Why Democrats Should Worry About Evan Bayh

He’s got a lot in common with Senate candidate Ted Strickland, who struggled once the campaigning began.

Democratic Senate candidate Evan Byah campaigns at a senior living community in Indianapolis.
AP Photo/Michael Conroy
Sept. 9, 2016, 5:17 p.m.

After re­cruit­ing a highly cel­eb­rated Sen­ate can­did­ate with en­vi­able fa­vor­ab­il­ity rat­ings back home, Demo­crats cheered when this former statewide of­fice­hold­er de­cided to reenter polit­ics. He left of­fice after the Re­pub­lic­an wave elec­tion of 2010, and in the en­su­ing years spent much of his time away from his home state. Even so, he star­ted out ahead of his GOP rival in many early polls. One red flag: He hadn’t won a race in nearly a dec­ade, liv­ing more on his past polit­ic­al glory than any re­cent elect­ive ac­com­plish­ments.

I could be writ­ing about former Ohio Gov. Ted Strick­land, the once-cel­eb­rated re­cruit turned Demo­crat­ic polit­ic­al pari­ah. But a sim­il­ar pro­file ap­plies to In­di­ana Sen­ate can­did­ate Evan Bayh, who many pun­dits as­sume will be the Demo­crats’ ma­jor­ity-maker come Novem­ber.

In real­ity, Bayh is vul­ner­able to the same forces that are dog­ging his Demo­crat­ic com­pat­ri­ot. Both are seni­or states­men who are rusty in the mod­ern meth­ods of cam­paign­ing. Neither spent much time in their home states after leav­ing of­fice. Both are run­ning in states with siz­able white, work­ing-class pop­u­la­tions where Don­ald Trump could ac­tu­ally pre­vail in the pres­id­en­tial elec­tion (he’s solidly favored in In­di­ana and a slight un­der­dog in Ohio.) And Strick­land’s lead only dis­sip­ated when Re­pub­lic­ans star­ted un­leash­ing oppo against him months ago—and kept up the bar­rage.

The well-fun­ded GOP cam­paign to define Bayh as a self-in­ter­ested car­pet­bag­ger is only just be­gin­ning in In­di­ana. If any­thing, Bayh could be more tox­ic than Strick­land, who was a res­id­ent fel­low at Har­vard’s In­sti­tute of Polit­ics be­fore spend­ing 10 months at a pro­gress­ive re­search and ad­vocacy group. Bayh went right through the re­volving door in­to big-time Wash­ing­ton lob­by­ing.

Bayh does have ad­vant­ages that Strick­land doesn’t. The Bayh name is a polit­ic­al by­word in In­di­ana, where his fath­er, Birch Bayh, was a three-term sen­at­or. Strick­land has struggled to raise money, and has been sig­ni­fic­antly out­spent by Sen. Rob Port­man and his al­lies in Ohio. Bayh had been sit­ting on a $10 mil­lion stock­pile since he re­tired, and starts out with a crit­ic­al fin­an­cial ad­vant­age against his rival, GOP Rep. Todd Young. Bayh only entered the race in Ju­ly, de­priving Re­pub­lic­ans as much time to define him as they had with Strick­land. And Young, while a sol­id re­cruit, isn’t as polit­ic­ally seasoned as Port­man.

On the oth­er hand, In­di­ana is a much more re­li­ably Re­pub­lic­an state than Ohio. Bayh will need to win a siz­able chunk of Trump sup­port­ers, which is still dif­fi­cult in these po­lar­ized times. The same Demo­crat­ic spin­meisters who dis­miss the pos­sib­il­ity of tick­et-split­ting among Clin­ton sup­port­ers are eager to tout the pres­ence of nu­mer­ous Trump-Bayh voters in In­di­ana. And des­pite Bayh’s icon­ic im­age in his home state, he de­cided to re­tire from the Sen­ate in 2010 out of fear that he could lose reelec­tion—even as he pub­licly spun it as a move out of dis­gust with Wash­ing­ton grid­lock. (In­deed, a pop­u­lar Demo­crat­ic con­gress­man got trounced by 15 points in that same elec­tion.)

At a time when voters claim to be out­raged at the polit­ic­al es­tab­lish­ments of both parties, Bayh will need to ex­plain why he cashed in as a lob­by­ist and barely re­turned home. Re­pub­lic­ans had a field day after he couldn’t even re­call the ad­dress of his In­di­ana con­domin­i­um. Ask former Sen. Richard Lugar of In­di­ana about the dam­age that en­sues when you’re at­tacked for los­ing touch with your con­stitu­ents.

Re­pub­lic­ans are also furi­ously try­ing to dent Bayh’s repu­ta­tion as a bridge-build­ing mod­er­ate. The U.S. Cham­ber of Com­merce, which once sup­por­ted Bayh, is now back­ing Young and air­ing ads against the former sen­at­or. One re­cent ad from the Na­tion­al Re­pub­lic­an Sen­at­ori­al Com­mit­tee pins him as the de­cis­ive vote for Pres­id­ent Obama’s health care law, which was a pivotal reas­on why Demo­crats lost four of the state’s 11 con­gres­sion­al seats in the 2010 midterms. An­oth­er Re­pub­lic­an spot at­tacks him for sup­port­ing a na­tion­al en­ergy tax. Strick­land, who ran for reelec­tion as gov­ernor that same year in Ohio, was badly dam­aged by these same na­tion­al is­sues, thanks to the Demo­crat­ic Party’s left­ward drift un­der Obama.

Ohio’s Sen­ate race de­veloped early be­cause of Port­man’s cash-flush cam­paign ac­count. In­di­ana’s Sen­ate race is only just be­gin­ning. Demo­crats ar­gue that’s an ad­vant­age since Re­pub­lic­ans have less time to take Bayh down. But the TV war has barely be­gun. The Sen­ate Lead­er­ship Fund is spend­ing $4 mil­lion in ads over the next month to re­mind voters of Bayh’s checkered re­cord. Des­pite Bayh’s huge war chest, Re­pub­lic­an groups are keep­ing pace on the air­waves, ac­cord­ing to a Demo­crat­ic source.

A re­spec­ted WTHR/Howey poll re­leased Fri­day showed Bayh with a four-point lead, down from sev­en points in a Mon­mouth poll a month ago and a far cry from the double-di­git lead he re­cently held in Demo­crat­ic sur­veys. He’s only polling at 44 per­cent, des­pite near-uni­ver­sal name iden­ti­fic­a­tion. If Re­pub­lic­ans can keep chip­ping away at Bayh’s lead with car­pet­bag­ger at­tack lines, it would give them a des­per­ately-needed life­line in their bid to save their Sen­ate ma­jor­ity.

What We're Following See More »
Mueller Agrees to Testify, but Only in Private
2 days ago
Trump Loses in Court Again
4 days ago
Trump Pulls the Plug on Infrastructure
4 days ago
Parties Go to Court Today Over Trump Banking Records
4 days ago
Tillerson Talking to House Foreign Affairs
5 days ago

"Former Secretary of State Rex Tillerson was spotted entering a congressional office building on Tuesday morning for what a committee aide told The Daily Beast was a meeting with the leaders of the House Foreign Affairs committee and relevant staff about his time working in the Trump administration. ... Tillerson’s arrival at the Capitol was handled with extreme secrecy. No media advisories or press releases were sent out announcing his appearance. And he took a little noticed route into the building in order to avoid being seen by members of the media."


Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.