Why the GOP Figures to Hold the House

Five contiguous districts in upstate New York provide a microcosm of what Democrats are up against.

Rep. Tom Reed
AP Photo/Charles Dharapak
Alex Rogers
Add to Briefcase
Alex Rogers
Aug. 17, 2016, 8:01 p.m.

Less than three months from Elec­tion Day, it ap­pears that Don­ald Trump’s col­lapsing cam­paign has for­feited the Re­pub­lic­an Party’s chances of tak­ing back the White House and jeop­ard­ized the GOP’s hold of the Sen­ate. But few pre­dict that his deep un­pop­ular­ity will threaten the over­whelm­ing Re­pub­lic­an ma­jor­ity in the House.

There are a num­ber of reas­ons why Demo­crats aren’t likely to win con­trol of the lower cham­ber, ac­cord­ing to Dave Wasser­man of The Cook Polit­ic­al Re­port: Few­er than 10 per­cent of seats are con­sidered com­pet­it­ive; Demo­crats were as sur­prised as any­one that Trump took the GOP nom­in­a­tion, and they didn’t re­cruit and pre­pare as well as they could have; and Re­pub­lic­ans may split their tick­ets more than usu­al, opt­ing not to vote for Trump but stick­ing with their loc­al GOP law­maker or can­did­ate.

Con­sider the five, con­tigu­ous con­gres­sion­al dis­tricts across up­state New York—the 19th, 21st, 22nd, 23rd, and 24th—that in­cum­bent Re­pub­lic­ans have held for no longer than three terms. The dis­tricts were all re­drawn in 2012 by a fed­er­al court.

The re­gion—broadly defined here—stretches from west­ern New York, through Utica, Syra­cuse, the Cat­skills, and out east to the North Coun­try. It’s over­whelm­ingly white, and with the ex­cep­tion of the dis­trict around Syra­cuse, mostly rur­al. Its polit­ics have been long dom­in­ated by so-called Rock­e­feller Re­pub­lic­ans, and its lean­ings are mod­er­ate, less defined by the coun­try’s ideo­lo­gic­al cul­tur­al battles as pock­et­book is­sues and the re­gion’s eco­nom­ic de­cline. Polit­ic­al map­makers col­or the five dis­tricts light red or purple.

“When you com­pare this re­gion polit­ic­ally to where it was 20 and 30 years ago, the reas­on they tend to be con­tested elec­tions is you have a dra­mat­ic shift in the re­gis­tra­tion basis of grav­ity,” said Bruce Gy­ory, a New York Demo­crat­ic polit­ic­al con­sult­ant. “These used to be bed­rock Re­pub­lic­an areas that are now nar­rowly Demo­crat­ic or dead even—and with there­fore of huge per­cent­age of … in­de­pend­ent voters.”

Some Re­pub­lic­ans in the re­gion blame the loss of man­u­fac­tur­ing jobs and en­su­ing eco­nom­ic un­cer­tainty for the weak­en­ing GOP hold on the dis­tricts, while some Demo­crats now see up­state’s in­creas­ing eco­nom­ic re­li­ance on col­leges and uni­versit­ies as a strength.

But the most ob­vi­ous factor de­term­in­ing re­cent House races is the nat­ur­al turnout mod­el that be­ne­fits Demo­crats in pres­id­en­tial years and Re­pub­lic­ans in midterm cycles. An ad­viser to Demo­crat­ic former Rep. Dan Maf­fei, who rep­res­en­ted Syra­cuse, told Wasser­man in 2014 that the cam­paign ex­pec­ted 40,000 more voters to show up that year.

Demo­crats are hop­ing to get a boost from an­ti­pathy to Trump, par­tic­u­larly in dis­tricts now held by Re­pub­lic­an Reps. Elise Stefanik and Tom Reed, both of whom are favored and rais­ing far more money than their op­pon­ents. The oth­er three dis­tricts are con­sidered toss-ups by The Cook Polit­ic­al Re­port, even though a re­cent poll by Si­ena Col­lege showed Hil­lary Clin­ton up by 8 points in the re­gion.

“Over­all, the ques­tion of where this re­gion is go­ing, what it will take to re­vital­ize it, what we can do about young people leav­ing, what we can do about cre­at­ing a bet­ter eco­nom­ic cli­mate and more jobs, just keeps res­on­at­ing,” said Grant Ree­her, a pro­fess­or of polit­ic­al sci­ence at Syra­cuse Uni­versity.And so I think that’s what you saw tapped in­to with Bernie Sanders and Don­ald Trump and their mes­sages. How does that play out in a gen­er­al elec­tion, though?”

