How Uber Could Help Solve National Security Problems

The U.S. intelligence community wants feedback from the innovative car-sharing company and other commercial start-ups on its 5-year data-analysis road map.

National Journal
Aug. 10, 2015, 12:18 p.m.

The in­tel­li­gence com­munity this month quietly re­leased an un­pre­ced­en­ted, un­clas­si­fied five-year-road map chart­ing the fu­ture of data ana­lys­is it wants com­mer­cial start-ups like ride-shar­ing firm Uber to read.

The chart, part of a lar­ger sci­ence and tech­no­logy strategy, is aimed at en­cour­aging un­con­ven­tion­al makers like the car ser­vice app-de­veloper and tra­di­tion­al tech con­tract­ors to help fund an­swers to on­com­ing na­tion­al se­cur­ity prob­lems.

The road map is an out­growth of spring work­shops with 40 com­pan­ies that do clas­si­fied work and a gov­ern­ment ana­lys­is of the in­tel­li­gence com­munity’s sci­ence and tech­no­logy needs.

By syncing private-sec­tor re­search now un­der­way with the Of­fice of the Dir­ect­or of Na­tion­al In­tel­li­gence’s threat pre­dic­tions, the right tech­no­logy will be ready at the right time at the right price, DNI of­fi­cials say.

The pub­licly avail­able gap ana­lys­is, titled “En­hanced Pro­cessing and Man­age­ment of Data from Dis­par­ate Sources,” maps out one of six fu­ture growth areas for the spy com­munity. The oth­er graph­ics are only for the eyes of in­di­vidu­als hold­ing secret se­cur­ity clear­ances.

So, how might Uber help the dir­ect­or of na­tion­al in­tel­li­gence?

“Maybe they’ve got schedul­ing al­gorithms that would help us with our lo­gist­ics prob­lems,” Dav­id Honey, DNI dir­ect­or of sci­ence and tech­no­logy, said dur­ing a re­cent in­ter­view with Nex­t­gov. “If we can lever­age those kinds of tools, maybe we gotta ad­apt them a little bit, but that cer­tainly beats hav­ing to go and pay for those things from scratch.”

The na­tion­al in­tel­li­gence pro­gram is fa­cing its fourth year of budget cuts.

Powers U.S. spies need that no one is fund­ing yet in­clude, for ex­ample, ex­pert­ise in de­term­in­ing the bi­ases of so­cial-me­dia site mod­er­at­ors, geo­loca­tion in the pres­ence of en­cryp­tion, room-tem­per­at­ure quantum com­put­ing, and im­mers­ive vir­tu­al-world user ex­per­i­ence.

“One of our goals for the com­ing year is to try and ex­tend our out­reach via whichever trade as­so­ci­ations are will­ing to take it on, in­to the un­cleared com­munity as well,” Honey said, sit­ting in­side DNI’s McLean, Vir­gin­ia headquar­ters. “That’s why get­ting this in­form­a­tion on to the ODNI’s open web­site was so im­port­ant to us. We want to have that out­reach to the non­tra­di­tion­als to in­clude the un­cleared per­former com­munity so that they can gain in­sight in­to what the chal­lenges are that we face so that they can come for­ward with ideas.”

As of four years ago, in­form­a­tion tech­no­logy con­sumed about 23 per­cent of in­tel­li­gence pro­gram fund­ing, ac­cord­ing to DNI. Pres­id­ent Obama has re­ques­ted $53.9 bil­lion for the pro­gram in 2016.

So­cial-Me­dia Over­load

Dir­ect­or of Na­tion­al In­tel­li­gence James Clap­per last month de­scribed some in­form­a­tion-munch­ing dif­fi­culties con­front­ing ana­lysts, such as track­ing down lone-wolf ex­trem­ists who have been in­spired by Is­lam­ic State rhet­or­ic.

“With the way people rad­ic­al­ize on their own, or are rad­ic­al­ized via so­cial me­dia where they don’t leave out a sig­na­ture, they don’t emit — some at­trib­ute or trait or be­ha­vi­or that would lead you to be­gin watch­ing them,” Clap­per said at the As­pen Se­cur­ity For­um in Col­or­ado. “And so we’re lack­ing that.”

The dif­fi­culty is then ex­acer­bated by the use of “en­cryp­ted,” or di­git­ally scrambled, com­mu­nic­a­tions, he said.

“Someone is pros­elyted by an ISIL re­cruit­er sit­ting in Syr­ia or some place,” and if that po­ten­tial ex­trem­ist takes an in­terest, “then they’ll switch to, you know, en­cryp­ted com­mu­nic­a­tions that we can’t watch,” Clap­per said.

However, it is not be­lieved the homegrown rad­ic­al Mo­hammad Ab­dulaz­eez, who gunned down five ser­vice­men in Chat­tanooga, Ten­ness­ee, in Ju­ly, used en­cryp­tion to hide plot­ting.

“There’s been no con­nec­tion made” yet, Clap­per ac­know­ledged. He ad­ded that it might be be­ne­fi­cial to quanti­fy the use of en­cryp­tion by ter­ror­ists: “I think we prob­ably need to see what we can do to do a bet­ter job of keep­ing some met­rics” on in­cid­ents “where we ran in­to an en­cryp­tion situ­ation and that sty­mies an in­vest­ig­a­tion,” he said.

The in­tel­li­gence com­munity is not bank­rupt of in­nov­at­ors, by any means.

In-Q-Tel, a CIA-backed ven­ture-cap­it­al firm, has borne fruit from tech­no­lo­gies it helped seed at open-source threat-ana­lys­is firm Re­cor­ded Fu­ture and data-sleuth­ing com­pany Pa­lantir, among some roughly 200 start-ups.

