This Letter Reveals the Harrowing Details of Oklahoma’s Botched Execution

A minute-by-minute timeline of Clayton Lockett’s death reveals his lethal injection was administered via his groin.

A view of the death chamber from the witness room at the Southern Ohio Correctional Facility in Lucasville, Ohio. 
National Journal
Dustin Volz
See more stories about...
Dustin Volz
May 1, 2014, 12:45 p.m.

The Ok­lahoma De­part­ment of Cor­rec­tions is call­ing for an in­def­in­ite stay on ex­e­cu­tions in the wake of the state’s botched killing of in­mate Clayton Lock­ett earli­er this week, an in­cid­ent some have likened to tor­ture.

Robert Pat­ton, the de­part­ment dir­ect­or, sent a minute-by-minute ex­e­cu­tion timeline to Gov. Mary Fal­l­in on Thursday that in­cludes a re­quest for the state to halt all ex­e­cu­tions un­til it can re­view and re­vise its pro­to­cols for car­ry­ing out death sen­tences.

“It will take sev­er­al days or pos­sibly a few weeks to re­fine the new pro­to­cols,” said Pat­ton, who at­ten­ded Lock­ett’s ex­e­cu­tion. “Once writ­ten, staff will re­quire ex­tens­ive train­ing and un­der­stand­ing of new pro­to­cols be­fore an ex­e­cu­tion can be sched­uled.”

Pat­ton’s re­com­mend­a­tions in­clude more over­sight placed in the hands of “up­per man­age­ment and ul­ti­mately on the Dir­ect­or of Cor­rec­tions.” Less re­spons­ib­il­ity, he said, should fall to the warden.

The de­tailed timeline in­cluded in Pat­ton’s let­ter walks through the events lead­ing up to Lock­ett’s death, which oc­curred 43 minutes after the pris­on­er was ad­min­istered a new and un­tested leth­al in­jec­tion. Those three drugs were in­tra­ven­ously pushed in­to Lock­ett via his “groin area,” ac­cord­ing to the timeline, after a med­ic­al of­fi­cial could not loc­ate a “vi­able in­ser­tion point” on Lock­ett’s arms, legs or feet.

Once it was clear the ex­e­cu­tion was not go­ing as planned, about 19 minutes since it star­ted, of­fi­cials lowered the death cham­ber’s blinds. This is what happened next:

The doc­tor checked the IV and re­por­ted the blood vein had col­lapsed, and the drugs had either ab­sorbed in­to the tis­sue, leaked out or both. The warden im­me­di­ately con­tac­ted the dir­ect­or by phone and re­por­ted the in­form­a­tion to the dir­ect­or. The dir­ect­or asked the fol­low­ing ques­tion, “Have enough drugs been ad­min­istered to cause death?” The doc­tor re­spon­ded, “No.” The dir­ect­or asked, “Is an­oth­er vein avail­able, and if so, are there enough drugs re­main­ing?” The doc­tor re­spon­ded, “No” to both ques­tions. The dir­ect­or re­ques­ted cla­ri­fic­a­tion as to wheth­er enough drugs had been ad­min­istered to cause death. The doc­tor re­spon­ded, “No.” The dir­ect­or asked the con­di­tion of the of­fend­er, the warden re­spon­ded the doc­tor was check­ing the of­fend­er’s heart beat and found a faint heart­beat and the of­fend­er was un­con­scious.

Twelve minutes after be­ing con­tac­ted, Pat­ton called off the ex­e­cu­tion “un­der the au­thor­ity gran­ted by the gov­ernor.” Lock­ett was pro­nounced dead due to a heart at­tack 10 minutes later, ac­cord­ing to the timeline.

Madeline Co­hen, an at­tor­ney for death-row in­mate Charles Warner, who was ori­gin­ally sched­uled for ex­e­cu­tion just hours after Lock­ett, con­demned Ok­lahoma for “re­veal­ing in­form­a­tion about this ex­cru­ci­at­ingly in­hu­mane ex­e­cu­tion in a chaot­ic man­ner, with the threat of ex­e­cu­tion loom­ing.”

