Obama Should Ask Dennis Kucinich About Fighting Nuns

The president’s Justice Department could take a cautionary lesson from the Cleveland mayor’s tussle with the Little Sisters.

National Journal
George E. Condon Jr.
Add to Briefcase
George E. Condon Jr.
Jan. 3, 2014, 12:10 p.m.

If Pres­id­ent Obama thinks he has a chance to win a pub­lic re­la­tions battle with the Little Sis­ters of the Poor, per­haps he should talk to Den­nis Ku­cinich. The former con­gress­man is one of the few politi­cians who took on the nuns. It was dur­ing Ku­cinich’s tu­mul­tu­ous one term as may­or of Clev­e­land and Ku­cinich lost. De­cis­ively. Mem­or­ably.

That was in 1978, 36 years be­fore Obama’s Justice De­part­ment got tangled up in this week’s leg­al skir­mish with the 160-year-old or­der of sis­ters de­voted to help­ing the old and needy. The nuns are caught up in the ad­min­is­tra­tion’s re­quire­ment that em­ploy­er-offered health plans cov­er con­tra­cep­tion and abor­tion drugs, both of which are against Cath­ol­ic teach­ing.

This battle is far more leg­al­ist­ic and much less col­or­ful than the fight Ku­cinich picked soon after his 1977 elec­tion as may­or. He took of­fice in Janu­ary, a no­tori­ously fri­gid month along the shores of Lake Erie. And one of his ad­min­is­tra­tion’s first acts was to toss the nuns out of City Hall and out in­to the snow. The nuns in that case were not the Little Sis­ters of the Poor; they were the Daugh­ters of St. Paul, a smal­ler or­der also noted for their good works in the com­munity. Oddly, as news stor­ies about Ku­cinich’s ac­tion spread across the coun­try, the epis­ode be­came known as “Ku­cinich versus the Little Sis­ters of the Poor.”

Re­gard­less of the name of the or­der, tak­ing on nuns was not a pub­lic-re­la­tions stroke of geni­us in a city with a large eth­nic Cath­ol­ic pop­u­la­tion. Ku­cinich coun­ted on a leg­al­ist­ic de­fense, with his Law Dir­ect­or ar­guing that if you let nuns so­li­cit in­side City Hall “then you let every­one in, and that in­cludes the Moon­ies.” But Sis­ter Mary Le­onora was giv­en an un­usu­al pub­lic for­um by the city coun­cil to point out how much money the may­or’s policy had cost them. Ku­cinich, who him­self had been taught by nuns, said he wanted to “be on the side of the an­gels.” But he de­cidedly was not on the side of the voters and his clash with the nuns was cited al­most as much as the city’s his­tor­ic in­solv­ency when Ku­cinich was forced in­to a re­call elec­tion.

Clev­e­land’s ex­per­i­ence res­on­ates today be­cause Ku­cinich was al­most cer­tainly cor­rect in his as­sess­ment of the state of the law and the un­ortho­dox nature of let­ting one char­ity so­li­cit funds in a pub­lic build­ing. But that cor­rect­ness was lost against the vivid pic­tures of nuns be­ing tossed out in the Clev­e­land snows at Christ­mas­time.

Today, the Justice De­part­ment is con­vinced that the Cath­ol­ic or­gan­iz­a­tions su­ing to keep the gov­ern­ment from en­for­cing the con­tra­cep­tion man­date in the new health care law do not need an ex­emp­tion from the law. At is­sue for the Su­preme Court is wheth­er to ex­tend a tem­por­ary in­junc­tion gran­ted the church groups by Justice So­nia So­to­may­or. The gov­ern­ment ar­gued that groups like the Little Sis­ters of the Poor can’t ap­peal be­cause the law really doesn’t re­quire them to of­fer con­tra­cep­tion be­cause their in­sur­ance is provided by Chris­ti­an Broth­ers Ser­vices, a church or­gan­iz­a­tion the Justice De­part­ment says is already ex­cused from the law’s man­date.

But con­ser­vat­ive groups are in­tent on cast­ing this as Big Gov­ern­ment against Nuns. What the gov­ern­ment wants the Little Sis­ters of the Poor to do, con­tends the Beck­et Fund for Re­li­gious Liberty, “vi­ol­ates their faith.” The con­ser­vat­ive group ad­ded, “They shouldn’t be forced to di­vert funds from the poor eld­erly and dy­ing people they’ve de­voted their lives to serve.”

On the pos­it­ive side for the gov­ern­ment, though, no nuns have been tossed out in­to the snow this time. But the polit­ic­al les­son is prob­ably still the same, ac­cord­ing to Brent Lar­kin, who was the polit­ic­al writer at the Plain Deal­er when Ku­cinich was may­or. “It wasn’t pretty” he told Na­tion­al Journ­al. “Ku­cinich learned that politi­cians don’t win when they take on nuns.”

What We're Following See More »
BOON TO PROSECUTORS
SCOTUS Rules that Insider Trading Can’t Be “Gifted”
10 hours ago
THE DETAILS

In a unanimous decision, "the Supreme Court on Tuesday said it violates insider-trading laws for a corporate officer to make a “gift” of insider information to a relative, a decision that makes it easier for those who police Wall Street to bring prosecutions."

Source:
EFFORT LIKELY TO DIE IN COMMITTEE
Jordan Can’t Force a Floor Vote on Impeaching Koskinen
11 hours ago
THE LATEST
House Freedom Caucus Chairman Jim Jordan attempted to force a floor vote on impeaching IRS Commissioner John Koskinen, but "the House voted overwhelmingly to refer it to the Judiciary Committee. ... The committee will not be required to take up the resolution." Earlier, House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi "made a motion to table the resolution, which the House voted against by a 180-235 margin, mostly along party lines."
Source:
AFTER THE VOTE FOR SPEAKER
Ryan: No Committee Assignments Until New Year
16 hours ago
THE DETAILS

House Speaker Paul Ryan has decreed that House members "won’t receive their committee assignments until January — after they cast a public vote on the House floor for speaker. "The move has sparked behind-the-scenes grumbling from a handful of Ryan critics, who say the delay allows him and the Speaker-aligned Steering Committee to dole out committee assignments based on political loyalty rather than merit or expertise." The roll call to elect the speaker is set for Jan. 3, the first vote of the new Congress.

Source:
EXPECTED TO FUND THE GOVERNMENT THROUGH SPRING
Funding Bill To Be Released Tuesday
1 days ago
THE LATEST

House Majority Leader Kevin McCarthy told reporters on Monday that the government funding bill will be released on Tuesday. The bill is the last piece of legislation Congress needs to pass before leaving for the year and is expected to fund the government through the spring. The exact time date the bill would fund the government through is unclear, though it is expected to be in April or May.

Source:
IT’S OFFICIAL
Trump to Nominate Carson to Lead HUD
1 days ago
THE LATEST

As has been rumored for a week, Donald Trump will nominate Ben Carson, his former rival, to lead the Department of Housing and Urban Development. In a statement, Trump said, "We have talked at length about my urban renewal agenda and our message of economic revival, very much including our inner cities. Ben shares my optimism about the future of our country and is part of ensuring that this is a Presidency representing all Americans. He is a tough competitor and never gives up."

Source:
×
×

Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.

Login