But some­times, un­cleared ex­ecs cre­ate gad­gets and ser­vices that have un­in­ten­tion­al clas­si­fied ap­plic­a­tions, Honey said.

The spy com­munity might look at, for in­stance, Twit­ter ana­lyt­ics to dis­cern how a mass-ci­vil­ian-cas­u­alty in­cid­ent over­seas is af­fect­ing for­eign sen­ti­ment to­ward Amer­ica.

So­cial me­dia “is in many cases an in­dic­at­or of de­vel­op­ments that pre­vi­ously we nev­er would have had ac­cess to. One time, the best open-source in­form­a­tion source would have been CNN,” Honey said. “But today, with all the so­cial-me­dia activ­ity that’s out there, we need to un­der­stand what’s com­ing be­fore it gets here — not after it’s already here and now we’re be­hind the curve in un­der­stand­ing how to in­ter­pret it.”

People might ask, “How could you not fol­low what goes on on Twit­ter?” he ad­ded. “Well, it hasn’t been around that long.”

Crowd­sourcing Clas­si­fied R&D

The data-ana­lyt­ics road map fills up a couple of sheets in a 26-page un­clas­si­fied 2016-2020 DNI sci­ence and tech­no­logy strategy pos­ted on­line in re­cent days.

Bring­ing the pa­per to life already has re­quired the use of so­cial me­dia. Con­tract­ors and in­tel­li­gence agen­cies are crowd­sourcing up­dates to the doc­u­ment and match­ing agency needs with fun­ded cor­por­ate pro­jects on a clas­si­fied web­site, Honey said.

The col­lab­or­a­tion en­vir­on­ment is loc­ated on a top-secret sys­tem called Jwics, for Joint World­wide In­tel­li­gence Com­mu­nic­a­tions Sys­tem.

It’s easy to com­pare this ven­ture to a wiki, but un­like, say, Wiki­pe­dia, the spy sys­tem must be able to push out ed­its to rel­ev­ant agen­cies and rel­ev­ant com­pan­ies in a timely fash­ion.

Agen­cies “need to be able to post the chal­lenge in a way that the sys­tem auto­mat­ic­ally alerts the right tech­no­logy sup­pli­ers,” and “if you’re a tech­no­logy pro­vider and you are post­ing new solu­tions, the solu­tions need to be able to find their way to the cus­tom­er” without every­body do­ing a search every day, Honey said.

If feas­ible, DNI will cre­ate a pub­lic Web space for in­di­vidu­als without clear­ances to con­trib­ute sug­ges­tions for the un­clas­si­fied strategy, he said.

Oth­er road maps de­signed dur­ing the re­cent con­tract­or work­shops chart rifts in, among oth­er things, space cap­ab­il­it­ies, glob­al pro­lif­er­a­tion pre­dic­tion ca­pa­city, and the abil­ity of nov­el sensors to re­veal ad­versary ac­tions.

The busi­nesses that par­ti­cip­ated in the meet­ings are gath­er­ing a week from Monday to start de­vel­op­ing yard­sticks for meas­ur­ing pro­gress in each gap area, Honey said.

Out­siders want­ing to help equip spies who have not been briefed on top-secret in­tel­li­gence are not ne­ces­sar­ily at a dis­ad­vant­age. They might be more likely to de­vise tech­no­lo­gies that go bey­ond mere up­grades.

“If you are too close to the clas­si­fied in­form­a­tion, you are go­ing to try to cre­ate a faster horse,” Honey said. “Quite of­ten, people who have just a gen­er­al know­ledge of what we’re try­ing to do are in a bet­ter po­s­i­tion to help us think about new solu­tions than those who are deeply in­grained in the ma­chine.”

What We're Following See More »
McCain Family to Endorse Biden
54 minutes ago

"The late Sen. John McCain's family plans to support former Vice President Joe Biden's White House bid, backing the Democrat not only in his party's crowded primary race but also in a general election matchup with President Trump, the Washington Examiner has learned. In an extraordinary snub to Trump, who derided McCain's Vietnam War service and mocked him even after his death last August at age 81, the McCain family is preparing to break with the Republican Party. McCain represented the party in Congress for 35 years and was chosen as its presidential nominee in 2008, losing to Barack Obama."

IRS Resists Giving Congress Trump's Tax Returns
4 hours ago

"Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin left little doubt Tuesday that the administration will reject a congressional request for President Donald Trump's tax returns by a self-imposed May 6 target for a "final decision," setting the stage for a legal battle that will test the limits of congressional oversight."

Trump Opposes White House Aides Giving Congressional Testimony
5 hours ago

"President Trump on Tuesday said he is opposed to current and former White House aides providing testimony to congressional panels in the wake of the special counsel report, intensifying a power struggle between his administration and House Democrats. In an interview with The Washington Post, Trump said that complying with congressional requests was unnecessary after the White House cooperated with special counsel Robert S. Mueller III’s probe of Russian interference and the president’s own conduct in office."

Judge Blocks Trump Abortion Rule
5 hours ago

"U.S. District Judge Michael J. McShane late Tuesday said he’ll grant a preliminary injunction against new federal restrictions that bar taxpayer-funded family planning clinics from referring patients to abortion providers, calling the rule a 'ham-fisted approach to public health policy.' Oregon is one of 20 states and the District of Columbia that challenged the Trump administration’s changes to the Title X family planning program in U.S. District Court in Oregon, along with Planned Parenthood affiliates and the American Medical Association."

Nadler Subpoenas Unredacted Report
5 days ago

Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.