It Was the Best Exchange, It Was the Worst Exchange

In the first three months of Obamacare enrollment, the insurance exchanges have been a very mixed bag.

National Journal
Sophie Novack
Add to Briefcase
See more stories about...
Sophie Novack
Dec. 26, 2013, 1 a.m.

Con­sumers’ ex­per­i­ence with Obama­care has var­ied a great deal de­pend­ing on where they live. At the Oct. 1 launch, state-run ex­changes claimed most of the in­sur­ance suc­cess stor­ies, while con­sumers try­ing to sign up through Health­ found it largely non­func­tion­al. Among those 15 state-based ex­changes (in­clud­ing the Dis­trict of Columbia), the ex­per­i­ence ranged from easy to lit­er­ally im­possible. 

Now past the ini­tial en­roll­ment dead­line of Dec. 24 for most states, the in­sur­ance ex­changes have come a long way since the be­gin­ning of Oc­to­ber. As the next phase of en­roll­ment be­gins, ex­changes can learn from those that suc­ceeded and those that went very wrong. 

The Best


A state with nearly 7 mil­lion un­in­sured res­id­ents, Cali­for­nia is boast­ing the highest en­roll­ment num­bers dur­ing the first three months of Obama­care im­ple­ment­a­tion.

As of early this week, about 400,000 people had en­rolled in private plans through the state’s ex­change, Covered Cali­for­nia. Cali­for­nia saw a huge surge in en­roll­ments in Decem­ber, par­tic­u­larly ahead of the dead­line for Jan. 1 cov­er­age. Between this past Fri­day and Sunday, 77,000 people chose a private in­sur­ance plan on the ex­change, with a re­cord 29,000 en­roll­ments on Fri­day alone.

“We’re all in the first in­ning of a nine-in­ning game,” Peter Lee, ex­ec­ut­ive dir­ect­or of Covered Cali­for­nia, said on a press call last week. “But we’re start­ing to see data in­dic­at­ive of where we’re go­ing, and data to learn from.” Lee poin­ted out that the en­roll­ments do not in­clude those buy­ing dir­ectly from in­sur­ance com­pan­ies.

Lee says Covered Cali­for­nia has not ex­per­i­enced the back-end prob­lems that have plagued Health­, which were caus­ing in­surers to re­ceive in­ac­cur­ate con­sumer in­form­a­tion. Plans are billing con­sumers between one and three days after re­ceipt of their ap­plic­a­tion.

The dead­line to pay premi­ums for cov­er­age be­gin­ning Jan. 1 is Jan. 6 in Cali­for­nia.


Ken­tucky is un­usu­al as a red state that is ag­gress­ively im­ple­ment­ing Obama­care — both ex­pand­ing Medi­caid and set­ting up its own ex­change — thanks to Demo­crat­ic Gov. Steve Be­s­hear’s no-par­tis­an-non­sense ap­proach to im­ple­ment­a­tion.

As of Dec. 21, more than 100,000 Ken­tucki­ans had en­rolled through the state’s ex­change, Kynect, with about a 75 per­cent to 25 per­cent split between Medi­caid and private-plan en­roll­ment. Over 640,000 Ken­tucky res­id­ents — about 15 per­cent of the state’s pop­u­la­tion — are un­in­sured, with a great deal to gain from ex­pan­ded cov­er­age.

Kynect has been op­er­at­ing smoothly, and the back-end has not been an is­sue, ac­cord­ing to Car­rie Ba­na­han, ex­ec­ut­ive dir­ect­or of the Ken­tucky Health Be­ne­fit Ex­change. Once ap­plic­a­tions are ap­proved, the forms are trans­mit­ted to in­surers nightly, and ap­plic­ants can be billed as early as the next day.

Con­sumer in­terest and en­roll­ment has been high in the state since Oct. 1, with a re­cent surge ahead of the first dead­line. Since Thanks­giv­ing, pur­chases of private ex­change plans have in­creased by 121 per­cent. The ex­change is ap­prov­ing around 3,000 people for Medi­caid or private cov­er­age each day, up from 1,000 and 2,000 in pre­vi­ous es­tim­ates.

Ken­tucki­ans must pay their premi­ums by Jan. 1 for cov­er­age to be­gin on that date.

Run­ners-up: New York, Wash­ing­ton

The Worst


The Ore­gon health ex­change, Cov­er Ore­gon, has con­sist­ently per­formed worse than the much-ma­ligned Health­ Three months in­to open en­roll­ment, the web­site is still a fail­ure, and the ex­change has been the slow­est to en­roll people in private cov­er­age.

Ore­gon has re­lied on pa­per ap­plic­a­tions, which are slow to pro­cess, and the prob­lems will leave many Ore­go­ni­ans without cov­er­age at the be­gin­ning of the year. The state set a Dec. 4 dead­line to sub­mit pa­per ap­plic­a­tions. Once an ap­plic­a­tion is ap­proved, the in­di­vidu­al re­ceives an en­roll­ment pack­et in the mail, and must then se­lect a plan through the Cov­er Ore­gon web­site.

