Need to Know: National Security

Missed Direction

Washington is obsessed with U.S. progress in southern Afghanistan. But the real fight is in the east.

US soldiers from 1st Platoon Alpha Company 3-187 3BCT 101 Airborne walk during a patrol in Yosef Khel district of Paktika province on April 3, 2010. The United States has rejected President Hamid Karzai's anti-foreigner outburst as "troubling" and "preposterous," prompting a hurried effort by the Afghan leader to make amends. AFP Photo/Massoud HOSSAINI (Photo credit should read MASSOUD HOSSAINI/AFP/Getty Images)
National Journal
Add to Briefcase
Yochi J. Dreazen
June 23, 2011, 1:14 p.m.

ED­IT­OR’S NOTE: A U.S. heli­copter was shot down in east­ern Afgh­anistan, ac­cord­ing to news re­ports. East­ern Afgh­anistan is an area long troubled and only re­cently get­ting the full at­ten­tion of the U.S. mil­it­ary strategy. The fol­low­ing ap­peared in the June 25, 2011, edi­tion of Na­tion­al Journ­al.

When Pres­id­ent Obama an­nounced the Afgh­anistan draw­down on June 22, he poin­ted to pro­gress in the coun­try’s south, a re­gion long con­trolled by the Taliban and its al­lies. The White House says that Amer­ic­ans have driv­en the Taliban out of its former strong­holds in Hel­mand and Kanda­har provinces, re­vers­ing its bat­tle­field mo­mentum and killing many Taliban fight­ers and lead­ers. Top U.S. mil­it­ary com­mand­ers ar­gue that re­cent gains there show that the broad­er war strategy is bear­ing fruit.

But the real story is not in the south; it’s in the east. Seni­or of­ficers in­creas­ingly be­lieve that the con­flict will be de­cided in the val­leys and moun­tain ranges of east­ern Afgh­anistan, a vi­ol­ent re­gion that abuts some of Pakistan’s most un­ruly provinces. The Taliban and its al­lies — es­pe­cially the Pakistan-based Haqqani net­work — are wa­ging a cam­paign of road­side bomb­ings, ar­til­lery at­tacks, and am­bushes there; the Amer­ic­an death toll has ris­en sharply. Al-Qaida and the Haqqani net­work have been un­will­ing to ne­go­ti­ate with the Amer­ic­an or Afghan gov­ern­ments, lead­ing top U.S. com­mand­ers to con­clude that the war can’t be won without de­feat­ing the armed group. “The east is the place that needs to be the next fo­cus of the war, and maybe the last fo­cus of the war,” said Jef­frey Dressler, an ex­pert on the re­gion at the In­sti­tute for the Study of War. “It hasn’t got­ten re­motely enough at­ten­tion in the past.” While Wash­ing­ton ob­sesses over south­ern Afgh­anistan, it is miss­ing the point.

That may soon change. The mil­it­ary has de­cided that it needs more troops in the east and is con­sid­er­ing the re­deploy­ment of sev­er­al thou­sand from else­where in the coun­try, ac­cord­ing to a seni­or Pentagon of­fi­cial with dir­ect know­ledge of the de­lib­er­a­tions. Cur­rently, just over 31,000 troops are in east­ern Afgh­anistan, com­pared with 38,000 in the south. Un­der some re­deploy­ment plans, the of­fi­cial said, the num­ber of troops in the two re­gions would gradu­ally equal­ize. In the in­tern­al de­lib­er­a­tions be­fore Wed­nes­day’s draw­down an­nounce­ment, Obama signed off on plans to dis­patch new spe­cial-op­er­a­tions forces to the east, ac­cord­ing to an­oth­er ad­min­is­tra­tion of­fi­cial. The mini-surge will take part in in­ter­dic­tion ef­forts along the bor­der and es­cal­ate the U.S.-led of­fens­ive against the Haqqani net­work, the mil­it­ary of­fi­cial said.

Maj. Gen. Dan Allyn, the top Amer­ic­an com­mand­er in east­ern Afgh­anistan, says that his forces are work­ing to push mil­it­ants out of their tra­di­tion­al strong­holds in Log­ar and Wardak, key provinces just south of Ka­bul, while step­ping up ef­forts to mon­it­or the Pakistani bor­der. Afghan and Amer­ic­an troops are also try­ing to ex­pand the so-called Ka­bul se­cur­ity zone, which sur­rounds the cap­it­al, deep­er in­to nearby provinces such as Lagh­man and Nangar­har, Allyn said. Much of the area with­in the zone — in­clud­ing High­way 1, the main road through Ka­bul, and High­way 7, which con­nects Ka­bul to a cru­cial bor­der cross­ing — is already un­der full Afghan con­trol.

But the Haqqani net­work and the Taliban have stepped up their at­tacks, killing more than 60 ci­vil­ians in the past four weeks alone, nearly triple the pre­vi­ous monthly av­er­age for the re­gion, and armed groups are try­ing to mount at­tacks in and around Ka­bul, Allyn said. His forces have also no­ticed a sys­tem­at­ic re­cruit­ment of child sui­cide bombers. In one of the dead­li­est such at­tacks, a 12-year-old boy det­on­ated him­self in a crowded mar­ket­place in Pak­tika province last month, killing four people, in­clud­ing a high-rank­ing loc­al of­fi­cial, and wound­ing a dozen oth­ers. More than two dozen would-be child bombers are in Afghan cus­tody; most of them were ar­res­ted in east­ern Afgh­anistan, ac­cord­ing to a seni­or Afghan gov­ern­ment of­fi­cial. “The en­emy is try­ing very hard to hold on to what few footholds they still re­tain,” Allyn said. “It’s a tough fight every day.”

In­deed, the U.S. has taken about as many cas­u­al­ties in the east in the past six months as it has in the south — about 70 in each re­gion — even though there are 20 per­cent few­er troops in the east. In the four weeks since Allyn took com­mand, co­ali­tion forces there have suffered 17 fatal­it­ies, in­clud­ing a dozen Amer­ic­ans. He says there will be more losses ahead.

East­ern Afgh­anistan is cent­ral to the coun­try’s re­cent bloody his­tory. Osama bin Laden plot­ted the Septem­ber 11 at­tacks there. When U.S. forces swept in­to Afgh­anistan a few months later, al-Qaida’s lead­ers fled in­to Pakistan, fuel­ing the vi­ol­ence that has destabil­ized both coun­tries. The Afghan war began in east­ern Afgh­anistan. With Obama’s de­cision to start the with­draw­al next month, it looks like it will end there, too.


Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.