A Radical Rethinking of Primary Care That Could Make Everyone Healthier

Iora Health practices replace the general practitioner model with a hands-on health team.

National Journal
Sophie Quinton
Add to Briefcase
See more stories about...
Sophie Quinton
March 4, 2014, 2:47 a.m.

At 8:15 every week­day morn­ing, the Culin­ary Ex­tra Clin­ic team meets to talk about pa­tients its mem­bers are most wor­ried about. There are more than one thou­sand reg­u­lar clin­ic pa­tients in the Las Ve­gas area, most of whom work in hos­pit­al­ity jobs at the city’s ho­tels and casi­nos. All of the pa­tients are chron­ic­ally ill, and the team mem­bers dis­cuss those who are cur­rently in the hos­pit­al or have just been dis­charged. But they also fo­cus on oth­er, less ob­vi­ous, con­cerns.

The team — which in­cludes doc­tors, health coaches, a so­cial work­er and a be­ha­vi­or­al health spe­cial­ist — might brain­storm a way to pay for an ex­pens­ive test, like an MRI, that a pa­tient can’t af­ford. They might de­cide to take a pa­tient to the gro­cery store. Last week, they chose to soothe a hos­pit­al­ized pa­tient’s over­whelmed wife by get­ting her a mas­sage. Car­o­lina Pavese, the head nurse, says of the team’s ap­proach: “If that’s go­ing to make it bet­ter, let’s do that.”

The clin­ic prac­tice is run by Iora Health, a Cam­bridge-based start-up that be­lieves it can make pa­tients health­i­er at a lower cost by in­creas­ing ac­cess to ba­sic health care ser­vices and by think­ing more broadly about what ba­sic ser­vices should be. “We of­ten say, our job is not to im­prove people’s health,” says founder and CEO Dr. Rushi­ka Fernan­dopulle. “Our job is to im­prove people’s life. And that will im­prove people’s health.”

Na­tion­ally, sev­en of 10 Amer­ic­ans die from chron­ic dis­eases — primar­ily heart dis­ease, can­cer, and stroke. Low-in­come and minor­ity groups tend to have high­er risk factors for those dis­eases, like high blood pres­sure, ac­cord­ing to a 2012 stat­ist­ic­al up­date from the Amer­ic­an Heart As­so­ci­ation. The up­date also found that Afric­an-Amer­ic­ans and His­pan­ics were less likely than whites to re­ceive all the sug­ges­ted care for ad­dress­ing those risk factors. 

“Iora health was nev­er meant as a health-dis­par­it­ies re­duc­tion ef­fort, but it turns out that ac­tu­ally by do­ing primary care right — which we do — you are ac­tu­ally able to re­duce dis­par­it­ies con­sid­er­ably,” Fernan­dopulle says. A prac­ti­cing primary care doc­tor and former health-care con­sult­ant, he foun­ded Iora Health in 2011 be­cause he wanted to re­in­vent the way ba­sic health care is de­livered. 

Typ­ic­ally, says Fernan­dopulle, primary care ac­counts for about 5 per­cent of total health-care spend­ing. Iora Health asks in­sur­ance com­pan­ies spon­sor­ing a prac­tice to double that amount. The com­pany also pays doc­tors fixed salar­ies, a change Fernan­dopulle says leads doc­tors to re­cog­nize that “my job is to take care of this whole pop­u­la­tion, and to help them no mat­ter what it takes.”

Iora health-care teams are also or­gan­ized very dif­fer­ently than the av­er­age med­ic­al of­fice. A typ­ic­al Iora Health prac­tice in­cludes two doc­tors, a nurse, a so­cial work­er, and more than a half-dozen health coaches. Each pa­tient is con­sidered the re­spons­ib­il­ity of the en­tire team. De­pend­ing on the ser­vices pa­tients want and need, ad­di­tion­al health-care pro­fes­sion­als might round out the team — a nu­tri­tion­ist, say, or a per­son­al train­er.

Iora Health pa­tients can drop by without an ap­point­ment, and they are en­cour­aged to stay in touch with health coaches and doc­tors by email, text mes­sages, phone calls, and video con­fer­en­cing. The com­pany hires staff who speak the lan­guages and re­flect the cul­tur­al back­grounds of the pa­tients they serve. At the Culin­ary Ex­tra Clin­ic, where 73 per­cent of pa­tients are His­pan­ic and the av­er­age age is 56, pa­tients tend to fa­vor face-to-face meet­ings and phone calls.

This new ap­proach to health care re­quires part­ner­ing with in­sur­ance pro­viders will­ing to pay more for primary care. The Culin­ary Ex­tra Clin­ic is sponsored by the Culin­ary Health Fund, a plan that cov­ers mem­bers of the loc­al culin­ary work­ers uni­on and their de­pend­ents. “It was ex­pens­ive for us in the be­gin­ning,” says Kim Voss, seni­or dir­ect­or of health care net­works and ad­vocacy at the Culin­ary Health Fund. “But it was a long-term com­mit­ment to im­prove par­ti­cipant health and to be fisc­ally re­spons­ible.”

Oth­er prac­tices — such as a clin­ic for Dart­mouth Col­lege em­ploy­ees in Han­over, N.H., and clin­ics for mem­bers of the Freel­an­cers Uni­on in New York City — serve all adults covered by the spon­sor­ing in­sur­ance com­pany. Be­cause they tend to serve health­i­er pop­u­la­tions, those prac­tices can reach many more pa­tients.

