De Blasio Needs to Take a Lesson From Chicago Snowstorms

Snow has buried or made political careers in the Windy City. The New York mayor should take note.

National Journal
Add to Briefcase
Matt Vasilogambros
Jan. 22, 2014, 8:41 a.m.

For many places, snow is snow. In ma­jor cit­ies like Chica­go or New York, snow is polit­ics.

Newly min­ted New York May­or Bill de Bla­sio is learn­ing this les­son fol­low­ing a snowstorm that swept the East Coast on Tues­day, dump­ing sev­er­al inches of snow and de­creas­ing tem­per­at­ures across the re­gion. Some res­id­ents of the well-to-do Up­per East Side neigh­bor­hood are com­plain­ing that the Demo­crat­ic may­or is pun­ish­ing them for op­pos­ing his may­or­al bid by not plow­ing their streets soon­er.

“He is try­ing to get us back. He is very di­vis­ive and polit­ic­al,” one res­id­ent told the New York Post.

“De Bla­sio is try­ing to hurt the more wealthy people by ig­nor­ing us but there’s no lo­gic to that,” an­oth­er res­id­ent said.

Now, the re­port is a bit hy­per­bol­ic, but it does show how snow can af­fect the pop­ular­ity of elec­ted of­fi­cials, es­pe­cially in ma­jor cit­ies. Just look at Chica­go.

In the Windy City, where polit­ics is king, snow has been used to pun­ish cer­tain neigh­bor­hoods and snow has ruined polit­ic­al ca­reers.

Former may­or Richard J. Da­ley was known to pun­ish neigh­bor­hoods that op­posed his policies or voted for his op­pon­ents. So for Hyde Park, which was seen as re­form­ist and “anti-ma­chine,” Da­ley went after them with the snowplows.

Drake Uni­versity polit­ics pro­fess­or Den­nis Gold­ford, who went to the Uni­versity of Chica­go dur­ing the early 1970s, de­scribes the old-style ma­chine polit­ics:

Dur­ing one of the first par­tic­u­larly bad snowstorms, there was an is­sue about why the 5th Ward re­mains un­plowed for so long. Of course re­port­ers said, ‘Does this have any­thing to do with the fact that the 5th Ward tends to be re­form­ist and op­posed the Ma­chine?’ “¦ The may­or or the spokes­man would say, ‘Of course not. It’s no polit­ic­al is­sue here. It’s simply that we have 50 wards and some­body’s got to be first.’ This was usu­ally the may­or’s ward. ‘And some­body ends up last. It’s just as simple as that. You can’t plow every­body at once.’ It just so happened that the 5th Ward was last.

Snow also ruined the ca­reer of the man who suc­ceeded the Boss of Chica­go. From The Phil­adelphia In­quirer:

In 1979, then-May­or Mi­chael Bil­and­ic saw his reelec­tion bid bur­ied un­der a snowstorm that the city could not clear.

Bil­and­ic’s fail­ure, coupled with news ac­counts of how the streets of his neigh­bor­hood were sur­pris­ingly clear, gave chal­lenger Jane Byrne the is­sue she needed to win.

“I hate to say it, but I love snow,” Byrne said this week, watch­ing as 22 inches of snow, the most since 1979, settled on the city.

To this day, that bliz­zard is still called the “Bil­and­ic-Byrne storm”.

Just be­fore leav­ing of­fice, then-New York May­or Mi­chael Bloomberg found him­self in his own con­tro­versy sur­round­ing lackluster snow re­mov­al, a dis­aster that one news or­gan­iz­a­tion called “polit­ic­al sui­cide,” and saw his ap­prov­al rat­ing plum­met.

If de Bla­sio wants to make it as a big-city may­or, he’d bet­ter learn how to handle the snowstorms — which could bury the city and his ca­reer in snow.


Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.