Free Community College Gets Mixed Reviews

Tennessee and Oregon will offer tuition-free community college, but not everyone thinks it’s such a good idea.

Tennessee and Oregon will offer certain students access to community college at no cost. 
National Journal
July 23, 2015, 6:30 a.m.

This fall, Cesar Sanc­hez, 18, will do something he nev­er thought pos­sible.

He’ll en­roll at South­w­est Ten­ness­ee Com­munity Col­lege through a state pro­gram called Ten­ness­ee Prom­ise, which lets stu­dents com­plete two years of com­munity col­lege at no cost.

“At one point, I didn’t see my­self go­ing to col­lege after gradu­ation,” he said. “It made me really happy. It really made me set my mind to a goal and ac­com­plish it.”

While the Obama ad­min­is­tra­tion’s pro­pos­al to make com­munity col­lege free lan­guishes in the Belt­way, sev­er­al states, in­clud­ing Ten­ness­ee, are mov­ing ahead with their own plans to make earn­ing an as­so­ci­ate’s de­gree as stand­ard as a high school dip­loma.

This month, Ore­gon Gov­ernor Kate Brown signed in­to law a pro­gram that will of­fer tu­ition-free com­munity col­lege to the state’s re­cent high school gradu­ates. Oth­er states are also ex­plor­ing the concept.

“Today, we fling wide open the doors of op­por­tun­ity by ex­pand­ing ac­cess to post­sec­ond­ary edu­ca­tion, the pre­curs­or to a bet­ter life,” Brown said in a state­ment after sign­ing the bill.

It might ini­tially seem sur­pris­ing that a blue state and a red state are pur­su­ing such sim­il­ar goals, but demo­graph­ic sim­il­ar­it­ies between the states provide some clues.

Both Ore­gon and Ten­ness­ee have seen shift­ing pop­u­la­tions in re­cent dec­ades, with par­tic­u­lar in­creases in the Latino pop­u­la­tion, ac­cord­ing to Census fig­ures. The Pew Re­search Cen­ter names Ten­ness­ee as hav­ing one of the fast­est-grow­ing Latino pop­u­la­tions, with growth com­ing both from im­mig­ra­tion and births in the state. The states have high­er-than-av­er­age poverty levels and lower-than-av­er­age me­di­an house­hold in­comes. Few­er than 30 per­cent of res­id­ents in each state hold a bach­el­or’s de­gree and there are thou­sands of stu­dents who may be in­ter­ested in col­lege but lack par­ent­al guid­ance and fin­an­cial sup­port when it comes to nav­ig­at­ing the sys­tem.

“I would ab­so­lutely say this is the be­gin­ning of a na­tion­wide con­ver­sa­tion about go­ing to com­munity col­lege.” — Mike Krause, Ten­ness­ee Prom­ise Ex­ec­ut­ive Dir­ect­or

Stu­dents like Sanc­hez see an op­por­tun­ity to go to col­lege that didn’t ex­ist be­fore.

Raised by a moth­er who came to the United States from Mex­ico and didn’t at­tend col­lege her­self, Sanc­hez said his fam­ily had no money to pay for school.

“I went through a little stage where I … was kind of feel­ing down,” he said. “I didn’t know what I was go­ing to do after high school.”

Pro­ponents of the Ten­ness­ee and Ore­gon pro­grams have said of­fer­ing tu­ition waivers will help boost col­lege gradu­ation rates and grow their states’ eco­nom­ies as they ad­just to less ho­mo­gen­ous pop­u­la­tions.

Ten­ness­ee’s pro­gram is aimed at “work­force and eco­nom­ic de­vel­op­ment,” said Mike Krause, ex­ec­ut­ive dir­ect­or of Ten­ness­ee Prom­ise, the state’s pro­gram. “The haz­ard is that people see it as [high­er-edu­ca­tion policy.]”

How to make col­lege af­ford­able is a con­ten­tious top­ic right now, and Ten­ness­ee’s Re­pub­lic­an gov­ernor doesn’t ne­ces­sar­ily want to look like he’s get­ting in line with the White House’s free com­munity-col­lege pro­pos­al. Stu­dents like Sanc­hez are not as con­cerned with how Ten­ness­ee Prom­ise is cat­egor­ized when it launches this year.

“I think it’s a really good thing be­cause it helps people like me,” Sanc­hez said. “It gives them a hope for something.”

