The Betty White of American Politics: Why Bernie’s Young Fans Love Him

Why his young fans like him

This illustration can only be used with the Nora Caplan-Bricker piece that originally ran in the 6/20/2015 issue of National Journal magazine.
Ryan Inzana
Nora Caplan-Bricker
Add to Briefcase
See more stories about...
Nora Caplan-Bricker
June 19, 2015, 1:01 a.m.

Brendan Eprile re­mem­bers the first time he saw Bernie Sanders on TV. Eprile was an 8-year-old grow­ing up in Ver­mont, and he re­calls “be­ing amazed, be­cause I un­der­stood what he was talk­ing about, un­like all the oth­er politi­cians.” Sanders was on his soap­box about Ir­aq — or maybe it was eco­nom­ic in­equal­ity? In any case, the fam­ously blunt in­de­pend­ent from Bur­l­ing­ton had him riv­eted. Jo­nah Ra­gir has a sim­il­ar re­col­lec­tion. When he was young, he says, his grand­moth­er was watch­ing Sanders on C-SPAN in her Cali­for­nia liv­ing room. “I asked my grandma who he was, be­cause he didn’t sound like the oth­er guys who were speak­ing,” Ra­gir says. “He wasn’t ‘bor­ing’ and he wasn’t ‘ly­ing,’ were the words I used as a little kid.”

When Sanders an­nounced in late April that he was run­ning for pres­id­ent, Eprile, now a rising ju­ni­or at Ober­lin Col­lege, and Ra­gir, who at­tends Santa Mon­ica Col­lege, were among the stu­dents who con­tac­ted his cam­paign to vo­lun­teer. (As of early June, Bernie 2016 told me it had heard from schools in al­most every state.) As the most lib­er­al can­did­ate in the race, Sanders is, in many ways, the nat­ur­al can­did­ate of the cam­pus left. He is also, however, a no­tori­ously tetchy sep­tua­gen­ari­an. How, I wondered, do the young­est gen­er­a­tion of Bernie sup­port­ers re­late to him? What ex­actly is driv­ing their en­thu­si­asm for this throw­back product of the 1960s?

Cer­tainly, his po­s­i­tions on the is­sues are part of the equa­tion. Sanders, like most left-wing stu­dents, is an­ti­war, anti-money-in-polit­ics — and anti-stu­dent-loan-debt, which he has pro­posed to cur­tail by mak­ing col­lege free. “As a per­son in his 70s, he’s more in tune with our gen­er­a­tion’s plight than I would ar­gue Hil­lary Clin­ton is, and even Mar­tin O’Mal­ley at this point, and for sure the right wing,” says Adam Schwartz, a stu­dent at the Uni­versity of Wis­con­sin, Madis­on. They like him on so­cial is­sues as well — even though Sanders re­gards those as very sec­ond­ary to his eco­nom­ic mes­sage. One stu­dent after an­oth­er noted Sanders’s long-stand­ing sup­port of mar­riage equal­ity as com­pared with Hil­lary Clin­ton’s slow “evol­u­tion.” Plus, his car­bon-tax pro­pos­al has en­deared him to the en­vir­on­ment­al crowd.

Sanders is also the kind of politi­cian stu­dents tend to em­brace be­cause they see him as above polit­ics. “He’s not play­ing the role of a politi­cian, but of a per­son who wants to do good,” says Eliza­beth Lee of Middle­bury Col­lege. Where most pols “in­tro­duce le­gis­la­tion just to get the brownie points,” says Schwartz, Sanders “stands by it, and then he floats it re­peatedly.” Nikolaus Hofer, a stu­dent at Prin­ceton Uni­versity, vo­lun­teered for Barack Obama in 2012 and New Jer­sey Sen­at­or Cory Book­er in 2013 — but says he feels let down by both former idols. “The prob­lem was, they’re politi­cians,” he ex­plains. “They’re trad­ing things for each oth­er, bal­an­cing one thing against an­oth­er.” Sanders, he says, is “not try­ing to swim through all this muck — he’s on a surf­board cruis­ing right over it. I love the guy.”

Sanders on a surf­board? “I love the guy”? It wasn’t just Hofer: In talk­ing to Sanders’s young sup­port­ers, it be­came clear that their en­thu­si­asm for him ex­ten­ded well bey­ond his po­s­i­tions. The stu­dents who sup­port him don’t just agree with him: They seem to think that he, per­son­ally, is kind of awe­some.

