For Democrats, the Race That Got Away

Thanks to Tom Daschle and a vocal liberal base, Democrats weren’t able to put red state South Dakota’s Senate seat in play.

National Journal
Josh Kraushaar
June 2, 2014, 4:01 p.m.

If Demo­crats fall a seat short of hold­ing the Sen­ate, there will be a lot of second-guess­ing on the one race that nev­er ma­ter­i­al­ized but should have held a lot more prom­ise: South Dakota.

The state is hold­ing its primar­ies Tues­day, and they’re an af­ter­thought. Former Gov. Mike Rounds is the Re­pub­lic­an now on a glide path to the Sen­ate, fa­cing weak op­pos­i­tion in the GOP primary. In the gen­er­al elec­tion, he’ll face Rick Wei­l­and, a former state dir­ect­or for Tom Daschle who (even the most op­tim­ist­ic Demo­crats will ac­know­ledge) faces near-im­possible odds in the solidly red state.

But it didn’t have to be that way. The Sen­ate race to suc­ceed re­tir­ing Demo­crat­ic Sen. Tim John­son could have been one of the most con­sequen­tial con­tests in the coun­try, if Demo­crats had a little more luck. Just over a year ago, the polit­ic­al talk in South Dakota centered on which of their up-and-com­ing pro­spects would run — former Rep. Stephanie Her­seth Sand­lin, one of the most pop­u­lar fig­ures in the state after rep­res­ent­ing it for three full terms in the House, or Tim John­son’s son Brendan John­son, who’s serving as a U.S. at­tor­ney. Des­pite the state’s Re­pub­lic­an moor­ings, now-Sen. Heidi Heitkamp’s sur­pris­ing 2012 vic­tory in neigh­bor­ing North Dakota served as a fresh re­mind­er that strong can­did­ates run­ning in con­ser­vat­ive-minded states can over­come dis­ad­vant­ages.

As Sen­ate Ma­jor­ity Lead­er Harry Re­id and the Demo­crat­ic Sen­at­ori­al Cam­paign Com­mit­tee tried to en­gin­eer the situ­ation to their ad­vant­age — they pre­ferred Her­seth Sand­lin to the more-lib­er­al John­son, and wanted to avoid a con­ten­tious primary — the party’s worst-case scen­ario ma­ter­i­al­ized. John­son first ex­pressed his dis­in­terest in May 2013, leav­ing the door wide open for the former con­gress­wo­man to run. At the same time John­son made his de­cision, Wei­l­and an­nounced his can­did­acy with sup­port from some John­son al­lies. Less than a week later, Her­seth Sand­lin sur­prised sup­port­ers by passing on a bid, even without John­son in the race. She an­nounced the de­sire to spend more time with her fam­ily as the reas­on for step­ping aside, but sev­er­al Demo­crat­ic op­er­at­ives fa­mil­i­ar with her de­cision said she didn’t want to face any primary op­pos­i­tion, even against a longer-shot can­did­ate like Wei­l­and.

“I had sev­er­al con­ver­sa­tions with her, she soun­ded like a can­did­ate. She was on the cusp of run­ning,” said former South Dakota state party Chair­man Ben Nes­sel­huf, who de­camped the state after the dus­tup to man­age an Iowa con­gres­sion­al cam­paign.

Against Wei­l­and, Her­seth Sand­lin would have been a clear fa­vor­ite to win the nom­in­a­tion. But against the more-lib­er­al chal­lenger, she would have been forced to de­fend her vote against the pres­id­ent’s health care law, an is­sue she trum­peted in her un­suc­cess­ful 2010 reelec­tion. In a state where Demo­crats have little mar­gin for er­ror, be­ing pushed to the left in a primary would have been costly in a gen­er­al elec­tion.

In­deed, for all the at­ten­tion the GOP’s es­tab­lish­ment-tea party di­vide re­ceives, this is a race where Demo­crat­ic di­vi­sions between the party’s pro­gress­ive and cent­rist wings cost them an op­por­tun­ity to com­pete. To the ir­rit­a­tion of Re­id and oth­er cam­paign of­fi­cials in Wash­ing­ton, Daschle en­cour­aged Wei­l­and to run, even though his former staffer’s un­abashedly lib­er­al views make it dif­fi­cult to win in con­ser­vat­ive South Dakota. Re­id even went so far as to pro­claim Wei­l­and wasn’t “his choice” in the race, dis­miss­ing his can­did­acy. But in echoes of the tea party-es­tab­lish­ment battles roil­ing the Re­pub­lic­an Party, to the small uni­verse of Demo­crat­ic act­iv­ists with­in the state, Wei­l­and’s pro­gress­ive prin­ciples trumped Her­seth Sand­lin’s more-elect­able pro­file.

“Stephanie’s still try­ing to lick some wounds with the party faith­ful that were dis­ap­poin­ted in her health care vote, and can’t get over that. There was a motive there to shut her out, from even en­ter­tain­ing the op­tion from run­ning,” said state Sen­ate Minor­ity Lead­er Jason Frerichs, an ally of Her­seth Sand­lin. “Her de­cision not to run sur­prised so many of us, we’re kick­ing ourselves for not push­ing harder on her to run.”

