Politics: Need to Know Video

GOP’s Leading Ladies: Bachmann’s Her Own Woman

Add to Briefcase
May 31, 2011, 4:37 p.m.

A Rasmussen Re­ports (IVR) poll; con­duc­ted 10/4; sur­veyed 500 LVs; mar­gin of er­ror +/- 4.4% (re­lease, 10/9). Tested: LG Den­nis Daugaard (R) and state Sen. Scott Heide­priem (D).

Gen­er­al Elec­tion Match­up

- Now 9/8 8/3 7/6 6/10 5/26 4/21 3/25 2/23 D. Daugaard 57% 57% 59% 52% 52% 51% 53% 49% 41% S. Heide­priem 33 28 27 35 36 36 33 32 32 Oth­er 4 4 4 4 3 7 5 6 7 Un­dec 6 11 10 9 9 6 9 13 19

I’ve spent a fair amount of time this week pon­der­ing what it means to stand one’s ground.

The term has taken on a new, dis­turb­ing mean­ing as the story of the shoot­ing of an un­armed Flor­ida teen­ager took on a life of its own. I don’t know any­one who’s ever loved a boy who was not un­nerved by this. Flor­ida’s self-de­fense law, known as “Stand Your Ground,” al­lows cit­izens who feel they are in im­min­ent danger to pro­tect them­selves — with a gun, if need be.

The idea of pro­tect­ing one­self, one’s fam­ily, and one’s prop­erty from in­truders is so ap­peal­ing that 21 states have ad­op­ted some ver­sion of the law. In this case, the pro­tec­tions of the Flor­ida law ap­peared to have al­lowed 28-year-old George Zi­m­mer­man to es­cape im­me­di­ate ar­rest and pro­sec­u­tion for shoot­ing 17-year-old Trayvon Mar­tin dead late last month. Mar­tin was walk­ing through a gated com­munity with candy and a can of iced tea.

Cit­izens of San­ford, Fla., protest the death of Trayvon Mar­tin (CNN)

The up­roar con­sumed the blo­go­sphere, talk shows, news­pa­per front pages, black ra­dio, and in­nu­mer­able kit­chen-table con­ver­sa­tions. Does stand­ing one’s ground mean de­fend­ing one­self no mat­ter what? And when civil rights lead­ers in San­ford, Fla., later de­clared “the line has been drawn in the sand,” wer­en’t they too stand­ing their ground?

Stand­ing one’s ground sounds great. It sig­nals cour­age and back­bone. Politi­cians have been trad­ing in this cur­rency forever. They call it lead­er­ship, and voters usu­ally agree.

Stand­ing one’s ground has polit­ic­al as well as so­cial con­sequences, as we have seen this week — which brings us to Mitt Rom­ney. As I have writ­ten in this space be­fore, the former Mas­sachu­setts gov­ernor and still-likely GOP pres­id­en­tial nom­in­ee can­not shake his chief weak­ness — the per­cep­tion that he is too flex­ible.

This repu­ta­tion, rooted in his days as the Re­pub­lic­an gov­ernor of a no­tori­ously blue state, has dogged him throughout the primar­ies. Fueled by the de­term­ined pur­suit of Newt Gin­grich and Rick San­tor­um, the Rom­ney-as-un­re­li­able meme has now be­come a re­cur­ring top­ic on the trail.

And just when he seemed to re­gain the sense of in­ev­it­ab­il­ity that he wore as a front-run­ner’s cape by scor­ing a de­cis­ive win in Illinois, his chief spokes­man re­minded every­one of his can­did­ate’s chief weak­ness.

Ap­pear­ing on a CNN talk show, strategist Eric Fehrn­strom re­spon­ded to a ques­tion about wheth­er Rom­ney would be able to veer back to­ward the cen­ter dur­ing a gen­er­al elec­tion cam­paign after re­peatedly trum­pet­ing his con­ser­vat­ive bona fides dur­ing the primary sea­son.

“Well, I think you hit a re­set but­ton for the fall cam­paign,” he said. “Everything changes. It’s al­most like an Etch A Sketch. You can kind of shake it up and start all over again.”

