air force

Add to Briefcase
See more stories about...
March 6, 2014, 9:28 a.m.

George W. Bush sat down for an in­ter­view with NBC’s Matt Lauer for the NBC spe­cial “De­cision Points” 11/8.

Mis­sion Kind Of Ac­com­plished

On why he thinks wa­ter­board­ing is leg­al: “Be­cause the law­yer said it was leg­al. He said it did not fall with­in the Anti-Tor­ture Act. I’m not a law­yer, but you gotta trust the judg­ment of people around you and I do.”

Bush, on the fail­ure to cap­ture Osama Bin Laden: “Well, first of all, the— the truth is, I was— I was dis­ap­poin­ted, deeply dis­ap­poin­ted, and still am. And, secondly, you know, I heard all that noise. We would have moved heav­en and earth to get him if we’d have known where he was.”

Bush, on if he ever doubted the Ir­aq War in­tel­li­gence: “No, I didn’t. I really didn’t,” and on go­ing to war with Ir­aq: “I was a dis­sent­ing voice. I didn’t wanna use force.”

On if he ever thought about apo­lo­giz­ing for the Ir­aq War: “I mean apo­lo­giz­ing would ba­sic­ally say the de­cision was a wrong de­cision. I don’t be­lieve it was the wrong de­cision,” and on the “Mis­sion Ac­com­plished” ban­ner: “No ques­tion it was a mis­take. … And that hap­pens when you’re Pres­id­ent and if I had to do it all over again, which you don’t get to do when you’re the Pres­id­ent, you know, I’d have said, ‘Good goin’, men and wo­men. Great mis­sion’ or something” (NBC, 11/8).

What Did Brown Do To You?

Bush, on the im­age of him look­ing out the win­dow dur­ing Kat­rina: “Yes. Huge mis­take,” and on the polit­ic­al dam­age: “I think it re­in­forced dam­age that was tak­ing place. I had failed to get Con­gress to move on So­cial Se­cur­ity. Ir­aq was still very dif­fi­cult. And so Kat­rina came along and it gave crit­ics an op­por­tun­ity to— to kind of un­der­mine the Pres­id­ency, I guess you could say.”

Bush, on what he should have done dur­ing Kat­rina: “It’s al­ways my fault. I should have touched down in Bat­on Rouge, met with the gov­ernor, and, you know, walked out and said, ‘I hear you.’ I mean, ‘We know. We un­der­stand. And we’re gonna, you know, help the state and help the loc­als, gov­ern­ments with as much re­sources as needed.’ And— and then got back on a flight up to Wash­ing­ton. I did not do that and paid a price for it.”

Bush, on ‘heck of a job’: “I tend to boost people’s spir­its dur­ing dif­fi­cult times. And these two gov­ernors are say­in, ‘This guy’s doin’ a good job’ and of course I say …”

Bush, on Kanye West‘s com­ment about him: “That’s, ‘he’s a ra­cist’. And I didn’t ap­pre­ci­ate it then. I don’t ap­pre­ci­ate it now. It’s one thing to say, you know, ‘I don’t ap­pre­ci­ate the way he’s— handles his busi­ness.’ It’s an­oth­er thing to say, ‘This man’s a ra­cist.’ I re­sent it. It’s not true, and it was one of the most dis­gust­ing mo­ments in my Pres­id­ency” (NBC, 11/8).

Feel­ings… Noth­ing But Feel­ings

Bush, on con­sid­er­ing re­pla­cing VP Cheney: “I’m a de­lib­er­at­ive per­son. And you know I thought about it. But I came down to the— to this con­clu­sion. He was a sol­id ad­visor. He nev­er went around my back. When I made a de­cision, he sup­por­ted it. And I liked him a lot, and so…”

Bush, on his re­la­tion­ship with his fath­er: “It’s not as com­plex as some would like it to be. I ad­mired him. And he nev­er dis­ap­poin­ted me. He was al­ways a great fath­er. He was al­ways a man who gave un­con­di­tion­al love. And so when it came time to run for Pres­id­ent I was mo­tiv­ated in large part— look, I wanted to run. I had an agenda. You know, I had a team of people I was com­in’ with. The truth of the mat­ter is the fi­nal mo­tiv­at­ing factor was my ad­mir­a­tion for George Bush, and I wondered wheth­er or not I had what it took to get in the arena like he did.”

Bush, on why he doesn’t cri­ti­cizes Pres. Obama: “One: I just didn’t want to get out there any­more. I didn’t want to get back in­to what I call ‘the swamp.’ I’m try­ing to re­gain a sense of an­onym­ity. And the oth­er reas­on why is I don’t think it’s good for the Pres­id­ency for a former Pres­id­ent to be opin­ing about his suc­cessor. Pres­id­ent Obama’s got plenty of crit­ics and— and I’m just not gonna be one.”

On how his­tory will judge him: “I hope I’m judged a suc­cess. I’m gonna be dead, Matt, when they fi­nally fig­ure it out. And I’m com­fort­able know­ing that I gave it my all, that I love Amer­ica and that— and I know it was an hon­or to serve” (NBC, 11/8).