Culin­ary Ex­tra Clin­ic pa­tients are gen­er­ally happy cus­tom­ers. Ar­range­ments with in­surers guar­an­tee that pa­tients don’t have to pay out of pock­et for any care they re­ceive at an Iora prac­tice. “They take care of everything you need there,” says Al­fred Flores, 73, a re­cent re­tir­ee who worked as a cook at the Stra­to­sphere, a hotel and casino on the Strip, for al­most two dec­ades. The only down­side, he says, is that wait times for ap­point­ments can some­times be long. Doc­tors and health coaches take time with their pa­tients, and the large num­ber of walk-ins makes each day’s sched­ule un­pre­dict­able.

Flores also likes the fact that Culin­ary Ex­tra Clin­ic staff greet him with hugs and they know every­one by name. Clin­ic staff are also aided by a soft­ware sys­tem that alerts the team to signs of trouble, like when a pa­tient fails to pick up his med­ic­a­tion, so they can reach out with as­sist­ance. Per­haps more im­port­ant, each pa­tient has a health coach who serves as a listen­er and a guide. Health coaches per­form some ba­sic clin­ic­al tasks, such as tak­ing vi­tal signs, but many have no form­al clin­ic­al train­ing. They’re se­lec­ted for their em­pathy. Some­times, pa­tients will stop by just be­cause they want to talk, says Yan­ell Nava, a nurse and health coach at the Culin­ary Ex­tra Clin­ic. Of­ten, it turns out that seem­ingly un­re­lated cir­cum­stances in a pa­tient’s life are af­fect­ing his or her health.

It’s too early to tell wheth­er the Culin­ary Ex­tra Clin­ic is im­prov­ing health and lower­ing costs, Voss says. But evid­ence from an At­lantic City, N.J. clin­ic that Fernan­dopulle es­tab­lished along the same mod­el be­fore he foun­ded Iora sug­gests that it might. In 2009, pa­tients en­rolled in the At­lantic City chron­ic-care clin­ic ex­per­i­enced 48 per­cent few­er emer­gency room vis­its and 41 per­cent few­er hos­pit­al ad­mis­sions than a com­par­able pop­u­la­tion, ac­cord­ing to an eval­u­ation by Dr. Nit­eesh Choudhry, an as­so­ci­ate pro­fess­or at Har­vard Med­ic­al School. Health care costs for the At­lantic City group were 12.3 per­cent lower over­all than for the con­trol group.

And all At­lantic City pa­tients ex­per­i­enced re­duc­tions in blood pres­sure, cho­les­ter­ol, and blood sug­ar levels. Afric­an-Amer­ic­an and His­pan­ic pa­tients ten­ded to enter the prac­tice with high­er levels of all three than their white and Asi­an-Amer­ic­an coun­ter­parts. “Six months after be­ing in the prac­tice, those dis­par­it­ies pretty much van­ished. You couldn’t tell the dif­fer­ence,” Fernan­dopulle says. 

Iora Health is privately fun­ded by ven­ture cap­it­al funds and sev­er­al private in­vestors, in­clud­ing Tony Hsieh, CEO of the Las Ve­gas-based Zap­pos. The com­pany isn’t yet prof­it­able but it’s already suc­ceeded in prov­ing that a cul­ture shift in health care pro­vi­sion is pos­sible. “In health care, we’re here to do the right thing for people,” says head nurse Pavese. “If you start with that and stick to it, then good things hap­pen for them and every­one around them.” That ap­proach, she says, has re­newed her faith in her pro­fes­sion.

What We're Following See More »
John Warner to Endorse Clinton
3 hours ago

"Democratic presidential nominee Hillary Clinton will score another high-powered Republican endorsement on Wednesday, according to a campaign aide: retired senator John Warner of Virginia, a popular GOP maverick with renowned military credentials."

Appeals Court Hears Clean Power Plant Case
3 hours ago

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit on Tuesday "heard several hours of oral arguments" over the Environmental Protection Agency's Clean Power Plan rules. The 10-judge panel "focused much of their questioning on whether the EPA had overstepped its legal authority by seeking to broadly compel this shift away from coal, a move the EPA calls the Best System of Emission Reduction, or BSER. The states and companies suing the EPA argue the agency doesn’t have the authority to regulate anything outside of a power plant itself."

Here Come the Ad Buys
3 hours ago

"Spending by super PACs tied to Donald Trump friends such as Ben Carson and banker Andy Beal will help make this week the general election's most expensive yet. Republicans and Democrats will spend almost $28 million on radio and television this week, according to advertising records, as Trump substantially increases his advertising buy for the final stretch. He's spending $6.4 million in nine states, part of what aides have said will be a $100 million television campaign through Election Day."

Obama Nominates Ambassador to Cuba
8 hours ago
Reid Blocks Tech Bill Over “Broken Promise”
8 hours ago

Monday night's debate may have inspired some in Congress, as Senate Minority Leader has decided to take a stand of his own. Reid is declining to allow a vote on a "bipartisan bill that would bolster U.S. spectrum availability and the deployment of wireless broadband." Why? Because of a "broken promise" made a year ago by Republicans, who have refused to vote on confirmation for a Democratic commissioner on the Federal Communications Commission to a second term. Harry Reid then took it a step further, invoking another confirmation vote still outstanding, that of Supreme Court nominee Merrick Garland.