The com­par­is­on between Sanders and Obama is, it turns out, in­struct­ive. Sanders is in most sig­ni­fic­ant ways the op­pos­ite of the can­did­ate young pro­gress­ives fell for eight years ago. It’s true that Obama, like Sanders today, ran in 2008 as a kind of anti-politi­cian, but he was non­ethe­less the con­sum­mate mod­ern can­did­ate: young, pol­ished, so­cial-me­dia-ready. Sanders, mean­while, is dour, pess­im­ist­ic, and not the kind of guy one ex­pects to share a laugh with — un­less maybe it’s over the words “hope and change.” Wit­tingly or not, Sanders seems to be join­ing a small cadre of oth­er no-bull­shit old people — think Betty White or Chuck Grass­ley — whose per­ceived lack of guile res­on­ates with di­git­al nat­ives. He’s “dis­arm­ingly straight­for­ward,” says Frank Fritz, a stu­dent at George Wash­ing­ton Uni­versity. “He’s not try­ing to win the game of who acts the most pres­id­en­tial or has the best me­dia team. He’s good on so­cial me­dia be­cause he’s hon­est about what he thinks.”

Sanders’s groom­ing habits are a key part of his charm. One stu­dent after an­oth­er praised his white hair, which is in­fam­ous for lift­ing off his head in struck-by-light­ning-level dis­ar­ray. A guy that un­con­cerned with sur­faces, the stu­dents ar­gue, must be worthy of their trust. He “doesn’t care about his im­age,” says Hofer; he is “clearly not con­cerned about keep­ing up an ap­peal.” Sanders might be a 73-year-old man, “but at the end of the day, it seems he’s the most youth­ful can­did­ate out there,” Hofer says. “That he’s un­kempt is a draw for people,” says Ra­gir. “I know in my life — I’m 21 — I’ve seen Clin­ton, Bush, Obama. These are people who just look per­fect. Everything about them is per­fect. And Bernie is this real per­son.” He “comes off a little grungy,” says Lee. “It works for him.”

It even seems to help that Sanders is so un­likely to make it to the Oval Of­fice. “You know, our gen­er­a­tion is sort of the hip­ster gen­er­a­tion, and the school I go to, people are very in­to not be­ing main­stream,” says Eprile. “I think, hon­estly, a lot of people don’t think he’s go­ing to win and like that in a weird way. “… He’s the edgy can­did­ate.” The sen­at­or, con­curs Uni­versity of Texas of the Per­mi­an Basin gradu­ate Timothy McDaniel, “is kind of re­bel­li­ous.” Like a fixed-gear bike or a col­lec­tion of vinyl, Sanders is trend­ily ana­log and im­prac­tic­al. Says Eprile: “I do hear a lot of people say, ‘Oh, he’s so cool.‘“Š”

What We're Following See More »
European Commission President to Visit White House
2 hours ago

With President Trump back from a trip in which he seemed to undermine European alliances while cozying up to Vladimir Putin, the White House has announced that European Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker will visit on July 25. According to a statement, the two "will focus on improving transatlantic trade and forging a stronger economic partnership."

IRS Relaxes Reporting Rules for Dark Money Groups
3 hours ago
House Launches Investigation Into VA Nursing Homes
3 hours ago

"The House Veterans Affairs Committee has launched an investigation into care at the VA’s 133 nursing homes after learning the agency had given almost half of them the lowest possible score in secret, internal rankings. The probe follows an investigation by The Boston Globe and USA TODAY that showed 60 VA nursing homes ... rated only one out of five stars for quality last year in the agency’s own ranking system." Internal documents revealed that "patients in more than two-thirds of VA nursing homes were more likely to suffer pain and serious bedsores than their private sector counterparts, and that "VA nursing homes scored worse than private nursing homes on a majority of key quality indicators, including rates of anti-psychotic drug prescription and decline in daily living skills."

House Republican Introduces Net Neutrality Legislation
3 hours ago

Colorado Representative Mike Coffman has introduced a bill "that would codify free internet regulations into law" by instituting the "basic outlines of the Federal Communication Commission’s 2015 Open Internet order." Coffman's bill amends the 1934 Telecommunications Act by "banning providers from controlling traffic quality and speed and forbidding them from participating in paid prioritization programs or charging access fees from edge providers." The GOP congressman has also "signed on to a Democrat-led effort to reinstate the net neutrality rules that the FCC voted to repeal late last year."

DOJ Indicts Another Russian National
22 hours ago

Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.