How Green Energy Won Out Over Fossil Fuels in a Red State

In Texas, wind power is set to come online faster than natural gas over the course of the next decade.

GERDSHAGEN, GERMANY - JUNE 22: Wind turbines producing electricity spin in a field on June 22, 2012 near Gerdshagen, Germany. Germany is investing heavily in renewable energy sources as part of a government initiative to wean the country off nuclear, and eventually coal-based, energy. 
National Journal
Clare Foran
Add to Briefcase
See more stories about...
Clare Foran
May 22, 2014, 3:59 p.m.

Wind is go­ing head to head with nat­ur­al gas at the heart of the frack­ing boom — and wind is win­ning.

Frack­ing — a drilling tech­nique that in­volves break­ing open shale rock form­a­tions to ex­tract oil and nat­ur­al gas — has taken Texas by storm. The Lone Star State is dot­ted with drill sites and leads the na­tion in nat­ur­al-gas pro­duc­tion. But wide open spaces and strong gusts make it an ideal place to turn tur­bines. And Texas also takes the top spot for states with the most wind power.

Green en­ergy has stead­ily gained trac­tion in the deep-red state. In 2003, wind made up less than 1 per­cent of the power sup­ply, ac­cord­ing to state grid op­er­at­or the Elec­tric Re­li­ab­il­ity Coun­cil of Texas. By 2013, that share had ris­en to roughly 10 per­cent.

Tex­an wind power is set to take off in a ma­jor way. From 2013 to 2014, ER­COT es­tim­ates that wind ca­pa­city will in­crease by 33 per­cent. Wind-power po­ten­tial is pro­jec­ted to jump an­oth­er 25 per­cent from 2014 to 2015 — a sharp up­tick in in­stall­a­tion that comes on the heels of a half dec­ade of re­l­at­ively slow growth. (From 2008 to 2013, in­stall­a­tions av­er­aged a 7 per­cent in­crease each year).

It’s also on track to com­mand an out­sized share of newly min­ted power po­ten­tial in the Lone Star State. And wind is troun­cing nat­ur­al gas in early es­tim­ates of ca­pa­city set to come on­line over the course of the next dec­ade.

Wind-power pro­jects are poised to make up nearly 70 per­cent of new power ca­pa­city in the de­reg­u­lated mar­ket, ac­cord­ing to ER­COT. The grid op­er­at­or pro­jects that more than 8,600 mega­watts of wind power — enough en­ergy to keep the lights on for hun­dreds of house­holds across Texas — will be up and run­ning by 2024.

Nat­ur­al gas won’t fare nearly as well. About 3,580 mega­watts of gas-fired power po­ten­tial are slated to come on­line in the same in­ter­val. If that fore­cast holds true, gas would make up only 28 per­cent of fresh power po­ten­tial in the state.

What’s caus­ing wind pro­duc­tion to soar?

In a word: in­fra­struc­ture. Tex­an wind had been plagued by a ma­jor prob­lem in the past. The win­di­est parts of the sprawl­ing state are hun­dreds of miles away from its largest pop­u­la­tion cen­ters. And the op­tions for send­ing elec­tri­city from areas with the best wind po­ten­tial like West Texas and the north­ern­most part of the state — known as the Pan­handle — to cit­ies like Hou­s­ton, Dal­las, and San Ant­o­nio have his­tor­ic­ally been lim­ited.

In 2005, the Texas le­gis­lature ap­proved a sprawl­ing net­work of trans­mis­sion lines de­signed to solve ex­actly this prob­lem. After years of con­struc­tion, the power lines — known as Com­pet­it­ive Re­new­able En­ergy Zones — star­ted ship­ping elec­trons across the state in Decem­ber.

De­velopers say the power lines are key to un­lock­ing the state’s wind-power po­ten­tial. “For the longest time there was noth­ing there,” said Jim Swaf­ford, the CEO of Scan­dia Wind South­w­est. Scan­dia is one of sev­er­al com­pan­ies back­ing a large-scale wind-power pro­ject in the Texas Pan­handle. Swaf­ford says the power lines made it all pos­sible. “I had people com­ing from all over the coun­try who wanted to build. But they’d walk away every time, be­cause be­fore there was no way to get the wind from point A to point B,” he said.