James Eagan, a former top of­fi­cial for the New York State Demo­crat­ic Com­mit­tee, told Na­tion­al Journ­al, “It all de­pends on what words come out of Don­ald Trump’s mouth.”

The dis­tricts rep­res­ent­ing the west and north­east of the state are more com­pet­it­ive dur­ing pres­id­en­tial years—Reed took over from a resign­ing Demo­crat in 2010, and Stefanik did the same in 2014. Obama won both of their dis­tricts in 2008 and lost Reed’s dis­trict by only a few thou­sand votes in 2012.

Of the three toss-up dis­tricts, two are seats left open by re­tir­ing Re­pub­lic­ans, the 19th and 22nd.

In the north­ern Hud­son Val­ley, Re­pub­lic­an John Faso, a former state law­maker, faces pro­gress­ive firebrand Zephyr Teachout, who moved to the dis­trict 10 months ago from New York City. Faso ac­cuses Teachout of be­ing a car­pet­bag­ger.

In cent­ral New York, GOP state As­semb­ly­wo­man Claudia Ten­ney has to deal with op­pos­i­tion from es­tab­lish­ment-minded Re­pub­lic­ans, who be­lieve she is too con­ser­vat­ive. In her race against Demo­crat­ic county le­gis­lat­or Kim My­ers, Ten­ney also faces a threat from third-party busi­ness­man Mar­tin Babinec.

Re­tir­ing GOP Rep. Richard Hanna, who beat Ten­ney in a 2014 primary, said in Ju­ly that he would not sup­port her in the gen­er­al elec­tion, ac­cord­ing to WRVO, the loc­al NPR af­fil­i­ate.

Fi­nally, the seat rep­res­ent­ing Syra­cuse is the most highly edu­cated and di­verse of the five dis­tricts, and a fre­quent flip­per de­pend­ing on wheth­er it’s a pres­id­en­tial year. In June, the Demo­crat­ic Con­gres­sion­al Cam­paign Com­mit­tee re­leased ads ty­ing Trump to Re­pub­lic­ans in House races across the coun­try, in­clud­ing in this dis­trict.

But Re­pub­lic­ans are con­fid­ent that Rep. John Katko, with his fun­drais­ing ad­vant­age and early re­cord of passing le­gis­la­tion, will still find a way to beat Colleen Dea­con, a former top aide to Sen. Kirsten Gil­librand, des­pite Katko’s party-line votes to de­fund Planned Par­ent­hood and his pub­lic con­cerns with Trump.

“If I had to put money on it, I would think that John Katko would win a close elec­tion there,” said Ree­her of Syra­cuse Uni­versity. “I think he’s done all the right things for this dis­trict. And it goes back to the ques­tion of wheth­er voters will care. If you don’t have the en­vir­on­ment that we have right now and he runs in a ‘nor­mal’ elec­tion year, he’s done the things that he needs to do to be reelec­ted.”

What We're Following See More »
Byrd Rule Could Trip Up Health Legislation
53 minutes ago

"Even if House Republicans manage to get enough members of their party on board with the latest version of their health care bill, they will face another battle in the Senate: whether the bill complies with the chamber’s arcane ... Byrd rule, which stipulates all provisions in a reconciliation bill must affect federal spending and revenues in a way that is not merely incidental." Democrats should have the advantage in that fight, "unless the Senate pulls another 'nuclear option.'”

Senate Votes To Fund Government
1 days ago
House Passes Spending Bill
1 days ago

The House has passed a one-week spending bill that will avert a government shutdown which was set to begin at midnight. Lawmakers now have an extra week to come to a longer agreement which is expected to fund the government through the end of the fiscal year in September. The legislation now goes to the Senate, where it is expected to pass before President Trump signs it.

Puerto Rico Another Sticking Point in Budget Talks
1 days ago

President Trump’s portrayal of an effort to funnel more Medicaid dollars to Puerto Rico as a "bailout" is complicating negotiations over a continuing resolution on the budget. "House Democrats are now requiring such assistance as a condition for supporting the continuing resolution," a position that the GOP leadership is amenable to. "But Mr. Trump’s apparent skepticism aligns him with conservative House Republicans inclined to view its request as a bailout, leaving the deal a narrow path to passage in Congress."

Democrats Threaten Spending Bill Over Obamacare
2 days ago

Democrats in the House are threatening to shut down the government if Republicans expedite a vote on a bill to repeal and replace Obamacare, said Democratic House Whip Steny Hoyer Thursday. Lawmakers have introduced a one-week spending bill to give themselves an extra week to reach a long-term funding deal, which seemed poised to pass easily. However, the White House is pressuring House Republicans to take a vote on their Obamacare replacement Friday to give Trump a legislative victory, though it is still not clear that they have the necessary votes to pass the health care bill. This could go down to the wire.


Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.