James Inhofe, Tax-Reform Skeptic

Key Republicans want to use a tax-code overhaul to pay for a highway bill, but Inhofe has his doubts.

Senate Armed Service Committee ranking member Sen. James Inhofe (R-OK) talks with reporters.
National Journal
May 4, 2015, 4:05 p.m.

James In­hofe is known for his be­lief that man-made cli­mate change is not hap­pen­ing. Here’s something else he doesn’t think is hap­pen­ing — tax re­form.

That doubt has pro­found im­plic­a­tions for the up­com­ing fight over high­way fund­ing be­cause oth­er prom­in­ent Re­pub­lic­ans are stak­ing their hopes on tax re­form as the sa­vior of the high­way and trans­it sys­tem. In­hofe doesn’t share their faith, and he doesn’t want in­fra­struc­ture fund­ing to be tied to cor­por­ate tax re­form be­cause he be­lieves the chances of suc­cess are too slim to risk a high­way-fund­ing short­fall.

In­hofe’s opin­ions clash dir­ectly with House Re­pub­lic­ans, who are lay­ing out a plan to fund a long-term high­way law with some type of tax-re­form pack­age. The de­tails on this tax bill are vague, to say the least. Law­makers with know­ledge of the dis­cus­sions can only say that it will be smal­ler than the massive over­haul pro­posed last year by former Ways and Means Com­mit­tee Chair­man Dave Camp (which went nowhere) and big­ger than a one-time over­seas tax hol­i­day as pro­posed by the ad­min­is­tra­tion and some mem­bers of Con­gress.

In­hofe isn’t buy­ing it, and his opin­ion mat­ters. He chairs the Sen­ate com­mit­tee charged with set­ting high­way and trans­it policy. While he clashes al­most glee­fully on en­vir­on­ment­al is­sues with his lib­er­al coun­ter­part, rank­ing mem­ber Bar­bara Box­er, the two lead­ers see eye to eye on in­fra­struc­ture. Both In­hofe and Box­er be­lieve a long-term fund­ing bill for high­ways and trans­it should be passed this year. Both also be­lieve that whatever stop­gap meas­ure is put in place this month should be short.

House Re­pub­lic­ans see it dif­fer­ently. In or­der to buy time for their mini tax pack­age to come to­geth­er, they are now scram­bling to find around $10 bil­lion to fund a stop­gap high­way ex­ten­sion through the end of the year.

“We most cer­tainly are still work­ing to­ward some type of tax re­form with the hope that it could provide a way to get high­ways done,” said an aide for the Ways and Means Com­mit­tee, where the law is be­ing writ­ten.

They have to act quickly. Cur­rent law ex­pires May 31. If Con­gress does noth­ing, states will have to halt their sum­mer road and rail con­struc­tion pro­jects, cost­ing thou­sands of jobs and mil­lions in in­vest­ments.

The com­mit­tee isn’t very far along, though. The Ways and Means aide said Re­pub­lic­ans on the pan­el still haven’t de­cided how to off­set even a few bil­lion that would be needed for a short-term ex­ten­sion. Mean­while, Demo­crats on the com­mit­tee haven’t been briefed at all, oth­er than re­ceiv­ing vague com­mit­ments that there will be a hear­ing at some un­deter­mined time on trans­port­a­tion rev­en­ues.

“There’s talk that, ‘Well, there’s a rab­bit to be pulled out of the hat.’ I’m will­ing to call the ques­tion,” said Rep. Earl Blumenauer, a Demo­crat from Ore­gon and seni­or com­mit­tee mem­ber.

Watch­ing from the Sen­ate, In­hofe thinks the tax-re­form ne­go­ti­ations are not yet ripe enough to bear fruit. He would like to settle the in­fra­struc­ture mat­ter an­oth­er way, be­fore the end of the sum­mer. “Some people, for an­oth­er reas­on, want to go longer so they can tie it to either tax re­form or tax ex­tenders. I don’t agree with that. I don’t want to do that,” In­hofe told Na­tion­al Journ­al.

An aide to In­hofe ex­pan­ded on the sen­at­or’s think­ing, say­ing he wor­ries that any tax-re­form ef­fort will get bogged down in polit­ics and lob­by­ing—as has happened be­fore—and that fail­ure will take the high­way bill down with it.

In­hofe isn’t alone in his opin­ion on taxes. He is ex­press­ing a skep­ti­cism widely cir­cu­lated among tax ana­lysts. They say that any mean­ing­ful re­form pack­age would be too com­plic­ated and packed with too many win­ners and losers to cleanly make it through Con­gress in a few months. If it has to raise money for high­ways, too, ne­go­ti­at­ors might as well throw in the tow­el now.