Of­fi­cials say they have only just got­ten through most of the on-time ap­plic­a­tions, fol­low­ing a back­log of over 30,000 un­pro­cessed ap­plic­a­tions two weeks ago.

Around 70,000 Ore­go­ni­ans have been deemed eli­gible for cov­er­age through private plans or the state Medi­caid pro­gram. About 36,000 con­sumers en­rolled as of Tues­day — 12,000 in private plans and 24,000 through Medi­caid. In Oc­to­ber and Novem­ber, a total of only 44 in­di­vidu­als se­lec­ted private plans on the ex­change.

Of­fi­cials are still work­ing to no­ti­fy those who have been deemed eli­gible in time for them to en­roll in cov­er­age by this Fri­day. Most con­sumers whose ap­plic­a­tions were on time but in­com­plete have not been con­tac­ted, and they will likely face a cov­er­age gap un­til they com­plete their ap­plic­a­tions for cov­er­age be­gin­ning Feb­ru­ary. 

Eli­gible ap­plic­ants must choose a plan by 5 p.m. on Dec. 27 and pay their premi­um by Jan. 15 to re­ceive cov­er­age be­gin­ning Jan. 1.


The prob­lems with the fed­er­al ex­change have been well-known, be­cause the web­site serves all 36 states us­ing the fed­er­al mar­ket­place. For­tu­nately, the spot­light forced re­pairs, and the web­site has been run­ning smoothly for the most part since the ad­min­is­tra­tion’s self-im­posed fix date of Dec. 1. However, tech­nic­al prob­lems dur­ing the first couple of months pre­ven­ted many who ini­tially flooded the site from en­rolling, and this set cov­er­age goals back severely.

En­roll­ment dur­ing the first month was dis­mal, hampered by high er­ror rates, long wait times, and web­site crashes. The fed­er­al mar­ket­place ac­coun­ted for only 25 per­cent of the 106,000 total en­roll­ments in the fed­er­al and state ex­changes in Oc­to­ber, des­pite serving 36 states.

The num­ber of en­roll­ments through Health­ jumped in Novem­ber, and dra­mat­ic­ally in Decem­ber. Around 29,000 people en­rolled in the fed­er­al ex­change in the first two days in Decem­ber — more than in the en­tire month of Oc­to­ber. Over 500,000 people en­rolled in cov­er­age through the fed­er­al ex­change this month, Pres­id­ent Obama said at a news con­fer­ence Fri­day.

The Health and Hu­man Ser­vices De­part­ment ini­tially ex­pec­ted 3.3 mil­lion people to en­roll in cov­er­age by the end of Decem­ber, and 7 mil­lion by March 31. The ad­min­is­tra­tion will surely miss its end-of-year goal, but the ac­cel­er­a­tion of en­roll­ment in Decem­ber is a good sign for the next three months.

Back-end prob­lems with Health­ were still cre­at­ing ser­i­ous prob­lems for in­surers in Decem­ber, al­though er­ror rates in trans­mis­sion forms dropped dra­mat­ic­ally from 25 per­cent in Oc­to­ber and Novem­ber. It re­mains to be seen wheth­er prob­lems will oc­cur when con­sumers be­gin us­ing their in­sur­ance in Janu­ary.

In­di­vidu­als on the fed­er­al ex­change must pay their premi­ums by Jan. 10 for cov­er­age be­gin­ning Jan. 1.

Run­ner-up: Mary­land 

Obama­care open en­roll­ment in all states runs through March 31, 2014. Con­sumers must en­roll by Jan. 15 for cov­er­age be­gin­ning Feb. 1. 

What We're Following See More »
Spending Bill Fails to Clear 60-Vote Hurdle
15 minutes ago
Monday’s Debate Was Most Watched Ever
50 minutes ago
Hill Republicans Don’t Like What They See in Debate
1 hours ago

"It was obvious he wasn't prepared." “He only mentioned her email scandal once." "I think he took things a little too personal and missed a lot of opportunities to make very good debate points." That's just a smattering of the reactions of some elected Republicans to Donald Trump's debate performance.

Little Ratings Drop-Off from Beginning to End of Debate
3 hours ago

The conventional wisdom is already emerging that Donald Trump opened last night's debate well, but that he faded badly down the stretch. And most viewers apparently witnessed it. "The early Nielsen data confirms that viewership stayed high the entire time. Contrary to some speculation, there was not a big drop-off after the first hour of the 98-minute debate." Final data is still being tallied, but "Monday's face-off may well have been the most-watched debate in American history. CNN and other cable news channels saw big increases over past election years. So did some of the broadcast networks."

Federal Agencies Prepare for Govt Shutdown
4 hours ago

As Congress continues to bicker on riders to a continuing resolution, federal agencies have started working with the Office of Management and Budget to prepare for a government shutdown, which will occur if no continuing resolution is passed by 11:59 p.m. on Friday night. The OMB held a call with agencies on Sept. 23, one that is required one week before a possible shutdown. The government last shut down for 16 days in 2013, and multiple shutdowns have been narrowly avoided since then. It is expected that Congress will reach a deal before the clock strikes midnight, but until it does, preparations will continue.