Bush Family Values Pit Jeb Against Grover Norquist

Jeb Bush has never signed Norquist’s no-tax pledge, and there’s no reason to believe he ever will.

Former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush speaks at a dinner during the Republican National Committee Spring Meeting at The Phoenician May 14, 2015 in Scottsdale, Arizona.
National Journal
S.V. Dáte
Add to Briefcase
See more stories about...
S.V. Dáte
May 18, 2015, 11:38 a.m.

Grover Nor­quist hates taxes. Jeb Bush made a ca­reer of cut­ting them as Flor­ida gov­ernor.

Yet Bush won’t touch Nor­quist’s baby, the Tax­pay­er Pro­tec­tion Pledge, which the an­ti­tax cru­sader tries to get every Re­pub­lic­an can­did­ate for state or fed­er­al of­fice to sign.

Bush was asked about it again re­cently, at a con­fer­ence sponsored by the Nor­quist-friendly Na­tion­al Re­view. Would he sign it? “No,” Bush answered, and then poin­ted to his Flor­ida re­cord, where by the end of his second term he had cut the state’s tax base by $1.8 bil­lion a year against total col­lec­tions of about $50 bil­lion. “I don’t have to be told how im­port­ant that is. I did it.”

So how did the Re­pub­lic­an Party’s most fam­ous tax en­for­cer get cross­wise with the Re­pub­lic­an al­most-pres­id­en­tial can­did­ate? The an­swer could be in quarter-cen­tury-old his­tory, the af­ter­math of a budget deal struck by Jeb Bush’s fath­er, then-Pres­id­ent George H.W. Bush, in 1990.

Many con­ser­vat­ives in the party, Nor­quist among them, were out­raged that Bush agreed to raise some taxes to help erase budget de­fi­cits gen­er­ated un­der pre­de­cessor Ron­ald Re­agan. After Bush lost to Bill Clin­ton, Nor­quist blamed it on the aban­don­ment of the “no new taxes” pledge.

In a Janu­ary 1993 op-ed in The Amer­ic­an Spec­tat­or, Nor­quist wrote: “There is the stench of be­tray­al and treas­on in the air, and it comes from the biggest be­tray­al of all: George Bush’s de­cision in 1990 to tear the heart out of the Re­pub­lic­an co­ali­tion.”

As per­haps Nor­quist did not ap­pre­ci­ate, the easi­est way to get on Jeb Bush’s wrong side is to in­sult his fath­er, whom he’s been fiercely loy­al to and pro­tect­ive of for dec­ades. While George W. Bush sent Nor­quist a let­ter es­sen­tially mir­ror­ing the no-tax pledge dur­ing his 2000 pres­id­en­tial run, Jeb Bush has nev­er agreed to Nor­quist’s pledge—through three runs for gov­ernor in 1994, 1998, and 2002, and now as he nears a pres­id­en­tial run.

In a phone in­ter­view with Na­tion­al Journ­al as he strolled through a bazaar in Istan­bul, Nor­quist said he had no idea if Jeb Bush was ir­rit­ated with him over his com­ments about his fath­er. “You’d have to check with him on that,” Nor­quist said.

Neither a Bush spokes­wo­man nor Bush him­self re­spon­ded to Na­tion­al Journ­al quer­ies about Nor­quist.

Bush’s at­ti­tude to­ward Nor­quist stands in con­trast with a keen sens­it­iv­ity that Bush has shown through the years to his party base’s an­ti­pathy to­ward taxes. As Flor­ida com­merce sec­ret­ary in 1987, Bush pub­licly backed Re­pub­lic­an Gov. Bob Mar­tinez’s push to widen the state’s sales tax to in­clude ser­vices in ad­di­tion to goods—but privately wrote Mar­tinez a let­ter say­ing he op­posed the idea. In 1998, while run­ning for gov­ernor him­self, Bush was able to pull out the let­ter when the is­sue was raised by Demo­crat Buddy MacK­ay.

Bush’s re­fus­al to pledge not­with­stand­ing, Nor­quist en­thu­si­ast­ic­ally praised Bush’s gov­ernor­ship as it was un­fold­ing. In 2003, he told the St. Peters­burg Times that he of­ten poin­ted to Bush in meet­ings with oth­er gov­ernors. “I use him as the mod­el when I talk to the oth­er gov­ernors, to shame them,” he said. In late 2006, with Bush’s ten­ure al­most over, Nor­quist called Bush the best gov­ernor in the coun­try and told The Palm Beach Post that he should run for pres­id­ent.

All of Nor­quist’s gush­ing, though, seemed a case of un­re­quited love.

Bush turned down meet­ing re­quests from Nor­quist dur­ing his two terms in Tal­l­a­hassee. In 2003, Bush’s sched­uler emailed him to see if he was in­ter­ested in meet­ing Nor­quist the fol­low­ing week when he was vis­it­ing the Flor­ida Cap­it­ol. Bush’s re­sponse: “Not really.”

