Debbie Dingell in the Spotlight

Succeeding a famous spouse isn’t easy.

This illustration can only be used with the Nora Caplan-Bricker piece that originally ran in the 2/14/2015 issue of National Journal magazine.
National Journal
Add to Briefcase
Nora Caplan-Bricker
Feb. 13, 2015, midnight

I’m not try­ing to be John Din­gell. I’m Debbie Din­gell.” Dur­ing a re­cent morn­ing of shad­ow­ing the fresh­man rep­res­ent­at­ive from Michigan, I learn that this is about as philo­soph­ic­al as she wants to get on the com­plex­it­ies of in­her­it­ing a seat — and a leg­acy — from her hus­band, former Rep. John Din­gell, the longest-serving mem­ber in the his­tory of Cap­it­ol Hill.

Debbie Din­gell is known for her wry warmth: In the Can­non House Of­fice Build­ing — her glasses pushed rak­ishly back over fly­away blond hair — she greets friends as “honey,” with a kiss on the cheek. But on the ques­tion of her lar­ger-than-life pre­de­cessor, she has been stick­ing to an­swers such as, “I’m not try­ing to fill his shoes.” “We’re just two dif­fer­ent people,” she says, with a hint of a sigh, when I ask about her hus­band for the ump­teenth time.

It’s easy to see why Debbie — who is 61 to John’s 88, and who met and mar­ried him when she was in her twen­ties and he was already a power­ful mem­ber of the House — is tired of talk­ing about it. She has been field­ing this line of in­quiry since the mo­ment she an­nounced she would com­pete to suc­ceed him. (“Debbie Din­gell Poised to Keep U.S. House Seat in the Fam­ily,” pro­claimed an NPR story in Feb­ru­ary 2014.) More-re­cent cov­er­age has been in the same vein. (“Debbie Din­gell Ready for Spot­light as Her Hus­band, the ‘Dean’ of Con­gress, Steps Aside,” ob­served The New York Times in Novem­ber.)

Gran­ted, it’s im­possible to un­der­stand this con­sum­mate Wash­ing­ton spouse without con­sid­er­ing her icon­ic hus­band — who came to Cap­it­ol Hill as a page in 1938. But Debbie, as she says, isn’t John. While she calls her hus­band “the most im­port­ant thing in my life” — and while their polit­ic­al com­mon­al­it­ies dwarf their dif­fer­ences — it’s also true that her ten­ure on the Hill will not be a car­bon copy of his.

Even be­fore she ran for of­fice, Debbie Din­gell al­ways guarded her own iden­tity. She worked at Gen­er­al Mo­tors for 32 years (she’s a scion of Michigan auto roy­alty: the Fish­er fam­ily of Fish­er Body) and has said of­ten that she stayed at GM in part be­cause she already had the job when she and John met — so no one could as­sume that her power­ful hus­band got it for her.

Debbie and John Dingell don't see eye to eye on gun control. (Paul Warner/Getty Images) Getty Images

Din­gell also built her own CV in polit­ics, as a mem­ber of the Demo­crat­ic Na­tion­al Com­mit­tee. Be­fore she met her hus­band, she wrote her mas­ter’s thes­is at Geor­getown on “ci­vil­ity in Con­gress”; in the 1990s, she helped start a series of bi­par­tis­an lunches (with Mar­lene Malek, wife of GOP donor and strategist Fred Malek) for well-to-do Wash­ing­ton wo­men, which has con­tin­ued ever since. “I don’t know that I have the con­tacts that Debbie has in this town,” Minor­ity Whip Steny Hoy­er re­cently told The New York Times. Debbie and John Din­gell don’t see eye to eye on gun con­trol. (Paul Warner/Getty Im­ages)

