Report: Don’t Try to Block the Sun to Fix Climate Change

Geoengineering solutions for global warming not ready for prime time.

The planet Venus passes before the sun, a very rarely-seen event, on June 5, 2012 near Orange, California. 
National Journal
Jason Plautz
Add to Briefcase
See more stories about...
Jason Plautz
Feb. 10, 2015, 6:15 a.m.

Sure, we can fight the effects of climate change by cleaning the emissions from cars and putting scrubbers on the smokestacks of power plants. But doesn’t a massive problem require a big solution like, say, spraying sulfur dioxide into the atmosphere to reflect the rays of the sun back into space?

That’s the concept behind geoengineering, a broad term that refers to hypothetical strategies to artificially engineer the Earth’s climate. For example, the atmosphere spraying, which would mirror the effects of a volcanic eruption, would effectively cool the Earth in a bid to stem global warming. Theoretically, that could offer a fix if temperatures rose so rapidly that crops could no longer grow or sea levels went perilously high.

The concepts have been kicked around for a long time. It was Benjamin Franklin who is credited with first making the connection between volcanoes and cooling, when in 1783 he noticed a “constant fog” over Europe that meant the sun’s rays’ “summer effect in heating the earth was exceedingly diminished.” And various national and scientific studies have kicked the concepts around since the 1960s.

So is geoengineering ready to take off? In a word: no.

A major report released today by a National Research Council committee says it’s too early and much too risky to start tinkering with the climate, even if global warming is getting worse.

A panel of academics, engineers, and environmentalists, chaired by former U.S. Geological Survey Director Marcia McNutt, did say that albedo modification — the technical term for atmospheric engineering — could potentially “rapidly offset” some of the consequences of global warming. It’s theoretically possible, although unproven, that within a few years of spraying, the Earth could be cooled.

But, the report found, the idea carries “environmental, ethical, social, political, economic, and legal risks associated with intended and unintended consequences.”

The unpredictably of climate change and a lack of knowledge means that albedo modification could upend precipitation or atmospheric patterns, the report stated. The social impacts of blocking out the sun are unknown, but they could carry serious political consequences depending on what countries possess the technology to control the atmosphere.

The technology could even be used in a military fashion, the NRC report warns (the 1998 Avengers movie features Sean Connery as the villainous Sir August De Wynter, who produces a weather-controlling machine to blackmail world leaders).

More to the point, blocking out the sun does nothing to fix the problem of greenhouse gases, whose effects will be felt for centuries. Spraying the atmosphere is nothing more than a short-term fix.

“That scientists are even considering technological interventions should be a wake-up call that we need to do more now to reduce emissions, which is the most effective, least risky way to combat climate change,” said McNutt, now the editor-in-chief of the journal Science.

A second study also focused on more proven carbon dioxide removal and sequestration techniques, saying they would do more to take carbon out of the economy and limit the direct emissions that are contributing to climate change.

McNutt said the committee decided to separate carbon dioxide removal from atmospheric modification to avoid conflating the two. The former concept is more proven, even if its still in its early technological stages, but is likely to be deployed. As the report lays out, the lingering concerns with carbon dioxide removal are about cost, rather than the risk-based concerns about albedo modification.

National Academy of Sciences President Ralph Cicerone made it clear that mitigating emissions is the best course of action, but he said that “every year of inaction on the emissions reduction does increase the likelihood” that more drastic intervention will be necessary. Thus, he said, “the scientific community needs to have answers and a much better understanding” of geoengineering.

Rafe Pomerance, a former State Department climate official who was not involved in the NRC report, said in an interview that with extreme storms and sea-level rise showing the growing risk of climate change, the time is ripe to put every option on the table.

“How can we not think about this?,” he asked. “If you think there are catastrophic outcomes in the future, why wouldn’t you think about responses to avoid it? If you don’t intervene, and we keep going on this trajectory, then we may want these options. In the end, it’s just going to be a comparison of risks.”

What We're Following See More »
Mueller Hits Manafort, Gates with New Charges
14 hours ago

Robert Mueller announced new charges against former Trump campaign chairman Paul Manafort advisor Rick Gates. "The new indictment contains 32 counts, including tax charges." The pair had been indicted on 12 charges in October. Since then, Gates's attorneys have asked to be excused from the case.

FBI Failed To Act On Parkland Shooter Tip
21 hours ago

The FBI has reported that it failed to respond to a warning from "a person close to" Nikolas Cruz, the teen accused of killing 17 people at Parkland High School on Thursday. "It was the second time the FBI apparently failed to follow up on Cruz." On the first occasion, it failed to properly investigate Cruz after it was reported to them that he left the following comment on a Youtube video: "Im going to be a school shooter."

Florida Governor Calls on FBI Director to Resign
21 hours ago

Florida Governor Rick Scott called on FBI Director Christopher Wray to resign following revelations that the FBI had failed to adequately investigate multiple warnings about Parkland High School gunman Nikolas Cruz. “The FBI’s failure to take action against this killer is unacceptable,'" said Scott. '...We constantly promote ‘see something, say something,’ and a courageous person did just that to the FBI. And the FBI failed to act.'" According to an FBI statement, the FBI failed to inform local offices of information regarding "Cruz's desire to kill people, erratic behavior, disturbing social media posts, as well as the potential of him conducting a school shooting."

Quinnipiac Poll Shows 97% Support for Expanded Background Checks
21 hours ago
Rubio Talks Gun Control At CNN Town Hall
21 hours ago

Following the mass shooting in Parkland, Florida, Senator Rubio (R-FL) was grilled by survivors of the shooting and parents of victims at a CNN town hall Thursday night. The senator was booed loudly by the audience when he refused to endorse an assault weapons ban, including by one parent who called his response to the mass shooting "pathetically weak." Rubio said he was open to reconsidering the capacity of gun magazines, supports raising the age at which people can buy rifles, and that he disagreed with Trump's proposal to arm teachers.


Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.