Yes, Chris Christie, “˜Not Every Vaccine Is Created Equal.’ Get Them Anyway.

When a vaccine is ineffective, it’s even more important for everyone to have it.

National Journal
Brian Resnick
Add to Briefcase
See more stories about...
Brian Resnick
Feb. 2, 2015, 7:52 a.m.

With pres­id­en­tial primary sea­son loom­ing, New Jer­sey Gov. Chris Christie is fi­nally voicing his opin­ion on na­tion­al is­sues. And out of the gate, he’s stir­ring up con­tro­versy. Monday morn­ing, Christie said that while he be­lieves vac­cin­a­tion is a pub­lic good, par­ents should have a de­gree of choice in the mat­ter. The Wash­ing­ton Post quoted him say­ing, “Not every vac­cine is cre­ated equal, and not every dis­ease type is as great a pub­lic health threat as oth­ers.” These com­ments come just a day after Pres­id­ent Obama urged all par­ents to “get your kids vac­cin­ated,” in light of the re­cent measles out­break in Cali­for­nia.

Christie’s of­fice did cla­ri­fy his po­s­i­tion. “There is no ques­tion kids should be vac­cin­ated,” a state­ment read. But his thoughts on policy are vague. He calls for “a meas­ure of choice,” and “bal­ance” over which vac­cines the gov­ern­ment should man­date. Yes, it would be prob­ably be weird pub­lic policy if the U.S. gov­ern­ment took a to­tal­it­ari­an ap­proach: bar­ging in­to homes with nurses and syr­inges. There are some le­git­im­ate reas­ons not to vac­cin­ate a child. Al­ler­gic re­ac­tions can hap­pen. There are tricky vac­cin­a­tion de­cisions to make for chil­dren born with HIV. But for the vast, vast ma­jor­ity of chil­dren, vac­cines are safe, and they should stay to the pre­scribed sched­ule.

If Christie is ad­voc­at­ing for the par­ent­al right to choose vac­cin­a­tions à la carte (it isn’t clear if he is) based on how ef­fect­ive the vac­cines are and how dan­ger­ous the dis­eases are, his think­ing is curi­ous. Look no fur­ther than the mumps and the flu.

The mumps vac­cine — in­cluded in the MMR shot that also in­ocu­lates for measles and ru­bella — is not that great. De­pend­ing on how many doses a per­son gets, the mumps vac­cine is about 80 to 90 per­cent ef­fect­ive. Mean­ing that out of 100 people with the shot, about 20 still might be able to get the mumps.

But more people with the vac­cine means few­er op­por­tun­it­ies for those 20 people to be­come in­fec­ted. It’s called herd im­munity: Hav­ing more people in a com­munity with the mumps vac­cine makes every in­di­vidu­al’s dose of the vac­cine, in ef­fect, stronger. For mumps, doc­tors say between 88 and 92 per­cent of people in a group need to have the vac­cine to keep the dis­ease from spread­ing.

And con­sider the flu, a dis­ease that most healthy kids can ride out just fine. It’s really im­port­ant for chil­dren to get the flu shot. Be­cause kids are gross. Chil­dren most read­ily pass the flu on to oth­ers, in­clud­ing the eld­erly, who of­ten don’t ride out the dis­ease just fine. The journ­al Vac­cine finds that the op­tim­al way to mit­ig­ate a flu sea­son is to pri­or­it­ize kids.

So yes, Gov­ernor, not all vac­cines are cre­ated equal. And neither are dis­eases. But wheth­er those facts should factor in­to a vac­cin­a­tion de­cision … well, it’s a lot more com­plic­ated than that.

What We're Following See More »
Nadler: Goodlatte Could Subpoena Rosenstein
3 days ago

"The top Democrat on the House Judiciary Committee says Chairman Bob Goodlatte, R-Va., is poised to subpoena the Justice Department for former FBI Director James Comey’s memos, which the agency so far has failed to produce. Rep. Jerrold Nadler, D-N.Y., warned such a move puts Deputy Attorney General Rod Rosenstein in jeopardy of being placed in contempt of Congress and the special counsel investigation of being shut down prematurely."

House Ag Committee Passes Farm Bill
3 days ago
"On a party-line vote, the House Agriculture Committee approved a five-year farm bill on Wednesday that tweaks the supports now in place—a promise of certainty, leaders said, during a period of low commodity prices and threats of a trade war with agriculture on the front line." The bill includes no new funding over the last farm bill.
Schneiderman Urges NY Lawmakers to Close “Double Jeopardy Loophole”
3 days ago
Ryan Tamps Down AUMF Talk
4 days ago

Referring to the AUMF introduced by Sens. Tim Kaine and Bob Corker Monday evening, House Speaker Paul Ryan said Tuesday "he won’t allow any bill to come to the House floor that he thinks would restrict military commanders’ ability to fight." Ryan "defended the legality of U.S. military strikes last week against chemical weapons-related sites in Syria, saying President Trump had the authority to order them under the Constitution’s Article II commander-in-chief powers."

Judge Denies Requests by Cohen, Trump
5 days ago

Attorneys for both President Trump and his attorney Michael Cohen lost a court challenge today, as they sought to suppress evidence gathered in a raid of Cohen's office and hotel room. "U.S. District Court Judge Kimba Wood denied the requests and ruled that prosecutors will get first access to the information, followed by Cohen’s defense team ten days later. Wood noted that she has not yet decided whether she will appoint a special master in the case at all."


Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.