Stat­ist­ics tell the same story. Eighty per­cent of the total wind ca­pa­city es­tim­ated to come on­line by the end of 2024 will ori­gin­ate from the spin­ning blades of wind tur­bines set to spring up in West Texas and the Pan­handle.

The boost that the power lines are giv­ing to wind power il­lus­trates in­fra­struc­ture’s abil­ity to slow or speed an en­ergy boom. But trans­mis­sion isn’t the only reas­on wind power is tak­ing off in Texas.

Policy has also played a role. The ex­pir­a­tion of the re­new­able pro­duc­tion tax cred­it — an in­cent­ive that pays out 2.3 cents per kilo­watt hour of wind pro­duced — promp­ted a rush to break ground on new wind pro­jects be­fore the cred­it lapsed at the end of last year.

If the cred­it is not ex­ten­ded, the wind in­dustry’s growth in Texas could lag. And ana­lysts warn that even with the new trans­mis­sion lines, green en­ergy could hit a bot­tle­neck in the Pan­handle as de­velopers race to churn out more wind.

For now, however, the avail­ab­il­ity of the tax cred­it along­side the po­ten­tial for tur­bines to link up with power lines means that the fu­ture of wind power in the Lone Star State is bright.

Nat­ur­al gas, mean­while, faces hurdles of its own. Gas re­mains the dom­in­ant Tex­an fuel. But power ginned up by gas plants dropped from 46 per­cent of total elec­tri­city gen­er­a­tion in 2003 to 40 per­cent in 2013. And gas plants slated to come on­line in the next dec­ade only prom­ise to provide a frac­tion of the power po­ten­tial of wind pro­jects in the queue.

This is partly be­cause gas has fallen vic­tim to its own suc­cess. The flood of nat­ur­al gas that has res­ul­ted from frack­ing has sent elec­tri­city prices in­to a down­ward spir­al in Texas. Monthly elec­tri­city bills have de­creased dra­mat­ic­ally. But that also means that gas plants are mak­ing less money — a trend that has slowed in­vest­ment in nat­ur­al-gas gen­er­a­tion.

“Texas is in a pickle right now,” said Alan Lam­mey, a seni­or en­ergy ana­lyst with LCI En­ergy In­sight and the Oil Price In­form­a­tion Ser­vice. “Low elec­tri­city prices have hurt power pro­duc­tion across the board, but wind has be­nefited from in­vest­ment in tech­no­logy and in­fra­struc­ture — and that’s help­ing it pull ahead.”

What We're Following See More »
TERROR HITS THE UK AGAIN
19 Dead, 50 Wounded in Bomb Blast in Manchester
1 hours ago
THE DETAILS

"At least 19 people have been killed after a suspected terrorist attack at the Manchester Arena. Thousands of gig-goers were packed into the venue to see American singer Ariana Grande when two explosions were reported." The incident is being treated by authorities as a terror attack.

Source:
CITES SCHEDULING CONFLICT
Sessions Cancels Testimony on Justice Approps
1 hours ago
THE LATEST

"Attorney General Jeff Sessions will no longer testify before Congress this week on funding for the Justice Department, aides said Monday—hearings that would likely have been overtaken by questions about the federal probe into potential collusion between Russian officials and the Trump campaign. DOJ spokeswoman Sarah Isgur Flores said the canceled testimonies, which had been planned for Wednesday in the House and Thursday in the Senate, was due to a scheduling conflict." He will instead appear on June 13.

Source:
OUTLAYS TO DECREASE 2% PER YEAR
Trump Budget Would Cut $1.4 Trillion from Non-Defense Spending
11 hours ago
THE LATEST
Source:
MORE PROBLEMS FOR WHITE HOUSE
Flynn Lied To Investigators About Foreign Payments
11 hours ago
BREAKING
COMEY WANTS TO TALK TO MUELLER FIRST
Chaffetz Postpones Comey’s Testimony
13 hours ago
THE LATEST

Former FBI Director Jim Comey won't be testifying before Jason Chaffetz's House Oversight and Government Reform Committee on Wednesday as originally planned. Chaffetz, the committee chairman, "announced Monday that Comey wants to speak with Robert Mueller, the former FBI director now serving as a special counsel overseeing the agency's investigation into the Trump campaign's ties to Russia during the 2016 campaign, before testifying publicly."

Source:
×
×

Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.

Login