“As the Ok­lahoma De­part­ment of Cor­rec­tions dribbles out piece­meal in­form­a­tion about Clayton Lock­ett’s botched ex­e­cu­tion, they have re­vealed that Mr. Lock­ett was killed us­ing an in­vas­ive and pain­ful meth­od — an IV line in his groin,” Co­hen said in a state­ment. “The timeline “¦ strongly in­dic­ates that the femor­al IV was nev­er prop­erly in­ser­ted, and the drugs were in­jec­ted in­to Mr. Lock­ett’s flesh, rather than his veins.”

The timeline also says that Lock­ett was Tasered by guards in the early morn­ing hours be­fore his even­ing ex­e­cu­tion on Tues­day for fail­ing to com­ply with or­ders to un­der­go med­ic­al X-rays. Lock­ett also cut his right arm, a wound for which he was treated.

In ad­di­tion to a re­quest to in­def­in­itely stay ex­e­cu­tions, Pat­ton’s let­ter asks for an ex­tern­al in­vest­ig­a­tion in­to the cir­cum­stances of Lock­ett’s death.

“While I have com­plete con­fid­ence in the abil­it­ies of my in­spect­or gen­er­al and his staff, I be­lieve the re­port will be per­ceived as more cred­ible if con­duc­ted by an ex­tern­al en­tity,” he said.

On Wed­nes­day, Fal­l­in, a Re­pub­lic­an, said she would halt ex­e­cu­tions un­til the state’s pub­lic-safety com­mis­sion­er could con­duct an in­vest­ig­a­tion in­to Ok­lahoma’s ex­e­cu­tion pro­to­cols and Lock­ett’s death. Death-pen­alty op­pon­ents have at­tacked that de­cision as not truly in­de­pend­ent be­cause it will still come from Fal­l­in’s ad­min­is­tra­tion.

The White House said Wed­nes­day that Lock­ett’s death “fell short” of hu­mane stand­ards that should be ex­pec­ted in all ex­e­cu­tions.

What We're Following See More »
Sanders and Clinton Spar Over … President Obama
5 hours ago

President Obama became a surprise topic of contention toward the end of the Democratic debate, as Hillary Clinton reminded viewers that Sanders had challenged the progressive bona fides of President Obama in 2011 and suggested that someone might challenge him from the left. “The kind of criticism that we’ve heard from Senator Sanders about our president I expect from Republicans, I do not expect from someone running for the Democratic nomination to succeed President Obama,” she said. “Madame Secretary, that is a low blow,” replied Sanders, before getting in another dig during his closing statement: “One of us ran against Barack Obama. I was not that candidate.”

THE 1%
Sanders’s Appeals to Minorities Still Filtered Through Wall Street Talk
7 hours ago

It’s all about the 1% and Wall Street versus everyone else for Bernie Sanders—even when he’s talking about race relations. Like Hillary Clinton, he needs to appeal to African-American and Hispanic voters in coming states, but he insists on doing so through his lens of class warfare. When he got a question from the moderators about the plight of black America, he noted that during the great recession, African Americans “lost half their wealth,” and “instead of tax breaks for billionaires,” a Sanders presidency would deliver jobs for kids. On the very next question, he downplayed the role of race in inequality, saying, “It’s a racial issue, but it’s also a general economic issue.”

Clinton Already Pivoting Her Messaging
7 hours ago

It’s been said in just about every news story since New Hampshire: the primaries are headed to states where Hillary Clinton will do well among minority voters. Leaving nothing to chance, she underscored that point in her opening statement in the Milwaukee debate tonight, saying more needs to be done to help “African Americans who face discrimination in the job market” and immigrant families. She also made an explicit reference to “equal pay for women’s work.” Those boxes she’s checking are no coincidence: if she wins women, blacks and Hispanics, she wins the nomination.

How Many Jobs Would Be Lost Under Bernie Sanders’s Single-Payer System?
15 hours ago

More than 11 million, according to Manhattan Institute fellow Yevgeniy Feyman, writing in RealClearPolicy.

State to Release 550 More Clinton Emails on Saturday
15 hours ago

Under pressure from a judge, the State Department will release about 550 of Hillary Clinton’s emails—“roughly 14 percent of the 3,700 remaining Clinton emails—on Saturday, in the middle of the Presidents Day holiday weekend.” All of the emails were supposed to have been released last month. Related: State subpoenaed the Clinton Foundation last year, which brings the total number of current Clinton investigations to four, says the Daily Caller.