ing for more de­tails on an Obama­care-re­place­ment plan be­fore ab­ol­ish­ing a law that gave cov­er­age to some of their con­stitu­ents.

Speak­ing at a private mem­ber re­treat in Phil­adelphia last month whose pro­ceed­ings were secretly re­cor­ded and dis­trib­uted to news or­gan­iz­a­tions, Rep. Tom Ma­cAr­thur of New Jer­sey warned that if Re­pub­lic­ans move “too fast” on the re­peal, they would “pull the rug out from un­der” the mil­lions of people who re­ceived cov­er­age from Medi­caid ex­pan­sion.

But after years of help­ing Re­pub­lic­ans cam­paign on prom­ises to get rid of the law, AFP Pres­id­ent Tim Phil­lips said he be­lieved the party’s “biggest per­il” was in fail­ing to fol­low through quickly. In an in­ter­view with Na­tion­al Journ­al, Phil­lips called on Re­pub­lic­ans to “go big and go fast” on re­peal­ing the law, sug­gest­ing his group wouldn’t hes­it­ate to with­draw sup­port from any mem­ber who stood in the way.

“There isn’t a Re­pub­lic­an elec­ted in the last four cycles who didn’t say Obama­care was a dis­aster and that they were go­ing to go in there and re­peal it,” said Phil­lips.

Point­ing to a 2015 re­peal bill sponsored by then-Rep. Tom Price that passed both cham­bers, Phil­lips said Re­pub­lic­ans should at min­im­um be will­ing to re­peat votes they’ve already taken, quip­ping he was “con­fid­ent those wer­en’t just show votes.” (Many House GOP con­ser­vat­ives agree, and hope the cham­ber will pass the 2015 bill again.)

“When we see some of the con­sterna­tion that some of the tapes from Phil­adelphia showed, plus the two town halls that were pro­tested … I think those mem­bers have more to fear from the folks who be­lieved that prom­ise and punched the tick­et for them … than they do from their ideo­lo­gic­al op­pon­ents on the Left,” Phil­lips said.

Though AFP his­tor­ic­ally hasn’t en­gaged in primary fights, it did pull sup­port from former Sen. Kelly Ayotte of New Hamp­shire in her 2016 reelec­tion after she sup­por­ted Pres­id­ent Obama’s Clean Power Plan. Phil­lips said his group could do something sim­il­ar in 2018, as well as paid me­dia and grass­roots cam­paigns to push Re­pub­lic­ans to move fast.

Giv­en the grow­ing in­flu­ence of AFP’s state chapters, one GOP strategist sug­ges­ted los­ing that sup­port could be a sig­ni­fic­ant blow to Re­pub­lic­ans gear­ing up for tough 2018 con­tests.

“It’s not a group that para­chutes in and drops money or something like that. … They really do en­gage with act­iv­ists and vo­lun­teers and oth­ers who are im­port­ant in power­ing Re­pub­lic­an vic­tor­ies,” the strategist said.

Demo­crats, for their part, say the protests of­fer a clear sign of the polit­ic­al per­il Re­pub­lic­ans could face in the midterms if they take away con­stitu­ents’ health care ac­cess.

In a let­ter en­cour­aging the move­ment, Sen­ate Minor­ity Lead­er Chuck Schu­mer and Sen. Bernie Sanders wrote this week­end that “the Re­pub­lic­an Party’s plan to re­peal the Af­ford­able Care Act is in chaos” and “the over­whelm­ing ma­jor­ity of Amer­ic­ans” are con­cerned.

In a nod to that con­cern, Club for Growth Pres­id­ent Dav­id McIn­tosh said GOP lead­ers on the Hill should do a bet­ter job equip­ping their mem­bers to talk about the be­ne­fits of re­peal when fa­cing pro­test­ers. But, he said, GOP lead­ers shouldn’t let those ef­forts slow them down. The Club has spent mil­lions tak­ing sides in in­tra-party battles with­in the GOP, and McIn­tosh vowed to show “tough love” to Re­pub­lic­ans who stood in the way.

Singling out GOP law­makers from states that ex­pan­ded Medi­caid, McIn­tosh said “it’s not right” for those mem­bers to “hold up the whole re­peal and re­place of Obama­care to pro­tect a bad de­cision” made by their states.

In a sim­il­ar nod to the pro­test­ers, Phil­lips said his group would “nev­er pre­tend” that the Left was not ser­i­ous, and that his group would provide re­in­force­ments for those races if Re­pub­lic­ans stood their ground. Point­ing to Demo­crats’ 2012 re­call ef­fort against Wis­con­sin Gov. Scott Walk­er, in which thou­sands of Demo­crats pos­ted up out­side the state cap­it­ol for months, he sug­ges­ted Re­pub­lic­ans toughen up for the battle to come.

“If the Wis­con­sin le­gis­lature or Gov­ernor Walk­er had said, ‘Hey, we’re get­ting a lot of calls, there’s some pro­test­ers; should we keep our word?’—keep your word,” Phil­lips said.

What We're Following See More »
Two of Trump’s Top Advisors Feuding
0 minute ago

"A long-simmering feud between two of President Trump’s top advisers reached a boiling point Thursday, as White House communications director Anthony Scaramucci publicly insinuated that chief of staff Reince Priebus is a leaker."

Trump Admin Threatens Alaska
46 minutes ago

"President Donald Trump isn't going to just let go of Sen. Lisa Murkowski's no vote on Tuesday's health care. Early Wednesday, Trump took to Twitter to express displeasure with Murkowski's vote. By that afternoon, each of Alaska's two Republican senators had received a phone call from Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke letting them know the vote had put Alaska's future with the administration in jeopardy."

Trump Names Brownback Ambassador at Large
2 hours ago

President Trump has nominated Kansas Gov. Sam Brownback to be ambassador at large for international religious freedom at the Department of State. Governor since 2011, Brownback worked on religious freedom issues while a U.S. senator from 1996 to 2011.

More Sanctions, This Time on Venezuela
2 hours ago

"The Treasury Department imposed financial sanctions on a host of current and former senior Venezuelan officials on Wednesday and threatened to take more stringent action if President Nicolás Maduro proceeds with plans for a constituent assembly on Sunday that critics consider a danger to democracy."

LGBT Groups Threaten to Sue Trump Over Trans Ban
2 hours ago

LGBT groups are unsure how literally to take President Trump's tweet on Wednesday that he wants to ban transgender persons from the military, or whether it will be followed up by an official order. But if so, groups like Lambda Legal and the American Civil Liberties Union "are ready to take legal action."


Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.