In­hofe is also one of the few Re­pub­lic­ans who is will­ing to say out­right that drivers should pay for their roads. He be­lieves all op­tions for fund­ing a long-term trans­port­a­tion bill should be on the table, his aide said, in­clud­ing a “user fee” for drivers—Re­pub­lic­an-speak for rais­ing the fed­er­al gas tax. Sen­ate Fin­ance Com­mit­tee Chair­man Or­rin Hatch made sim­il­ar state­ments earli­er in the year be­fore back­ing off to say that such an op­tion was polit­ic­ally un­pal­at­able.

Last week, Sen­ate Re­pub­lic­ans huddled on the trans­port­a­tion is­sue, hash­ing out their op­tions. There are two camps, ac­cord­ing to law­makers. On the one hand, law­makers could cobble to­geth­er enough spare change to get the high­way law to con­tin­ue in­to Ju­ly, when they could then pass a longer-term bill. The only is­sue there is that they don’t have a way to fin­ance it. And it’s $89 bil­lion.

On the oth­er hand, they could squeeze from the bot­tom of the gen­er­al treas­ury’s tooth­paste tube to ex­tend the high­way au­thor­ity through the end of the year. They could then link the trans­port­a­tion meas­ure to some type of cor­por­ate tax re­form, an ex­ten­sion of pop­u­lar tax breaks, or both. In the­ory, that would raise the needed $89 bil­lion. But nobody knows ex­actly how.

“We’re in dif­fer­ent places,” said Sen. John Thune, the No. 3 Re­pub­lic­an in the Sen­ate, after the meet­ing. “We’ll even­tu­ally come to­geth­er be­hind a strategy.”

The House GOP, for the mo­ment, is hunkered in on the idea of tax re­form. “I want to see a tax re­form. I think ab­so­lutely we need to do it,” said Rep. Bill Shuster, who is In­hofe’s coun­ter­part in the House as chair­man of the Trans­port­a­tion and In­fra­struc­ture Com­mit­tee.

Shuster says the tax piece of the high­way bill is in the hands of the tax writers, and he is wait­ing for the money the tax bill would gen­er­ate for his own in­fra­struc­ture meas­ure. The tax writers have lofti­er goals, like lower­ing the cor­por­ate tax rate. “I want to get the dol­lars [for in­fra­struc­ture], but I un­der­stand they have something big­ger that they need to do,” Shuster said.

Re­pub­lic­ans will need Demo­crats’ help to pass any­thing that raises money for trans­port­a­tion be­cause ul­tracon­ser­vat­ive House GOP mem­bers will likely ob­ject to the idea on prin­ciple. Blumenauer said Demo­crats are open to everything from a gas tax to a fair cor­por­ate-tax bill, but they aren’t go­ing to sign off on something sight un­seen. “I think Demo­crats on the com­mit­tee would be sup­port­ive of something like a gas tax or something that’s big. I don’t see the groundswell for something that nobody’s seen or [makes] it more com­plex,” he said.

What We're Following See More »
Former Pilot Steve Dickson to Head Federal Aviation Administration
2 hours ago

President Donald Trump will nominate former airline pilot Steve Dickson to be administrator of the Federal Aviation Administration, a move that comes amid a major crisis for the agency following the fatal crashes of two Boeing 737 MAX passenger jets in Indonesia and Ethiopia, the White House said Tuesday.

Trump Threatens New Sanctions Against Venezuela
4 hours ago

"President Donald Trump on Tuesday said he may impose new strict sanctions on Venezuela in another attempt to force President Nićolas Maduro from office. ... Trump’s remarks came during a joint Rose Garden press conference with new Brazilian President Jair Bolsonaro." The two are working on a rocket launch facility in Brazil, and Bolsonaro is weighing whether to allow "U.S. or international forces to mass along his border with Venezuela."

Paul Ryan to Join Board of Fox Corporation
7 hours ago
Scott Walker to Lead Effort for Constitutional Convention
8 hours ago

"A national group says its campaign to convene an unprecedented U.S. constitutional convention to balance the federal budget has a new leader: former Republican Gov. Scott Walker. The Center for State-led National Debt Solutions on Monday announced Walker will serve as its national honorary chairman. It marks one of the first efforts by Walker to re-enter the political fray since his November election loss to Gov. Tony Evers. In 2017, Wisconsin became the 28th state to request an Article V convention — so named for the article of the U.S. Constitution that sanctions the process." Thirty-four states must sign on to trigger a convention.

Administration Aims to Cap Student Borrowing
8 hours ago

"The Trump administration on Monday proposed placing limits on federal student borrowing programs as part of a series of initiatives to amend the Higher Education Act. ... A number of the proposals seek to change the borrowing and loan repayment process. A senior administration official said the White House wants to institute a limit on loans through the PLUS program, which graduate students and parents of undergraduates use to help pay for college or trade school."

The official did not say what the loan cap would be, but that it could vary by program rather than by institution.

The administration is also calling for Congress to simplify loan repayment programs, in part by condensing five income-driven repayment plans into one plan that would cap monthly payments at 12.5 percent of the borrower's discretionary income.


Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.