The Art Historian Advising Ted Cruz

How an art historian became Ted Cruz’s foreign policy guru

This illustration can only be used with the Nora Caplan-Bricker piece that originally ran in the 7/25/2015 issue of National Journal magazine.
National Journal
July 24, 2015, 1 a.m.

When a ter­ror­ist at­tack killed Amer­ic­an per­son­nel in Benghazi, Libya, in 2012, Re­pub­lic­an for­eign policy wonks were sud­denly very busy. There was blame to cast and danger to as­sess, and their opin­ions were in un­usu­ally high de­mand. One of their num­ber, however, was busy with a melt­down of dif­fer­ent pro­por­tions: Vic­tor­ia Coates was in Los Angeles, at the Getty Mu­seum, open­ing a show called “The Last Days of Pom­peii.” In one life, Coates is a pro­fes­sion­al art his­tor­i­an who de­scribes her schol­ar­ship as “con­ser­vat­ive with a small ‘c.‘“Š” She’s in­ter­ested in the clas­sics, the can­on; she likes works that can be ana­lyzed in terms of “con­text, ori­gin­al in­ten­tions, prac­tic­al func­tions, that kind of thing.” In her oth­er life, Coates is a na­tion­al se­cur­ity ad­viser to politi­cians who are con­ser­vat­ive with a big “C.” In 2011, she was on the pres­id­en­tial cam­paign trail with Texas Gov. Rick Perry. Now she’s the chief for­eign policy brain for Sen. Ted Cruz.

With her boss run­ning for the GOP pres­id­en­tial nom­in­a­tion in 2016, Coates is tog­gling back and forth between her two ca­reers. She’s about to re­lease her first com­mer­cial book, a glossy sur­vey of fam­ous art­works that cel­eb­rate demo­crat­ic so­ci­et­ies. “The pur­pose of this book is to high­light the syn­ergy between liberty and cre­ativ­ity,” she writes in the in­tro­duc­tion to Dav­id’s Sling — named after Michelan­gelo’s fam­ous statue, craf­ted at the height of the Renais­sance-era Florentine Re­pub­lic — “and so to bring a fresh per­spect­ive to both.” At the same time, she’s busy mak­ing the case that Cruz would be the best de­fend­er of this leg­acy of de­mokra­tia, as she calls it in her chapter about Athens and the Parthen­on.

Coates came on­board soon after Cruz ar­rived in Wash­ing­ton in 2013, which put her in the middle of the sen­at­or’s in­fam­ous fili­buster of Chuck Hagel’s nom­in­a­tion as De­fense sec­ret­ary — an epis­ode that got the Tex­an labeled “Mc­Carthy­ite” by many for his at­tacks on his fel­low Re­pub­lic­an. At first, Cruz wanted help with talk­ing points. Now, Coates is not only Cruz’s seni­or na­tion­al se­cur­ity ad­viser in the Sen­ate, she’s also his cam­paign’s main in­ter­na­tion­al strategist. Says Coates’s friend and agent Keith Ur­bahn, who worked for years for former De­fense Sec­ret­ary Don­ald Rums­feld: “My tagline for her is, ‘The most in­ter­est­ing Cap­it­ol Hill staffer out there.‘“Š”

Coates’s un­likely road to Wash­ing­ton star­ted at the Uni­versity of Pennsylvania, where she earned her art-his­tory Ph.d. and taught — and found her­self frus­trated by the ivory tower’s lib­er­al ho­mo­gen­eity. “Every­body thinks the same, and it’s shock­ing that any­one would think dif­fer­ently,” says Coates, who grew up in a Re­pub­lic­an fam­ily. “I mean, every­body’s jokes are the same jokes. It’s like a club you don’t be­long to.” To let off steam, she star­ted post­ing at the brand-new web­site Red­State, un­der the monik­er “Aca­dem­ic Ele­phant.” Her qual­i­fic­a­tions were com­posed of the polit­ic­al-sci­ence courses she’d taken in col­lege and a pas­sion for in­ter­na­tion­al polit­ics she’d nursed on her own time. But her com­ment­ary on mil­it­ary is­sues and na­tion­al se­cur­ity caught the at­ten­tion of Red­State founder Er­ick Er­ick­son, who made her a reg­u­lar con­trib­ut­or — and then of Rums­feld, who, Ur­bahn says, first no­ticed her when she “put to­geth­er a blog post that sys­tem­at­ic­ally dis­mantled” Bob Wood­ward’s book on the Bush White House, State of Deni­al. 

Ques­tions of doc­trine and back­ground aside, Cruz’s staffers say Coates has earned their trust and the sen­at­or’s.