For a time last year, the pro­spect of a messy primary fight on the Re­pub­lic­an side seemed more likely. Rounds entered the race in early 2013 to much fan­fare, but struggled to raise money and faced grumbling from out­side con­ser­vat­ive groups over his spend­ing re­cord and in­clin­a­tion to­ward deal-mak­ing as gov­ernor. One of the GOP’s rising stars, Rep. Kristi Noem, who un­seated Her­seth Sand­lin in 2010, was ser­i­ously con­sid­er­ing en­ter­ing the race, hop­ing to cap­it­al­ize on the con­ser­vat­ive dis­con­tent. But to out­side con­ser­vat­ive groups, her re­cord was as un­ten­able as Rounds’s, with her sup­port of the farm bill and near-the-bot­tom vote rat­ings among House Re­pub­lic­ans from the an­ti­tax Club for Growth. After meet­ing with GOP lead­ers, in­clud­ing Sen. John Thune, she passed on a bid last June. “She real­ized that she could jeop­ard­ize what would be a slam-dunk Re­pub­lic­an op­por­tun­ity,” said one Re­pub­lic­an of­fi­cial with ties to South Dakota.

In­stead, the primary op­pos­i­tion to Rounds back home has been splintered among four Re­pub­lic­an can­did­ates, none of whom have the re­sources to mount a cred­ible cam­paign. (State Rep. Stace Nel­son is ex­pec­ted to be his closest com­pet­it­or.) One of his chal­lengers, phys­i­cian An­nette Bos­worth, drew ri­dicule for hold­ing a press con­fer­ence to de­cry hate­ful rhet­or­ic dir­ec­ted at her cam­paign, where she stood in front of a graf­fiti-scrawled back­drop of epi­thets. Rounds may struggle to re­ceive 55 per­cent of the GOP vote — a mid­dling total for a well-known former gov­ernor, but enough to coast to vic­tory.

An­oth­er reas­on Demo­crats may re­gret not field­ing a stronger can­did­ate: the pres­ence of former Re­pub­lic­an Sen. Larry Pressler on the Novem­ber bal­lot as an in­de­pend­ent. If Her­seth Sand­lin ran, Pressler could have played a sig­ni­fic­ant role in a com­pet­it­ive race, but he’s now a quirky af­ter­thought. Out of polit­ics for over a dec­ade, Pressler was nev­er a threat to win, but he could have peeled away enough Re­pub­lic­an votes from Rounds to make the gen­er­al elec­tion highly com­pet­it­ive.

For her part, Her­seth Sand­lin may have missed her best op­por­tun­ity to com­pete for a polit­ic­al comeback in South Dakota. Un­like oth­er los­ing mem­bers of Con­gress who re­gister as lob­by­ists, Her­seth Sand­lin only spent one year work­ing in Wash­ing­ton (as part­ner at the law firm OFW) be­fore mov­ing back to South Dakota to serve as gen­er­al coun­sel for Raven In­dus­tries. It was a clear sign she wanted to run for of­fice again in her home state. But after passing on the Sen­ate race, it’s hard to find many fu­ture op­por­tun­it­ies.

Thune is a near lock for reelec­tion in 2016, Rounds will have one term of ser­vice un­der his belt, and the gov­ernor’s race won’t be on the bal­lot again un­til 2018. Frerichs said she re­ceived a stand­ing ova­tion at the state party’s April McGov­ern Day fun­drais­ing din­ner — an ac­know­ledg­ment that the state’s pro­gress­ive base is over its an­ti­pathy to­ward her can­did­acy, even though it’s far too late to change the tra­ject­ory of the Sen­ate race.

“Des­pite be­ing a Demo­crat, she’s well-liked in the state. She’s still got really strong num­bers. That would have been a le­git­im­ate battle with Rounds,” said the Re­pub­lic­an strategist with ties to South Dakota. “She still would still have the same up­hill sled­ding in a tough en­vir­on­ment, but she would have made Rounds really work for the seat.”

What We're Following See More »
EpiPen Prices Draw Scrutiny from Congress
55 minutes ago

The cost of EpiPens have risen 400% since 2007, and members of Congress increasingly want to know why. Judiciary Chairman Charles Grassley (R-IA) sent a letter to Mylan, which makes the allergy injection devices, on Monday. “Many of the children who are prescribed EpiPens are covered by Medicaid, and therefore, the taxpayers are picking up the tab for this medication," he wrote. Sen. Amy Klobuchar (D-MN) "called earlier for a Judiciary Committee inquiry into the pricing and an investigation by the Federal Trade Commission."

U.S. May Aid Turkey in Fight Against ISIS
55 minutes ago

"The U.S. is considering providing military support for hundreds of Turkish-backed rebels massing at the border with Syria for a major offensive meant to sever Islamic State’s supply routes there, officials from both countries said." As Turkey looks to reestablish its military's credibility after the recent coup attempt there, the U.S. is considering providing intelligence and air support.

Trump Enriching His Businesses with Donor Money
15 hours ago

Donald Trump "nearly quintupled the monthly rent his presidential campaign pays for its headquarters at Trump Tower to $169,758 in July, when he was raising funds from donors, compared with March, when he was self-funding his campaign." A campaign spokesman "said the increased office space was needed to accommodate an anticipated increase in employees," but the campaign's paid staff has actually dipped by about 25 since March. The campaign has also paid his golf courses and restaurants about $260,000 since mid-May.

Trump Cancels Rallies
23 hours ago

Donald Trump probably isn't taking seriously John Oliver's suggestion that he quit the race. But he has canceled or rescheduled rallies amid questions over his stance on immigration. Trump rescheduled a speech on the topic that he was set to give later this week. Plus, he's also nixed planned rallies in Oregon and Las Vegas this month.

Sean Hannity Is Also Advising Trump
1 days ago

Donald Trump's Fox News brain trust keeps growing. After it was revealed that former Fox chief Roger Ailes is informally advising Trump on debate preparation, host Sean Hannity admitted over the weekend that he's also advising Trump on "strategy and messaging." He told the New York Times: “I’m not hiding the fact that I want Donald Trump to be the next president of the United States. I never claimed to be a journalist.”