Why Obama is Worried About ‘Class Segregation’

At forum on poverty, the president laments “those who are doing better … withdrawing from the commons.”

President Obama participates in a discussion on poverty with moderator E.J. Dionne, Jr. at Georgetown University.
Mark Wilson/Getty Images
May 12, 2015, 1:20 p.m.

Ex­tend­ing his in­creas­ing fo­cus on race and poverty, Pres­id­ent Obama on Tues­day lamen­ted widen­ing in­come and ra­cial se­greg­a­tion around the coun­try.

“Con­cen­tra­tions of wealth can lead to some be­ing left be­hind,” Obama said in a pan­el on poverty at Geor­getown Uni­versity for a sum­mit bring­ing to­geth­er Cath­ol­ic and evan­gel­ic­al faith lead­ers. “What’s happened in our eco­nomy is that those who are do­ing bet­ter and bet­ter—more skilled, more edu­cated, luck­i­er, hav­ing great­er ad­vant­ages—are with­draw­ing from the com­mons.”

Stud­ies have shown that in many cit­ies the num­ber of mixed-in­come neigh­bor­hoods is de­clin­ing, widen­ing the gap between af­flu­ent and poor com­munit­ies. That sep­ar­a­tion, Obama ar­gued, has both isol­ated lower-in­come chil­dren from com­munity in­sti­tu­tions that could help them get ahead, and also re­duced the polit­ic­al will to in­vest in pub­lic in­sti­tu­tions and ser­vices.

“Part of what’s happened is that elites in a very mo­bile, glob­al­ized world are able to live to­geth­er, away from folks who are not as wealthy, and so they feel less of a com­mit­ment to mak­ing those in­vest­ments,” Obama said. “In that sense, what used to be ra­cial se­greg­a­tion now mir­rors it­self in class se­greg­a­tion and this great sort­ing that’s tak­ing place.”

With this “class se­greg­a­tion” and sort­ing, Obama said, young people from dif­fer­ent rungs on the in­come lad­der are less likely to in­ter­act—and those on the low­est rungs are less likely to have ac­cess to com­munity in­sti­tu­tions that could sup­port their rise. Obama noted how Har­vard polit­ic­al sci­ent­ist Robert Put­nam, who also ap­peared on the pan­el, il­lus­trated in his re­cent book, Our Kids, that young people from di­ver­gent eco­nom­ic back­grounds grew up largely to­geth­er in Port Clin­ton, Ohio, dur­ing his own youth.

“The jan­it­or’s daugh­ter may be go­ing out with the banker’s son,” Obama said. “There are a set of com­mon in­sti­tu­tions—they may at­tend the same church, they may be mem­bers of the same Rotary Club, they may be act­ive at the same parks—and all the things that stitch them to­geth­er. And that is all con­trib­ut­ing to so­cial mo­bil­ity and to a sense of pos­sib­il­ity and op­por­tun­ity for all kids in that com­munity.”

With that world largely gone, Obama said, lev­el­ing the play­ing field will re­quire in­vest­ments from “so­ci­ety as a whole” in pub­lic schools and in­sti­tu­tions, early child­hood edu­ca­tion, teach­ers, in­fra­struc­ture to con­nect people to jobs, and bet­ter broad­band ac­cess in rur­al com­munit­ies.

“Those things aren’t go­ing to hap­pen through mar­ket forces alone. If that’s the case, our gov­ern­ment and our budgets have to re­flect our will­ing­ness to make those in­vest­ments,” Obama said. “Those [in­vest­ments] will make a dif­fer­ence, but the broad­er trends in our so­ci­ety will make it harder and harder for us to deal with both in­equal­ity and poverty.”

Obama’s fel­low pan­el­ists—Put­nam and Ar­thur Brooks, pres­id­ent of the Amer­ic­an En­ter­prise In­sti­tute—both ex­pressed op­tim­ism for a polit­ic­al solu­tion on eco­nom­ic and mor­al grounds.

