Obama’s Image Machine: Monopolistic Propaganda Funded by You

News organizations protest White House restrictions on independent photo coverage.

Nov. 21, 2013, 5:39 a.m.

New York Times pho­to­graph­er Doug Mills strode in­to Jay Car­ney’s of­fice Oct. 29 with a pile of pic­tures taken ex­clus­ively by Pres­id­ent Obama’s of­fi­cial pho­to­graph­er at events the White House press corps was for­bid­den to cov­er. “This one,” Mills said, slid­ing one pic­ture after an­oth­er off his stack and onto the press sec­ret­ary’s desk. “This one, too—and this one and this one and “¦”

The red-faced pho­to­graph­er, joined by col­leagues on the White House Cor­res­pond­ents’ As­so­ci­ation board, fin­ished his 10-minute present­a­tion with a flour­ish that made Car­ney, a former Mo­scow cor­res­pond­ent for Time, wince.

“You guys,” Mills said, “are just like Tass.”

Com­par­ing the White House to the Rus­si­an news agency is a hy­per­bole, of course, but less so with each new ad­min­is­tra­tion. Obama’s im­age-makers are tak­ing ad­vant­age of new tech­no­lo­gies that demo­crat­ized the me­dia, sub­vert­ing in­de­pend­ent news or­gan­iz­a­tions that hold the pres­id­ent ac­count­able. A gen­er­a­tion ago, a few main­stream me­dia or­gan­iz­a­tions held a mono­poly on pub­lic in­form­a­tion about the White House. Today, the White House it­self is be­hav­ing mono­pol­ist­ic­ally.

The fast-mov­ing trend is ham­per­ing re­port­ers and video­graph­ers who cov­er the White House, but Mills’s pro­fes­sion has prob­ably been hard­est hit. “As surely as if they were pla­cing a hand over a journ­al­ist’s cam­era lens, of­fi­cials in this ad­min­is­tra­tion are block­ing the pub­lic from hav­ing an in­de­pend­ent view of im­port­ant func­tions of the Ex­ec­ut­ive Branch of gov­ern­ment,” reads a let­ter de­livered today to Car­ney by the WHCA and sev­er­al mem­ber news or­gan­iz­a­tions in­clud­ing The As­so­ci­ated Press and The New York Times.

The let­ter in­cludes ex­amples of im­port­ant news events that were not covered by me­dia pho­to­graph­ers, and yet pic­tures were taken by the White House im­age team and widely dis­trib­uted via so­cial me­dia. This hap­pens al­most daily.

Un­like me­dia pho­to­graph­ers, of­fi­cial White House pho­to­graph­ers are paid by tax­pay­ers and re­port to the pres­id­ent. Their job is to make Obama look good. They are pro­pa­gand­ists—in the purest sense of the word.

The let­ter re­minds Car­ney that Obama prom­ised to run the most trans­par­ent ad­min­is­tra­tion in his­tory. It ar­gues that the re­stric­tions “raise con­sti­tu­tion­al con­cerns” and amount to “ar­bit­rary re­straint and un­war­ran­ted in­ter­fer­ence on le­git­im­ate news­gath­er­ing activ­it­ies.”

Journ­al­ists un­der­stand that the pres­id­ent’s fam­ily and na­tion­al se­cur­ity events must be off-lim­its at times. Journ­al­ists also don’t ob­ject to the White House us­ing so­cial me­dia; those are plat­forms as le­git­im­ate as tele­vi­sions and print. The prob­lem is that the Obama White House is sim­ul­tan­eously re­strict­ing ac­cess of in­de­pend­ent me­dia while flood­ing the pub­lic with state-run me­dia.

Again, this is pro­pa­ganda—ut­terly lack­ing a skep­tic­al eye. The irony is that Obama is us­ing tech­no­logy that demo­crat­ized and flattened the me­dia to cent­ral­ize and strengthen the powers an in­sti­tu­tion, The Pres­id­ency.

That was the sen­ti­ment be­hind Mills’s crack about Tass, ac­cord­ing to people who at­ten­ded the Oct. 29 meet­ing. Car­ney took of­fense.

“Oh, so now we’re like Stal­in?” the White House press sec­ret­ary replied, laugh­ing at the vet­er­an New York Times pho­to­graph­er.

Olivi­er Knox, a Ya­hoo re­port­er and long-time White House cor­res­pond­ent who at­ten­ded the meet­ing with Mills, shot an angry look at Car­ney and said, “It’s not funny, Jay.”

Here are just a few ex­amples of how the White House uses your taxes to ma­nip­u­late Obama’s im­age.

Left (AP Photo/Evan Vucci), right (Pete Souza/The White House) National Journal
Left (The White House travel pool press photographers), right (Pete Souza/The White House) National Journal
Left (Doug Mills / The New York Times), Right ( Pete Souza/The White House) National Journal
Labor rally event in Michigan. National Journal
The White House/Flickr National Journal
Obama meets with Hillary (Flickr) National Journal
Flickr livestream video National Journal
Left (AP Photo/Pablo Martinez Monsivais), Right (Pete Souza/The White House) National Journal
Pete Souza/The White House National Journal

Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.