Why Orrin Hatch Could Run Again in 2018

The senator pledged during his reelection campaign four years ago that this would be his last term.

Sen. Orrin Hatch, a senior member of the Senate Judiciary Committee, speaks with reporters in a basement corridor at the Capitol just after President Obama urged Senate Republicans to grant hearings and a confirmation vote to Merrick Garland, his nominee to replace the late Justice Antonin Scalia on the Supreme Court, on March 16, 2016.
AP Photo/J. Scott Applewhite
Ally Mutnick
Add to Briefcase
Ally Mutnick
March 31, 2016, 8 p.m.

Fa­cing his most com­pet­it­ive reelec­tion in years, Re­pub­lic­an Sen. Or­rin Hatch pledged in 2012 that this would be his fi­nal term. But as 2018 nears, Utah Re­pub­lic­ans and politicos are bet­ting that he will make an­oth­er run.

A little more than a year in­to his gig as pres­id­ent pro tem­pore of the Sen­ate—a job that comes with a se­cur­ity de­tail and leaves him third in line to the pres­id­ency—ob­serv­ers and former staffers said they see no sign of the 82-year-old slow­ing down, es­pe­cially if Re­pub­lic­ans hang onto the Sen­ate.

“I worked for him on the 1994 Hatch cam­paign, 22 years ago,” said Jef­frey Hartley, a former ex­ec­ut­ive dir­ect­or of the state Re­pub­lic­an Party. “My opin­ion, be­ing an ob­serv­er of Sen­at­or Hatch since then, is that if he’s in good health, he’s go­ing to run again be­cause be­ing a United States sen­at­or is in his DNA.”

Hatch stoked spec­u­la­tion that he could seek reelec­tion in a 2014 ra­dio in­ter­view, when the sev­en-term sen­at­or sug­ges­ted that he might stick around if the Sen­ate was in the middle of tax re­form and “people were de­mand­ing that I get it done.”

“You’d al­ways have to put the coun­try first,” Hatch said then. “We’ll just have to see.”

Tax re­form could drag out to 2018, but some state Re­pub­lic­ans sug­gest the fu­ture of the Su­preme Court ig­nites a more com­pel­ling case for an­oth­er Hatch term.

He has placed him­self at the cen­ter of the cur­rent nom­in­a­tion battle, stick­ing firmly by the party line of delay­ing hear­ings even as Pres­id­ent Obama re­peatedly used Hatch’s sup­port­ive com­ments about Mer­rick Gar­land in 1997 as evid­ence of the judge’s bi­par­tis­an ap­peal.

Hatch sat down with loc­al press dur­ing the spring re­cess to dis­cuss the Su­preme Court and his work in the Sen­ate. And in an op-ed Monday in The New York Times, Hatch re­minded voters of his “nearly four dec­ades” on the Sen­ate Ju­di­ciary Com­mit­tee, de­scrib­ing what he saw as a “de­teri­or­a­tion of the con­firm­a­tion pro­cess.” Hatch has been on the com­mit­tee for the nom­in­a­tion of every justice since Sandra Day O’Con­nor.

“There’s a po­ten­tial of four new justices in the next pres­id­ent’s ad­min­is­tra­tion,” said Spen­cer Stokes, who worked on Hatch’s 2000 pres­id­en­tial cam­paign and is a former chief of staff for Sen. Mike Lee. “It’s the one thing that every­body in Utah knows, and that is that Sen­at­or Hatch is a mem­ber of the Ju­di­ciary Com­mit­tee.”

Hatch’s of­fice did not re­spond to sev­er­al re­quests from Na­tion­al Journ­al for com­ment about his plans. If he does run, Hatch should prob­ably ex­pect an­oth­er con­ten­tious race.

State Re­pub­lic­ans have thrown around names of po­ten­tial chal­lengers, in­clud­ing former state Sen. Dan Liljen­quist, who lost to Hatch in 2012, Mitt Rom­ney’s son Josh, and state Sen. Deidre Hende­r­son.

Reached for com­ment, Liljen­quist said he’s con­sid­er­ing an­oth­er run but won’t make a de­cision for at least a year.

“I had a great time run­ning. I loved it,” Liljen­quist said. “Next time, I cer­tainly have more abil­ity to fun­draise and reach people that didn’t know me be­fore.”

A change in Utah’s primary-elec­tion laws could be­ne­fit Hatch. The state le­gis­lature passed a bill in 2014 that al­lows can­did­ates to by­pass the party con­ven­tion and se­cure a spot on the primary bal­lot by gath­er­ing sig­na­tures. This could act as a safety net for the sen­at­or if op­pon­ents try to shut him out at the con­ven­tion, as two tea-party-backed can­did­ates did to former Sen. Bob Ben­nett in 2010. The state GOP is chal­len­ging the law in court.  