“It also is, by the way, bad for our eco­nomy, be­cause when we have this large num­ber of kids grow­ing up in poverty, it’s not like that’s go­ing to make things bet­ter for my grand­chil­dren,” Put­nam said. “It’s go­ing to make things worse for my grand­chil­dren. So this is, in prin­ciple, a prob­lem that we ought to find solu­tions to.”

Brooks ar­gued that, while polit­ic­al com­prom­ise may be pos­sible, many pub­lic pro­grams fail to pro­duce be­ne­fits that jus­ti­fy their costs, and that aus­ter­ity as a con­sequence of gov­ern­ment over­spend­ing dis­pro­por­tion­ately hurts the poor.

“When are the be­ne­fits high­er than the costs of the gov­ern­ment prov­ing these things?” Brooks asked the pan­el. “Be­cause, in point of fact, when we don’t make cost-be­ne­fit cal­cu­la­tions at least at the macro level about pub­lic goods, the poor pay. This is a fact.”

The gen­er­al pub­lic’s sat­is­fac­tion with the fed­er­al re­sponse to poverty is also at an all-time low, ac­cord­ing to a re­cent Gal­lup poll. Only 16 per­cent of Amer­ic­ans say they are sat­is­fied with the gov­ern­ment’s ef­forts on fight­ing poverty, the low­est point since sat­is­fac­tion was at 26 per­cent in 2001, when the polling firm first began sur­vey­ing Amer­ic­ans on the ques­tion. Re­pub­lic­ans are slightly less sat­is­fied (14 per­cent) than Demo­crats (18 per­cent). Gal­lup saw little dif­fer­ence in sat­is­fac­tion levels among race, edu­ca­tion, gender, and age sub­groups.

What We're Following See More »
Republican Candidate Mark Harris Supports New Election in NC-9
7 minutes ago

"The North Carolina State Board of Elections is hearing evidence this week to decide whether a suspected ballot-tampering scheme tainted the outcome in the 9th Congressional District where Republican Mark Harris leads Democrat Dan McCready by 905 votes in unofficial returns."

Pence Traveling to Colombia
4 hours ago

"Vice President Mike Pence will go to Colombia on Monday to speak with the Colombian president and regional leaders about the ongoing turmoil in Venezuela and rally the international community behind opposition leader Juan Guaidó." Pence "will deliver remarks to the 14 nations that are part of the 'Lima Group' in Bogota," and will meet with Colombian President Ivan Duque.

Rep. Bradley Byrne Announces Bid Against Sen. Doug Jones
4 hours ago

"U.S. Rep. Bradley Byrne became the first official Republican entrant into the 2020 U.S. Senate race announcing his intention to run in a race that could become one of the most expensive political contests in Alabama history. Byrne, a three-term congressman from Fairhope, said he anticipates the fundraising during the lengthy 2020 campaign to eclipse the 2017 special Senate election, in which an estimated $50 million was spent during the contest. Democratic U.S. Senator Doug Jones, who narrowly defeated Republican Roy Moore in that election, raised more than $24 million."

Coast Guard Lt. Planned Large-scale Terrorist Attack
5 hours ago

"A U.S. Coast Guard lieutenant and self-identified white nationalist was arrested after federal investigators uncovered a cache of weapons and ammunition in his Maryland home that authorities say he stockpiled to launch a widespread domestic terrorist attack targeting politicians and journalists...Though court documents do not detail a specific planned date for an attack, the government said he had been amassing supplies and weapons since at least 2017, developed a spreadsheet of targets that included House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) and searched the Internet using phrases such as “best place in dc to see congress people” and “are supreme court justices protected.”

Trump Signs Border Deal
5 days ago

"President Trump signed a sweeping spending bill Friday afternoon, averting another partial government shutdown. The action came after Trump had declared a national emergency in a move designed to circumvent Congress and build additional barriers at the southern border, where he said the United States faces 'an invasion of our country.'"


Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.