The Supreme Court on Friday granted a temporary exemption from Obamacare’s contraception mandate to a religious nonprofit organization that sued the administration on the grounds that the mandate violated its religious beliefs.
The case of Little Sisters of the Poor, a nursing home run by Catholic nuns, will return to the 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Denver for a ruling on the nonprofit’s suit. But thanks to Friday’s ruling, Little Sisters will not be penalized for not covering contraception for its employees while the case is pending.
Justice Sonia Sotomayor referred the case to the full Court following her decision on New Year’s Eve to grant Little Sisters a preliminary injunction. Had Sotomayor not granted the reprieve before Jan. 1 — when the mandate took effect — Little Sisters would have had to pay a penalty or comply.
“Compliance” with Obamacare’s mandate, however, does not mean Little Sisters would have had to pay for its employees’ contraception.
As stated under the law, religious organizations are exempt from the mandate requiring employers to include contraceptive services in employees’ health plans.
Because Little Sisters is a religiously affiliated organization — rather than a religious organization, such as a church — it did not qualify for the exemption.
Instead, it was covered under a separate, compromise regulation the Obama administration issued almost one year ago. Under that deal, Little Sisters — and thousands of other similarly classified organizations who objected to the mandate on grounds that it violated their religious liberty — would have to sign a form indicating that they objected to providing contraception on religious grounds. In exchange, they would not be penalized for failing to meet the mandate, because the insurance company would instead pay for the contraceptive coverage for their employees.
Little Sisters argues that by signing the form that “triggers the start of coverage,” they are complicit in the act of providing contraception. “In good conscience, they cannot do that,” wrote the lawyers for the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty, the firm representing Little Sisters. “So the ‘accommodation’ still violates their religious beliefs.”
In December, the Denver appellate court declined to grant a preliminary injunction, judging that the Little Sisters “reads too much into the language of the form, which requires only that the individual signing it certify that her organization opposes providing contraceptive coverage.”
After Little Sisters filed an emergency appeal to the Supreme Court, the Obama administration had hoped the justices would agree, but its defeat Friday may only be temporary: The Court stressed it was not ruling on the merits of Little Sisters’ case in issuing the decision to continue the stay.
While the Supreme Court won’t be taking up the Little Sisters case, it is scheduled to review a claim by for-profit companies with religious objections to the contraception mandate on March 25, a debate which will require the Court to review whether corporations First Amendment rights — extended through the Citizens United decision — include religious rights.
What We're Following See More »
Donald Trump's "transition team will meet next week with representatives of the tech industry, multiple sources confirmed, even as their candidate largely has been largely shunned by Silicon Valley. The meeting, scheduled for next Thursday at the offices of law and lobbying firm BakerHostetler, will include trade groups like the Information Technology Industry Council and the Internet Association that represent major Silicon Valley companies."
Today in bad news for Donald Trump:
- Newsweek found that a company he controlled did business with Cuba under Fidel Castro "despite strict American trade bans that made such undertakings illegal, according to interviews with former Trump executives, internal company records and court filings." In 1998, he spent at least $68,000 there, which was funneled through a consluting company "to make it appear legal."
- The Los Angeles Times reports that at a golf club he owns in California, Trump ordered that unattractive female staff be fired and replaced with prettier women.
In some of the first state-by-state surveys since Monday night's debate, Hillary Clinton has the edge in five battlegrounds, according to polls by Public Policy Polling. In four-way matchups, Clinton leads Donald Trump 46%-40% in Colorado, 45%-43% in Florida, 44%-42% in North Carolina, 45%-39% in Pennsylvania, and 46%-40% in Virginia. Gary Johnson doesn't top 7% in any state. Voters in all five states thought that Clinton decisively won the debate.