John and Debbie may dif­fer most in per­son­al style. Where­as John was known for his ag­gress­ive con­fid­ence and im­per­i­ous con­trol over his com­mit­tee — he was some­times called “The Truck,” for his 6-foot-3 inch height and his hard-driv­ing ap­proach — Debbie “has more of a bed­side man­ner,” says Susan De­mas, ed­it­or and pub­lish­er of the news­let­ter In­side Michigan Polit­ics. Former Gov. Jen­nifer Gran­holm told me that Debbie reg­u­larly ac­ted as an un­of­fi­cial in­ter­me­di­ary for her when she clashed with Re­pub­lic­ans in the state Le­gis­lature. “She will al­ways know people’s birth­days, people’s chil­dren,” Gran­holm says. “She knows ways to hu­man­ize re­la­tion­ships.”

On most is­sues, in­clud­ing eco­nom­ic policy and Michigan’s all-im­port­ant auto in­dustry, John and Debbie seem to be sim­patico. (She has in­her­ited a fair num­ber of his staff: Eight of her 14 aides are old-time Din­gell hands.) But there’s at least one area where the couple doesn’t see eye to eye, and this di­ver­gence was on dis­play dur­ing Debbie’s first month in of­fice. John is staunchly pro-gun, a former board mem­ber of the Na­tion­al Rifle As­so­ci­ation (though he resigned in 1994, when he voted for Pres­id­ent Clin­ton’s om­ni­bus crime bill). Debbie, on the oth­er hand, grew up with a men­tally un­stable fath­er who kept guns in the house; she has writ­ten about try­ing to grab one from his hands as he threatened her moth­er when she was 12 years old. In Janu­ary, she wrote to Michigan’s Re­pub­lic­an gov­ernor, Rick Snyder, about a bill passed by the state Le­gis­lature that would have al­lowed people ac­cused of do­mest­ic vi­ol­ence to ob­tain per­mits for con­cealed weapons. He ul­ti­mately ve­toed it.

{{third­PartyEmbed type:magazineAd source:magazine_mid}}

What did John think of that? “I re­spect him, and he re­spects me,” Debbie says. “I think we each un­der­stand each oth­er’s view­point. He prob­ably wishes and hopes that I would not be as vo­cal as I have been.”

Carving out her own iden­tity won’t be a simple task for Debbie, of course. “The real ques­tion is, how much is the news me­dia go­ing to try to get to John Din­gell, to ask him to say something about his wife’s vote or something — and how much will he be will­ing to en­ter­tain that kind of at­ten­tion,” says Bill Bal­lenger, founder of In­side Michigan Polit­ics, who has known Debbie since be­fore she met John. “Dis­cre­tion is the bet­ter part of val­or, and he’d prob­ably be bet­ter off not com­ment­ing.”

Even if John’s leg­acy looms large, though, Debbie is in some ways a bet­ter fit with today’s Demo­crat­ic caucus than he was. John’s loy­alty to the auto in­dustry, for in­stance, meant that he had a de­cidedly mixed re­la­tion­ship with the en­vir­on­ment­al move­ment. De­mas re­mem­bers that when the Din­gells’ dis­trict was re­drawn in 2002 to in­clude the lib­er­al uni­versity town of Ann Ar­bor, Debbie “was the am­bas­sad­or there [who] really built re­la­tion­ships with the lib­er­al wing, with people in­volved in en­vir­on­ment­al polit­ics who were pretty sus­pi­cious of him.”

{{third­PartyEmbed type:magazineAd source:magazine_bot­tom}}

“I don’t think it’s un­likely she’s go­ing to see things dif­fer­ently than he sees things, be­cause she’s young­er than he is,” says friend Susanna Quinn (whose mar­riage to lob­by­ist Jack Quinn is also a May-Decem­ber pair­ing). “Some things are gen­er­a­tion­al.”

For now, Debbie Din­gell says her hus­band, who is re­cov­er­ing from a re­cent fall, isn’t weigh­ing in much on her work — something that makes her “sad, a little.” His at­ti­tude, she ex­plains, seems to be, “It’s your turn now.”


Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.