Obama’s Ideas Offer Ray of Hope

President Barack Obama holds a meeting on Libya in the Situation Room of the White House, March 15, 2011. (Official White House Photo by Pete Souza)
National Journal
Add to Briefcase
Ronald Brownstein
Oct. 2, 2011, 8 a.m.

On the core is­sues of cre­at­ing jobs and con­trolling the fed­er­al budget de­fi­cit, Pres­id­ent Obama faces a con­sist­ent di­vide in pub­lic opin­ion — par­tic­u­larly among whites — that could of­fer his best op­por­tun­ity in the 2012 race to over­come dis­ap­point­ment in his per­form­ance so far.

On both the de­fi­cit and the eco­nomy, a sub­stan­tial plur­al­ity of white voters say they trust Re­pub­lic­ans more than Obama to find an­swers, ac­cord­ing to the most re­cent United Tech­no­lo­gies/Na­tion­al Journ­al Con­gres­sion­al Con­nec­tion sur­veys. These res­ults track find­ings in oth­er polls that show Obama’s over­all ap­prov­al rat­ing among white voters skid­ding be­low 35 per­cent in some cases.

And yet when asked to com­pare spe­cif­ic strategies from Obama and Re­pub­lic­ans to re­vive job growth or con­trol the de­fi­cit, the pres­id­ent’s pro­pos­als con­sist­ently scored bet­ter in the Con­gres­sion­al Con­nec­tion polls.

That stark and stable con­trast sug­gests that one of the key ques­tions in 2012 will be wheth­er voters primar­ily look back, or ahead, when cast­ing their pres­id­en­tial bal­lots. Tra­di­tion­ally, voters base their de­cisions about in­cum­bent pres­id­ents primar­ily on a back­ward-look­ing judg­ment about his per­form­ance, notes Emory Uni­versity polit­ic­al sci­ent­ist Alan Ab­ramow­itz. But that pat­tern, he ar­gues, won’t ne­ces­sar­ily hold next year be­cause voters are sour­ing on the GOP at least as fast as they are on Obama.

“Gen­er­ally in pres­id­en­tial elec­tions when an in­cum­bent is run­ning, the ret­ro­spect­ive judg­ments are usu­ally more im­port­ant rather than the pro­spect­ive judg­ments,” said Ab­ramow­itz. “But I’m not sure [that will con­tin­ue] be­cause what you’re find­ing [in these polls] about the pref­er­ence for what Obama is pro­pos­ing over what the Re­pub­lic­ans are pro­pos­ing ties in with some of the doubts voters are ex­press­ing about the Re­pub­lic­an Party.”

The con­trast between pro­spect­ive and ret­ro­spect­ive judg­ments on Obama in the Con­gres­sion­al Con­nec­tion polls is strik­ing. In an early Septem­ber sur­vey, for in­stance, the share of re­spond­ents who said Obama’s policies made the eco­nomy worse was nearly double the per­cent­age who said he im­proved con­di­tions; among whites the ra­tio was al­most three-to-one.

But when the poll asked re­spond­ents to as­sess five ideas from Obama and five from the GOP to cre­ate jobs, Obama’s pro­pos­als gen­er­ally drew more sup­port, even among groups usu­ally skep­tic­al of him. For in­stance, white in­de­pend­ents were the most sup­port­ive of cut­ting the taxes of em­ploy­ers who hire new work­ers and provid­ing states money to avoid lay­offs. They also liked Obama’s pro­pos­al to help homeown­ers re­fin­ance their mort­gages at lower in­terest rates and to spend more on fed­er­al in­fra­struc­ture pro­jects. The only GOP job-cre­ation idea crack­ing the top five for these swing voters was passing a bal­anced-budget amend­ment that lim­ited fed­er­al spend­ing.

Obama’s job-cre­ation ideas also took four of the top five spots in the sur­vey among white wo­men, both with and without col­lege de­grees. His ideas took three of the top four spots for non-col­lege white men, who have res­isted Obama from the out­set. Only among col­lege-edu­cated white men did GOP ideas dom­in­ate, tak­ing four of the top five spots.

Ques­tions about the de­fi­cit in a mid-Septem­ber sur­vey pro­duced the same pat­tern. Whites strongly pre­ferred the GOP over Obama when asked which side they trust to blot the red ink. But Obama’s spe­cif­ic ideas to do so grabbed four of the top five rungs among whites when they were asked again to judge five pro­pos­als from each side. Re­peal­ing Obama’s health care law did draw sub­stan­tial sup­port among white men (if not white wo­men), but a core GOP pro­pos­al to con­vert Medi­care in­to a vouch­er-like sys­tem, freeze dis­cre­tion­ary spend­ing through 2019, and trans­form Medi­caid in­to a block grant all faced wide­spread res­ist­ance among whites.

Re­pub­lic­an poll­ster Glen Bol­ger pre­dicts such pref­er­ences won’t be­ne­fit Obama much in 2012 if his per­form­ance as­sess­ments don’t im­prove. “By that point in time he will have had four years, and if he hasn’t got­ten the job done, why would you re­hire the guy?” Bol­ger said.

But Joel Ben­en­son, Obama’s poll­ster, says that voters’ as­sess­ments of the two sides’ pro­spect­ive agen­das will not only play the largest role next year, but will also shape their ret­ro­spect­ive judg­ments on Obama’s per­form­ance. “Elec­tions are about choices. When there is a choice in front of these folks who are fight­ing every day to grab back some of the se­cur­ity they had “¦ they are go­ing to look a little bit back­wards, more at the [cur­rent] mo­ment and more than any­thing at go­ing for­ward,” he said. “They know that the old rules haven’t ap­plied in a while.”

Demo­crat­ic poll­ster Mark Penn, who helped guide Pres­id­ent Clin­ton’s 1996 reelec­tion and served as the chief strategist for Hil­lary Rod­ham Clin­ton’s bid for the Demo­crat­ic nom­in­a­tion in 2008, says the key for an in­cum­bent pres­id­ent, es­pe­cially dur­ing hard times, is for­mu­lat­ing an agenda at­tract­ive enough that voters be­lieve “that the second term is go­ing to ful­fill the prom­ise of your first.” And on that front, he ar­gues, Obama, des­pite the pos­it­ive re­sponses in the Con­gres­sion­al Con­nec­tion Poll, still has his work cut out for him. “So far I don’t think we’ve seen that de­vel­op­ment of a big second-term agenda,” Penn says.


Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.