Let us pause here to say this made the folks at Obama headquar­ters in Chica­go very, very happy.

Rick San­tor­um holds up an Etch A Sketch in San Ant­o­nio, Texas (CNN)

By the end of the day on Wed­nes­day, Rom­ney was try­ing to clean up the day’s mini-storm by stat­ing flatly that his is­sues would be “ex­actly the same” in the fall gen­er­al elec­tion. But by then, the Rom­ney cam­paign had — not for the first time — com­mit­ted an­oth­er un­forced er­ror, and on the very day he should have been cel­eb­rat­ing his win in Illinois and a Jeb Bush en­dorse­ment. Gin­grich and San­tor­um promptly got hold of Etch A Sketches to bran­dish on the cam­paign trail. A San­tor­um aide even raced to a Rom­ney event in Mary­land to hand out the toys to re­port­ers.

We can­not res­ist a toy. And we can­not res­ist a ker­fuffle that plays in­to a pre­con­ceived no­tion.

But we do like con­sist­ency. I was re­minded of that this week when I sat down on Cap­it­ol Hill to in­ter­view re­tir­ing Sens. Olympia Snowe, R-Maine, and Jeff Binga­man, D-N.M. As we chat­ted be­fore the in­ter­view began, it hit me how long it had been since I had been able to get sen­at­ors of op­pos­ing parties to sit down next to each oth­er for a joint in­ter­view. At best, we are only able to get Re­pub­lic­ans and Demo­crats to sit down “back to back,” rather than en­gage each oth­er dir­ectly.

Binga­man and Snowe, of course, who rep­res­ent the van­ish­ing middle in their parties, are on their way out of the Sen­ate. Their con­sist­ency is rooted in a firm be­lief in the value of bi­par­tis­an­ship. But Demo­crats on the left and Re­pub­lic­ans on the right have come to treat the search for com­mon ground as a sign of un­re­li­ab­il­ity.

“There’s not much of a cen­ter,” Snowe told me. “And we have to de­cide that the in­sti­tu­tion has to not only solve prob­lems, but the Amer­ic­an people have to give re­wards to those people and in­di­vidu­als who are will­ing to work across party lines. There are no polit­ic­al re­wards for that today.”

So of­ten our ideals clash with our ac­tions, wheth­er in life or in polit­ics or in stand­ing your ground.

What We're Following See More »
Cornyn Attempting to Get McCain Back for Health Vote
3 hours ago
Charlie Gard’s Parents End Legal Fight
4 hours ago

"A lawyer representing Chris Gard and Connie Yates told the High Court 'time had run out' for the baby. Mr. Gard said it meant his 'sweet, gorgeous, innocent little boy' will not reach his first birthday on 4 August. 'To let our beautiful little Charlie go' is 'the hardest thing we'll ever have to do,' his mother said. Charlie's parents said they made the decision because a US doctor had told them it was now too late to give Charlie nucleoside therapy.

11 States Sue EPA Over Chemical Rule
4 hours ago

"Eleven states have sued the Environmental Protection Agency over its June decision to delay implementation of a chemical safety rule" until 2019. "The state attorneys general, led by New York’s Eric Schneiderman (D), argue the rule is important for 'protecting our workers, first-responders and communities from chemical accidents' and should be allowed to take affect as planned by the Obama administration’s EPA.

Trump: You’re With Us Or Against Us
4 hours ago
House Freedom Caucus Chair: Shutdown Over Wall Funding Unlikely
4 hours ago

"House Freedom Caucus Chairman Mark Meadows (R-N.C.) on Monday said that funding for President Trump's controversial border wall is unlikely to cause a government shutdown. 'The odds of a government shutdown are very minimal when it comes to that,' the conservative lawmaker said at an event in Washington, D.C. 'I do think the funding of the border wall will happen,' he added. Appropriators have set aside $1.6 billion to fund new wall and fencing sections on parts of the U.S.-Mexico border covering a few dozen miles."


Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.