Winners: Trump, Kasich, Rubio. Losers: Bush, Carson, Cruz.

Donald Trump’s campaign might eventually unravel, but it didn’t happen Thursday night.

National Journal
Alex Roarty
Add to Briefcase
See more stories about...
Alex Roarty
Aug. 6, 2015, 7:59 p.m.

The win­ners and losers from Thursday night’s prime-time GOP de­bate:


Don­ald Trump

Trump’s cam­paign might even­tu­ally un­ravel, but it didn’t hap­pen Thursday night. The front-run­ner in the polls thrived off a series of tough ques­tions about his past — in most cases, quickly pivot­ing to a con­dem­na­tion of polit­ic­al cor­rect­ness and polit­ics as usu­al. Trump is clearly a TV vet­er­an: His tim­ing was im­pec­cable when he quipped to de­bate mod­er­at­or Me­gyn Kelly that the only wo­man he ever trash-talked was Rosie O’Don­nell. It wasn’t true, but in Trump­World, it didn’t really mat­ter.

The re­cit­a­tion of many of Trump’s past lib­er­al po­s­i­tions — his sup­port for abor­tion rights and single-pay­er health care, for in­stance — might ali­en­ate some sup­port­ers un­fa­mil­i­ar with the finer points of his re­cord. But time and again he demon­strated why so many con­ser­vat­ives are in love with his blunt mes­sage. “I’ve been chal­lenged by so many people, and I don’t frankly have time for total polit­ic­al cor­rect­ness,” he said at one point. “And to be hon­est with you, this coun­try doesn’t have time either.”

(RE­LATED: Re­pub­lic­an De­bate Turns Spec­tacle and Leaves Trump on Top)

John Kasich

The Ohio gov­ernor snuck onto the main de­bate stage thanks to a late surge in the polls — and im­me­di­ately proved he might be­long in the field’s top tier. It wasn’t just his strong com­mand of the facts, though he demon­strated that with a de­tailed de­fense of his de­cision as gov­ernor to ex­pand Medi­caid. Kasich also showed a cha­risma that made him — and not Jeb Bush — look like the most elect­able Re­pub­lic­an in a gen­er­al elec­tion. Wheth­er he was tout­ing his re­cord as a swing-state gov­ernor or fin­ess­ing a ques­tion about how he could jus­ti­fy his op­pos­i­tion to gay mar­riage to a gay son or daugh­ter, he talked like a for­mid­able po­ten­tial nom­in­ee.

“You know, Amer­ica is a mir­acle coun­try,” Kasich said, re­spond­ing to the ques­tion of how he would de­feat Hil­lary Clin­ton. “And we have to re­store the sense that the ‘Amir­acle’ will ap­ply to you. Each and every one of the people in this coun­try who’s watch­ing to­night, lift every­body, unite every­body, and build a stronger United States of Amer­ica again. It will be and can be done.”

Marco Ru­bio

Of the three can­did­ates most likely to win the nom­in­a­tion — Marco Ru­bio, Jeb Bush, and Scott Walk­er — the sen­at­or from Flor­ida had the best night. He seemed to grow in con­fid­ence as the de­bate wore on, cul­min­at­ing in a rous­ing speech ex­plain­ing his op­pos­i­tion to abor­tion rights.

More than any­thing else, however, he un­der­scored again and again why he would be a strong op­pon­ent against Clin­ton. “If I’m our nom­in­ee, how is Hil­lary Clin­ton go­ing to lec­ture me about liv­ing paycheck to paycheck?” Ru­bio asked. “I was raised paycheck to paycheck. How is she go­ing to lec­ture me about stu­dent loans? I owed over $100,000 just four years ago.”

(RE­LATED: John Kasich Is Steal­ing Jeb Bush’s Thun­der)


Jeb Bush

Bush didn’t stumble badly. But the former Flor­ida gov­ernor didn’t come off as the man most likely to be pres­id­ent, either; he was awk­ward at times, un­in­spir­ing at oth­ers. He did little to dis­pel the no­tion that his pub­lic pres­ence can be un­der­whelm­ing. He brought back pain­ful memor­ies of his cam­paign’s worst mo­ment, when Kelly re­vis­ited his sug­ges­tion earli­er this year that he would have ordered the in­va­sion of Ir­aq know­ing what he knows now.

“I re­mem­ber, Me­gyn,” he said, try­ing to laugh it off.

Bush’s ex­per­i­ence and gar­gan­tu­an bank ac­count guar­an­tee that most will still see him as the GOP front-run­ner after this — but it wasn’t his best night.

Ben Car­son

Car­son scored points at the night’s con­clu­sion, jok­ing about all the things that he, as a sur­geon, has done that his rivals hadn’t. But of the 10 can­did­ates on stage, he’s the one who came off as if he be­longed in Thursday’s earli­er “Happy Hour” de­bate. Car­son him­self seemed to sense he was the night’s for­got­ten man, jok­ing that the mod­er­at­ors had gone a long time between ask­ing him ques­tions.

“Well, thank you, Me­gyn,” he said when it was fi­nally his turn again. “I wasn’t sure I was go­ing to get to talk again.”

(RE­LATED: Trump Voters: Is This Really What You Want?)

Ted Cruz

Cruz sub­mit­ted a sol­id — if un­mem­or­able — per­form­ance. But he gets graded on a curve — and not well: This should be the former col­lege de­bater’s best format, and a hand­ful of his rivals had a bet­ter night. Worse yet for the sen­at­or from Texas was Trump’s per­form­ance, which sug­ges­ted that the bil­lion­aire — and his hold over the con­ser­vat­ive voters Cruz cov­ets — won’t fade from the race any­time soon.

What We're Following See More »
Trump’s SEC Chair Nominee Faces Tough Questioning
4 hours ago

Jay Clayton, Donald Trump's nominee to lead the Securities and Exchange Commission, was grilled today during his hearing in front of the Senate Committee on Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs. In question were his extensive ties to Wall Street and his potential conflicts of interest. During his hearing, Clayton promised he would not show favoritism to anyone. Clayton's financial disclosure revealed that Clayton "raked in $7.6 million in the year leading up to his nomination, buoyed by a client roster that included big banks such as Goldman Sachs. President Donald Trump has picked Goldman alums for several regulatory roles in his administration."

GSA Says Trump Hotel in Full Compliance
4 hours ago

The Trump Organization, which operates the Trump International Hotel in the Old Post Office building, is in full compliance with its lease with the General Services Administration, according to a letter issued by the agency today. The agreement states that no member of the group holding the lease may be an officer of the federal government. The Trump Organization satisfies that provision, according to GSA Contracting Officer Kevin Terry, who "noted the entity that leases the property from the federal government revised its ownership structure to ensure that the president does not receive any profits from the hotel while serving as president even though he still will hold a stake in related affiliates that will profit from the hotel's operations."

Health Vote Postponed
4 hours ago
Senators Press Sonny Perdue on Budget Cuts
5 hours ago

"Former Georgia governor Sonny Perdue, President Trump’s pick to lead the Agriculture Department, faced pointed questions about the administration’s proposed cuts to rural assistance programs during his otherwise friendly Senate confirmation hearing Thursday. Throughout the hearing, Perdue affirmed his commitment to several programs that could face cuts due to Trump’s budget: the Rural Utilities Service; the Natural Resource Conservation Center; and various agricultural research programs," even as the president's budget would cut his agency by 20 percent.

Rep. Duncan Hunter Under Investigation
6 hours ago

Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.