It was at the con­ven­tion—gen­er­ally pop­u­lated by the party’s most con­ser­vat­ive act­iv­ists—where Hatch was most vul­ner­able in 2012. But after a con­cer­ted ef­fort to pack the con­ven­tion with Hatch sup­port­ers, he only nar­rowly missed out on se­cur­ing the nom­in­a­tion, com­ing up a point shy of the 60 per­cent threshold. That launched the sen­at­or and Liljen­quist in­to the Hatch-friendly con­fines of the far more ex­pans­ive and mod­er­ate primary elect­or­ate.

Freedom­Works spent $750,000 to topple Hatch at the con­ven­tion, but de­clined to go all-in for the primary, where Hatch crushed Liljen­quist by a nearly 2-1 ra­tio. Both Freedom­Works and the Club For Growth, which de­clined to go after Hatch in 2012, said they likely won’t de­cide 2018 tar­gets un­til after this cycle ends.

If Hatch sticks by his 2012 de­clar­a­tion that this is his fi­nal term, the race to re­place him will have no short­age of pos­sible can­did­ates. Of Utah’s four-mem­ber House del­eg­a­tion, many state Re­pub­lic­ans think Rep. Chris Stew­art is the most likely con­tender for an open seat.

Stew­art said his only fo­cus is on his cur­rent con­stitu­ents and his reelec­tion. In an in­ter­view at the Cap­it­ol last week, he called Hatch a “good friend,” who is likely aware that the race could be com­pet­it­ive if he seeks reelec­tion.

Rep. Jason Chaf­fetz said in an in­ter­view that “it’s doubt­ful” he would give up his spot as chair­man of the Over­sight com­mit­tee to be­come a fresh­man sen­at­or, adding that he finds the 2020 gov­ernor­ship race more ap­peal­ing.

Hende­r­son, known for her work on tax policy in the state, and Boyd Math­eson, Lee’s former chief of staff, didn’t rule out bids. But both said they were not cur­rently con­sid­er­ing a run.

Spokes­men for Reps. Rob Bish­op and Mia Love both said they do not in­tend to run for Sen­ate in 2018. Bish­op is rid­ing out the end of his ten­ure as chair­man of the Nat­ur­al Re­sources Com­mit­tee and Love is grap­pling with a tricky reelec­tion cam­paign this cycle.

Oth­er pos­sible con­tenders in­clude former state GOP chair­man Thomas Wright, Josh Rom­ney, and Derek Miller, head of the Utah World Trade Cen­ter and a former chief of staff to Utah Gov. Gary Her­bert. State GOP con­sult­ants also poin­ted to Kirk Jowers, who left the Hinckley In­sti­tute of Polit­ics at the Uni­versity of Utah for a job in the private sec­tor last year.

“Any open Sen­ate seat, should Sen­at­or Hatch de­cide not to run,” Stew­art said, “every­one and their dog is go­ing to be look­ing at that race.”

What We're Following See More »
Government Shutdown Begins, as Senate Balks at Stopgap
1 hours ago

"A stopgap spending bill stalled in the Senate Friday night, leading to a government shutdown for the first time since 2013. The continuing resolution funding agencies expired at midnight, and lawmakers were unable to spell out any path forward to keep government open. The Senate on Friday night failed to reach cloture on a four-week spending bill the House had already approved."

Mueller’s Team Scrutinizing Russian Embassy Transactions
1 days ago
FBI Investigating Potential Russian Donations to NRA
1 days ago

"The FBI is investigating whether a top Russian banker with ties to the Kremlin illegally funneled money to the National Rifle Association to help Donald Trump win the presidency." Investigators have focused on Alexander Torshin, the deputy governor of Russia’s central bank "who is known for his close relationships with both Russian President Vladimir Putin and the NRA." The solicitation or use of foreign funds is illegal in U.S. elections under the Federal Election Campaign Act (FECA) by either lobbying groups or political campaigns. The NRA reported spending a record $55 million on the 2016 elections.

Mueller Investigation Leads to Hundreds of New FARA Filings
1 days ago

"Hundreds of new and supplemental FARA filings by U.S. lobbyists and public relations firms" have been submitted "since Special Counsel Mueller charged two Trump aides with failing to disclose their lobbying work on behalf of foreign countries. The number of first-time filings ... rose 50 percent to 102 between 2016 and 2017, an NBC News analysis found. The number of supplemental filings, which include details about campaign donations, meetings and phone calls more than doubled from 618 to 1,244 last year as lobbyists scrambled to avoid the same fate as some of Trump's associates and their business partners."

Hicks to Testify on Friday
1 days ago

Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.