Want Women to Earn More? Train Them for Manufacturing

One way to boost earnings of single, low-income women is to urge them to seek out jobs in skilled trades instead of retail and service gigs.

Some female watchmakers at work at Shinola's Detroit factory on Oct. 2, 2013 in Detroit, Mich.
National Journal
Stephanie Czekalinsk
Feb. 13, 2014, midnight

Help­ing single work­ing moth­ers move in­to jobs tra­di­tion­ally held by men could help more than 4.1 mil­lion low-in­come fam­il­ies move to­ward join­ing the middle class, ac­cord­ing to a re­port re­leased this week by the Work­ing Poor Fam­il­ies Pro­ject, a not-for-profit that stud­ies state work­force de­vel­op­ment policies.

If wo­men moved in­to jobs in man­u­fac­tur­ing, skilled trades, or trans­port­a­tion in great­er num­bers, they could in­crease their earn­ings by up to 30 per­cent. Cur­rently, nearly half of all low-in­come, work­ing wo­men — those who earn be­low 200 per­cent of the fed­er­al poverty line and who head house­holds — work primar­ily in 16 oc­cu­pa­tions clustered around the ser­vice and re­tail sec­tors. Of­ten, these lower-pay­ing jobs do not provide be­ne­fits like health in­sur­ance or paid sick leave, ac­cord­ing to the re­port.

To break it down fur­ther, that’s more than 7 per­cent of work­ing single wo­men with chil­dren who are em­ployed as home health aides; 5.3 per­cent as cashiers; and 5 per­cent as maids or house­keep­ers. Sig­ni­fic­ant num­bers also work as wait­resses, cus­tom­er-ser­vice rep­res­ent­at­ives, per­son­al care aides, ad­min­is­trat­ive as­sist­ants, cooks, or child-care work­ers.

Yet while the mean an­nu­al in­come in 2012 for all work­ers in the ac­com­mod­a­tion and food-ser­vice and re­tail sec­tors was $22,800 and $26,960, re­spect­ively, the mean for those in man­u­fac­tur­ing jobs was $47,240, ac­cord­ing to the Bur­eau of Labor Stat­ist­ics.

In­creas­ing the pool of wo­men in man­u­fac­tur­ing may seem like clear rem­edy, but there’s a wrinkle. Of­ten man­u­fac­tur­ing or oth­er well-pay­ing blue-col­lar jobs re­quire at least some kind of spe­cial­ized cre­den­tial, says De­borah Povich, an au­thor of the study; that can act as a bar­ri­er for single work­ing moms. “What hap­pens when a single mom needs to go back to school? She’s go­ing to need help pay­ing for it, and she’s go­ing to need qual­ity child care,” Povich adds.

Fin­an­cing an edu­ca­tion while foot­ing the bill for child care is dif­fi­cult, par­tic­u­larly those work­ing in low-pay­ing in­dus­tries.

Some of the fast­est-grow­ing oc­cu­pa­tions dur­ing the eco­nom­ic re­cov­ery re­main in the ser­vice and re­tail sec­tors. And de­mand for home health care aides is ex­pec­ted to in­crease by 69 per­cent by 2020. Home health aides typ­ic­ally earn about $21,000 a year, less than half the an­nu­al mean wage of $46,000 across all oc­cu­pa­tions. All the more reas­on for low-in­come wo­men to look in­to get­ting in­to man­u­fac­tur­ing, or oth­er jobs that re­quire tech­nic­al skills.

What We're Following See More »
Freedom Caucus Members May Bolt the RSC
59 minutes ago

The Republican Study Committee may lose several members of the House Freedom Caucus next year, "potentially creating a split between two influential groups of House conservatives." The Freedom Caucus was founded at the inception of the current Congress by members who felt that the conservative RSC had gotten too cozy with leadership, "and its roughly 40 members have long clashed with the RSC over what tactics to use when pushing for conservative legislation." As many as 20 members may not join the RSC for the new Congress next year.

FDA Approves Emergency Zika Test
2 hours ago

"The U.S. Food and Drug Administration on Monday issued emergency authorization for a Zika diagnostics test from Swiss drugmaker Roche, skirting normal approval channels as the regulator moves to fight the disease's spread." Meanwhile, the Wall Street Journal reports that a new study in Nature identifies "about a dozen substances" that could "suppress the pathogen's replication." Some of them are already in clinical trials.

Medicare Advantage Plans Overcharged Government
3 hours ago

According to 37 newly released audits, "some private Medicare plans overcharged the government for the majority of elderly patients they treated." A number of Medicare Advantage plans overstated "the severity of medical conditions like diabetes and depression." The money has since been paid back, though some plans are appealing the federal audits.

Omnibus Spending Bill Likely Getting a Lame-Duck Vote
3 hours ago

"GOP leaders and House Democrats are already laying the groundwork for a short-term continuing resolution" on the budget this fall "that will set up a vote on a catch-all spending bill right before the holidays." As usual, however, the House Freedom Caucus may throw a wrench in Speaker Paul Ryan's gears. The conservative bloc doesn't appear willing to accept any CR that doesn't fund the government into 2017.

Foreign Agents Have Hacked State Voting Databases
4 hours ago

"The FBI has uncovered evidence that foreign hackers penetrated two state election databases in recent weeks, prompting the bureau to warn election officials across the country to take new steps to enhance the security of their computer systems." Homeland Security Secretary Jeh Johnson earlier this month conferred with state election officials, offering his department's assistance in scanning for vulnerabilities."