A few months later, Er­ick­son got a call from a Rums­feld staffer. “He said, ‘The sec­ret­ary has been hav­ing this guy’s work prin­ted out for him for his reg­u­lar daily brief­ing pack­age, and he would really like to see if this guy, giv­en his back­ground and ex­pert­ise in the mil­it­ary, would help write his mem­oir,‘“Š” Er­ick­son re­calls. “I fell over laugh­ing and said: ‘One, not a guy. Two, not in the mil­it­ary.‘“Š”

Rums­feld needed someone with the chops to turn his vast per­son­al archive in­to a book — in oth­er words, an aca­dem­ic sim­patico with his polit­ics. Coates fit the bill. She de­scribes her four years work­ing on Known and Un­known, Rums­feld’s 800-page auto­bi­o­graphy, as a crash course in for­eign policy. “His life goes from Pearl Har­bor to 9/11 and bey­ond, so that was a tu­tori­al,” she says. As she wrapped up the pro­ject in 2011, she was plan­ning to re­turn to art his­tory full-time. Then a friend from Red­State, Chip Roy, called to tell her that his boss, Texas Gov. Rick Perry, was as­sem­bling a last-minute pres­id­en­tial cam­paign — was she in­ter­ested in serving as for­eign policy ad­viser?

“At the Perry camp, everything was go­ing so quickly,” Roy ex­plains when I ask him how he made the case for bring­ing in an art his­tor­i­an to do for­eign policy. After Perry flamed out in 2012, Roy be­came chief of staff for Cruz. It didn’t re­quire much of a sales job to bring Coates along with him. “It doesn’t take long to say, ‘She’s earned the trust of Don­ald Rums­feld,‘“Š” he says. “You have your Ph.D. in any­thing, every­one knows you are edu­cated. The ques­tion is, are you ex­pert in this area?”

That is no small ques­tion, ar­gues Kori Schake, a re­search fel­low at Stan­ford’s Hoover In­sti­tu­tion who thinks Cruz would have been wise to pick a wonki­er coun­selor. Cruz “is one of the least ex­per­i­enced can­did­ates over­all, and that shows up in his re­ac­tions on for­eign and de­fense policy is­sues,” Schake says. “For­eign and de­fense policy tend to be gate­way vot­ing is­sues — people look at can­did­ates and say, ‘Are they ser­i­ous on these is­sues?’ Only if you pass that test do Amer­ic­ans go on to pay at­ten­tion to the things they ac­tu­ally vote on.”

Coates, for one, seems con­fid­ent in her un­usu­al résumé. “If you’re an art his­tor­i­an and not a good for­eign policy ad­viser, I could see it be­ing a li­ab­il­ity,” she says. But “if you’re a suc­cess­ful ad­viser, and know your sub­ject mat­ter,” then she be­lieves the ex­tra ex­pert­ise “be­comes an as­set” — giv­ing her, and by ex­ten­sion the sen­at­or, a broad­er and more cre­at­ive way to look at the world.

Her ap­proach to for­eign policy is cer­tainly out­side the box. “She’s def­in­itely not a neo­con­ser­vat­ive,” Ur­bahn says. Roy calls her “not re­flex­ively hawk­ish — rather she has a well-in­formed peace-through-strength world­view.” When I press Coates to de­scribe her doc­trine — hawk? neo­con? real­ist? — she doesn’t of­fer much cla­ri­fic­a­tion. “I think doc­trines are dan­ger­ous,” she says. “I think they lead to sloppy think­ing.” She knows that makes her rather hard to pin down. “Yes, I’m a hawk. Yes, I’m a dove,” she says. “There are times I would ad­voc­ate great re­luct­ance to use U.S. force. There are times I would ad­voc­ate a ro­bust use of U.S. force.”

Ques­tions of doc­trine and back­ground aside, Cruz’s staffers say Coates has earned their trust and the sen­at­or’s. “Her great tal­ent is fol­low­ing what is driv­ing the news and find­ing a way to al­low Sen­at­or Cruz’s mes­sage on na­tion­al se­cur­ity to res­on­ate,” says Cruz’s press sec­ret­ary, Cath­er­ine Fra­zi­er. “She’s a good writer and can dis­till in­form­a­tion in a mean­ing­ful way,” Roy says. “People ask, ‘How’s she qual­i­fied for ad­vising a pres­id­en­tial nom­in­ee?’ All I can say to that is, ‘How are any ad­visers able to ad­vise any­body?’ You have to know your sub­ject, but it has more to do with con­nect­ing with the prin­cip­al in a way that res­on­ates.”

What We're Following See More »
Trump Loses in Court Again
1 days ago
Trump Pulls the Plug on Infrastructure
1 days ago
Parties Go to Court Today Over Trump Banking Records
1 days ago
Tillerson Talking to House Foreign Affairs
2 days ago

"Former Secretary of State Rex Tillerson was spotted entering a congressional office building on Tuesday morning for what a committee aide told The Daily Beast was a meeting with the leaders of the House Foreign Affairs committee and relevant staff about his time working in the Trump administration. ... Tillerson’s arrival at the Capitol was handled with extreme secrecy. No media advisories or press releases were sent out announcing his appearance. And he took a little noticed route into the building in order to avoid being seen by members of the media."

House Subpoenas Hope Hicks, Annie Donaldson
2 days ago

Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.