High school seni­ors in Ten­ness­ee are eli­gible to at­tend two years of com­munity col­lege at no cost. Un­like the Ore­gon pro­gram, Ten­ness­ee’s does not have a min­im­um GPA re­quire­ment, and stu­dents are re­quired to per­form eight hours of com­munity ser­vice and meet with ment­ors. The Ore­gon pro­gram will per­mit stu­dents to en­roll in com­munity col­lege with­in six months of gradu­at­ing from high school at no cost. Stu­dents must have lived in Ore­gon for at least a year, have at least a 2.5 high school GPA and com­plete a FAF­SA, the fed­er­al fin­an­cial-aid ap­plic­a­tion.

Ore­gon ex­pects up to 6,000 stu­dents to en­roll in the 2016-2017 school year, the ex­pec­ted launch year.

“I hope op­por­tun­it­ies like this cre­ate a col­lege-go­ing cul­ture,” said Meghan Moy­er, dir­ect­or of gov­ern­ment re­la­tions at Port­land Com­munity Col­lege.

Her school ex­pects, she said, to see between 1,200 and 2,000 stu­dents per year from the pro­gram.

But Moy­er, whose col­lege will be tasked with im­ple­ment­ing the new pro­gram’s policies on a daily basis, poin­ted out that most of her stu­dents are older (the av­er­age age is 29) and don’t fit the re­quire­ments.

She also noted that any stu­dent, even one without fin­an­cial need, could take ad­vant­age of the pro­gram.

“PCC would like to see stu­dents pri­or­it­ized who would be un­likely to at­tend high­er edu­ca­tion without as­sist­ance,” Moy­er said.

Mi­chael Horn, ex­ec­ut­ive dir­ect­or of edu­ca­tion at the Clayton Christensen In­sti­tute, a think tank that fo­cuses on us­ing dis­rupt­ive in­nov­a­tion to de­vel­op solu­tions for the world’s prob­lems, said his con­cern with the idea of free com­munity col­lege is that the people who will take ad­vant­age of the of­fer are not the stu­dents who need fin­an­cial as­sist­ance the most. He’d like to see tests done on oth­er ap­proaches, such as in­come-shar­ing, where a com­pany or oth­er en­tity pays for a stu­dent’s tu­ition and the gradu­ate pays a per­cent­age of his in­come for a set num­ber of years in ex­change, in­stead.

Mam­ie Voight, dir­ect­or of policy re­search at the In­sti­tute for High­er Edu­ca­tion Policy, which fo­cuses on ways to ex­pand ac­cess to col­lege to un­der­served stu­dents, shares Horn’s con­cern.

In­stead of al­low­ing stu­dents who will at­tend col­lege re­gard­less of the pro­grams to re­ceive funds, she’d like to see funds dir­ec­ted spe­cific­ally to low-in­come stu­dents. The pro­grams work by help­ing fill the gap left after Pell and oth­er grants kick in, and Voight is con­cerned that someone with a high­er in­come who isn’t eli­gible for those grants could ul­ti­mately re­ceive more money.

But to Krause, the Ten­ness­ee pro­gram’s dir­ect­or, that mind-set “com­pletely fails to ac­count for the cata­lyz­ing ef­fect fin­an­cial aid has,” he said.

First-gen­er­a­tion col­lege stu­dents, he ex­plained, don’t ne­ces­sar­ily know what FAF­SA is, or what a Pell Grant is, or how to get them. With Ten­ness­ee Prom­ise, the mes­sage that col­lege is an op­tion is clear, and there’s a spelled-out path­way for how to achieve it.

“It has the po­ten­tial to be a game-changer,” said Dwayne Scott, vice pres­id­ent of Stu­dent Ser­vices and En­roll­ment Man­age­ment at South­w­est Ten­ness­ee Com­munity Col­lege, where Sanc­hez plans to en­roll.

While he doesn’t know yet how many stu­dents his school will add as a res­ult of the pro­gram, he sup­ports the idea and said his school hasn’t been tasked with ad­di­tion­al work bey­ond re­mind­ing stu­dents, in con­junc­tion with the non­profit Ten­ness­ee Achieves, the pro­gram’s part­ner, that they must com­plete com­munity-ser­vice hours and fill out the FAF­SA each year.

“I don’t think we make it easy for first-gen­er­a­tion stu­dents to see them­selves in col­lege,” Krause said. “What the Ten­ness­ee Prom­ise brings is a clear sense of vis­ion … that you can go tu­ition-free, you are col­lege ma­ter­i­al.”