Bush did meet with Nor­quist in 2005 (Bush told The Palm Beach Post that they spoke about “free­dom and lim­ited gov­ern­ment”), but both Bush’s hos­til­ity to­ward Nor­quist’s pledge and Nor­quist’s cri­ti­cisms of the first Pres­id­ent Bush have per­sisted.

“If my fath­er had thrown away a per­fectly good pres­id­ency by rais­ing taxes, I think one of the things in life that I would learn is, ‘Don’t do that,’ ” Nor­quist told Politico last fall. “But here you have Jeb Bush go­ing, ‘I learned noth­ing from my fath­er’s self-im­mol­a­tion.’ “

For fed­er­al of­fice­hold­ers, the pledge reads: “ONE, op­pose any and all ef­forts to in­crease the mar­gin­al in­come tax rates for in­di­vidu­als and/or busi­nesses; and TWO, op­pose any net re­duc­tion or elim­in­a­tion of de­duc­tions and cred­its, un­less matched dol­lar for dol­lar by fur­ther re­du­cing tax rates.”

The pledge is big busi­ness for Nor­quist and his group. In 2012, its last elec­tion year tax fil­ing avail­able, Amer­ic­ans for Tax Re­form took in $30.9 mil­lion in con­tri­bu­tions (with $26.4 mil­lion of that com­ing from Re­pub­lic­an strategist Karl Rove’s Cross­roads GPS secret-money polit­ic­al group) and spent 90 per­cent of it on ex­penses, in­clud­ing polit­ic­al ads, as­so­ci­ated with its pledge. Nor­quist per­son­ally was paid $448,000 by Amer­ic­ans for Tax Re­form and af­fil­i­ated or­gan­iz­a­tions.

Nor­quist told Na­tion­al Journ­al that he still ad­mires Bush’s gov­ernor­ship. “His track re­cord on taxes has been quite good,” Nor­quist said, and ad­ded that he hopes as the weeks and months pass, Bush will re­con­sider the pledge. “We’ll see how it goes. Jeb Bush hasn’t an­nounced his can­did­acy yet. All the can­did­ates who have an­nounced have signed it.”

What We're Following See More »
Congressional Budget Office Scores House Trumpcare Bill
8 hours ago

The nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office has released its score of the House-passed American Health Care Act, which would replace Obamacare. According to the CBO, the bill would reduce the deficit by $119 billion by 2026, while leaving 14 million more Americans uninsured in 2018 than under current law, a number swelling to 23 million by 2026. Further, insurance premiums would balloon 20 percent in 2018 and five percent in 2019 before the waiver provision in the legislation would kick in. The provision allows states to apply for waivers and permit insurers to offer skimpier plans, which would likely entice younger and healthier individuals to buy health insurance while potentially pricing older and less healthy Americans out of insurance plans. House Republicans approved this bill in late April without waiting for the CBO score.

Graham Rejects Trump’s Budget In Hearing
8 hours ago

Republican Sen. Lindsey Graham said Wednesday during a Senate Appropriations subcommittee hearing that President Donald Trump's budget is little more than recycling bin material. "The budget proposed by the president doesn't have a snowball's chance in hell of passing," Graham said. Graham had previously opposed the budget over its nearly 30 percent cut to the budget of the State Department. The budget slashes spending on domestic priorities while increasing military spending.

Ethics Cops Clear Mueller to Work on Trump Case
1 days ago

"Former FBI Director Robert Mueller has been cleared by U.S. Department of Justice ethics experts to oversee an investigation into possible collusion between then-candidate Donald Trump's 2016 election campaign and Russia." Some had speculated that the White House would use "an ethics rule limiting government attorneys from investigating people their former law firm represented" to trip up Mueller's appointment. Jared Kushner is a client of Mueller's firm, WilmerHale. "Although Mueller has now been cleared by the Justice Department, the White House may still use his former law firm's connection to Manafort and Kushner to undermine the findings of his investigation, according to two sources close to the White House."

Senate Intel to Subpoena Two of Flynn’s Businesses
1 days ago

Senate Intelligence Committee chairman Richard Burr (R-NC) and ranking member Mark Warner (D-VA) will subpoena two businesses owned by former National Security Advisor Michael Flynn. Burr said, "We would like to hear from General Flynn. We'd like to see his documents. We'd like him to tell his story because he publicly said he had a story to tell."

Brennan Saw Russia Intelligence “Worthy” of Investigation
1 days ago

At an open hearing of the House Intelligence Committee, former CIA chief John Brennan said he saw information on Trump-Russia contacts that were worth a further look. "Having been involved in many counterintelligence cases in the past, I know what the Russians do. They try to suborn individuals," Brennan said. "And they try to get individuals, including U.S. persons, to act on their behalf, whether wittingly or unwittingly. And I was worried by a number of the contacts that the Russians had with U.S. persons, and so therefore by the time I left office ... I had unresolved questions in my mind."


Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.