Still No Clear Path to Boost High-Skilled Immigration

Both parties want to bring more entrepreneurs and scientists in the country, but can’t agree how to get there.

Rep. John Delaney speaks at a National Journal event on high-skilled immigration June 2, 2015.
National Journal
Caitlin Owens
Add to Briefcase
See more stories about...
Caitlin Owens
June 2, 2015, 9:46 a.m.

Demo­crat­ic Rep. John Delaney and Re­pub­lic­an Sen. Ron John­son agree that highly-skilled im­mig­rants are valu­able to the U.S. eco­nomy—they just dis­agree on what to do about it.

As Delaney put it: Demo­crats pri­or­it­ize find­ing a path to leg­al­iz­a­tion for un­doc­u­mented im­mig­rants while Re­pub­lic­ans want to first fo­cus on se­cur­ing the bor­der.

“We all want every Amer­ic­an to have the op­por­tun­ity to build a good life for them­selves and their fam­ily,” John­son said. “There’s wide dis­par­ity in terms of how to provide those types of op­por­tun­it­ies, how to achieve that prosper­ity.”

Delaney, a mem­ber of the Joint Eco­nom­ic Com­mit­tee, and John­son, chair­man of the Sen­ate Home­land Se­cur­ity and Gov­ern­ment­al Af­fairs Com­mit­tee, on Tues­day key­noted a Na­tion­al Journ­al event, “Path­ways to Re­form: A Dis­cus­sion on High-Skilled Im­mig­ra­tion Policy,” un­der­writ­ten by Qual­comm.

“I agree with so much I heard,” said John­son, who spoke after Delaney, “but there’s a heavy dis­agree­ment in terms of what the fed­er­al gov­ern­ment really ought to do.”

Echo­ing the po­s­i­tions of their re­spect­ive parties, Delaney talked about com­pre­hens­ive re­form and John­son talked about piece­meal, step-by-step change.

Delaney said he thinks there will even­tu­ally be a House ver­sion of the 2013 im­mig­ra­tion bill passed in the Sen­ate; John­son said he would ar­gue the “com­pre­hens­ive bill … wasn’t go­ing to work.”

But at the end of the day, both want to re­tain tal­ent in the U.S.

“Let’s make sure the smartest minds stay here to grow the eco­nomy,” John­son said.

Delaney said ideo­lo­gic­al pro­gress on the eco­nom­ic ar­gu­ments would be an im­port­ant step to­wards achiev­ing more com­pre­hens­ive re­form, des­pite core dis­agree­ments between parties.

“One of the paths to en­han­cing eco­nom­ic growth is to em­brace a for­ward-look­ing im­mig­ra­tion strategy that al­lows more visas, more green cards, al­lows more en­tre­pren­eurs to work in our eco­nomy, cre­ate jobs, get that lever­age that we need, and al­low these com­pan­ies to com­pete glob­ally,” Delaney said. “So this is a growth is­sue. It’s a cur­rent is­sue and it’s a long term growth is­sue.”

Harry Holzer, a Geor­getown Uni­versity pro­fess­or, spoke on a pan­el of ex­perts fol­low­ing the key­note ad­dresses. He offered a more nu­anced view of im­mig­ra­tion re­form than either politi­cian.

“Right now, we need more in­nov­a­tion, we need more pat­ents gen­er­ated, we need more star­tups. There’s been a de­cline in busi­ness star­tups “¦ high-skill im­mig­ra­tion is good for that. High-skilled im­mig­rants cre­ate more star­tups,” he said. “I think the best thing we can do is open the per­man­ent path­ways to high-skill im­mig­ra­tion.”

On the oth­er hand, he said, there is a “mod­est neg­at­ive ef­fect on the wages of un­skilled nat­ive work­ers” and he agrees with John­son that “we want to raise the in­cent­ives for the leg­als, re­duce the in­cent­ives for the il­leg­als.”

And while he sup­ports a path to leg­al­iz­a­tion for un­doc­u­mented im­mig­rants, at the end of the day it’s about the eco­nom­ics.

“Oth­er people talk about the val­ues, and I’ll let oth­er people talk about that,” Holzer said. “The eco­nom­ic ar­gu­ment to me is quite strong.”

What We're Following See More »
A.T.F. Agents Filled Secret Coffers
51 minutes ago

Agents for the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives " used a web of shadowy cigarette sales to funnel tens of millions of dollars into a secret bank account," according to a federal racketeering lawsuit filed by a group of tobacco farmers who claim they were "swindled out of $24 million." The agents allegedly used shipments of snack food disguised as tobacco. The Justice Department is reportedly investigating the matter, though as of now it is unclear how widespread the practice was or if it is still ongoing.

How Many Signatures Has the Petition for Trump’s Tax Returns Received?
1 hours ago

More than 1 million, setting a record. More than 100,000 signatures triggers an official White House response.

Sen. Collins Open to Subpoena of Trump’s Tax Returns
1 hours ago

Sen. Susan Collins, who sits on the Intelligence Committee, "said on Wednesday she's open to using a subpoena to investigate President Donald Trump's tax returns for potential connections to Russia." She said the committee is also open to subpoenaing Trump himself. "This is a counter-intelligence operation in many ways," she said of Russia's interference. "That's what our committee specializes in. We are used to probing in depth in this area."

Obama Staffers Launch Group to Monitor Trump Ethics
1 hours ago

"Top lawyers who helped the Obama White House craft and hold to rules of conduct believe President Donald Trump and his staff will break ethics norms meant to guard against politicization of the government — and they’ve formed a new group to prepare, and fight. United to Protect Democracy, which draws its name from a line in President Barack Obama’s farewell address that urged his supporters to pick up where he was leaving off, has already raised a $1.5 million operating budget, hired five staffers and has plans to double that in the coming months." Meanwhile, NPR has launched a "Trump Ethics Monitor" to track the resolution of ten ethics-related promises that the president has made.

Christie Turned Down Labor Secretary
1 hours ago

Over a meatloaf lunch at the White House last week, Donald Trump offered the job of Labor secretary to New Jersey Governor Chris Christie, a longtime loyalist. Christie promptly turned down the offer, once again signaling that he has no desire to move to Washington, D.C. to join the Trump administration. The job ended up going to Alexander Acosta, who is expected to sail through the Senate confirmation process.


Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.