African-Americans With College Degrees Are Twice As Likely to Be Unemployed as Other Graduates

A new study finds that 12.4 percent of black college graduates were unemployed. For all college graduates, the unemployment rate stood at just 5.6 percent.

National Journal
Add to Briefcase
Janell Ross
May 27, 2014, 1 a.m.

The Ivy-League-edu­cated barista who can’t find a job that pays enough to live any­where be­sides her child­hood bed­room. The freshly min­ted MBA and law school gradu­ates strapped with debt and frus­trated about the six-fig­ure jobs and mas­ter-of-the-uni­verse titles that haven’t ma­ter­i­al­ized. 

Nearly five years after the Great Re­ces­sion of­fi­cially ended, the struggles and dampened ex­pect­a­tions of young col­lege gradu­ates have be­come a fix­ture of Amer­ic­an polit­ics and even pop­u­lar cul­ture. But amid all the fo­cus on the dif­fi­culties of col­lege-edu­cated mil­len­ni­als, one fa­cet of this up­heav­al has re­mained largely un­ex­plored: the con­tin­ued sig­ni­fic­ance of race.

As a new crop of col­lege gradu­ates joins the Amer­ic­an work­force, un­em­ploy­ment rates among minor­it­ies with de­grees re­main dis­tinctly el­ev­ated and their eco­nom­ic pro­spects dis­pro­por­tion­ately dimmed, a new re­port re­leased by the Cen­ter for Eco­nom­ic and Policy Re­search has found. 

In 2013, the most re­cent peri­od for which un­em­ploy­ment data are avail­able by both race and edu­ca­tion­al at­tain­ment, 12.4 per­cent of black col­lege gradu­ates between the ages of 22 and 27 were un­em­ployed. For all col­lege gradu­ates in the same age range, the un­em­ploy­ment rate stood at just 5.6 per­cent. The fig­ures point to an ugly truth: Black col­lege gradu­ates are more than twice as likely to be un­em­ployed.

White men with re­cent crim­in­al his­tor­ies are far more likely to re­ceive calls back than black men with no crim­in­al re­cord at all.

“We ab­so­lutely aren’t try­ing to dis­cour­age people from go­ing to col­lege,” said John Schmitt, a seni­or eco­nom­ist at the Wash­ing­ton-based Cen­ter for Eco­nom­ic and Policy Re­search who coau­thored the study. “Col­lege de­grees do have value. But what we are try­ing to show here is that this is not about in­di­vidu­als, or in­di­vidu­al ef­fort. There is simply over­whelm­ing evid­ence that dis­crim­in­a­tion re­mains a ma­jor fea­ture of the labor mar­ket.”

Schmitt poin­ted to a series of stud­ies that have in re­cent years found that when trained sets of black and white test­ers with identic­al re­sumes are sent on in­ter­views, white men with re­cent crim­in­al his­tor­ies are far more likely to re­ceive calls back than black men with no crim­in­al re­cord at all.

In fact, the cen­ter’s study found that even black stu­dents who ma­jored in high-de­mand fields such as en­gin­eer­ing fare only slightly bet­ter than those who spent their col­lege years earn­ing lib­er­al arts de­grees. Between 2010 and 2012, 10 per­cent of black col­lege gradu­ates with en­gin­eer­ing de­grees and 11 per­cent of those with math and com­puter-re­lated de­grees were un­em­ployed, com­pared with 6 per­cent of all en­gin­eer­ing gradu­ates and 7 per­cent of all those who fo­cused their stud­ies on math and com­puters.

Col­lege-edu­cated blacks are also more likely than all oth­ers with de­grees to con­front un­der­em­ploy­ment, which the study defined as work­ing in jobs that don’t re­quire a four-year de­gree. The pro­por­tion of young Afric­an-Amer­ic­an col­lege gradu­ates who are un­der­em­ployed has spiked since 2007 by fully 10 per­cent­age points to a strik­ing 56 per­cent. Dur­ing that same peri­od, un­der­em­ploy­ment among all re­cent col­lege gradu­ates has edged up only slightly to around 45 per­cent.

The study also found that among older col­lege gradu­ates, the gap in the un­em­ploy­ment rate nar­rows but doesn’t dis­ap­pear. Bur­eau of Labor Stat­ist­ics data in­dic­ates that in 2013, 3.5 per­cent of all white col­lege gradu­ates were un­em­ployed while nearly 6 per­cent of all black col­lege gradu­ates sought work but could not find it.

Many stud­ies have found that work­ers un­able to find steady em­ploy­ment dur­ing their first years in the labor mar­ket of­ten pay long-term costs. Dur­ing the first five years after school, people try on, dis­card and pick up bet­ter-fit­ting ca­reers, de­vel­op key skills, typ­ic­ally make ma­jor in­come gains, and be­gin to plug in­to the pro­fes­sion­al net­works that provide train­ing, con­tacts, and new job op­por­tun­it­ies in the fu­ture. When un­em­ploy­ment dis­rupts that pro­cess it can per­man­ently al­ter the tra­ject­ory of a work­er’s life­time earn­ings, eco­nom­ists have con­cluded.