Bad Deja Vu, Or Just An­oth­er Vu?

New York TimesStan­ley says the Lauer in­ter­view was “a fas­cin­at­ing, at times dis­arm­ing, per­form­ance, but also a con­fus­ing one: a plea for un­der­stand­ing from a pres­id­ent who says he doesn’t give a fig about pop­ular­ity.” When pressed about crit­ic­al de­cisions, Bush was “both more forth­com­ing and mad­den­ingly opaque” (11/8).

Time‘s Ca­labresi says “the in­ter­view did bring back the per­son­al at­mo­spher­ics of the pres­id­ency.” But “there was the per­petu­al, un­com­fort­able co­ex­ist­ence of con­fid­ence and de­fens­ive­ness that ended up giv­ing the coun­try the im­pres­sion that he had been in over his head all along.” It’s “safe to say NBC’s re­view of Bush’s pres­id­ency won’t move the needle much. What it did do is re­mind view­ers of the par­tic­u­lar brand of de­fens­ive pat­ri­ot­ism Bush em­bod­ied” (“Swamp­land,” 11/8).

Wall Street Journ­al‘s Hein­ni­ger re­views “De­cision Points.” “Com­mit­ment and clar­ity of com­mit­ment were Bush vir­tues.” The down­side of be­ing “all in,” however, is that much can be lost be­fore the need for a course cor­rec­tion be­comes too ob­vi­ous to ig­nore. What emerges across the pages of “De­cision Points” is a pres­id­ent “who at times let his strong code of per­son­al loy­alty and com­mit­ment cloud his de­cision-mak­ing.”

“The book con­tains de­light­ful and telling per­son­al ob­ser­va­tions.” After Bush re­fuses to par­don Scoot­er Libby Cheney tells him: “I can’t be­lieve you’re go­ing to leave a sol­dier on the bat­tle­field.” Bush “is un­fail­ingly gra­cious to vir­tu­ally all his op­pon­ents.” Bush “be­longs to his­tory. His­tory will judge him al­most solely by what he did” in the war on ter­ror and the wars in Afgh­anistan and Ir­aq. “If in time they suc­ceed, he was a good pres­id­ent. If they fail, his pres­id­ency falls. For every­one’s sake, one should hope that he was a good pres­id­ent” (11/9).

The Fi­nal Word (For Now)

USA Today‘s Keen in­ter­viewed Bush as well. Bush: “I read­ily con­cede I could have done things bet­ter. I had to con­cede that I did make mis­takes, and there was no ques­tion I did.” Bush says he was “blind­sided” by the fin­an­cial melt­down, “but he shares blame with Con­gress and de­fends his de­cisions when asked about the role of his policies in the re­ces­sion.”

On TARP: “I can’t prove that the de­cision I made pre­ven­ted a de­pres­sion, but I can say we didn’t have one. The TARP (money) spent un­der me by and large has been paid back to the tax­pay­ers.”

Bush “seems to have lost all ap­pet­ite for polit­ics” and “pro­fesses no in­terest in wield­ing his in­flu­ence.”

Bush says Tea Party move­ment is com­par­able to earli­er polit­ic­al fac­tions. Bush: “I am pleased to see that our demo­cracy is work­ing. In oth­er words, there’s a level of frus­tra­tion in our so­ci­ety and people de­cided to do something. The more our cit­izens par­ti­cip­ate in our demo­cracy, the bet­ter it is.”

Bush: “I don’t be­lieve there’s go­ing to be an ac­cur­ate short-term his­tory done of my ad­min­is­tra­tion or any ad­min­is­tra­tion. I fully ex­pect people to say, ‘Well, I’ve read his mem­oir and I still dis­agree with his de­cisions,’ or ‘I’ve read his mem­oir and now I un­der­stand why he did what he did.’ I’m not try­ing to change people’s opin­ions. I’m try­ing to give mod­ern-day read­ers and fu­ture read­ers a con­text for my ad­min­is­tra­tion” (11/9).

What We're Following See More »
Pelosi Calls for Ethics Investigation of Conyers
8 hours ago

House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi has called for an ethics investigation of Rep. John Conyers, amidst reports that the Michigan Democrat settled sexual harassment charges. "My office resolved the allegations — with an express denial of liability — in order to save all involved from the rigors of protracted litigation," Conyers admitted, after first denying any knowledge of the charges.

Pai Officially Announces Intent to Scrap Net Neutrality Rules
11 hours ago
Conyers Denies Settling Harassment Claims
11 hours ago
Mugabe Resigns, Ending Impeachment Debate
11 hours ago
Mueller Seeks Documents from DOJ
1 days ago

Special counsel Robert Mueller "is now demanding documents from the department overseeing his investigation." A source tells ABC News that "Mueller's investigators are keen to obtain emails related to the firing of FBI Director James Comey and the earlier decision of Attorney General Jeff Sessions to recuse himself from the entire matter."


Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.