Need to Know: House


The 2010 House freshmen now control virtually the entire GOP agenda, and they appear utterly unconcerned about 2012.

Congressman Tom Perriello, D-Va., right, speaks as State Sen. Robert Hurt, R-Chatum, listens during a debate sponsored by the Lynchburg Chamber of Commerce at Randolph college  in Lynchburg, Va., Wednesday, Oct. 27, 2010. (AP Photo/Steve Helber)
National Journal
Add to Briefcase
Terence Samuel
March 17, 2011, 10:46 a.m.

The last elec­tion, rather than the next, is the force driv­ing Re­pub­lic­an na­tion­al polit­ics. Car­ried by its mo­mentum, the party in Con­gress and state le­gis­latures is fo­cused en­tirely on spend­ing cuts. Most of the ac­tion so far is in Wash­ing­ton, where the huge House fresh­man class has the wider GOP in its thrall.

The chal­lenges that this dy­nam­ic will pose star­ted to be­come clear this week. So many House Re­pub­lic­ans de­fec­ted on a vote to ex­tend spend­ing au­thor­ity for three more weeks that Demo­crats had to help pass it. Fifty-four Re­pub­lic­ans, al­most 40 per­cent of them fresh­men, snubbed the party lead­er­ship and joined a ma­jor­ity of Demo­crats in vot­ing against the con­tinu­ing res­ol­u­tion. The Demo­crats voted no be­cause they found the pro­posed new cuts of $6 bil­lion too severe. Re­pub­lic­ans, on the oth­er hand, voted no be­cause they thought the hits were too mild or be­cause they ob­jec­ted to the drip-by-drip ap­proach, or both.

Speak­er John Boehner found him­self in the wobbly po­s­i­tion of hav­ing to rely on Demo­crat­ic yeas to pass a bill to avoid a gov­ern­ment shut­down. He is left with an ugly choice: Com­prom­ise with Demo­crats or ca­pit­u­late to his own caucus. The weak­ness of Boehner’s po­s­i­tion be­comes clear­er when you ex­am­ine the pat­tern of de­fec­tions in Tues­day’s vote. The GOP dis­sent­ers, for the most part, were not can­did­ates in mar­gin­al dis­tricts, wor­ried about their chances in 2012. It is more the op­pos­ite. Forty-six of them rep­res­ent dis­tricts that John Mc­Cain won in 2008, and 29 of them are from dis­tricts that he won by at least 55 per­cent.

They are not run­ning scared but stand­ing firm, and no one can say dif­fer­ent: no George Bush call­ing for com­pas­sion­ate con­ser­vat­ism; no Bob Dole or oth­er or­tho­dox fisc­al con­ser­vat­ive soft-ped­al­ing tax cuts. Boehner’s prob­lem is not the pull of the middle but the en­er­gized and un­op­posed forces on the right.

Tues­day’s vote ac­tu­ally un­der­stated his quandary. There are more de­fec­tions where those came from. As em­bar­rass­ing as the no votes were, many of those who voted for the CR pledged that it was the last time. Of the GOP’s yes votes, 133 rep­res­ent dis­tricts that Mc­Cain won; 41 of them are fresh­men. If they choose to defy the party next time, Boehner can do little about it.

So, ex­pect a more con­front­a­tion­al tone from the Re­pub­lic­an side. From the Demo­crat­ic side, ex­pect the same. When the House passed a fund­ing res­ol­u­tion on March 1 to keep the gov­ern­ment op­er­at­ing for two weeks, 104 Demo­crats voted for it and 85 against. This week, for the three-week ex­ten­sion, those num­bers were re­versed: 85 yeas and 104 nays. Among Demo­crats, the switch­ers were also mem­bers with safe seats. Of the 19 new no votes, 17 were cast by mem­bers in dis­tricts where Barack Obama won with at least 55 per­cent of the vote.

The bases are as­sert­ing them­selves. “Let’s re­mem­ber that on Novem­ber 2, the people of Vir­gin­ia’s 5th Dis­trict and the people across this coun­try sent a mes­sage to Wash­ing­ton,” Rep. Robert Hurt, a fresh­man from cent­ral Vir­gin­ia, de­clared on the House floor. “The mes­sage was ur­gent, it was clear, and it was loud. The mes­sage sent was that now is the time to stop the gov­ern­ment spend­ing, stop the gov­ern­ment bor­row­ing, and stop the raid on our chil­dren’s fu­ture.”

There you have it: the en­tire Re­pub­lic­an agenda, boiled down to its es­sence. The no-com­prom­ise ap­proach is com­ing from Hurt and oth­er new mem­bers whose single-minded­ness is likely to be prob­lem­at­ic for a party look­ing to craft a mes­sage of broad­er ap­peal go­ing in­to the 2012 pres­id­en­tial cycle. Already, polling sug­gests that voters would like a more meas­ured ap­proach than that es­poused by some in the fresh­man class.

A mod­er­at­ing in­flu­ence in this struggle might even­tu­ally come from the pres­id­en­tial field, but the field has yet to take shape — and for the most part re­mains si­lent. Four years ago, Hil­lary Rod­ham Clin­ton, John Ed­wards, and Obama were already en­gaged in elab­or­ate pos­tur­ing, all try­ing to fin­esse their po­s­i­tions on the war in Ir­aq. And, in­stantly, some of the Hill’s most lib­er­al Demo­crats were ex­press­ing dis­ap­point­ment that their can­did­ates had gone soft on the war. “We’ve got a fake de­bate go­ing on in­side the Demo­crat­ic Party right now on the war,” Rep. Den­nis Ku­cinich of Ohio com­plained. “People are say­ing they are for peace, and they are vot­ing to keep the war go­ing.”

No such mod­er­at­ing pres­sure is yet forth­com­ing in the GOP. The mutiny on gov­ern­ment fund­ing this week went way bey­ond the fresh­man class, but — no ques­tion — the 87 new House Re­pub­lic­ans have re­defined what it means to be a con­tem­por­ary GOP con­ser­vat­ive. House Ma­jor­ity Whip Kev­in Mc­Carthy says that the fresh­man class is the key to the party’s suc­cess and that its mem­bers are uni­fied and com­mit­ted to the budget-cut­ting mis­sion. “Some people will lose [elec­tion] over some of what we do,” Mc­Carthy ad­mit­ted, pla­cidly.

It will be in­ter­est­ing to see how far up the na­tion­al tick­et they ex­pect this noble sac­ri­fice to reach.

Contributions by Scott Bland

Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.