When un­em­ploy­ment dis­rupts that pro­cess it can per­man­ently al­ter the tra­ject­ory of a work­er’s life­time earn­ings, eco­nom­ists have con­cluded.

The situ­ation for oth­er minor­it­ies falls some­where in between that of blacks and whites, ac­cord­ing to fed­er­al data. In 2013, the share of all col­lege-edu­cated Asi­an-Amer­ic­ans who were un­em­ployed roughly equaled the pro­por­tion of whites: 3.6 per­cent. All His­pan­ic col­lege gradu­ates faced a 5 per­cent un­em­ploy­ment rate, more than whites but less than Afric­an-Amer­ic­ans.

For most of the past 50 years, the over­all black un­em­ploy­ment rate has re­mained twice as high as the white un­em­ploy­ment rate. That gap has con­sist­ently grown lar­ger dur­ing times of eco­nom­ic dis­tress. In­deed, the cen­ter study found that the gap between the un­em­ploy­ment rate for young Afric­an-Amer­ic­an col­lege gradu­ates and all oth­er gradu­ates has soared from 3.7 per­cent­age points in 2007 to 6.8 points today.

“This study — its find­ings, as ter­rible as they are — hon­estly should not come as a shock to any­one who is will­ing to face the truth about em­ploy­ment and un­em­ploy­ment in the United States,” said Nancy DiTo­maso, a pro­fess­or at Rut­gers Uni­versity who stud­ies in­equal­ity and or­gan­iz­a­tion­al di­versity.

DiTo­maso says the study, like oth­er re­search, chal­lenges the as­sump­tion that op­por­tun­ity is avail­able to all Amer­ic­ans who equip them­selves with the right skills. Private-sec­tor labor data re­por­ted to the fed­er­al gov­ern­ment shows little change in the share of man­age­ment and ex­ec­ut­ive-level jobs held by ra­cial and eth­nic minor­it­ies since the 1980s, she said. In fact, in in­dus­tries that of­fer work­ers the best wages, the share of white men in these jobs has ac­tu­ally grown.

The cen­ter’s study noted that half of the na­tion’s man­age­ment, pro­fes­sion­al, and re­lated oc­cu­pa­tions — those the study de­scribed as fields where many col­lege gradu­ates ul­ti­mately work — em­ploy a dis­pro­por­tion­ately small share of black male work­ers. 

In her 2013 book, The Amer­ic­an Non-Di­lemma: Ra­cial In­equal­ity Without Ra­cism, DiTo­maso con­cluded that ra­cial in­equal­ity isn’t rooted solely in ra­cist ideas or con­scious ef­forts to ex­clude some groups from dis­tinct op­por­tun­it­ies. In­stead, she ar­gued that in­form­al net­works al­low whites, who still hold most of the de­cision-mak­ing po­s­i­tions in the private eco­nomy, to hoard and dis­trib­ute ad­vant­age among their fam­ily and friends, who tend to be mostly white.

While re­search­ing her book, DiTomaco con­duc­ted 246 in­ter­views with work­ing-class and middle-class white in­di­vidu­als over a dec­ade in Ten­ness­ee, Ohio, and New Jer­sey. DiTo­maso gathered de­tailed job his­tor­ies and in­form­a­tion about the way her study par­ti­cipants ob­tained jobs over the course of their ca­reers. The whites among those DiTo­maso in­ter­viewed found 70 per­cent of the jobs they held over their life­times through in­side in­form­a­tion shared by a fam­ily mem­ber, friend, or neigh­bor, a dir­ect in­ter­ven­tion (someone walk­ing a re­sume in­to a hir­ing man­ager’s of­fice or a dir­ect re­quest that a fam­ily mem­ber or friend get an open job) or oth­er means not open to the gen­er­al pub­lic. 

“I think it’s high time,” DiTo­maso said, “that we really star­ted to look closely not just at the ways that the labor mar­ket is biased against blacks but the ways in which it is biased in fa­vor of whites.”

The re­search­ers be­hind the cen­ter’s study of black col­lege gradu­ate em­ploy­ment pat­terns em­phas­ized the role that the re­ces­sion has played in dampen­ing every work­er’s em­ploy­ment pro­spects. But they con­cluded that the long-term un­em­ploy­ment crisis among black col­lege gradu­ates ul­ti­mately could not be ex­plained without ac­count­ing for con­tinu­ing dis­crim­in­a­tion against black ap­plic­ants.

One of their fi­nal pieces of evid­ence: a study pushed in­to the na­tion­al spot­light last month in which part­ners at a num­ber of law firms scored the same memo far dif­fer­ently when told that the au­thor was white or black. “Those are the in­sti­tu­tion­al factors that have a long-term ef­fect on people’s eco­nom­ic lives,” Schmitt said.


Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.