That mes­sage ap­pears to be res­on­at­ing.

Krause said that 58,000 stu­dents, or about 80 per­cent of the seni­or class, ap­plied, and he ex­pects 16,000 to ac­tu­ally en­roll. Many of those who ap­plied, he said, will likely at­tend four-year uni­versit­ies in­stead.

While Krause said fig­ures aren’t yet in on how many are first-gen­er­a­tion col­lege stu­dents or how many would be un­able to at­tend oth­er­wise, about half are on full Pell Grants, de­signed to help the na­tion’s poorest stu­dents at­tend col­lege.

“We have a range of an­ec­dot­al evid­ence in­dic­at­ing these stu­dents are dif­fer­ent than the stu­dents who would typ­ic­ally en­roll,” he said.

Krause was in­volved in the de­vel­op­ment of the Ore­gon pro­gram and said the state isn’t the only one that has reached out. While he de­clined to name oth­er states who have in­quired about the pro­gram, Krause said he has had “ser­i­ous in­terest” from five oth­er states and is aware that more are watch­ing closely as the pro­gram gets un­der­way.

“I would ab­so­lutely say this is the be­gin­ning of a na­tion­wide con­ver­sa­tion about go­ing to com­munity col­lege,” he said.

The mo­mentum comes as Pres­id­ent Barack Obama con­tin­ues to call for free com­munity col­lege na­tion­wide, and 2016 pres­id­en­tial can­did­ates are lay­ing out their own plans to make col­lege more af­ford­able. While he out­lined a plan in Janu­ary and sev­er­al Demo­crat­ic law­makers have in­tro­duced a bill to move it for­ward, the chances of com­munity col­leges na­tion­wide be­com­ing free are slim. The White House has said it would cost the fed­er­al gov­ern­ment about $60 bil­lion over 10 years, a price tag that Re­pub­lic­an law­makers are re­luct­ant to ac­cept. But if in­terest in Ten­ness­ee’s and Ore­gon’s pro­grams is an in­dic­a­tion, more states may soon draft their own pro­pos­als.

What We're Following See More »
Mueller Has Interviewed Press Sec. Sarah Sanders
5 hours ago

"Special counsel Robert Mueller's team has interviewed White House press secretary Sarah Sanders, she told CNN on Friday...The interview is one of the final known interviews by Mueller's team. It was conducted late last year, around the same time as the special counsel interviewed then-White House chief of staff John Kelly, well after a number of other senior officials, including former White House communications director Hope Hicks and former press secretary Sean Spicer, were brought in for questioning."

Gov. Newsom Says California Will Sue Trump Over Emergency Declaration
5 hours ago

"Gov. Gavin Newsom said Friday that California was planning to sue the Trump administration over its declaration of a national emergency on the southern border with Mexico, delivering on a promise state Atty. Gen. Xavier Becerra made last week 'to reject this foolish proposal in court the moment it touches the ground.'...'No other state is going to be impacted by this declaration of emergency more than the state of California,' the governor said. Becerra said attorneys were reviewing the declaration and would develop the legal argument to take to court in the near future."

Trump Signs Border Deal
5 hours ago

"President Trump signed a sweeping spending bill Friday afternoon, averting another partial government shutdown. The action came after Trump had declared a national emergency in a move designed to circumvent Congress and build additional barriers at the southern border, where he said the United States faces 'an invasion of our country.'"

Stone Under Gag Order
7 hours ago

"A federal judge on Friday ordered Roger Stone, his attorneys and the special counsel’s office to halt all public commentary about the case involving charges that the longtime Donald Trump associate lied to Congress and obstructed its Russia investigation. In a four-page order, U.S. District Court Judge Amy Berman Jackson sided with Mueller that Stone and his attorneys 'must refrain from making statements to the media or in public settings that pose a substantial likelihood of material prejudice to this case.'"

Supreme Court Will Rule on Census Citizenship Question
9 hours ago

"The Supreme Court added a politically explosive case to its low-profile docket Friday, agreeing to decide by the end of June whether the Trump administration can add a question about citizenship to the 2020 Census form sent to every American household. The census hasn’t asked the question of each household since 1950, and a federal judge last month stopped the Commerce Department from adding it to the upcoming count. He questioned the motives of Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross, and said the secretary broke a 'veritable smorgasbord' of federal rules by overriding the advice of career officials."


Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.