Judge Shoots Down Anti-Obamacare Suit

The lawsuit would have crippled the health care law.

Obamacare supporters react to the U.S. Supreme Court decision to uphold President Obama's health care law, on June 28, 2012 in Washington, DC. Today the high court upheld the whole healthcare law of the Obama Administration.
National Journal
Sam Baker
Add to Briefcase
See more stories about...
Sam Baker
Jan. 15, 2014, 7:43 a.m.

A fed­er­al judge tossed out a law­suit today that sought to cripple Obama­care.

The suit — a chal­lenge to the law’s in­sur­ance sub­sidies — was a long shot but had the po­ten­tial to dev­ast­ate the health care law if it suc­ceeded. It would have blocked the law’s in­sur­ance sub­sidies — the main in­cent­ive for people to buy in­sur­ance — in 36 states.

The U.S. Dis­trict Court for the Dis­trict of Columbia ruled that the sub­sidies, which help low-in­come con­sumers cov­er their premi­ums, should be avail­able in all 50 states. He dis­missed a law­suit, filed by a group of in­di­vidu­als and busi­nesses, that sought to block sub­sidies in any state that didn’t op­er­ate its own in­sur­ance ex­change,

“The plain text of the stat­ute, the stat­utory struc­ture, and the stat­utory pur­pose make clear that Con­gress in­ten­ded to make premi­um tax cred­its avail­able on both state-run and fed­er­ally fa­cil­it­ated Ex­changes,” Judge Paul Fried­man wrote.

Chal­lengers ar­gued that Con­gress in­ten­ded for tax sub­sidies to flow only through state-run ex­changes, be­cause it wanted to en­cour­age states to set up their own mar­ket­places. The Justice De­part­ment ar­gued that the over­all goal of the Af­ford­able Care Act was to ex­pand cov­er­age in all 50 states, and that fed­er­al ex­changes were de­signed to stand in for state-run mar­ket­places.

Fried­man agreed with the Justice De­part­ment, say­ing the chal­lengers’ ar­gu­ment does not “make in­tu­it­ive sense,” and that “there is no evid­ence in the le­gis­lat­ive re­cord that the House, the Sen­ate, any rel­ev­ant com­mit­tee of either House, or any le­gis­lat­or ever en­ter­tained this idea.”

What We're Following See More »
KIM CALLS TRUMP A “DOTARD”
North Korea Threatens H-Bomb Test Over Pacific
2 days ago
THE LATEST

"North Korea said on Friday it might test a hydrogen bomb over the Pacific Ocean after President Donald Trump vowed to destroy the reclusive country, with leader Kim Jong Un promising to make Trump pay dearly for his threats. Kim did not specify what action he would take against the United States or Trump, whom he called a 'mentally deranged U.S. dotard' in the latest bout of insults the two leaders have traded in recent weeks."

Source:
INFORMS CONGRESS RE: EXECUTIVE ORDER
Trump Makes Good on Promise of New North Korea Sanctions
3 days ago
THE LATEST

President Trump this afternoon announced another round of sanctions on North Korea, calling the regime "a continuing threat." The executive order, which Trump relayed to Congress, bans any ship or plane that has visited North Korea from visiting the United States within 180 days. The order also authorizes sanctions on any financial institution doing business with North Korea, and permits the secretaries of State and the Treasury to sanction any person involved in trading with North Korea, operating a port there, or involved in a variety of industries there.

SOUTH KOREA WILL SEND AID
Trump Promises More Sanctions on North Korea
3 days ago
THE LATEST

In response to a reporter's question, President Trump said "he’ll be looking to impose further financial penalties on North Korea over its nuclear and ballistic tests. ... The U.N. has passed two resolutions recently aimed at squeezing the North Korean economy by cutting off oil, labor and exports to the nation." Meanwhile, the Guardian reports that South Korea's unification ministry is sending an $8m aid package aimed at infants and pregnant women in North Korea. The "humanitarian gesture [is] at odds with calls by Japan and the US for unwavering economic and diplomatic pressure on Pyongyang."

Source:
HIGHLIGHT ISSUES FACING KIDS
FLOTUS to Speak at UN Luncheon
4 days ago
THE LATEST
PRESSES CASE FOR REFORMS
Trump Meets with UN Leaders
4 days ago
THE LATEST

President Trump on Tuesday night met with UN Secretary Guterres and President of the General Assembly Miroslav Lajcak. In both cases, as per releases from the White House, Trump pressed them on the need to reform the UN bureaucracy.

×
×

Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.

Login